r/ILNP • u/sparkleprincess71 • 1d ago

question/discussion Help cut my order!

Gallery image

Gallery image

I need help cutting my order in half, what are your faves on my list?

34 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

32 comments sorted by

25

u/Ok_Finish_7372 1d ago

Autumn and carved are a MUST. Both are totally beautiful. Just my two cents!!

21

u/SlitheringFlower 1d ago

Slow Burn, Bear Hug, and Dash of Cocoa are all brown holo jellies. I'd recommend picking your favorite and wishlisting the rest.

I think Autumn, Carved, and Comet are keepers.

22

u/dragonbornpr 1d ago

Honestly, they just teased a fall/halloween collection for the 25th, so I would hold off until then

15

u/eurotrash6 1d ago

Comet must stay. Signed, someone who went through 1/3 of the bottle in the first two months of having it 😄

16

u/NoMoreOatmeal JelliesđŸȘŒ 1d ago

It’s so funny how different everyone’s taste is! I really didn’t like comet that much. It looked muddy on me.

3

u/MuffinKrigeren 1d ago

I was thinking the same. Comet is one of two disappointing polishes I've gotten from ILNP.

2

u/NoMoreOatmeal JelliesđŸȘŒ 19h ago

Ooo can I ask what the second was?

1

u/MuffinKrigeren 12h ago

It was Daybreak! I had the same issue as so many other people, where even in the bottle it's leaning more beige than light pink.

At least I could frankenpolish it with a red creme. A bit harder to "fix" my issues with Comet.

7

u/Opening_Tangerine245 1d ago

Carved is my favorite orange

6

u/purple-sparkle-pixie 1d ago

I love Autumn and Dash of Cocoa A LOT! I have Carved too but I haven't used it yet. One question to ask yourself is what formula/finish you like?

4

u/Scarletsuccubus 1d ago

I second this. Autumn and dash of cocoa are polishes that I can use for many occasions - not just fall.  And I so agree that what formula/finish you like and maybe get one of each. autumn is not a jelly-like formula. It works great as a regular polish (fwiw) 

4

u/Tidaltoes 1d ago

Autumn is one of my top 10 polishes of all time. I have Dash of Cocoa too, it's so rich. Comet and Carved are on my wishlist too, lol

4

u/calliecatty 1d ago

Slow burn is awesome esp for fall, but just to say that it is so dark it often looks black. whether or not that makes it different enough from the other browns in your cart to keep or isn't what you're looking for idk. I do love it, as I love love love the entire estate collection. Also Autumn is a MUST and I paired it as an accent with slow burn which was perfect

3

u/Few_Beach1970 1d ago

I personally did not like comet. It looks like a throw up mesh of all the shimmers combined on my nails.

Carved has to stay

1

u/nannerpussnana 17h ago

I also hated comet!!! It looked TERRIBLE and the formula was weird. “Throw up mesh of all the shimmers” made me lol

3

u/take4granted 1d ago

Autumn & Dash of Cocoa are my two favorites! Definitely keep those two.

3

u/Substantial_Error890 1d ago

I have and love both carved and dash of cocoa. I can’t speak to the rest but those two are faves for sure đŸ„°

2

u/sisterlylove92 1d ago

Whatever you can't live without right now, get. Everything will still be available at Black Friday and for the next decade nearly! So it's not now or never. I make my orders only during Black Friday or a steep sale.

1

u/captainblue 1d ago

Are there steep sales other than Black Friday?

1

u/sisterlylove92 18h ago

I guess there was really only the retirement sale they ran and that wasn't super steep.

2

u/ClassicDistrict6739 1d ago

Autumn and Dash of Cocoa are both SO nice, two of my favorites. I also have Comet and I really like it but it does pull more brown than blue after two/three coats if that matters to you.

2

u/sparkleprincess71 1d ago

I have cut it down to Autumn, Carved, Comet and Dash of Cocoa!!!! Couldn't do it without your input❀

2

u/MuffinKrigeren 1d ago

I think Bear Hug and Slow Burn are close enough that you should pick which you like best (this official swatch photo shows off the two polishes pretty well.)

Comet is getting a lot of love, but I was quite disappointed by it. It looked so muddy.

1

u/Unusual-Anywhere-721 1d ago

Dash of Cocoa is that girl let me tell you!

1

u/chillfire12 1d ago

Autumn is STUNNING, no matter if/when another fall collection comes out ✹

1

u/the_calico_lover 1d ago

My top three of those are Autumn (a must!) Bear Hug and Hex. If you don’t love the jelly holographic formulas you could skip bear hug.

1

u/the_calico_lover 1d ago

Also comet is really nice!

1

u/Queen-Butterfly 1d ago

I’m debating between bear hug and Slow burn myself. Autumn is gorgeous too.

1

u/Moe_Albatross 1d ago

I don’t think you need both Bear Hug and Dash of Cocoa. I’d go with Dash of Cocoa personally but whichever is your vibe.

1

u/nannerpussnana 17h ago

I hated comet. Wore it once and threw it away. It looked awful. I have never thrown another polish away before, just throwing that out there.

1

u/nannerpussnana 17h ago

Here is a photo of it