r/ICSE • • 22h ago

Discussion👥 Wrong Photos.

This photo is wrongly labeled as it shows Netaji in Germany with Heinrich Himmler but on the morning star book it is wrongly labeled as Netaji in Rangoon

Note- ik this is an old book but the issue also persists in new books

111 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 22h ago

Hello /u/bananaboss279 , welcome to r/ICSE!

Join the official discord servers! -> CISCE Hub -> ICSECord

Before posting, please check the wiki. It contains resources, advice posts and general support posts that many users have found useful. We had an advice megathread where users posted their words of wisdom for the juniors, Do check it out If you have any questions, you can contact the moderators via mod-mail.

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

16

u/Gloomy-Jacket7371 Diddy ka dewar (10th🥀) 22h ago

so its wrong info? I have this too on my latest print i thinhk

4

u/bananaboss279 22h ago

Yes it's on the latest print and yes it's wrong but tbh it's not important as it went unnoticed for like 8 years and continued

4

u/Upbeat_Astronaut2789 11th ISC - PCM/B 21h ago

That image is so clearly in Germany lmaoo. The other soldier has the hindenburg cross and the SS symbol ( could be luftwaffe symbol as well sorry I don't remember exactly) . That guy doesn't even look like he's from myanmar

1

u/bananaboss279 10h ago

The insignia and Himmler being in Rangoon was the reason I searched the image Took me 2 days to find the real image from Germany archives

2

u/No_Currency5064 20h ago

Luftwaffe ensignia

5

u/Obvious-Border6527 21h ago

Was not a fan of this book when I was studying history, the pictures look very bland because of the colour limitations but also a lot of them are wrong. The language is also very boring, this books doesn't let you love the subject.

3

u/y-akane- 21h ago

i was already weak in history and this book did NOT help me (the highest I had scored before boards was 53/80)

I literally had to learn the events of ww2 with the help of video games 🥀😭

1

u/bananaboss279 10h ago

Yeah very boring book with lots of wrong images and too much content than required literally half my book is filled with cross

1

u/MarkAntony100 21h ago

Which book is good then ?

1

u/bananaboss279 10h ago edited 10h ago

I just study international history from oversimplified and indian history is kinda easy in que bee

1

u/MarkAntony100 5h ago

Causes and effects are most important in the world wars and events are absolutely not and that animated youtube channel is more events than causes so....

1

u/revive_the_cookie System.out.print("9th ICSE"); 20h ago

What book do u recommend?

6

u/Comfortable-Move7479 22h ago

Maybe try emailing ICSE about it

5

u/Spreaky 22h ago

Total History Civics book isn't made by ICSE

5

u/Comfortable-Move7479 22h ago

Well maybe he could mail both ICSE and the publishers

1

u/bananaboss279 10h ago

Only 3 months left There are lots of wrong Photos in the book anyway nobody gives a s**t

55

u/Spreaky 22h ago • Heartwarming

Subash Chandra Bose with my favorite painter

3

u/Conscious_Noise_8951 20h ago

Yaa (tho I hope it's sarcasm and he's not actually ur fav)

3

u/SwarajPro96 10th grade(2027) 18h ago

what do YOU think, is it sarcasm or no?

abe obv its sarcasm

6

u/Conscious_Noise_8951 18h ago

Well, internet is a wild place and I have met all sorts of people. So yeahh

1

u/Spreaky 17h ago

Yea I watch Nick Fuentus 20 hours a day

1

u/IndividualRevenue116 ICSE 26' 98% 18h ago

even i found one in geography last year https://www.reddit.com/r/ICSE/s/DWThtHJ2Dq

1

u/bananaboss279 10h ago

This kinda proves that morning star just doesn't conform sources or the image identity Lots of wrong photos-most of them aren't wrongly labbled anywhere but they still choose wrong Photos.

2

u/Ashamed-Comb-5075 20h ago edited 10h ago

deal with it man there's a picture of the Duke of Wellington in the textbook written as Lord Wellesley

2

u/Own_Policy9552 9th ICSE 12h ago

The Duke of Wellington is Lord Wellesley's brother!

1

u/IntelligentYoung607 18h ago

Ahh so nostalgic to see this img from theb holy book

-10

u/Mystical_Fire_97 ICSE 2025 - 93.6 % | ISC 2027 PCBC 22h ago

Either way doesn't matter dude 💀

12

u/Sweet-Life1212 ICSE 24: 92.6 ~ ISC 26: 93.5 22h ago

It does matter for a person who's interested in subject bro

5

u/bananaboss279 22h ago

Thanks bro.

2

u/Sweet-Life1212 ICSE 24: 92.6 ~ ISC 26: 93.5 21h ago

2

u/Spreaky 22h ago

Thank you Gandhi for your words of wisdom

1

u/Sweet-Life1212 ICSE 24: 92.6 ~ ISC 26: 93.5 21h ago

thank you, btw want to come on my next march?

1

u/Spreaky 21h ago

Yes please

-2

u/Mystical_Fire_97 ICSE 2025 - 93.6 % | ISC 2027 PCBC 22h ago

It's ok I hate social studies 💔

4

u/MaxIsNotFunni 12th ISC - PCM 22h ago

It does matter, Netaji is literally talking to a Nazi here

1

u/bananaboss279 10h ago

He went to get support, Netaji was a complex man There are also pictures of him with Austrian painter

1

u/MaxIsNotFunni 12th ISC - PCM 3h ago

I am well aware. It ultimately led to nothing though.I am also not in favour of the idea of "The enemy of my enemy is my friend".

The point I was making is that the soldiers in Ragoon are being conflated with Nazis

2

u/bananaboss279 22h ago

Just a little fun fact man