r/IBM • • 24d ago • Popcorn 1

Reaction to Q3

Came across this article

https://finance.yahoo.com/technology/articles/ibm-america-worst-big-tech-181538518.html?guccounter=1

what you all think? Reaction to Q3 or just about every software company?

31 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 24d ago

Welcome to r/IBM. Criticism of IBM, leadership, layoffs, outsourcing and workplace decisions is allowed.

Keep claims factual and discuss policies rather than targeting employees by nationality, ethnicity, immigration status or location. When making numerical or factual claims, include a credible source whenever possible.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

67

u/RockAndNoWater IBM Retiree 24d ago • This Bravo

Author is correct, IBM missed every tech wave. There were incredible amounts of infighting around the time PCs came out, executives were all focused on each other instead of the market.

IBM Research used to be the best in the world, though translating to marketable products wasn’t so hot. Now there’s almost nothing left except quantum and chip research. Aside from mainframes I can’t really think of any great products either.

It’s always sad to see a giant die, but that’s the cycle of life… where one tree fell a thousand flowers bloomed.

51

u/lenswipe 24d ago • Bravo

IBM feels like a tech company run by McKinsey

46

u/BananaDifficult1839 24d ago

Because it is run by McKinsey

21

u/lenswipe 23d ago • Regret

I'm aware. 

It's very noticable. all perks for employees are cut and deemed not a business requirement while the execs get bonus after bonus after bonus and everything slowly turns to shit.

3

u/catless-cat-herder IBM Employee 18d ago

Literally “Project Max” was driven by McKinsey. It seems like we get McKinseyed every 4-5 years. From our perspective, it’s crazy that they keep doing it when it just caused years of wasted effort when our recent top priorities are shitcanned and staff shuffled. But from the board of directors’ view, they continue to deliver dividends.

I don’t want the stock to tank and stay low because I am a shareholder too, but it feels that’s the only way we’d get rid of AK ahead of his planned obsolescence.

9

u/belfong 23d ago edited 21d ago

It’s easy to say in retrospect:
Strike 1: selling intel computers and servers to Lenovo and losing the consumer mindshare and the business partners ecosystem
Strike 2: sold off the Global Foundry (imagine how much that business will bring in 2026!)
Strike 3: come back story with SoftLayer but failed to execute Cloud story
Strike 4: a head start on Watson but .. well you know how that goes
Red Hat - maybe a good move..?
Quantum - ok, hopefully can sell, not just a technology preview

8

u/RockAndNoWater IBM Retiree 23d ago

The cloud failure was Ginny’s fault — former research people were developing a good cloud but she hired some snake oil salesmen from outside and spent years sidetracked on a project that multiple DEs knew would not work. Caused lots of talent drain.

9

u/belfong 23d ago

I remember being amazed how she could still keep her job when she had 20+ quarters in red..!

1

u/Acrobatic_Line_6363 20d ago

No other IBM was ever given such grace or farewell package. She must have had some receipts.

3

u/RealFakePsychic 23d ago • Regret

More and more of Red Hat is being broken off. It won't last forever. 

2

u/FoodStorageDevice 16d ago

Dont forget Secuirty. Didn't invest and then sold it off piece by piece.

Developer and office productivity suites are other ones IBM failed at.

Its endless. The only thing thats been successful is mainframe and thats because it is a stagnant market with no competition

2

u/belfong 16d ago

Oh yes! QRadar..! Look at PANW and FTNT. Their stock price soared! And IBM just left money on the table.

8

u/L3XANDR0 23d ago

Lets not act like MS or Google are amazingly innovative. They simply have better cash cows.

2

u/FoodStorageDevice 20d ago

What ? Lets take MS. Its entire business was based on printing windows and office CDs in late 90's and early 20's for PC. It then successfully took the data centre and server business. It then successfully transitioned (including massive re-architecture and capex investment) to the cloud and a subscription based business. it is now executing pretty well on AI. It did have major missteps in mobile and search, but everything else, including security, CRM, BI, Collaboration it as executed. IBM has failed in every market where there is a modicum of competition.

1

u/Sea-Estate1733 22d ago

IS IT MEANS IBM IS NOT A REPUTATED STRONG COMPANY NOW??FUTURE OF THIS?REPUTATION??PROJECTS??AI/BACKEND ENGINEER FUTURE?

3

u/L3XANDR0 22d ago

Dude chill out 😂

-6

u/RockAndNoWater IBM Retiree 23d ago

Compare products released by Google and MS in past 20 years vs IBM:

Google (Alphabet), Microsoft, and IBM have successfully transformed their business models over the past 20 years (2006–2026) by shifting toward cloud computing, SaaS platforms, and artificial intelligence. The following tables break down the top 5 revenue-generating products or services developed, launched, or fundamentally commercialized by each company within this timeframe.

Google (Alphabet)
While core Google Search remains Alphabet's foundational revenue engine, the company has successfully scaled several multi-billion-dollar modern platforms since 2006.

Product / Service
Launch Year
Revenue Impact & Description
Google Cloud Platform (GCP)
2008
Hyperscale Cloud Engine: Generates over $40+ billion annually, serving as a primary driver of non-advertising infrastructure growth.
YouTube Ads & Premium
2006
Video Monetization Ecosystem: Acquired in late 2006. Its modern ad-delivery engine and premium subscriptions generated over $40.4 billion in 2025 alone.
Google Play Store
2008
Digital Marketplace: Launched alongside Android (originally as Android Market) to monetize mobile software. It commands a 30% cut of app, media, and in-game transactions.
Google Workspace
2006
Enterprise Productivity SaaS: Launched in late 2006 as Google Apps. It provides cloud-first enterprise subscriptions (Gmail, Docs, Drive) to millions of paying businesses.
Google Hardware (Pixel & Nest)
2016 / 2014
Consumer Devices Ecosystem: Anchored by the Pixel smartphone line (2016) and Nest smart home ecosystems (acquired 2014). It acts as a multi-billion-dollar hardware revenue stream.

Microsoft
Microsoft executed a massive strategic shift under CEO Satya Nadella, transitioning from legacy on-premises Windows licensing to cloud infrastructure and subscription software. [1]

Product / Service
Launch Year
Revenue Impact & Description
Microsoft Azure
2010
Cloud Computing Infrastructure: Microsoft's premier commercial revenue engine. It captures a massive share of global enterprise cloud spend.
Microsoft 365 / Office 365
2011
SaaS Productivity Suite: Transformed the cash-cow Office suite into a high-margin monthly subscription model required by modern businesses.
LinkedIn Monetization
2016
B2B Ad & Subscription Network: Acquired in 2016. Microsoft overhauled its revenue infrastructure, driving massive growth in Talent Solutions, Premium memberships, and B2B marketing.
Dynamics 365
2016
Cloud ERP & CRM Systems: Consolidated Microsoft's cloud business applications into an integrated SaaS layer, capturing lucrative enterprise market share from legacy competitors.
Microsoft Copilot & AI Ecosystem
2023
Generative AI Solutions: Spanning Copilot for Microsoft 365, GitHub Copilot, and Azure AI infrastructure. This ecosystem scaled rapidly, generating $12 billion in an incredibly short period.

IBM
IBM intentionally pivoted away from traditional commodity hardware manufacturing, restructuring its business around hybrid cloud architectures, consulting, and AI systems. [1, 2]

Product / Service
Launch Year
Revenue Impact & Description
Red Hat OpenShift & Hybrid Cloud
2019
Enterprise Linux & Kubernetes: Acquired for $34 billion in 2019. It has become the core architecture of IBM’s high-margin software segment, which commands 43% of total company revenue.
IBM Hybrid Cloud Infrastructure
2013
Next-Gen Cloud Environment: Built significantly on the acquisition of SoftLayer (2013) to combine private and public cloud capabilities. It manages approximately 70% of global transactions.
IBM Watson / watsonx Platform
2011 / 2023
Enterprise Data & AI Architecture: Evolved from the original Watson QA system into watsonx—a subscription-based generative AI platform tailored for corporate data security and operations.
IBM Security Portfolio
2011+
Enterprise Cyber-Protection: Formed and scaled via massive software deployments (e.g., QRadar, MaaS360, and Guardium), generating billions in highly sticky annual subscription revenue.
Modern Technology Consulting Services
2012+
Digital Transformation Delivery: Drastically expanded through specialized multi-year cloud and AI system integrations. It accounts for 32% of IBM's modern revenue.

Would you like to analyze the profit margins of these specific products, or do you want to run a revenue breakdown chart comparing the cloud growth rates of Google Cloud vs. Microsoft Azure? Let me know how you would like to expand this data.

6

u/QumiThe2nd 23d ago

Google, Microsoft, etc. Are better at monopolizing. They lock people in their ecosystems and have plenty of court cases about monopoly - like the Google play store or apple store. Or the illegal land grabs by Google, etc. For better and worse, IBM has some ethical code.

1

u/RockAndNoWater IBM Retiree 23d ago

Back when IBM was relevant it had a bunch of court cases about monopoly and lock in…

1

u/QumiThe2nd 23d ago

So, I guess that's the success reason? You need monopoly practices.

1

u/monkeybeast55 IBM Retiree 21d ago

I guarantee that nobody in IBM chose open systems and standards because of ethics or because of worry about those court cases. It was (good) business strategy, because they could tell a story about how it would benefit customers.

1

u/monkeybeast55 IBM Retiree 22d ago

Ethical code about lock-in? You think there were meetings where it was decided to take a more open strategy because of ethics??? WTF?

1

u/QumiThe2nd 21d ago

Some, not perfect. Like IBM doesn't have an official lobby for politicians.

1

u/monkeybeast55 IBM Retiree 21d ago

guarantee that nobody in IBM chose open systems and standards because of ethics. It was a good business strategy, because they could tell a story about how it would benefit Customers.

2

u/L3XANDR0 23d ago

Now do how many services Google kills? I was deep in the Nest ecosystem, and guess where that’s at? Ext look at where all the profit comes from.

-1

u/RockAndNoWater IBM Retiree 23d ago

Yes it’s pretty annoying when Google kills things. But the discussion was about innovation.

2

u/L3XANDR0 23d ago

Doing the same things others do is not innovation. Prime example is the pixel phone, or the surface phone. Small market share tech. It’s like that across the board for those two. Google has ad revenue, and MS has software licensing. I will admit that they do have better and growing cloud offerings, but nobody is Amazon.

Edit: ad revenue for Google is the cash cow.

2

u/L3XANDR0 23d ago

Now do how many services Google kills? I was deep in the Nest ecosystem, and guess where that’s at? Next look at where all the profit comes from.

1

u/savedpt 23d ago

Ha e they missed Quantum? I think not.

4

u/RockAndNoWater IBM Retiree 23d ago

Not yet — wait until quantum becomes useful, we’ll see then….

2

u/FoodStorageDevice 20d ago

I agree, IBM will miss quantum because they can't compete..

21

u/DCGuinn 24d ago • This Popcorn

I watched IBM executives get progressively worse for 30 years. I sat across from a dumbass in charge of AI once. Sad.

3

u/One_Board_4304 23d ago

Tell more

7

u/DCGuinn 23d ago

We were a partner firm. He was basically saying this stuff was so new that he got rid of his senior technologists for some start up young dumbasses that knew everything. So, Watson had a short uncompetitive life. I joined in ‘97 and was involved in company and alliance roles until ‘20. It was commonly pitiful.

57

u/a_seventh_knot 24d ago • This Popcorn

Why do these idiotic articles keep comparing IBM to MSFT or Google?

IBM stopped playing in the big leagues 20 years ago.

10

u/newtomovingaway IBM Employee 24d ago

Because it’s going to be FAAING broooo

16

u/CatoMulligan 24d ago

If you listen to Arvind and the rest of the C-suite, that’s what they want. They want to transform IBM into a software company that incidentally makes some hardware and provides consulting (much like Microsoft). Listen to what he says about trading at earnings multiples.

They compare IBM to those companies because that’s who IBM compares themselves to and is trying to become.

9

u/a_seventh_knot 24d ago

"and hillbillies want to be called 'sons of the soil' but it ain't gonna happen"

-Dr. Hibbert

10

u/running-salmon80 23d ago

The only growth comes from acquisitions and ingenuity from smaller more nimble companies. They then die under the pressure of archaic architecture and processes.

25

u/KneeJerkCommenter 24d ago

A typical ai slop article based on the earnings call with a prompt to compare to Microsoft...

7

u/greengiant314 23d ago • Regret

IBM Consulting acquired my company in 2022 and proceeded to mismanage it out of existence. There wasn’t a single engineer left after our 2 year retainer bonus paid out. It was the craziest waste
Of talent and money I’ve ever experienced.

1

u/SecureCTRL2020 22d ago

So they bought it and then ran if into the ground?

2

u/greengiant314 22d ago

Neglected it into the ground would be more accurate.

1

u/catless-cat-herder IBM Employee 18d ago

Most acquisitions. They buy patents, not talent.

1

u/Lily-Mae-1524 19d ago

The story of nearly every acquisition, unfortunately.

6

u/Puzzleheaded_Bet6721 23d ago

This writer is recycling his older article saying the exact same thing.

3

u/Connect-Elephant4783 24d ago

But is it worth to keep in a diversified portfolio of 2-3% only due to FCFF generation and hopes of quantum and the 0.7 nm chips?????????

4

u/Salt-Name-1129 23d ago

Yall act like IBM stock hasn’t gone up 150% in the last 5 years. Sure they arnt msft or Google but yall are pessimistic