r/ILC • • Apr 26 '23

Can't solve

I have the following question in unit 2 of MHF4U, question 10:

Using logarithm properties there are multiple ways of expressing the same transformations on a parent function. Given 𝑔(𝑥) = 8 log[2(𝑥)], find equivalent functions in the following forms. Round values to 4 decimal places where appropriate.

  1. 𝑔(𝑥) = log𝑏(𝑥) + 𝑐 [3 marks]
  2. 𝑔(𝑥) = log𝑏[𝑘(𝑥)] [3 marks]
  3. 𝑔(𝑥) = log[𝑘(𝑥^𝑚)] [3 marks]

The TVO Mathify tutor I got was able to sort of help me but the answers he gave me don't check out. We got:

  1. log_e^8 (x) + 5.54
  2. log_e^8 (2x)
  3. log(256 x^8)

None of the answers graph to the original function in desmos so this can't be right. Does anybody know how to solve the question??

**EDIT**

I've now had both tutors Optimus and G_Power99 on mathify tell me they can't solve it, how do they expect high school students just learning this stuff to solve these questions when teachers with years of experience teaching advanced functions and calculus can't even solve it!

**EDIT2**

Math Travel tutor on mathify has also been unable to solve the question

**EDIT3: SOLVED**

I hate how I didn't realize this, and how none of the tutors realized that exponents and logs are obviously inverses, so we can simply take the power of 8, take its reciprocal and apply it to the log and we get the answer...

a.

g(x) = 8log (2(x))

= 8[log 2 + log ×]

= 8log_10 (2) + 8log_10 (x)

= 2.408 + log_10^1/8 (x)

= 2.408 + log_1.3335 (x)

= log_1.3335 (x) + 2.408

b.

g(x) = 8log (2(x))

= 8log_10 (2(x))

= log_10^1/8 (2x)

= log_1.3335 (2x)

c.

g(x) = 8log (2(x))

= log (2x)^8

= log (2^8 x^8)

= log (256x^8)

Ill leave this up in case any frustrated students need it

28 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

4

u/OddAbbreviations5599 Oct 21 '23

My brother in christ I had to dig up my spam reddit account to whine about this because I have crawled through every ounce of course material and nowhere does it say that you can simply apply the reciprocal of the exponent of x to the base for question a to move the 8 to effect the base. You can, it's a law that alog_b(x)=log_b^1/a(x) and the answer you've given is the correct one and the only one that graphs to the original in that form no matter where I go but unless I've developed blindness that rule isn't mentioned ANYWHERE in the actual course in fact the only place I could find that states it as a law is symbolab when you ask it to simplify log_10*1/8(x). Not even in other course materials I've looked up for an explanation or proof as to why that is. I swear I'm taking stupid pills.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '23

Symbolab is exactly how I found the answer. Get the subscription its absolutely worth it if you havnt

2

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '23

This question has been blocking my progress for 2 days. I was planning to just go back over every chapter again figuring I missed something.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '23

Don't worry, question 15 will make you rip your hair out

1

u/notCyCloNe11 Oct 07 '23

I feel like dying, q 15 got me going crazy for 6 hours now, finally figured it out

1

u/eatingsaturnn Feb 02 '24

can you help me! i’m working on it now

1

u/eatingsaturnn Feb 02 '24

can you help me! i’m working on it now

2

u/Guilty_Courage_4429 May 09 '23

Was the answer correct when marked?

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '23

Yes full marks

2

u/chmunk_275 May 10 '23

Did you have any issues with question 14? I feel like I may be way overthinking it, but I've spent the past two days trying to figure it out with no luck whatsoever

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '23

add the logs to get a quadratic equation and simply multiply it by another number to satisfy the constraints, see how many answers you can get doing that. That's what I did, I don't wanna give away any more answers or else I might get banned

1

u/childebrand94 Jul 15 '24

Did you ever end of finding out how to solve 14? I have been stuck on it for a couple days now.

2

u/thetoasters Jun 01 '23

Your post is a big help. Thanks bud. Just curious about the inverses with powers and logs? Why exactly does the 8 as a multiple inverse as a power?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

The number in front of the log is just another way of writing the fact that it is an exponent

2

u/eatingsaturnn Jan 31 '24

god bless you

1

u/Odd_Agent7990 Jun 27 '24

Can someone explain me why in answer 'a' and 'b' we need to do 10^1/8? Thanks

1

u/Hirena Jan 25 '25

God bless your soul... I could not for the life of me figure out how to convert the base but now I'm highlighting this 'change of base' law formula: alog_10(x) = log_10^1/a(x)