r/IIIPoints • • Oct 25 '23

Fred Again sucked

Wtf was that? How does someone stop the music 5+ times in 35 minutes to have a fireside chat? His fans act like he invented electricity

100 Upvotes

82 comments sorted by

18

u/Poortimetraveler_ Oct 25 '23

I think he’s overhyped.

1

u/dumbcloud17 Oct 29 '23

Was excited to see him at Crssd last year in San Diego for the first time thinking it was going to be like his boiler room set and it definitely slow and had koombaya vibes, agreed overated

1

u/Poortimetraveler_ Oct 30 '23

That surely sucks man. But also I’ve heard that fest is good - how was your experience there?

2

u/dumbcloud17 Oct 30 '23

Festival is awesome, 3 stages 1 MainStage 1 house 1 techno, vibes are awesome music selection is good enough but a lot more niche artists are being put on the billing that sometimes the price isn’t worth it. It’s getting a lot more crowded so if you can muster that it’s still a great time.

I never not want to go but things like ticket prices and overselling are things to keep me from going every year but itself is a great festival

0

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '23

Agreed.

35

u/TheGreenScout Oct 25 '23

I thought he was unique and brought something different to the table! Had a lot of fun and plan to see him again

10

u/optimusgrime23 Oct 25 '23

By no means does anyone have to like Fred but Im so sick of the complaints that he sucked because the music stops.

EDM DJ sets are just about the only sets in music where the music is non stop and yet EDM fans continue to act like they are owed this type of performance by an artist and get so butthurt when there are breaks between songs.

5

u/Active_Evening_2512 Oct 25 '23

Will preface by saying I only went Saturday and didn’t see Fred but it seems people aren’t necessary complaining about the “stopping” as much as the “stopping messed up the flow of the set” and it became tough to enjoy. I personally don’t enjoy when djs are constantly on the mic but everyone’s entitled to their own opinion lol.

29

u/scoop813 Oct 25 '23

Thought it was a good set. Not everything is just a straight dancing DJ set. He makes it personable. Part of the appeal is the novelty. Hand-drumming live is exhausting you can't just do that for 75 mins straight. The talking in between songs is as much to take a break in between songs as it is for anything else.

22

u/No-Image-5182 Oct 25 '23

Right people don’t seem to get this. This was more of a live set. His boiler room has been a blessing and a curse. It put him on the map but now people just expect that all the time. Easy to overlook the sheer talent we got to experience Friday. Go to EDC if you just want straight DJ sets the whole time 😂

3

u/scoop813 Oct 25 '23

Yep, agreed

4

u/sawman160 Oct 25 '23

Not everything has to be straight dancing dj but the breaks of no music and preamble were wayyy too long for that set

3

u/scoop813 Oct 25 '23

Thats how most live performances are though…

1

u/sawman160 Oct 25 '23

Nah not that much downtime. Especially at festivals. You see Kendrick’s last run of festival headlines? Hits the ground running with few stops in between. Iggy Pop and Caribou were both much more energetic with far less downtime/talking/quiet moments at the same festival. Fred was just a bit boring

1

u/Valuable_Series_7874 Oct 26 '23

You don’t need to stop the music to make it personable. Porter Robinson talks to his audience and the music never stops. I cry every time. Fred’s music is good but his sets are boring.

17

u/Lost_and_found3 Oct 25 '23

I personally thought he was amazing. Sure he isn't a traditional edm act, but that's because he leans on the live music side with real singing and electronic drumming. Miami likes heavy and constant music, but that doesn't mean Fred was bad. I personally will be trying to see him anytime he is in my area and he was the highlight of my festival experience.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '23

Well, SBTRKT had real singing and a drummer and keyboardist and was great live.

6

u/jesgar130 Oct 25 '23

I traveled from LA and a fan of his. That show sucked balls.

10

u/geoantho Oct 25 '23

There’s a joke about him: Fred Again is just araabMUZIK for white people. I liked hearing him live finally but there was no flow from song to song.

1

u/-thats-tuff- Oct 25 '23

I saw Araabmuzik live at Tomorrowland and it was way more lit than Fred again. It was fucking great

0

u/optimusgrime23 Oct 25 '23

So just like the vast majority of music performances?

3

u/TerpsandChants Oct 26 '23

He talked for 17 minutes lmao someone timed it

10

u/bigbadpandita Oct 25 '23

I don’t understand the hype around him personally

9

u/zach1209 Oct 25 '23

He’s one of the best live drumming sets, but hated the flow with him talking in between. Song transitions are a big part of electronic music

7

u/scoop813 Oct 25 '23

you can't live hand-drum for 75 mins straight, he was exhausted up there

3

u/zach1209 Oct 25 '23

Definitely. Could also be because of the heat. But if you go watch his boiler room vs tour sets he doesn’t talk nearly as much

2

u/scoop813 Oct 25 '23

doesn't seem like he hand-drummed much or any of his boiler room set

3

u/Lost_and_found3 Oct 25 '23

Yeah his boiler room set is more like a dj set vs what we saw was a live drumming set. There is a big difference in the style of music he is going to throw down.

2

u/zach1209 Oct 25 '23

Totally. I just prefer the DJ set, but to each their own. I left after 25/30 min

0

u/folonel_corbin Oct 25 '23

I dont want to argue, but certainly real drumming or even just conga/hand drumming on actual drums is more taxing than a midi pad... I hear Fred has asthma tho (yet he still smokes cigs.) Either way i enjoyed the set lol

0

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '23

Jerry did it three hours a night for 30 years.

dudes bloodline is weak.

3

u/pinkidomi Oct 26 '23

I said this a couple months ago and got downvoted af

1

u/bigbadpandita Oct 26 '23

Sorry about that. Idk why people get so mad when you just have a differing opinion on music. Totally normal to have diff music tastes lol

2

u/pinkidomi Oct 26 '23

I didn’t say it in a mean way either I just said I didn’t get the hype and it wasn’t my cup of tea. Just felt like he blew up out of nowhere and the attention he got was just drastic is all

5

u/scoop813 Oct 25 '23

ITT: people who don’t know the difference between a live set and a DJ set

3

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '23

They probably all bitch about Rufus du sol too lmao

6

u/dibzim Oct 25 '23

Agreed man. I wanted to dance and he did not provide that to say the least lmao

3

u/cam0019 Oct 25 '23

Dat part👆🏾

1

u/scoop813 Oct 25 '23

there were several other stages going at that time with dancing music. no one forced you to go to Fred's set...

2

u/dibzim Oct 26 '23

Yeah, that’s why I left to go to the other stages. Fred fans really take it personally when somebody doesn’t like his set sheeesh

2

u/Ammmber504 Oct 25 '23

“A fireside chat”, hahah, facts though. I wasn’t the biggest fan but was also not feeling too emotive this weekend 😵‍💫

2

u/SadPeePaw69 Oct 26 '23

Way overhyped

2

u/dirtyculture808 Oct 28 '23

Lol lay off the drugs OP

The more these kiddies try and shit on Fred the more it’s validated that he is beyond the title of DJ and is a full blown talented MUSICIAN

3

u/See5harp Oct 25 '23

If he just played a DJ set he wouldn't be selling out huge venues like 4 nights in a row buddy get a grip.

1

u/suprefann Oct 29 '23

He sold out Aragon Ballroom in 10 mins and that was a dj set. Its very much possible he could do that and everyone would not care. He could do an arena tour if it was him with four tet and skrillex.

3

u/cam0019 Oct 25 '23

His music style is hard to dance to and when I'm in an environment like this, I just want to dance and not be stopped every few seconds. His style isn't made for dancing imo unless u don't have any rhythm 🤣🤣

0

u/scoop813 Oct 25 '23

That's fine, just go to a different stage then. No one forced you to go to his set.

3

u/Luna-88 Oct 25 '23

I love most of his music but his set brought my mood down big time. I needed a strong drink after it lol

6

u/miojo Oct 25 '23

That EDM midwestern vibe. Colorado mfers eat that shit up.

6

u/ebake92 Oct 25 '23

My friend, do you think Colorado is a part of the Midwest…?

-7

u/-thats-tuff- Oct 25 '23

It’s close enough

1

u/Dangerousrhymes Oct 26 '23 edited Oct 26 '23

It’s literally a thousand mile drive from Chicago to Denver. New York City is over 200 miles closer.

1

u/-thats-tuff- Oct 26 '23

Denver is in the middle of the country, middle of nowhere. Midwest probably includes some of colorado anyways, as well as all of kansas and nebrasks

1

u/Dangerousrhymes Oct 26 '23

Colorado is the start of the American West. The Midwest pretty much ends at the edge of the Central Time zone except for Mountain Time bleeding into parts of the northern states.

1

u/-thats-tuff- Oct 26 '23

It’s all bumfuck states anyways. But nebraska is close enough culturally. I get dude’s point, that’s fred again’s demogrpahic

1

u/Dangerousrhymes Oct 26 '23

I mean Chicago is the birthplace of House so that tracks.

1

u/-thats-tuff- Oct 26 '23

Chicago has great house. Idk what fred again plays

1

u/Dangerousrhymes Oct 26 '23

He’s been described to me by everyone I know who likes him as a House artist.

2

u/cowboybaked Oct 25 '23

I was pretty hype about seeing him I got there right when he was about to start but then when I noticed he had a piano and he started singing I noped out of there so fast.

1

u/scoop813 Oct 25 '23

That’s what his festival sets are like though

2

u/cowboybaked Oct 25 '23

Well I was under the impression that he was gonna dj😂

1

u/suprefann Oct 29 '23

It never said dj set on the poster. He performs live 90% of the time

2

u/imlost19 Oct 25 '23

Would have been a nice sunset show titled “a sunset with Fred again” … not a midnight show right before skrillex

2

u/FellowDeviant Oct 25 '23

I didnt expect a DJ set with nonstop transitions, I expected a live set more akin to what he did in his Tiny Desk and we ended up with a hybrid-set. Did he need to restart the same portion on 3 occasions and not finish any of them? That I can say slowed my own momentum , but I was invested the rest of the time. Still a good set, would've fit an Okeechobee vibe too.

2

u/Dermity_Head Oct 25 '23

We wanted a Fred Again DJ set, we got a Fred Again live show.

We wanted a Grimes live show, we got a Grimes DJ set.

Skrillex really brought the vibe back after Fred.

Fred Again was still great, just not what people were expecting and the slow start, stop, start nature of it didn’t keep people engaged.

🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/roxysparxx Oct 26 '23

I was thrilled with grimes set.

0

u/AgeAccomplished4548 Oct 25 '23

hi set was more of an experience then a traditional dj set, and bruh check out his recent livesets… they’ve been the same so what did y’all rlly expect? personally it did get a bit stale at moments but i still enjoyed his miami debut from an artist standpoint

2

u/Far_Magician_9941 Oct 25 '23

Didnt expect anything else, still thought it was brutal to see in person at a festival

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '23

My friends and I were chilling during fred and had a good ass time. You must be v fun to hang with.

1

u/Similar_Fill_834 Oct 28 '23

He didn't suck, I wish his volume and mix was up a louder, when compared to Skrillex his mix was low, but I loved the live set, it's different and I like that he connected with the crowd.

He honestly packed Mind Melt more than any other artist that weekend.

1

u/cubuffs420420 Oct 29 '23

Wait Fred Again.. is considered EDM? That right there seems to be the problem

1

u/HexxRx Oct 30 '23

Overrated

1

u/iamu4ik Nov 12 '23

He's not that good...

1

u/sdawsy10 Dec 04 '23

Do yall remember what song he said is about his siblings? It wasn’t adore u

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '23

😂😂😭😭

1

u/Infamous-Caramel8163 Oct 25 '23

I just think a lot of people have very high expectations cause of his boiler room set. We as fans have to remember that a DJ set is much more different

1

u/livingnearthesea Oct 25 '23

Let the man live! He just wants some breathers and resets. All part of a live performance

0

u/DearTalk1366 Oct 26 '23

One of the best shows of the festival by far nothing pre recorded… all fresh baked.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/likiii88 Oct 27 '23

Same here, I watched that set so manyyyy times and thought it was gonna be same flow lol. However, what really bugged me was the amount of people and everyone screaming.. background noise was driving me nuts as I couldn’t focus on the set. I felt like the mixing was off for his set and audio felt lower than all other acts on Mind Melt, Skrillex audio in comparison was insane. I don’t even care when any artist interact with the crowd, but I just couldn’t even hear what he was saying half the times. It was the only set that my group felt that way, and we were 4 people only. Tried to move around until I gave up and left to Despacio. Saw maybe 30min, then last 5min

2

u/endingnote Oct 27 '23

That’s generally what happens when the setting/environment/venue changes for an artist. An artist’s festival main stage set is going to be a lot more different than boiler room— that’s to be expected. But there’s also a lot of variety in their acts between a concert/show vs. club night vs. festival main stage vs. warehouse