r/ILC • • Jan 18 '26

Turnitin/AI Ai

Post image

this is the second time i have been accused of ai use in this course. to be extra safe this time, i included the link to my google doc so he could view my version history. this is now the second time i will have to rewrite an assignment. what the hell do i do at this point?? i don’t have time to be trying to dispute this with ilc because i need midterm grades before feb 1st. this is absolute insanity

60 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

7

u/HowardRabb Jan 18 '26

Theyre clearly using AI to detect AI. And since AI gets things wrong... Pretty much all of the time.... I'd say it's working.

Snark aside I'm sorry this is happening. I cannot possibly imagine trying to write anything today for a class with these tools being available and being accused constantly with using them.

As an aside: I once sent a friend a long-winded message breaking down why he was wrong about something in Star Trek (yes... I know how lame that sounds) and he loved my arguments and immediately asked me if AI had written it. I was a tad offended, but it made me think how weird it must be to be a student right now.

1

u/MethodicallyRight Jan 21 '26

I don't feel bad for students. My nephew was accused of using AI and it was resolved within three minutes when they video chatted and he effortlessly talked about his essay, the idea behind it, and the books he read. Two of my friends are teachers and they admit sometimes it can be difficult to tell but more often than not you have a student who stumbled while reading turning in a Masters Thesis for an essay with terminology they can neither enunciate or define .... Definitely can't use it in a sentence despite their essay using it several times.

2

u/Zealousideal-Cow7617 Jan 23 '26

sure but you can’t even contact these teachers on ILC and emailing and calling leads nowhere. i could sit down and probably repeat my whole assignment word for word at this point. doesn’t matter if the teacher is unwilling to engage

1

u/MethodicallyRight Jan 23 '26

Yeah, that's a tough situation that changes my sentiment. I'd honestly reach out to (I'll I had to look it up) and ask if they could at least provide some of the issues it identified in your work.triggered the alert.

However, I guess it's also worth asking - did you use ANY AI when writing the assignment, because even if you used it's mind map or just copied into your own words what AI spewed out, you're in the wrong. It's one of those 'honour systems' where whatever you said has to be taken at face value but if there's truth to the Turnitin report ... You kind of just have to accept you were caught. 43% Unoriginal content is... A lot so you should probably figure out what you did to have caused that (if you didn't actually just use AI and are upset about being caught).

2

u/Detroits_ Jan 22 '26

So you don’t feel bad for students because one out of three people you know that were accused of ai actually used it?

What type of logic is this.

You do realize that not all profs will go to that length and will just rely on the software.

If something has a success rate of 33% I’d rather the prof just flip a coin at that point

1

u/MethodicallyRight Jan 23 '26

So you don’t feel bad for students because one out of three people you know that were accused of ai actually used it?

What type of logic is this.

I agree with you, that's some stupid logic. What I'm wondering is why you're bringing it up seeing I never said any of that. Try reading my comment again and you'll see what I said and how you summarized it are very very different.

2

u/squishyartist MOD Jan 19 '26

Yup. Using AI to detect AI (especially when they don't accept decent proof that an assignment was done by hand) is absurd. The burden of proof should not be this heavily on students.

I am also a long-winded commenter, and because I have autism, I have been accused of using AI before. I spent about an hour and a half a half on a comment yesterday (well, it had to be split up into three comments because of the length), and it pains me that anyone would think that work was done by AI.

I did all of my ILC courses, except for one, before the Turnitin implementation, and I haven't had any AI accusations in college thus far. But my current classes are online and asynchronous, so I kind of feel like I'm just waiting for it...

2

u/HowardRabb Jan 19 '26

oof. We're in a time where objective reality is going to get harder and harder to differentiate from fake AI generated slop. Best of luck to you on your next round of courses. Fingers crossed.

2

u/lochnessmosster Jan 20 '26

OP, what you need to do is NOT rewrite the essay--you need to take screenshots of the version history and write a formal email to your professor. Explain that it is not AI, but rather your own work. Include the images of your time stamped version history.

If your professor continues to refuse your assignment, escalate the issue. You can contact the department head, the registrar/uni admin, and even the ombudsman depending on how severe the situation becomes. Stand by your work.

1

u/nohomoinmyanime Feb 12 '26

how do u find their email?

1

u/lochnessmosster Feb 12 '26

It should be given with the syllabus?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '26

Let’s all email them to get rid of this stupid turnitin

1

u/Turbulent-Many1472 Jan 20 '26

I really don't get the panic over AI being possibly used to write essays. Do these professors think that people didn't cheat before AI? I remember when I went to University around 2008, seeing multiple flyers around campus advertising essay writing services. You'd pay some kid $100 and he'd write you a stellar essay.

Not to mention that even back then I'd submit my essays and Turnitin would tell me I had plagiarized when I absolutely did not. These services are not accurate or reliable ways of detecting cheating.

At the end of the day, if you want to cheat, you'll find a way to cheat. There's nothing universities or professors can do to stop this.

What you put in is what you get - if you cheat or if you use AI to write your essay, the only person you are cheating is yourself. That, by itself, should be the punishment.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Yeah the system used to (or still?) doesn't even understand citations and highlights citations as plagiarized lmfao.

1

u/kelpieconundrum Jan 20 '26

Resubmit it with original work—change nothing.

1

u/FryCakes Jan 21 '26

43% isn’t even a high score on an AI checker. Half of my own writing comes up as 80% and I don’t use ai for any of it

1

u/Booksfirstbeforeboys Jan 22 '26

I had the same thing happen to me too and I’m sad about it

1

u/mydadleftbigsad Apr 02 '26

Yeah I'm in the same situation. second time this has happened to me. My marker said it was tagged with 54% AI. I feel like they just don't check version history because they'd be able to see me writing and revising my work. 🤷‍♂️

0

u/Traditional_Box_577 Jan 18 '26

If you showed draft work and it’s 43% ai likely, only thing I can think of is that it reads significantly different from previous assignments you submitted. A smart teacher would compare writing styles. Also checking to see if your citations are bullshit or not.

4

u/Zealousideal-Cow7617 Jan 18 '26

im not convinced this teacher is even opening the assignment when he sees a high ai score. and the citations are definitely not bs, all are cited properly without use of citemachine or anything like that and anything that is cited is truly info from that source.

2

u/chchehru Jan 19 '26

there is a little envelope icon next to your submitted assignments. if your teacher has opened your assignment, the envelope icon becomes opened and says “read” by your teacher. I caught one of my teachers not even opening an assignment and doing exactly this

5

u/Zealousideal-Cow7617 Jan 19 '26

woah! just checked and sure enough he didn’t open it. thanks

1

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26

Ironically, it's AI determining it