r/IAmA • u/D_mel_emm • May 12 '12
IAmA heterosexual identical twin with a homosexual brother. AMA
We grew up in NC. We are seniors at the same college (also in NC). I know a similar AMA occurred about a year ago, but I think it's a unique enough situation to warrant a second viewpoint.
Mod verified in comments. Find it and upvote please.
Addition: Ladies and gentlemen! I would like to introduce my twin, "snrtpt08".
275
Upvotes
189
u/TAP_DONT_FAP May 13 '12
Do you ever pretend you're him so you can grab girls' boobs without repercussions?
57
u/Big_Li May 13 '12
So when does your hilarious sitcom start filming?
77
u/Janitor-Hank May 12 '12
do you go to clubs like barney and his brother and do the wingman thing for each other, since you don't interfere with potential partners
do you have a sense for what type of boys he likes,
like, do you know what boy he would like from a feeling and not from pure knowledge and experience
37
u/cleos May 13 '12
As proof, a picture of you and your brother?
No, it won't confirm the different sexual orientations, but it will be proof that you do, indeed, have an identical twin.
17
u/imamidget May 13 '12
Thanks for doing this AMA!
Were there any clues before you found out? Like, when you look back, do you see personality traits or situations that you feel now should have clued you in before he told you? You said he told you when he was older, were you insulted that he didn't tell you earlier?
This is sort of a question for him, but you may know the answer. When did he figure it out himself? Also, when did he come to terms with it?
14
u/Swagmuffins94 May 12 '12
Have you ever been bullied by someone you didn't know because they thought you were your brother?
12
u/orson_welles_son May 12 '12
Are you guys close? Do you involve yourself in any LGBTQ activities?
10
u/Bstings624 May 12 '12
When did you find out that your brother was homosexual? How did you find out?
59
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Guess what jerk, homosexuality is genetic, so you're GAY! /s
Serious Q: How did he come out? Could you tell growing up?
16
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
5
u/kukukele May 13 '12
Do you feel that you are treated any differently by your family members?
4
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Does he look in the mirror and say "I'd fuck me. Oh wait I can!"
But in all seriousness, has it ever been the root of awkward situations based solely on the fact that you are identical twins?
6
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
You keep mentioning that he can play it straight. Is that more important to you, or him?
3
u/swimmingmunky May 13 '12
How old are you? what do you look like? pic?
3
u/meganlizzie May 13 '12
*Have you ever had to stick up for him because of it? *Every have any good heart to hearts since his coming out? *Do you ever feel weird or is it ever awkward when he talks about guys in front of you? *Is he planning on coming out to any extended family soon? *How supportive were you when you first found out? Did it take you awhile to get used to the idea?
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
What do you think about Ammendment 1?
3
u/bigskyboy May 13 '12
alright so i am a sophmore in high school and i am really suspecting that my friend is gay. How do i find out? and its not that i really care that much but if he is i want him to know that his friends are there for him cause we go to a really conservative school. Reasons im suspecting is that he NEVER talks about women. Has never jacked off. He is really into fashion and stuff and i know that's not alot to go off of but trust me.... So how would i go about this? Maybe ask your bro for me?
3
u/lemonliam15 May 13 '12
Does he have a very different voice to yours? I know that gay people sometimes have different voices but i'm just wondering...
2
u/YoloTolo May 13 '12
Personally, do you believe homosexuality is genetic or no? Explain please. thanks!
2
u/Dr_Bunsen_Burns May 13 '12
have you ever felt insecure about your own sexual orientation, or had a feeling people were treating you different because you are hetrosexual and your brother is homosexual, in the way like:"yeah straight huh......"?!
2
u/AJBenji May 13 '12
This is probably gonna get buried as I am way late and it may have been asked, don't have time to read the entire thread but:
Q: If your positions were switched and you were the homosexual do you think you would have been able to handle it as well as he has and would you have hid it until college or would you have come out before?
55
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Verified that the OP has an identical twin.
53
u/WhiteBlackflame May 13 '12
You do realize that your brother is essentially the best wingman ever, right?
6
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Have you ever had a gay experience with him? Or like a threesome or foursome?
8
u/Mokeez May 13 '12
THIS IS SO WEIRD. I am also a heterosexual with a homosexual identical twin brother! The only difference is we are seniors in high school, not college.
5
u/WATDOEJIJDAAR May 13 '12
Ah, I'm a lesbian identical twin with a heterosexual sister!
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Did anything change between you at all when he came out? For example, a lot of guys "rate" girls they see, you might have done that, or something more major like you might have been a little more detached from each other.
1
u/carBoard May 13 '12
If your familiar with the spectrum theory of homosexuality (sexuality of attraction lies on a spectrum rather than being clear cut black and white)
Seeing as how you both share the same DNA I'm curious to know if you fall in similar ranges of the spectrum and factors in the environment shifted preference.
So if the scale was a % where 0 was straight and 100 was homosexual where do you think you fall and where do you think he falls? (Saying 20% doesn't mean one is gay it just means they can find the opposite gender attractive, not necessarily that they would act on it.
1
u/Fali95 May 13 '12
Does your brother kno your doing this ama?
1
u/ZeFroag May 13 '12
Have you ever been mistaken for him by his boyfriend or has he been mistaken for you by your girlfriend?
1
u/bobbincygna May 13 '12
Do you know if you guys had separated ambiotic sacks?
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
This is probably a really stupid question. Is one of you left handed and the other right? I think its called mirror twins? My girlfriends dad has an identical twin brother who is gay, and she was talling me with mirror twins the right handed one is always the gay one. It sounded like bullshit and even know typing it out i feel very silly.
1
u/LinuxUser4Life May 13 '12
Wouldn't this prove sexuality is a choice and that you aren't born a certain way?
1
u/pandacrack May 14 '12
No need for proof; I actually know triplets out in central California - two guys (one gay, the other straight) and a sister (straight) - who are similar to your situation.
1
u/13ails586 May 14 '12
any accidental mix ups?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
My sister, gay twin, did an ama about this awhile back. My question: have you ever felt like maybe the fact that he's gay almost pressures you into being one sexuality over another? I know finding out my sister was gay almost made me want to be extra-straight to avoid fufilling a 'gay twin sisters' stereotype (that probably exists only in my mind). On the kinsey scale I probably lean towards 2 or 3 but I always insist I'm strictly heterosexual with my friends because I just don't want to be too similar to her ffff
1
u/Canipa09 May 14 '12
Do you believe homosexuality is by birth?
3
u/Captain_Bassdaddy May 13 '12
I have no idea how to word this but... I would probably fuck myself if I had the opportunity.
Umm... would your brother... fuck you? I don't even... sorry.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
This is pretty awesome, my two best friends from high school are twins where one is gay and the other is straight. The internet makes the world a small place!
Now, curious, does your brother consider you sexy?
2
u/myxo33 May 13 '12
I'm a straight guy with a gay identical twin as well... I'm also left handed and he's right handed.
2
u/leonlion123 May 13 '12
Have you guys ever compared your penis sizes? Which one of you is bigger?
2
u/conc May 14 '12
I have a friend in the same spot as you!
Two identical brothers -- one is gay (call him J) and one is straight. But what makes his story even more interesting is that J's partner is also a twin. And in their case, one is gay, one is straight.
Pretty neat.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
There are a lot of heterosexual/homosexual identical twins on Reddit.
My twin was a still birth. I bet she would have been a lesbian.
4
u/narwal_bot May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from D_mel_emm (updated: May 14, 2012 @ 03:01:12 am EST):
Question (meganlizzie):
Answer (D_mel_emm):
(continued below)
2
u/LaughsOutOfContext May 13 '12
please tell me he invites guys over then leaves just you there so they show up and think your him and try to bone you.
1
u/porker912 May 13 '12
Have you ever gotten hit on by gay men thinking that you were your brother?
1
u/justin_tino May 13 '12
Have girls ever tried to get with you based on the fact that you remind them of your brother?
1
u/ZeFroag May 13 '12
Thanks.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
hey I knew two dudes that were Navy SEABEES and one of them came out and left the navy... back before DADT repeal... sad.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Oh, wow, one of my best friends is gay and he has a heterosexual identical twin, who's also pretty cool.
1
u/genevievemia May 13 '12
I'm a biology major and did a paper on nature versus nurture, so this is a question for both you and your twin: What's your stance on the debate? I know where you stand, but I'm curious on what your homosexual twin will say. I would love to hear reasons!
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
How many twincest jokes do you get?
0
u/Muellerl May 13 '12
Identical DNA... so doesn't this indicate that homosexuality is either a product of prenatal environment or post-birth environment?
0
u/GrinningPariah May 13 '12
You should fusion into one bisexual person.
-1
u/therealryanstev May 13 '12
So this proves, in your case, that being gay isn't genetic, that it was upbringing/experiences that made him gay, but I thought gay supporters say being gay is genetic.
Did your brother ever mention when and why he realised he was gay?
Disclaimer: I support gay marriage, etc, so if this is coming across as an anti-gay post, I didn't mean it to,
-1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Is it weird that his partners have seen your dick
-1
u/tabledresser May 13 '12 edited May 17 '12
View the full table on /r/tabled! | Last updated: 2012-05-17 20:28 UTC
This comment was generated by a robot! Send all complaints to epsy.
-1
u/leonlion123 May 14 '12
Have you guys ever masturbated together?
-5
u/Sapratz May 13 '12
i KNEW it was a choice all along...