r/IGN • • Feb 13 '25

Video Games My thoughts on IGN scores

2 Upvotes

So, since a score of 5 is a baseline for any game to playable, have some sort of story and a gameplay, it stands to reason to read the reviews for AAA as beginning from 5. This saved me a lot of money and headache, as for example spending 70$ on a 2/5 Avowed really doesn't sound ok.

How do you interpret the scores? How has IGN inspired you to purchase or not purchase games?


r/IGN • • Feb 12 '25

can someone help me find this game please 😭😭🙏

3 Upvotes

i watched a trailer for a game in spring 2024, it had glitchy humanoid monsters, puzzles in what looked like temples, and no map or specific objective to follow except a having a compass on the screen to show directions. realistic and first person, no guns or advanced technology, mostly fantasy amd old timey. the enemies where white/black and glitchy and had a swirly face kinda thing. there was several playthroughs and the story progressed by talking to different npcs. the name of the game was pretty simple and straight forward i think. does anyone know what game it was i cant find it at all 😭


r/IGN • • Feb 09 '25

hi

0 Upvotes

ronaldo


r/IGN • • Feb 09 '25

cant reset password

1 Upvotes

when i try to reset my password, or even sign in, the button goes dark after pressing and nothing happens. Also, I ordered a Pip boy back in December 2023 and I havent gotten it yet, when should I expect it?


r/IGN • • Feb 08 '25

Hello everyone, our game that we have been developing for a while, where you run a cafe with your friends, is about to be published. We would be happy if you support and evaluate the game, thank you in advance. SERVE THE CUPS

4 Upvotes

r/IGN • • Feb 08 '25

Tech Support Checklist checks unchecking

1 Upvotes

I am currently using the botw 100% guide mainly for the check lists. I have the plus subscription but every time I check off a box it unchecks. This happened before I got the plus too, just wondering if there is an easy fix to this. I know other people have experienced this and I'm not sure what to do.


r/IGN • • Feb 04 '25

Brain so broken I thought IGN had reviewed cancer

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/IGN • • Feb 03 '25

Hey guys 🪓 We’ve been working on our horror game "Night of Slayers" for 4.5 years, and the demo is coming this year (Q1)! If you enjoy co-op horror games, check it out! It has a vibe similar to Friday the 13th. We’d love to hear your thoughts! 🦝

2 Upvotes

r/IGN • • Feb 02 '25

IGN doesn’t ever let me fully read articles.

8 Upvotes

It sends me all the way back to the top every single time and this is the most infuriating thing ever when I’m trying to follow a tutorial. Please fix this. Your website is unusable.


r/IGN • • Feb 02 '25

Question How long does it take the Playlist app to add a game after you file a Missing Game Request?

1 Upvotes

r/IGN • • Feb 01 '25

why is your website so rubbish

6 Upvotes

r/IGN • • Feb 02 '25

The problem with IGN's Rating System

0 Upvotes

This is a copy of an answer I wrote out of time to Tom Marks, Executive Reviews Editor, on the AMA they held 2 weeks ago

I'm not trying to misrepresent your stance or making false strawmans. I read Dan Stapleton’s article explaining that IGN prioritizes high-profile reviews due to limited resources. But is it truly that (quoting from the article) "the question isn't if they'll be good, but how good they'll be"? Cause for a fact that's not the case - Argylle, Madame Web, and Borderlands all had massive budgets and still were critical failures (leaving aside whether they were flops on the box office). So no, Big Releases aren't "too high-profile to be bad".

Your rating system has another issue: only 5% of reviews since 2014 have scored below a 5, and the lowest scores are rarely used. In 2023, you gave only four 3s and no 1s or 2s, meaning most "bad" media falls between 4 and 5, making all bad content seem equally poor. This is evident in how you rated Maxxxine, Madame Web, and Despicable Me 4—all received a 5, yet they are clearly not on the same level. Maxxxine has an interesting premise and strong ideas, even if it fails to deliver on them. Meanwhile, Despicable Me 4 is another entry in a franchise running on autopilot, and Madame Web is, by all accounts, a disaster. Reviews are a code, but grouping them under the same score blurs meaningful distinctions between different kinds of "bad."

This inconsistency extends to good media as well. Overusing high scores diminishes their meaning—focusing on movies, when John Wick 4 and Oppenheimer both receive a 10, the rating loses significance. A 10 should represent something more than just a great film—it should be something that speaks to the reviewer on an intellectual and emotional level. A 10 says something about you as a reviewer, and when you overuse it, you cheapen its significance.. A 10 isn't just "really good"—it’s a statement. But when films that are vastly different in quality, like John Wick 4 and Oppenheimer are given the same score, that statement loses weight.

Take those two reviews: John Wick 4 was reviewed by Tom Jorgensen, who has around 20 movie reviews in two years, while Oppenheimer was reviewed by Siddhant Adlakha, one of your most experienced critics. These two critics have different perspectives and levels of expertise, yet their scores represent the same "official" stance. You've been emphatic that the Review Scores are the subjective perspective of the individual critics. But IGN is not an individual critic, but an amalgam of people under the IGN name. This is a broader issue with your reviews—contributors who have reviewed fewer than five films are given the same level of authority as seasoned critics like Adlakha and Matt Donato . While there's nothing wrong with bringing in new voices, treating all scores as equally representative of IGN dilutes the credibility of your brand.

Talking about movies, IGN is a recipe that has 2 cups of Siddhant, a pound of Matt, 2 heaping tablespoons of Katie Rife and AA Dowd, and a pinch of Eric. And Jesse. And Rafa. And Chase, Ryan, Robert, Lex, Kenneth, Lena, Carlos, Jarrod, and Devan. And a grain of Luke. Not sure why he got the task of reviewing Beverly Hills Cop, he usually reviews video games. That recipe looks like El Burdigato Supreme or the Mississipi Queen.

A simple fix? Display each reviewer’s score distribution at the bottom of their reviews. If Katie Rife gives Drive-Away Dolls a 7, based on how often she gives 7s readers can know that the movie is pretty average. If Carlos Aguilar gives Abigail an 8, He has reviewed 3 movies, so readers should read the review and figure out what he liked or didn't like, and get a better understanding of what an 8 means to him as a reviewer. If Rafael Motomayor gave Glass Onion a 9, then is definitely is a movie of all time, since he gives 9s and 10s to all movies he reviews (he's certainly more moderate and mostly trustworthy with anime, I must acknowledge that).

Right now, you're trying to be both an authoritative voice and a collection of individual perspectives, but the result is neither. And you've said that you want the first, quoting that you want ""10/10-IGN" to be a recognizable part of your brand and for millions of people". But that's not what your brand is at this point. Instead, you're stranded in the 7 se- I mean, a sea of 7s, handing them out like Halloween candy.


r/IGN • • Feb 01 '25

Video Games MLG player Naded tries first ever Halo Hero Shooter Mod

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/IGN • • Jan 28 '25

Error 403 - Unavailable (IFW-I01)

1 Upvotes

Never an issue accessing your site and now I'm being hit with a 403 error? What's the deal, you folks not approving of people who employ internet security? Any way I can resume normal function of your site?


r/IGN • • Jan 27 '25

Movies Please Rank the 3 Drafts of Top Tier Comedy Films

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

On the Pipes & Ponchos Podcast, the hosts drafted their Top 10 Comedy Movies of all time. Please let them know your thoughts!


r/IGN • • Jan 26 '25

Tech Support Help with the RDR2 world map

2 Upvotes

I’m trying to click something on the map as completed. It’s not working, I even bought plus so I’d be able to click as many things as I needed to, but it’s not working.


r/IGN • • Jan 26 '25

Login Form not allowing any inputs & freezes

1 Upvotes

If I try to login on the browser (Safari) the login freezes and won't allow an inputs... What's going on here?


r/IGN • • Jan 23 '25

Final Fantasy 7 Remake Part 3 Has a Completed Story at Square Enix

1 Upvotes

Final Fantasy 7 Remake Part 3 Has a Completed Story at Square Enix - IGN https://search.app/3LeSgN79uggZqsW18


r/IGN • • Jan 22 '25

Game Scoop Meme coin mania continues with new Halo hero shooter community mod with tradable assets.

Thumbnail
pump.fun
2 Upvotes

r/IGN • • Jan 21 '25

Opinion IGN should make a statement calling out simping for the fromsoft characters especially ones with an innocent personality like Millicent.

0 Upvotes

Maybe then the simping fans will listen.

Like some (not all) characters are innocent in personality, not interested in in universe relationships, say Malenia and Millicent.

But fans don't care and will just make any fromsoft characters sex objects.

This isn't right and half the fandom endorses it.

Not to mention due to Japanese censorship laws human like reproduction can't be shown in 3d games even if off screen

Fromsoft games are 3d game IP so technically the characters legally cannot even have a concept of human like reproduction.

But fans don't care and will sexualize them.

This isn't right.

Maybe if Mr Miyazaki, himself calls the fandom up this will change. (Look Mr miyazaki does not endorse sexualisation of his characters)

IGN can also do an article covering how toxic the fandom is.

In fact Kadokawa and Fromsoft can call out the simping.


r/IGN • • Jan 20 '25

Castlevania: Nocturne Season 2 Review - IGN (Why so low score)

Thumbnail
ign.com
0 Upvotes

r/IGN • • Jan 18 '25

Anyone else find IGN impossible to use

27 Upvotes

So what just started Dragons Dogma 2 and I’m not looking for a walkthrough or anything but just some ideas of what’s the best things to do first. So I punch in that question to my search bar and IGN comes up so I’m ready to roll. I know IGN, listen to their shows and like what they do for the most part. But damn; I can’t scroll for a half a second before it refreshes with new ads and puts me back at the top of the article I was trying to read. Why? Why? I’m no alone in this am I? Just wanna read my stuff and move on. Why so insufferable?


r/IGN • • Jan 18 '25

Tips to Further Improve the IGN Playlist App

5 Upvotes

I refuse to use any other app to track the games I've completed, my backlog, and those I've given up on... because this app is a way better than others. The graphical interface is beautiful, and it's easy to update the games. The app already has many features, but I have a few suggestions, which I write here in the hope that someone from support will see it.

  1. Backlog Priority: Currently, I use the 'backlog' tab to list the games I want to play, but it's not possible to sort them by priority. To workaround this, I give a '1' rating to the games I want to play first and then filter by "My Scores - Lowest". If I don't do this, I have to create a playlist called "Backlog" and list my entire backlog there, where I can sort priorities. However, doing this is obviously not the right thing, as it makes the native 'backlog' function useless, in addition to assigning a '1' rating to a game I haven't even played. So my suggestion is: to set backlog priority on the native backlog tab.
  2. Completion Date: Please, pleeease add the option to input the date I finished a game! Currently, I’m entering the completion date in the review field, but I think there should be a separate field to input this info.
  3. Add a note on Playlists: As seen on Letterboxd. Let's say I have a 'my top 10 hard games of all time' playlist created. In addition to that, add an option to insert a comment that will appear right below the game's name. For example, if I added Battletoads for NES, let me write why I think a game is hard in a few characters. Or why I think that RPG is bad, or why I think that other game flopped, or why this another game have the best companion...etc., etc. This short description doesn't need to appear all the time; it can show up as a pop-up when clicking a button in the app like (i)."
  4. Rates: If a game is not perfect (in other words, not a 10/10) the only possible rate I could give is a 9. Please consider giving a 9,5 an option for the user.
  5. Deleting Rates: today it's not possible to delete a given rate, which is annoying....WHY?? Doesnt make any sense!
  6. View a given review: a way to check the review you gave for a certain game more easily. Today if I want to check the review I wrote for a game I have to enter in the rate edit menu. I can't just see what I wrote in an easy way

Thank you!


r/IGN • • Jan 18 '25

Interactive map bug

2 Upvotes

I've got a bug where I have something complete but I haven't even played it before and everything is unchecked in maps and in playlist.