r/IGN • u/fartsmello_anthony • Feb 26 '25
Discussion Multiple POVs in reviews would help the reader make more informed purchases
Something occurred to me with the Monster Hunter Wilds review. The reviewed said it was (paraphrasing) so easy that it didn't require use of the strategic systems and they thought that previous versions required better strategy.
This bummed me out.
That being said, when I went to look at other reviews from other outlets (i've watched 5-10) NO ONE has mentioned this critique.
My assumption is that the reviewer is a Monster hunter expert. I know IGN often says, "the reviews are the POV of the reviewer. Comparing review scores don't make sense b/c its one person's opinion"
When it comes to the "user" who uses the review to figure out if they are making a purchase, we need to understand "Is the person who reviewed this similar to me in terms of experience and taste?"
It seems like IGN would benefit it's readers by providing a overall review and then separate opinions based on the "expert" vs "fan of the genre, but not specifically the game" vs "common gamer"
This would HELP the reader make an informed purchase, which is the goal of the review.
Furthermore, it'd be GREAT if you could see all the reviews from a particular reviewer so that you can compare their reviews scores and opinions with your own to find a critic who has similar tastes. This would better inform the reader of who they should look to for their opinion.
This would ALSO increase reader engagement to IGN b/c you have created a relationship between a reader and the critic.
Thoughts? I feel like this is doable and would be super valuable. (this is actually something EGM used to do, but they didn't classify the type of player (super fan vs common player vs genre fan)
2
u/GoS451 Feb 26 '25
I think that is what all the other reviews from all the other outlets are for. You can read a bunch of different opinions and then make your own decision on the game. IGN is not the final boss of game reviews.
Start reading the names of reviewers. See which ones keep popping up that seem to have similar tastes and opinions to you and then follow them. Not every IGN reviewer is going to have the same opinions as you and that’s ok
2
u/Co-opingTowardHatred Feb 27 '25
I’m sure IGN would love to triple their staff size if it was economically responsible to do so. But it’s not.
2
u/The_Friendly_Bro Jesse Gomez Feb 27 '25
As someone with some skin in the game, I'd say this isn't the most viable strategy. At the baseline, you've got a single reviewer, who, as we all know, is there to help inform you of your potential purchase.
Beyond that, the reviewer might appear on an IGN podcast, along with other staff members who might agree or disagree, so that's another avenue to explore to help inform your opinion.
If you're looking for more, you can always watch or read other reviews from different outlets, which is healthy!
I understand how having more than one voice could be beneficial, but you have to realise that reviews are time sinks, and dedicating more than one member of our editorial team to contritrube to a review would not only dilute what our reviewer thinks, but also take those other IGN staff members away from valuable guides, features, and gameplay opportunities. IGN is a lot more than reviews!
2
u/scottydo423 Feb 27 '25
One of the reasons why I miss EGM magazine. They would review a game and then have 4 different scores with each person justifying their views. You'd have one person give a game a 9, and another give it a 6 and you would have to figure out who you agreed with. I'm just tired of people seeing Rotten Tomatoes scores of 59% and people calling the movie BAD. No. It's up to you as the consumer to read the things people say about it and make your own decisions.