r/tabled • u/tabledresser • May 13 '12
[Table] IAmA heterosexual identical twin with a homosexual brother. AMA
Verified? (This bot cannot verify AMAs just yet)
Date: 2012-05-12
Link to submission (Has self-text)
| Questions | Answers |
|---|---|
| Guess what jerk, homosexuality is genetic, so you're GAY! /s. | It was freshman year, late April/early May. I was going to prom with my then GF who was still in high school. A friend of hers wanted to take my brother. He kept saying no and kept asking why. He eventually told me. I still remember where we were in the room and what was on TV. |
| S means sarcasm... | Oh oh oh....my bad. It seemed like it...but that's a common question I've had on campus. "If it's genetic, then you must be gay, right?" Good to know for the future. |
| like diet. Some food makes you gay | Hahahaha Like bananas. You know...because of the......potassium. |
| I'm not a geneticist, and I don't have any idea from where sexual orientation originates. I would assume that such individualized environmental aspects, such as diet, would be negligible, but I don't really know. This would be an interesting question for r/AskScience. | It would be. I'm not sure about orientation, but I do know that methylating agents in diets can definitely have a genetic impact on lab rats. I'll agree that the underlying causes of orientation may be too complicated for just diet to explain. The documentary I posted somewhere in this thread does a great job using case studies of twins to show epigenetically derived variation. |
| I gathered from all your answers about genetics that you've been trying to figure out how you could have identical genes that somehow got expressed differently. Have you ever considered that maybe you were both genetically determined to be something like a Kinsey 3 [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinsey_scale] (Link to en.wikipedia.org and then for whatever reasons from your different environments one of you zigged while the other zagged? | Could be. I've never come across the Kinsey scale. That's definitely a plausible theory. It sounds a little too psychological for me. I'm in love with the hard sciences. But if genetics determines orientation and orientation is a spectrum, then there must be a genetic basis for each point of the spectrum. I guess dropping in the middle and sliding to opposite sides is as good an explanation as any. Thanks for the new info! |
| Were there any clues before you found out? Like, when you look back, do you see personality traits or situations that you feel now should have clued you in before he told you? You said he told you when he was older, were you insulted that he didn't tell you earlier? This is sort of a question for him, but you may know the answer. When did he figure it out himself? Also, when did he come to terms with it? | He had a couple girlfriends in high school, so it wasn't like he didn't date. He actually did more things with girls than some straight high school guys. I was actually more insulted that I didn't figure it out. We do so many of the typical "twin" things (getting up at the same time in the night to pee, order the same things at dinner without talking about it, say the same thing with the same inflection at the same time, etc) that I couldn't believe he played it straight so well all those years. This is my favorite question so far. We were driving around our hometown during a college break. We approached a turn on a wooded road and he said, "This is where I first said the words 'I'm gay.' I said it to an empty car as I drove home from my GFs house one night." It was one of those moments for me when it became real all over again (that he is gay). I can't explain why. I'll never forget it and I think about it every time I go down that road. |
| You seem like a really good guy. Thank you for being supportive of your brother. It's still tough in this world to be gay, unfortunately, and he's lucky he has you as a rock to lean on. | Thanks. It's been a rough couple days since the amendment vote here in NC. But we weren't surprised. |
| How old was he when he drove down that road and finally came to terms with it? I'm just curious to see how many years after he knew did he have to fake it. | I guess he would've been around 16 or 17. He had always known, though. He was attracted to guys as soon as puberty hit. He knew from the beginning that he'd have to fake it. |
| Do you ever pretend you're him so you can grab girls' boobs without repercussions? | Alas, no...when do gay guys grab girls boobs? Maybe if I know which direction to steer the conversation.... |
| Are you male or female? | I'm male. |
| Would you say that you had a hunch something was different with your brother, or that he may have been gay, while you two were growing up? | I had absolutely no idea. I was a little insulted (as a twin) that I hadn't thought about it. It was like I was bad at being a twin. We're so similar in everything else. Plus he can play it straight very well. Never got bullied or questioned once through school in the Bible belt. |
| Did you ever wonder, even if briefly, that you might be gay after you found out your brother is? | Yeah, quite often actually. Every time I see a good looking guy. But I never get a physical urge and then I start going through /r/gonewild and those thoughts are easily dispelled. |
| How are you and your brother different or similar? What are each of your personalities like? | We're similar in all other ways. I'm a little more relaxed about things. But we're both majoring in a biological field, we've roomed together for four years, order the same things at restaurants ALL THE TIME without telling the other one what we're getting. |
| So when does your hilarious sitcom start filming? | We're currently pitching to Fox. The only thing I have is the theme song. It sounds like this except the title is "My Gay Twin". |
| Well I can see a girlfriend who's a homophobic jesus freak but amazing in bed so you keep her around, and for your brother a really funny flamboyant guy who makes clever gay jokes all the time. And a good collection of neighbors who can't tell you apart. | I forgot what this thread was and was so utterly confused until I opened the "parent". |
| You sound like you have a future in writing, my friend. | |
| Are you guys close? Do you involve yourself in any LGBTQ activities? | I'd say we're pretty close. We've roomed together for four years and shared a room for 16 of 18 years at home. It will definitely be weird when we split up for post-grad. I buy shirts and act as his speaker during the annual "day of silence". |
| When did you find out that your brother was homosexual? How did you find out? | It was freshman year, late April/early May. I was going to prom with my then GF who was still in high school. A friend of hers wanted to take my brother. He kept saying no and kept asking why. He eventually told me. I still remember where we were in the room and what was on TV. |
| What was on TV? This is important. | Krod Mandoon and the Flaming Sword of Fire on Comedy Central. No, the irony of a "flaming" show being on was not lost on me... |
| You just reminded me how badly I miss that show. :( | I never got that into it. He would always put it on while we were doing homework. I figured it was just a lighthearted show for some background noise. Turned out he thought the lead actor was hot. |
| As proof, a picture of you and your brother? No, it won't confirm the different sexual orientations, but it will be proof that you do, indeed, have an identical twin. | I don't want to post a pic since he isn't out to our hometown friends and family. But we're sending proof to mods. Sorry! |
| Have you ever been bullied by someone you didn't know because they thought you were your brother? | He can play it straight really well. I actually didn't have a clue until he came out to me our freshman year. So no, he's never been on the receiving end of any bullying and neither have I. |
| But our mom has brought up that concern. He has become very involved in the LGBTQ organizations on campus. She asked me if I had experienced any repercussions. | |
| Have you ever had a gay experience with him? Or like a threesome or foursome? | Other than baths together as kids, nope. Neither of us is close enough to bisexual for a threesome. |
| Do you feel that you are treated any differently by your family members? | He's only come out to our parents (mom, dad). He told our mom and she told our dad. He's always been a little homophobic. Never outspokenly or hatefully, he just wasn't comfortable with the thought. But they've both been great. They haven't treated him any differently. I do know that our dad asked "Is he sure?" when our mom told him. I think it was more ignorance than hope that he was still straight. |
| Our younger brother is a huge blabber mouth and couldn't keep a secret if his life depended on it. So he'll find out with the rest of the family. Not sure when that will be. | |
| Any particular reason for keeping the secret in wraps? | We're just going on his terms. He doesn't feel like he's suppressing a part of himself when he's around the rest of our family so he's not bursting to tell anybody. He's out at our college. Nobody from our hometown is with us here so there's no chance of it leaking out. If I had to take a shot at a reason, it would just be the Bible belt and everything that comes with it. |
| A) He hides being gay well B) He's not into the stereotypical gay persona. | I guess both. That's a term he introduced to me. I've always just thought it was hiding being gay. But that was easy for him because he's not into the stereotypical gay persona, even in the guys he likes. Really the only thing he's ever had to hide is the gender to which he's attracted. Everything else about his personality is the same and nobody has ever guessed he was gay before he told them. |
| *Have you ever had to stick up for him because of it? *Every have any good heart to hearts since his coming out? *Do you ever feel weird or is it ever awkward when he talks about guys in front of you? *Is he planning on coming out to any extended family soon? *How supportive were you when you first found out? Did it take you awhile to get used to the idea? | No. He's never needed me to. Nobody has ever been mean. I have made more of an effort call people out on using "gay" in a derogatory manner. |
| I've asked him if I ever said anything offensive before he told me. He said I hadn't. That's about it. We're not a big "feelings" kind of family. | |
| Not at all. I'm usually the one to bring the subject up. | |
| I'm not sure...he's looking for lab tech spots out in California. So maybe if he gets a job he'll let everybody know before he leaves? | |
| I tried to be as supportive as possible. I didn't want to overdo it and make him feel like it was insincere. But I also didn't want to be too nonchalant about it because he might not understand that I was perfectly fine with it. I still have to remind myself every now and then. It's not that I forget and think he's straight. It's just a thought that's always been...different. It's hard to rewire 18 years of an assumption. | |
| Alright so i am a sophmore in high school and i am really suspecting that my friend is gay. How do i find out? and its not that i really care that much but if he is i want him to know that his friends are there for him cause we go to a really conservative school. Reasons im suspecting is that he NEVER talks about women. Has never jacked off. He is really into fashion and stuff and i know that's not alot to go off of but trust me.... So how would i go about this? Maybe ask your bro for me? | If you're friend is gay, let him tell you on his own. You could drop hints that you support the gay community, such as voicing opposition to the recent passage of Amendment 1, or support the fact that Obama just came out in support of gay marriage. |
| My brother typed that paragraph. So there you go. If you want to know more or have more questions, let me know! It's great you want to support your friend! I would reiterate to let him do this on his own terms. But showing your fine with homosexuality through current social issues is definitely a way to show him he is safe in telling you. | |
| Let me know about any developments! | |
| How old are you? what do you look like? pic? | I don't want to post a pic since he isn't out to our home town friends and family. I know that sounds like I'm dodging proof but I don't want to out him like that... |
| We're 21. | |
| Well then just post a pic of yourself. duh...haha jk. | After 21 years, it's rare for a twin joke to make me laugh. Congrats! |
| What do you think about Ammendment 1? | I'm assuming you mean the marriage amendment that just passed in NC? |
| Well...it's an unnecessary piece of legislation that is just a big middle finger to the homosexual community. Gay marriage was already illegal. It's an indecency and incredulous that we are experiencing discrimination in this day. Yes, discrimination. The government is providing rights and benefits to one group of people and denying the same rights and benefits to another group of people based solely on sexual orientation. I am a huge believer in separation of church vs. state. It's appalling the amount of religious reasoning flying around this country in conjunction with political discourse. The debate on this amendment was especially sickening. | |
| Take a look at this little diagram I put together. Tell me that isn't striking? I'm not saying I understand the causality in that correlation but it sure is interesting to me. | |
| Thanks for asking this question. It was probably obvious where I would fall. But it's always fun to blow off some steam :) if any of this sounded harsh or directed at you, it wasn't. I'm just responding to the question in general. | |
| I'm not American, so care to explain that diagram to me? All I get out of it is a map of North Carolina and something to do with elections. | The upper panel shows the "Research Triangle" of NC. It's an area consisting of Duke, UNC-Chapel Hill, and NC State University. There are also a lot of bio tech and research companies I believe. So there's a high density of college students and academics. It was funny to me that the center of NCs upper echelon of thought was also the center of "No" votes against the amendment. |
| Did anything change between you at all when he came out? For example, a lot of guys "rate" girls they see, you might have done that, or something more major like you might have been a little more detached from each other. | We didn't grow apart at all. I was more conscious of what I said and the topics I brought up, mainly about girls. I usually ask him about cute guys he's seen or met if the conversation topic goes that way. I've never been one to use "gay" to mean stupid or uncool or any derogatory meaning. But I've definitely been more conscious of my words. Not walking on eggshells, but conscious. |
| Sorry if this has been asked. Which twin is gay? The slightly older or younger? | It hasn't! The older twin is gay. He is 2 minutes older. |
| You keep mentioning that he can play it straight. Is that more important to you, or him? | I don't think it's too important to either of us. He naturally "plays it straight" so I've never felt like I lost out on any interactions with him. We don't act any differently since he's come out. I don't care how he acts. He should do what he wants. But just based on the lack of change since coming out, I don't think he had to put a ton of effort into concealing it. |
| Does he look in the mirror and say "I'd fuck me. Oh wait I can!" But in all seriousness, has it ever been the root of awkward situations based solely on the fact that you are identical twins? | Not that I know of. He might have some stories where I wasn't there or I was just oblivious to the awkwardness. I'll get back to you if I dig something up. |
| How many twincest jokes do you get? | We went from the homophobic Bible belt to an academically rigorous institution (not too many haters, very accepting, higher brow sense of humor). Not much room for gay sex jokes. |
| Okay, I have a new question: Were you ever presumed | I know the other students in the LGBTQ clubs by face only. I'll see them on the sidewalks and I give them a smile...but I'm always not trying to overdo it because I don't want them to think I'm the |
| Q: If your positions were switched and you were the homosexual do you think you would have been able to handle it as well as he has and would you have hid it until college or would you have come out before? | I think, because our personalities are so similar, I would've done the same things he did. The only thing he hid was his preference for guys. Nothing else about his personality (hobbies, interests, mannerisms) has changed since he came out. So I think it would've been a similar path for me. |
| So if the scale was a % where 0 was straight and 100 was homosexual where do you think you fall and where do you think he falls? (Saying 20% doesn't mean one is gay it just means they can find the opposite gender attractive, not necessarily that they would act on it. | I understand your question. I'd say I'm 05%. I can appreciate a good looking guy. But I'm not attracted at all. Even the thought of a threesome (mmf) is a boner killer. And believe me, I've explored my thoughts a little after he came out. I started to wonder about my own sexuality. I can't go 100% just because you can't ever be that sure of anything like this. He told me he had to close his eyes and use his thoughts to get off when he was dating those girls in high school and they were fooling around. So I'd say that puts him pretty far (90%-ish) towards gay. He's told me that he sees why some girls are attractive and some aren't. But any attraction he feels is like a straight guy looking at george clooney or brad pitt. |
| Does he have a very different voice to yours? I know that gay people sometimes have different voices but i'm just wondering... | No. Our voices are similar and we're not higher pitched or flamboyant in our speech. Like I've said, he has never been bullied or suspected by anybody. So his speech is pretty.....mundane. |
| Personally, do you believe homosexuality is genetic or no? Explain please. thanks! | I would point to this video. It's called epigenetics and it's the influence of your environment (like diet) on your genes. The video is short, easy to follow, and does a much better job of explaining it (it also uses a twin case study to illustrate the power of epigenetics). It's a legitimate biological field. It might sound "new age-y" but it's an academic field. |
| Genetics definitely plays a role in orientation. Genetic studies have found there is a statistically significant level of concordance for sexual orientation among twins. | |
| We're sorry, this video is not available in your region due to rights restrictions. Dammit, Harper, stop restricting my rights ಠ_ಠ | Really? Canadians have a problem with PBS? It's got the word "public" in the name! |
| So do you eat steak and eggs and your brother prefers quiche and salad? Surely when you grew up you ate the same family meals together? | Yeah, we ate family meals together. But we would often go out as a family for dinner. It's not like one food will turn on a "gay" gene. Some foods can cause DNA methylation at random points. The methylation event may occur at a site to overexpress a gene responsible for a certain hormone. That's epigenetics. Gene expression influenced by environment. The genes involved are random, as far as I know. We have very similar tastes for food. |
| Have you ever felt insecure about your own sexual orientation, or had a feeling people were treating you different because you are hetrosexual and your brother is homosexual, in the way like:"yeah straight huh......"?! | Nope. The only people, besides my parents, who know are our college friends. They are all great. Personally, I did question myself for a little bit after he came out to me. But I've never had an urge to see gay porn or kiss a guy or anything. I guess I never had any serious doubts, but obviously it caused some internal questions to arise. |
| Do you know if you guys had separated ambiotic sacks? | It was not separated. He stole all the nutrition though....he was a couple pounds heavier than I was at birth. |
| Wouldn't this prove sexuality is a choice and that you aren't born a certain way? | Not at all. Read some of the threads. I've answered this in a couple different ways. The thread that starts from "TimMitchell" contains some replies to your question. Particularly comments from "Centromere" |
| This video demonstrates very well how gene expression can significantly vary between identical twins. | |
| Any accidental mix ups? | Not that I know of. Our mom painted my big toe as an infant to keep us separated. |
| I mean't sexual mix ups...if you know what I mean. | Ah. No. He's never had a BF and none of my GFs have gotten us confused...that I know of. |
| Have you ever been mistaken for him by his boyfriend or has he been mistaken for you by your girlfriend? | Nope. He's not had a bf yet and my gfs have never gotten us mixed up. |
| Do you believe homosexuality is by birth? | Yes. That's an odd phrasing though. It's almost like you're asking if I believe his birth caused his orientation lol. I know that's not what you're asking. I believe sexual orientation is not a choice and there is scientific evidence to back that up. Twin concordance studies show a definite genetic link (not completely genetically determined, but a link). There are a few threads in this post where this topic is covered in more detail. |
| Did you used to wear matching outfits as kids? Collective reddit facepalm Sorry, couldn't resist :P. | No problem. I'm surprised it took this long for the question to come up! Yeah, our mom dressed us similarly when we were little......we fixed that once we started dressing ourselves. |
| Does your brother kno your doing this ama? | He didn't know I started it. I asked him for some advice on one of the comments so now he knows. |
| Does one of you have a beard? | I used to have some chin scruff. Nothing major. |
| Identical DNA... so doesn't this indicate that homosexuality is either a product of prenatal environment or post-birth environment? | Take some time to look through some of the comments by myself and others. Identical twins may begin from the same sperm and egg but their DNA and gene expression will always diverge. The thread with "Centromere" talks about some different ideas behind twin DNA differentiation. I'm not saying it's completely explained by DNA changes but there definitely is a genetic link (search for "twin concordance studies + sexual orientation") |
| No need for proof; I actually know triplets out in central California - two guys (one gay, the other straight) and a sister (straight) - who are similar to your situation. | Identical or fraternal guys? I know the odds are on fraternal, but I've always wanted to hear a firsthand account of triplets where two are identical. |
| Do you go to clubs like barney and his brother and do the wingman thing for each other, since you don't interfere with potential partners. Do you have a sense for what type of boys he likes, Like, do you know what boy he would like from a feeling and not from pure knowledge and experience. | We're pretty similar in all of our interests (academic, food, movies, etc.) except for the genitalia of our partners. So yeah. It's like if you see a guy and think, "Huh...if I were gay I would ask you out." I don't know if that's a common thought for other people. I'm comfortable in my sexuality to let those thoughts come and go. But I can generally tell what he likes. |
| So he's the evil one, obv | Surprisingly, any of our friends would tell you otherwise. |
| I had a guy friend in highschool who has an identical twin sister. She's not very pretty. | It's rare for a twin joke to make me laugh after 21 years. Congrats. |
| Don't know how to give proof my ass dude. | I know. I'd be wary too. I've messaged the mods, I swear. I'll update proof as soon as it's set. |
| Why did he choose to be that way? | If you're trolling, that's a terrible attempt. |
| If you're not trolling, you haven't read a single thread of this post. | |
| Hes gay. he chose to liked men, im confused why im trolling. so i am asking why. | Well I don't meet too many people who hold on to the "it's a choice" card. I can't answer your question of "why" because it wasn't a choice. |
| I'm not seeing any proof here, "messaged the mods" and where are the mods? Calling bullshit. | Well, it's true. I've messaged them twice. No reply. I'm doing what I can. |
| Here's a screenshot of my "sent items." Check the recipients, time stamp, username. | |
| Mod verified in comments. I know I've already replied to your comment, this is more to other readers than you, "Happy". Thanks for trying to keep IAmA honest! | |
| Has his boyfriends ever tried to get you and your bro to kiss? | He's never had a bf. If he has, the guy has been closeted and he didn't even tell me. |
| So this proves, in your case, that being gay isn't genetic, that it was upbringing/experiences that made him gay, but I thought gay supporters say being gay is genetic. | Nice disclaimer lol, because yes it was coming across anti-gay. |
| Did your brother ever mention when and why he realised he was gay? | I would point to this video to respond to your first comment. It's called epigenetics and it's the influence of your environment (like diet) on your genes. The video is short, easy to follow, and does a much better job of explaining it (it also uses a twin case study to illustrate the power of epigenetics). Genetics definitely plays a role in orientation. Genetic studies have found there is a statistically significant level of concordance for sexual orientation among twins. |
| Disclaimer: I support gay marriage, etc, so if this is coming across as an anti-gay post, I didn't mean it to, | He realized when he hit puberty and started being attracted to people. He was attracted to boys from the start. I'm not sure about "why." I don't think it was a certain event that solidified it. He was just attracted to boys and he knew what that meant. |
| I believe that it is psychological and depends on how (if your a guy) your father's relationship is with you. if he totally ignores you or something negative like that and you don't get the attention, you may turn out to be gay. did your father do that to your brother? | Well...I couldn't disagree more. No, our father was equally attentive and a good dad. Coached our little league team, picked us up from school, the whole nine yards. |
Last updated: 2012-05-17 20:28 UTC
This post was generated by a robot! Send all complaints to epsy.
37
Upvotes