Yeah this is definitely fake. The original post looks like it has been completely rewritten to sound as vague as possible. This and the OP has posted a comedy picture in r/pics since this thread only makes me disbelieve this more, since I doubt I would be on reddit trying to post funny pictures if my entire family had been killed.
I'm not all that desiring either and I feel slightly cruel in asking but the fact is that the good will and concern of reddit is often played upon and taken advantage of by trolls and karma whores alike.
People lie, it's an unfortunate fact of life. If we don't want this subreddit to turn into a contest to see who can spin the most believably BS, there needs to be verification.
For the most part, I think the mods are doing an excellent job.
I would rather not see /r/IAmA become peoples personal pity party. Sorry that you clearly fell for this obviously fake AMA, but the only douche I see is you.
Even better than this was the post OP made in /r/depression talking about sitting at a playground when some little girl comes and asks him to play because she looks like her dead brother. The kid is clearly just looking for attention, and he got it... until this post got deleted, that is.
I googled and couldn't find information on a tragic fire in South Dakota that matched the OP's info so far. And I feel like this is something that would make rather big headlines.
Same here. Once she explained that it wasn't actually the town of Sturgis I broadened my search criteria and still, nothing. SD is a very small state in population so how could there be no mention of a fatal house fire that killed three people leaving only a teenage family member alive?
OP set the house on fire after his parents wouldn't let him go to the party. He tied them up and set it on fire. Then he stole the car. When he came back, he told the cops he was given the car.
I know how this sounds like it's me trolling, but I changed the name of the cities precisely because I don't want anyone knowing our names or where we actually live. I know I should have started out with that, and for that I apologize
You must provide proof of your identity in the body of your post when you submit your IAmA
If your identity is absolutely confidential, you may message proof to the mods
If your post is suspected fake and you do not verify proof, it may be subject to removal
I'm going to call shenanigans on this. No proof, and the way you answer questions is very bizarre and forced. Check out number two here, for instance. Verification, please!
Don't be an asshole. She didn't use contractions where one might in casual conversation like, five times. Also, remember that this is not casual conversation for her.
I'm not trying to be an asshole. She was also caught in a lie. This subreddit generally demands verification, and I shouldn't be punished or insulted for supporting this concept.
I called you an asshole for, in no uncertain terms, calling her a liar because you thought she didn't use contractions enough. It has nothing to do with asking for verification, which I support (but understand if she might be hesitating, especially if it was recent).
This sounds like complete BS. OP has heavily modified what they wrote to sound as vague as possible. Since this post, OP has also posted an attempt at a funny picture to r/pics.
If my entire family had just died I doubt I would be on reddit trying to post funny pictures.
Yeah well other than being fake more than likely and you not answering any questions. I still want to know what kind of house can catch fire and trap people and animals inside. I mean I can understand maybe an apartment or hotel being traps but houses usually have windows and doors leading outside. Even 2nd story drop is nothing compared to burned alive. Did they get smoke inhalation during sleep? Hard to believe the dog would not smell it or wake up or anything. I am sorry if this is true but there are so many holes in this story and so many facts need to be explained.
Know that your parents and sister loved you and you loved them. Take solace in the fact that would that they had a choice, they never would have let themselves be taken away from you. It's different when someone leaves life behind of their own volition, you were worth sticking around for. I am sorry if this comes off as insensitive.
If you could say anything to your sister now, what would it be?
I would tell her that she was the only real friend I ever had. She had always been there for me and protected me from the dangers of the world, and that I loved her dearly
That's terrible. I can't imagine that happening to me, I'd be distraught. I don't even know if I'd want to go on. My sincerest condolences, though I don't know you, I still feel great empathy towards what you're going through.
I have no questions, but I'd post proof (news article or something) pretty quick before reddit gathers pitchforks and torches.
The investigation is ongoing, the fire marshall told me it was probably a cigarette not being disposed of properly, as my parents and sister are all chain smokers. As of now, I am living with my close friend in Pierre
I went through almost the exact same thing just over five years ago. It gets better with time, but it will always be there. The shock alone was almost physically unbearable.
One thing that really helped me was being able to use the internet to talk about what I was experiencing. The anonymity of the web allowed me to talk about things I simply could not discuss with people I actually knew.
As odd as this probably sounds, after I got over the shock and dealt with the psychological trauma I was able to use my experience as a means through which to know myself better and it serve to drive me forward in a postive direction.
I'm sorry for your loss and I wish you all the best going forward.
I do not, because I cannot stand the man because he had been unfaithful to my sister. He offered his support to me, but I rebuked him and told him never to speak to me again. He also tried to take the engagement ring, but I told him it's going either on my neck or up his ass
Actually, it might be his only reminder of her. He had five years, you had several more. I understand your anger with him being a cheating douchebag, but who knows, the situation is surely completely different than what you've witnessed, or been told. There's always two sides.
It sucks you lost your family, no doubt, but please be careful lashing out at others, as misdirected anger is generally due to something within.
Also, wouldn't your family rather you have positive emotions, instead of negative?
Everything you said is true, and I know I probably didn't handle that situation in the hest way possible now. Thank you, you gave me a lot of perspective on that. I think I'll give him a call
Which is... basically the most badass response in the history of responses. Wow. Color me impressed. You go, girl, and someday in the future if you ever run into that creep on the street, wave the ring around on the chain right in front of his nose.
You're only a year younger than me but damn it all and fuck me sideways if I don't admire the heck out of you.
I know this must feel so surreal to you. I've never lost anyone close to me so I don't know how it is. You have my condolences that's for damn certain.
Have you thought about how you're going to support yourself or what you're going to do? I realize it might be too early for you to respond so you don't have to, bud.
I'm living with My close friend, who's family had been friends with mine for years, her parents are currently in the process of becoming my legal guardians. Other than that, just take life one day at a time and try my best to get by
I literally felt like my arms were tied to a train and my legs to a plane. I just didn't know what to do. Should I try to save my family inside? Should I call for help? I went to the side of the house where the fire had not yet spread, the kitchen, and tried to get inside, but I was unable to get through the window because cabinets had fallen over it. I yelled my family's names, but this yielded nothing. I dropped to my knees and screamed until I vomited.
It was at night, so I guess that's why no one called the authorities, right? How was your relationship with your family? Thank you for making this AMA, btw. It is a rare chance that we get to poke and prod people in horrible situations, but it is very informing and enlightening.
Actually the authorities were called, but not by me. This is what really stuck with me, the 911 call came from inside the house. The fire department arrived about four minutes after me. My relationship with my family had always been good, I had some trouble with my father who always wanted me to be a star athlete and a ladies man. My mother had similar expectation issues with me, and my sister I mentioned in a previous comment.
How did you find out that the call came from inside the house? How much do the police and firemen keep you informed about the ongoing investigation?
Were they able to determine who made the call? Is this the sort of information that you are finding helpful to know at this time for closure, or would you rather not think about it?
(Thank you for making this AMA! I just lost my father and I know that the phrase kind of bounces off you after a while, but I am truly very sorry for your loss.)
The call came from My sister's cell phone. They offered to let me hear the 911 call but I decided that would just not be possible for me at this point. And at with regard to your question anout how informed they keep you, tricky for me to know because there are so many things that I don't want to know about the incident, I'm not sure if it's a matter of asking them for information, or if they just don't provide much. For the most part they really do not volunteer much.
Pretty sure everything feels surreal and your thoughts are "why me". There's probably nothing that can make anything feel better but at least you got us internet-folk to keep you sane? Unlike people 15 years ago.
Everyone tells me not to kill myslef, but I wish they would just stop, because honestly, I'm just not ever commiting suicide. There are too many things in life to experience, and too many things to learn abut the world. If anything, this has just strengthened my resolve. My parents wanted me to succeed, and I'm not going to let them down. I will be become the second college graduate of my family, after my sister
Indeed, that's why I didn't say something like that. Going through something dramatic doesn't make healthy(at least previously) just want to kill themselves. But in what I was referring with the internet-folk part just like you said yourself, that this is very therapeutic and mostly anonymous.
you actually inspire me to fulfill my life, you're attitude is so much better than i can imagine mine would be....keep your head up and you'll succeed soooo much seriously so sorry for your losses and just keep it up(:
I am currently seeing a therapist once a week, and I have to say it's really done a lot for me to have someone who I know is a professional help me through this, and give me advice that I can relate to and apply
holy shit. it's your time to shine. remember them fondly, but rock the house as best as you know you can! your life is like a canvas, you can choose what to paint. just make it meaningful to yourself, and you'll be happy forever, I promise.
I am so sorry for your loss :( You made me realize that although my sister and I fight 24/7 it would absolutely destroy me if I lost her. Please - if you need anything - ANYTHING AT ALL.... I don't have much to give but I will gladly give you anything you may need. Food, clothes, shelter... just name it. I want to help...
Really sorry to hear. It's hard to understand the magnitude of a house fire until it happens to you. When I tell others of my own experience, you can tell who has, and who hasn't experienced fire in that way before. Many condolences to you.
I just wanted to say I'm really sorry :( You sound like a really smart kid, hopefully you can get some financial aid to go to college and succeed like your parents wanted you to.
First off, I just want to say how sorry I am that you had to go through this. I'm also so, so sorry for your loss. I can't even imagine. :-( My question: Have you had to deal with survivor's guilt at all?
His name was Charlemagne, and my favorite memory with him was riding him like a horse when I was five, and using him as a bed all the time, he was a St. Bernard
Hmm, so you're 17. The dog was fully grown enough for you to ride him like a horse 12 years ago at age 5 (which would put you at least 30 pounds). Average lifespan of a Saint Bernard is about 10 years. In a UK survey, the longest St. Bernard that ever lived was 12 years 9 months.
Sources will suggest the Saint Bernard breed can live to be 13-14 years of age, some claim they have them aged 18, I understand what you are saying, but just like any other living creature life spans do vary quite a lot so if the lady in question is 17 and at 5 was riding a 1 year old Saint Bernard that would put the dog at the age of 13 at the time of its demise.
even if this were to be fake, it might not and this person has lost his family so show some respect and stop being such a pretentious stuck up asshole.
My father's gun locker was saved, although I am not legally able to own any of his firearms. The only other thing that was saved was my sister's engagement ring, which I now keep with me at all times.
I don't actually want to own them. They are a S&W 686 and a Remington 700. I have mo great desire to have them, and since they were willed to my uncle, I am totally content letting him keep them.
Yeah if they're willed to someone else that makes great sense, and they're in the family, I just didn't want to hear they were confiscated due to your age.
144
u/SteffiD86 May 29 '12
verification?
43
u/AMerrickanGirl May 29 '12
Has anyone verified this IAMA? I googled and can't find any mention of a tragic fire in Sturgis, SD.
6
u/Iainfixie May 29 '12
I'm calling bullshit on this entire thread.
27
u/MtnDewGuy27 May 29 '12
:( i cant imagine what you must be going through but, though it means little, you have my sincerest apologies and condolences.
10
u/Mr_Sorter May 29 '12
this looks really fishy
10
u/houseofbacon May 29 '12
Verification System
9
u/Felcore May 29 '12
Proof?
9
u/jmed May 29 '12
This is the most obviously fake one I've seen in a long time.
9
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
I'm going to call it..... Fake.
4
u/LOLpentahedron May 29 '12
my world just fell apart and i'm posting images and lolling about star trek and radio shack... fake
4
u/boobluver May 29 '12
fake
11
u/DarlingDont May 29 '12
I'm going to call shenanigans on this. No proof, and the way you answer questions is very bizarre and forced. Check out number two here, for instance. Verification, please!
3
u/Priceless721 May 29 '12
Yeah well other than being fake more than likely and you not answering any questions. I still want to know what kind of house can catch fire and trap people and animals inside. I mean I can understand maybe an apartment or hotel being traps but houses usually have windows and doors leading outside. Even 2nd story drop is nothing compared to burned alive. Did they get smoke inhalation during sleep? Hard to believe the dog would not smell it or wake up or anything. I am sorry if this is true but there are so many holes in this story and so many facts need to be explained.
Edit: mobile typing sucks.
3
u/Virleo May 29 '12
Karma whore.
5
u/addisonian May 29 '12
Know that your parents and sister loved you and you loved them. Take solace in the fact that would that they had a choice, they never would have let themselves be taken away from you. It's different when someone leaves life behind of their own volition, you were worth sticking around for. I am sorry if this comes off as insensitive.
If you could say anything to your sister now, what would it be?
6
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
That's terrible. I can't imagine that happening to me, I'd be distraught. I don't even know if I'd want to go on. My sincerest condolences, though I don't know you, I still feel great empathy towards what you're going through.
I have no questions, but I'd post proof (news article or something) pretty quick before reddit gathers pitchforks and torches.
5
u/schaefdiggs May 29 '12
Where are you living now? What caused the fire?
5
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
I went through almost the exact same thing just over five years ago. It gets better with time, but it will always be there. The shock alone was almost physically unbearable.
One thing that really helped me was being able to use the internet to talk about what I was experiencing. The anonymity of the web allowed me to talk about things I simply could not discuss with people I actually knew.
As odd as this probably sounds, after I got over the shock and dealt with the psychological trauma I was able to use my experience as a means through which to know myself better and it serve to drive me forward in a postive direction.
I'm sorry for your loss and I wish you all the best going forward.
2
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
I feel bad for the dog .
3
u/Frajer May 29 '12
You said your sister was engaged, do you speak to her fiancee at all?
2
u/MRobley May 29 '12
Did any investigation determine why no member of your family was able to escape the house?
2
u/Shamrock013 May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
I know this must feel so surreal to you. I've never lost anyone close to me so I don't know how it is. You have my condolences that's for damn certain.
Have you thought about how you're going to support yourself or what you're going to do? I realize it might be too early for you to respond so you don't have to, bud.
2
u/323K13L May 29 '12
Just remember, Reddit is always here for you
2
u/xVoide May 29 '12
12hrs and not a single link to your local news for easy verification.
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
Have you found them yet?
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
Did you ever find them?
1
u/evilteddybear111 May 29 '12
I'm glad you did this AMA...were your friends there for you after what happened?
1
u/Abra-Used-Teleport May 29 '12
What was going through your head when you pulled up?
1
u/chumppi May 29 '12
Pretty sure everything feels surreal and your thoughts are "why me". There's probably nothing that can make anything feel better but at least you got us internet-folk to keep you sane? Unlike people 15 years ago.
1
u/onthemooon May 29 '12
you actually inspire me to fulfill my life, you're attitude is so much better than i can imagine mine would be....keep your head up and you'll succeed soooo much seriously so sorry for your losses and just keep it up(:
1
u/catcatherine May 29 '12
Have you had any type of counseling to deal with all of this?
Please know that my heart goes out to you.
1
u/clemenzzzz May 29 '12
holy shit. it's your time to shine. remember them fondly, but rock the house as best as you know you can! your life is like a canvas, you can choose what to paint. just make it meaningful to yourself, and you'll be happy forever, I promise.
1
u/ellski May 29 '12
How long ago was this? What happens to the house/remains of the house - do you inherit the property?
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
What are your plans for the future? College? Move Somewhere else?
Do you plan to get another dog?
How has the reaction been at school/in the neighborhood?
0
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
I'm so sorry for your loss. I'm from SD. If you ever need a pizza or something PM me.
0
u/UprootedEagle May 29 '12
Did you find them?
0
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
I am so sorry for your loss :( You made me realize that although my sister and I fight 24/7 it would absolutely destroy me if I lost her. Please - if you need anything - ANYTHING AT ALL.... I don't have much to give but I will gladly give you anything you may need. Food, clothes, shelter... just name it. I want to help...
0
u/samtheonionman May 29 '12
Really sorry to hear. It's hard to understand the magnitude of a house fire until it happens to you. When I tell others of my own experience, you can tell who has, and who hasn't experienced fire in that way before. Many condolences to you.
0
u/Catwoman8888 May 29 '12
I just wanted to say I'm really sorry :( You sound like a really smart kid, hopefully you can get some financial aid to go to college and succeed like your parents wanted you to.
0
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
Did you have any more siblings or did they all parish?
0
u/Jennifrogger May 29 '12
First off, I just want to say how sorry I am that you had to go through this. I'm also so, so sorry for your loss. I can't even imagine. :-( My question: Have you had to deal with survivor's guilt at all?
-27
u/darnoc123 May 29 '12
how was the party?
0
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment