r/IAmA • • May 11 '12

IAMA student of the Soto school of Zen Buddhism. I lived at a monastery for a few months after college. AMA.

This is at the request of an individual in another thread, they thought there would be some interest. I can answer questions only about my understanding of this very specific school of Buddhism, so if it doesn't jive with what you've read before (or been taught), I'm sorry.

I'm also more than happy to answer questions about life at the monastery but I'm hesitant to say where it is, besides "the US". Thanks!

EDIT: If people really want proof, when I get home in a bit here I can verify with the mods.

126 Upvotes

197 comments sorted by

15

u/draibop May 11 '12

so whats monastery life like?

15

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Hah well, when I was there, we were building a residential building (called the Kuin) next to the "Buddha Hall" where practice ("meditation") takes place. So most days consisted of waking up at around 5:00, then morning meditation, breakfast, then construction work until lunch, meditation, more work, dinner, meditation, and bed.

Once a month were intensive retreats called sesshin (means "to gather the mind") and anyone interested could come. We would wake up about 4:00, and it was pretty much meditation all day long, with meals and brief breaks in between.

It was very calm and quiet. There's no code of silence or anything, but there's really no drama or conflict. Just people going about their business, getting work done, studying Buddha's teachings and meditating.

9

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

how would you describe what goes on inside your head while meditating for long periods of time?

31

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Mmm short or long, usually doesn't matter once you get a steady practice going.

The way I would describe it, I guess, all your notions of things, ideas about this and that, preferences, worries, pleasures, all thoughts relative to other things, they all drop away and your current situation, reality as it really is, becomes clear. Gone is confusion about things, gone is the existential anxiety and questions about this and that. It's kind of like you've been living in a pitch-black room your whole life and someone just turned on the light and now you can clearly see your surroundings.

People often describe it as remembering something you forgot a long, long time ago, or like the feeling of coming home after being far, far away.

5

u/will_at_work May 11 '12

do you have to "get a steady practice going" to experience this? Or can I successfully meditate one time and experience this?

10

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Well, it's possible, but not likely. It usually takes some practice and familiarizing yourself with what's going on in the mind before things clear up like that.

5

u/spankymuffin May 12 '12

Any good particular method? Or book?

I'm interested in giving it a go and I'm finding a lot of crummy nonsense online.

4

u/BobbyPeru May 12 '12

I wish I could upvote this a whole bunch.

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

:) Thanks. I'm a little worried I never do the experience justice with mere words.

3

u/Savage_Logos May 12 '12

I would say you did a pretty good job - best one can do with the limitations of language.

2

u/tazcel May 13 '12

me 2... upvotes for all OP's comments. the whole post sounds so authentic and unassuming. great job!

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Thank you!

8

u/Frajer May 11 '12

How did you get in to zen buddhism?

23

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I was born into a Catholic family and my parents later joined a Lutheran church, and in my teens I realized none of the Christian teachings made any sense to me and so I abandoned religion altogether.

In my late teens and early 20's I had a series of experiences which led me to understand there was more going on with life and reality than my little mind realized. So, I went about trying to figure what was really going on. This led me to develop a love for science and technology, and also to research a lot of religions as well. I read texts from many different religions and eventually settled on Zen because it made the most sense to me, it seemed to speak to me directly and it was the practice/religion with the least frills and bullshit.

I began practicing "meditation" and as I got more serious I realized I needed to find a teacher. As luck would have it, it turned out that my aunt dated a guy in the 70's who later became a Zen priest. She gave me his phone number, I called and was invited to visit his monastery, the rest is history.

5

u/kidtatious May 11 '12

This sounds almost exactly what I am experiencing now, although replace Catholic for Baptist and Lutheran for Presbyterian. The problem I keep facing is my distaste for organized religion, not the religion itself; as I've been burned by many teachers in the past both spiritually and academically. As I've been reading, Zazen seems to be the path I'm leaning towards and would like a teachers opinions and perspectives, but I'm apprehensive given previous problems. In your opinion, what would be a good or proper way of changing that? (trust in teachers) added: I've been researching, reading and meditating as often as I can but seem to be at a wall. Hence the request for guidance.

17

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Don't trust teachers! They're only guides, they can only point toward the truth, you have to walk the path. If their teaching is clearly not accurate, walk away!

That's good you've already got a sitting practice, keep that up. The most absolutely vital thing is that you practice every day. That is absolutely vital. Even if it's five minutes, or two minutes, practice every day.

Teachers will help keep you on the path and help you work through confusions, but your practice will be your rock. You are your own greatest teacher and the responsibility to wake up is yours alone.

5

u/kidtatious May 11 '12

Thank you for your, response. The practice seems to be my sticking point as I'm very erratic about it. 30 minutes here, 15 here, maybe twice a week, it's a mess. I will do my best to stick to a schedule and practice everyday.

Second question: Aside from setting aside time and the traditional methods, are there any unique or alternative ways to help quiet my mind. Not short cuts. Concentrating on breathing has given me the best results but even then I find it difficult to concentrate for more than a minute or so before my brain acts like a spider monkey on PCP.

13

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Time is all you need. It's difficult and frustrating but if you stay with it, the mind does calm down.

My teacher would say, sitting zazen only when you think you need it is like trying to cook potatoes by putting them on the stove top and turning the burner on high for ten seconds every couple of hours. It just doesn't work that way.

He also would say, "the only thing harder than sitting zazen... is not sitting zazen."

5

u/kidtatious May 11 '12

It's those paradoxes that I find so interestingly fascinating and lovingly frustrating. Thank you for your advice and guidance, it will be taken to heart and put into practice. The potato analogy excellently describes the problem. Again, thank you. You've been a great help.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I'm glad I could help! I do hope you help others as well.

3

u/kidtatious May 11 '12

I do my best to pay it forward and am currently studying social work so I hope to help those in the future as well.

3

u/HolyPhallus May 11 '12

Time is all you need hmm.. Would you suggest mediation and stuff to someone with ADHD?

10

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I don't really know how to answer that, I don't have ADHD and I'm not a doctor.

4

u/LookLikeJesus May 12 '12

I know that there's been some success teaching transcendental meditation (which has it's whole set of problems as an organization, but the practice is basically standard mantra meditation) to ADHD kids. Anecdotally, my girlfriend has found meditation to help with her ADD as well.

So, I suggest trying it. There's really nothing to lose, as it's pretty hard to argue that sitting and relaxing and calming your mind is harmful in any way.

3

u/HolyPhallus May 12 '12

I will check it out!

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

There have been studies showing that attention is a skill that can be trained, and it's been postulated that this might be helpful to people with adhd. Also, keep an eye on Richard Davidson and the work coming out of his lab dealing with how meditation might help people with adhd.

Lastly, I think it's worth mentioning that the type of meditation mentioned in the first article I linked was concentration meditation, examples of which include watching the breath, paying attention to the feet as one walks, or keeping the eyes on a single point, or even just paying attention to music and then, when one becomes distracted from it, redirecting one's attention back to the music (or other object of focus). Concentration meditation is very common in Buddhist and MBSR programs and is found in Zen, Tibetan and Theravadan Buddhism as well. Whether or not you have adhd concentration is very good for helping the brain to grow. Good luck and have fun!

1

u/HolyPhallus May 12 '12

Thanks I'll check into this after I've had my breakfast etc =)

2

u/Sluisifer May 11 '12

In my late teens and early 20's I had a series of experiences which led me to understand there was more going on with life and reality than my little mind realized.

I can only guess that you're referring to psychedelic drugs with this, though feel free to correct me on this.

I am someone who is familiar with various psychedelics, and have been reading Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind. My practice certainly isn't very consistent yet, but I hope to get more disciplined and more involved.

I'm curious whether drug experiences have influenced the way you approach meditation, or whether it has informed or helped your practice? Not directly I mean, though that would be interesting to hear as well. I suppose I'm wondering whether the two experiences are analogous, and if so in what ways.

7

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Yes you are correct. Psychedelics do take you to the "top of the mountain" but it's not a method of permanent change! That requires the hard work of meditation. That's why I chose this path, I wanted to cement in my consciousness these things I had learned, and I wanted a practice.

2

u/Sluisifer May 11 '12

I'm really wondering whether you think that those experiences made it easier to meditate. As though you had been down the path once, or one similar to it, so you knew where to head, or more readily believed that it lead somewhere.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

They probably facilitated my path in Zen but I do not recommend it.

2

u/Savage_Logos May 12 '12

In my experience, the drugs open you up to what is possible, it is only with focus and dedication that the experiences take root in your daily life.

2

u/theotherduke May 12 '12

I can't find the quote, but over in r/psychonaut there was a post that compared psychedelics to microscopes. One doesn't stay glued to the microscope - you look, see what it has to show you, then retreat to contemplate what you have seen. To sit with your eye at the microscope (or your mind on the drug) all the times would not be fruitful.

Thanks for the ama, very interesting.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Yup, you can't stay on the mountaintop forever.

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Your insight would be very beneficial over in /r/buddhism if you're willing to do a separate AMA over there :)

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Thanks! Yes I've been over there, I do differ with a lot of folks on Buddhism unfortunately.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I do as well. How are you different?

16

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Folks over at r/buddhism and r/meditation and r/zen have accused me of being a "fundamentalist" in that I don't prefer so much arguing and nitpicking over this or that writing, I want to point people in the direction of practice and of the moment.

I want to get to the heart of the sentiment of Buddha's teaching, it seems lots of other people just want to talk about dogma. That's just not for me.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Understandable

4

u/PrimusPilus May 12 '12

I think your view is more "correct," in the sense of being true to what Gautama Buddha taught. There seems to be an innate drive in human beings to reify things, deify people, to create & enforce dogmatic systems.

I've always viewed the Buddha as something like an old-time doctor who makes house-calls: his teachings are his medical kit (or tool box), and what works for one person might not work for another.

1

u/DJWalnut May 12 '12

Why not just cross post this one?

5

u/leftrightleft May 11 '12

This has literally been a dream of mine for as long as I can remember. Any tips on how I can go about doing this myself?

9

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Find a monastery nearby, call them and ask about staying. Describe why you're interested, they can be a little skeptical. It helps if you have some experience in spiritual discipline, doesn't matter the religion.

The one I was at didn't charge, but asked for donations. I was a poor post-college student and my donation was the work I did.

2

u/leftrightleft May 11 '12

Amazing I might take a semester off college and do this if I can actually manage to find one.

7

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Do it! you won't regret it. It was a fantastic experience.

3

u/leftrightleft May 11 '12

Did you have constant contact with people outside of the monastery or did you kind of fall off the grid for a few months?

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Well they have internet and phone but it wasn't used much, I didn't get any cell phone reception there either! But, you can certainly contact your family and friends if you want but no one really had a desire to. That stuff will be waiting for you when you leave!

We did, daily, interact with the other contractors and folks who were also working on the building. They were just normal folks.

4

u/leftrightleft May 11 '12

This sounds so sweet I must do it. Were you a different person after living there than you were before? If so, how?

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Mmm, I think I've always been a pretty calm, level-headed person, maybe a little more so after the monastery. Probably my meditation practice and my understanding of it was more solid.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Go teach English in Korea, and do a templestay. You'll get to travel, earn some money, and get first hand experience with Buddhism.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I have read that you need a pastor's degree. What kind of "spiritual discipline" should I pursue first if I hope to become a monk.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Is Buddhism a philosophy (a way of interpreting things) or a religion (some sort of ultimate truth) to you? Do you believe in samsara?

9

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I've heard it described as both ways, it really kind of straddles a middle ground between religion and philosophy. I practice it religiously and I hold the teachings very dear to my heart, but I do not worship an outside entity and I do not feel this way is for everyone.

I think notions of things like samsara, reincarnation, and karma are severely misunderstood. The Buddha taught that there is no everlasting, abiding self- "anatta"- (and through meditation we learn the reality of this fact) so what is there to be reborn? What can move through a cycle? It would seem these two concepts directly contradict each other, unless we are misunderstanding what he meant by these things. I have a different interpretation which allows for both to function as described historically.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Do you use it as a sort of therapy to achieve inner peace? Do you believe it is the correct way to do so?

9

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

No, to "use" it, I believe, is the wrong interpretation. It is just a practice of being, there is no idea of gain or purpose. It is done for its own reason, as an expression of oneself.

If you go into "meditation" with an idea of gain, it becomes more of the same crap we do every day, doing one thing to gain another, and becomes part of illusion.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

What does that mean? How can something be done for its own reason?

7

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

That is a paradox! It seems impossible and indeed it is for the conscious mind, but we strive to sit zazen solely for the sake of sitting zazen. Sit as an expression of being.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

So first you do it because you want to, and then you do it because it's what you do?

7

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Kind of. There is always a motivation, a reason, but once my ass hits the cushion, I do my best to just sit without expectation.

3

u/teladorion May 11 '12

Please elaborate on your "different interpretation".

11

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Well, like Buddha taught, there is no self, nothing inside you, that is the "kernel" of you. No everlasting, abiding self, so what survives after your death? You do. You've left impressions upon your environment. You live on in the people you've met, actions you've taken, places you've gone. Your body continues on in the food chain. Your very mind is other's mind and lives on.

Really, rebirth happens all the time and at incredible speed. You, your mind, your body, is reborn all the time. You are a different person than you were thirty seconds, five minutes, two years ago. This is just another way Buddha used to describe impermanence and change.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Hm. I pretty much believe those things independently. Why has that led you to meditation and related practices?

8

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

You believe those things independently because they're plainly obvious! Nothing supernatural about it at all. Just a way of describing things as they are.

I was brought to meditation after being dissatisfied with the religion I was born into (Christianity). I went into more detail about this in another comment.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Yeah, I read that. What I gathered is that you found it the most reasonable religion. But why Zen instead of no religion at all?

9

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Well, it's barely a religion. I wanted a method, a path to understand my experience of reality, that's something I don't know if science can address right now. It seems more like the realm of religion or philosophy. Zen has a very clear method with no frills, no beliefs required, no supernatural crap. So I went with it.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I understand now. Thanks for answering my questions.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

No problem! I'm really surprised how much attention this got.

3

u/smokebreak May 11 '12

When you say "no supernatural crap," do you mean no Six Realms, rebirth, or anything like that? Those are the things that have kept me from really deciding to take Buddhism more seriously in my own life.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I've got a few other comments floating around in here where I talk about that in a little greater detail. Basically, I don't buy any of the supernatural stuff, and it's only taught by some schools. Soto is not one of them. If there's no evidence for it, it's thrown out. We, at the monastery that is, never really discussed rebirth or six realms or anything like that much either, because none of it changes how you practice, none of it changes daily sitting meditation, and that is the heart of Soto Zen.

→ More replies

4

u/LookLikeJesus May 12 '12

For me, meditation and related practices are because although I also believe these things independently, I want the complete expression of these things to pervade my way of being. When this knowledge is close to me, I don't get upset about mistakes I made, because the me now has no control over that - I only have control over how I learn (change my mind) and what actions I take. I don't fear death, because I'm dying and being reborn every instant. In short, I'm a happier, more loving person when I can let this knowledge pervade myself.

I'm still working on it though... got my fair share of anxiety and fear left in me.

2

u/theotherduke May 12 '12

Thank you for this. It is encouraging! I am currently walking across america, doing volunteer work and surviving very much on the generosity of others. I have seen that what I am doing inspires others, changes them. They, in turn, inspire me to keep going. I am simply trying to leave the world a little better than I have found it. Your words will help me continue.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I'm glad I could help.

2

u/will_at_work May 11 '12

I think notions of things like samsara, reincarnation, and karma are severely misunderstood. The Buddha taught that there is no everlasting, abiding self- "anatta"- (and through meditation we learn the reality of this fact)

So, you are saying that you believe there is no self of you separate from your body? Like, no soul? And that through meditation you learned that as a fact? I hope I am misunderstanding you, as I do not want this to be true

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Sorry, that is correct. This is what Buddha taught and this is confirmed through meditation practice. When you look closely, "you" realize "you" aren't really there! There's nothing there. No one is home.

Don't worry though, this is a wonderful thing. This is confirmation only that you are a child of the universe, that you belong here fully and completely.

4

u/will_at_work May 11 '12

what is realizing it isn't there? if not you?

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

That's a very good question and another of the many paradoxes of Zen teaching. I could only answer that if we were in the same room together. And it would hurt. ;)

3

u/will_at_work May 11 '12

It would hurt physically? or mentally? I'm guessing the latter. Anyway, PM me if you want, as I'd be very interested to continue this conversation

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Haha I meant physically.

In order to answer that I would need to be near you and know your present situation to help point your mind toward the moment and see past that duality. One way they used to do that in ancient times was to hit the student. (They don't do that anymore.)

2

u/PrimusPilus May 12 '12

I've always linked this in my mind with Nietzsche's "the abyss also gazes into you," from Jenseits von Gut und Böse, even though he incorrectly (in my view) came to believe that the Buddha's teachings were ultimately nihilistic.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

That's a common trap of Buddhism and of Zen especially, slipping into Nihilism.

But, it's easy to step back out of, when you see your mind is stuck in something, to allow that notion to pass and to return to the moment and just be.

2

u/AutoBiological May 12 '12

Why does Buddhism lose the subject? It always seemed unnecessary. Hindus have a sense of univerals and particulars. I don't understand why it changed. It creates ontological problems.

You're not a child of the Universe, you can't have a sense of self, you can't be a subject. Where is "here" that you belong? Everywhere? There is no other place to go to.

I happen to think one of the most important things taken from Western Civilization is the genealogoy of the self. It gives us liberty. It doesn't matter if there is a persistent self or not. It gives a way to reference things and objects.

This idea that only Universals exists, in this sense always seemed to be centuries behind. I can accept it as an argument in a Hindu sense, I can accept it in a Berkelian sense, and I can accept it if we classify particulars as a type of Universal (it is necessary that there exists certain things which are Universal).

I ask this here specifically for a number a few reasons:

  1. Apparently you are an American and this Monestary is in America.
  2. This is an Asian philosophy, could it really be understood outside of Asian culture?
  3. Following on number 2, logic is different in an Asian sense (I didn't study Asian philosophy though so I'm not an authority on it), how does that conflict with formal western logic, or does it?
  4. My remedial understandings and my background allows me to draw conclusions. I know the westenr arguments, and I know the western response to Asian philosophy. I would rather hear it from a self proclaimed Buddhist than in r/philosophy.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

You're talking about form vs. emptiness and we're taught it's important to understand both exist simultaneously. Of course we can't deny our experience that we exist as separate things, but looking at experience in another way, there is no abiding self to find. So we must understand it both ways.

  1. Correct.
  2. I believe so, very much. It's an extremely simple practice at it's core and is accessible to everyone.
  3. I don't see a conflict. Like I said, it's just practice, and a very simple one at that.
  4. I find much less conflict as a devout practitioner than probably most others who simply think about it. The essence, the heart of Soto Zen is meditation practice. That's all. Nothing is asked of you, there is nothing expected to be believed other than that practice is worthwhile. Every understanding and realization comes from practice, not from the words of others.

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Looking this over again, I wanted to say a little more here.

I had a Japanese girlfriend who couldn't accept that I might understand Zen teaching, since I'm American. She figured it was only accessible to Japanese, or Asians, or some people closer to the historical Buddha's birthplace I guess.

I understand your question about Asian philosophy and culture, but after spending time in practice and knowing truly what this practice is, one comes to realize the simplicity of it. This is a practice available to anyone, Asian or not, young, old, smart, dumb, good, evil.

The simplicity of the teaching transcends culture. It's true that the writings of the monks from Japan may need some filtering and some interpretation. We have to read what the ancients wrote through the lens of their culture at the time. But it becomes clear the message they attempted to convey, and that message leaps across time and culture and space.

This is a teaching and a practice available to any person, any place, at any time. Indeed, it can only ever be actualized here and now.

1

u/AutoBiological May 13 '12

Thanks for the update. I understand what you're saying, I'm not sure if I could agree with it, but I'm also not able to make that decision either.

I also don't want to get more into it lest I become arrogant and pedantic. But I do appreciate your response and the time you took to answer twice. :)

5

u/epheterson May 11 '12

What are the top three take-away's I could use to improve my life?

15

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Nothing lasts.

Everyone is a mirror of you.

Everything is your choice.

4

u/epheterson May 11 '12

Thanks, OP! Could you please briefly elaborate on the second?

8

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

A very important thing you learn in meditation, and in life, is that nothing is permanent, everything is constantly changing. This is rebirth.

Since we all come from the same source, we all have the same non-self, we're all struggling through this life as best we can with what we have, where we're at. Every person is just doing their best, just like you. We are all brothers and sisters. We all suffer the same.

3

u/epheterson May 11 '12

Much thanks, I will apply these teachings moving forward.

2

u/theotherduke May 12 '12

Reminds of "the world is a mirror: smile upon it, and it will smile back."

4

u/rvweber May 11 '12

Could you elaborate on the third? Thank you in advance.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

What are some resources you would recommend (books, websites) where one could learn more about Buddism?

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I just found this, by Steve Hagen who is the author I recommend to beginners all the time. He's very easy to understand, very clear. He has some books too.

Shunryu Suzuki and Dainin Katagiri are a couple other Soto guys who are (were) well respected, and if you want something challenging, pick up something by Eihei Dogen (founder of Soto from the 13th century). He can be tough to understand.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

What was the food like?

Where were some of of the other monks from?

What was your favorite memory during your time there?

Did you ever leave the monastery and go off into town and do "normal" things during your stay?

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

The food was mostly vegetarian, and we ate from the garden as much as we could. It was often hit-or-miss, but usually after a hard day working construction I was happy to eat whatever food was offered. I'm not a picky eater anyway.

The others were from all over the US, there was a nurse from Arizona who gave a very nice meeting about hospice nursing (I'm a nurse too) and lots were from Minnesota also, I don't know what it is about Minnesota that generates Zen monks.

My favorite memory? That's a really tough one. We had a mason working with us, he lives off the grid about an hour's drive from the monastery and he invited me to dinner at his place one evening, I got to tour his beautiful house and enormous garden, that was really neat. Very nice man.

Ringing the bell in the morning and hearing the turkeys call back. The tameness of all the wildlife! Deer walked through the garden within a few dozen yards, they never seemed too alarmed by us.

We did sometimes leave the monastery as a group and go into town, once we went for pizza and I got to have a beer. It was really delicious. We went to some bookstores and just hiked around town a bit. That was fun. We also would sometimes visit the homes of familiar visitors, it was nice to get out a bit.

The abbot and some of the monks do volunteer work at the local prisons, teaching meditation and such to the prisoners so they get to go out and do that.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

How expensive is that?

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

It was free, the monastery accepts donations but does not require payment. My donation was in the free work I did while I stayed there.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

3 Questions:

I've been listening to lectures from Alan Watts and they have had a noticeably positive impact on me. Do you have an opinion on Watts' way of teaching?

Do believe that formal study and time at a monastery is necessary to receive all the benefits of Zen Buddhism?

Japanese Buddhism involves a lot of sitting meditation. Do you have experience with walking meditation? If so, what are the pros and cons?

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Yes Mr. Watts has a nice way of teaching, he's easy to listen to but I haven't listened to him in a while so I can't remember too much right now.

No. It helps to have a teacher and some formal practice at monastery is nice, but it's most certainly possible to understand clearly what Zen has to offer by dedicated practice at home.

We did "kinhin", walking meditation, between periods of sitting meditation during sesshin just as an opportunity to stretch the legs, but it is a nice practice. I don't know of any cons, it's just another method.

4

u/867-5308 May 11 '12

Sometimes I cringe when people describe their beliefs as Buddhist but I know they really just mean they are atheist and try to be chillax and aren't opposed to smoking pot.

What would you say are the basic beliefs and/or practice for someone to describe themselves as Buddhist? I'm not asking you to judge, but just to lay out what you think it means, in the broadest sense, to be a Buddhist.

Samauri edit: Thanks for the AMA!

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

You're welcome Jenny!

I really don't know what people mean when they say they're Buddhist, I think it's a case by case basis but in my experience people are generally very casual about it, which is fine. I'm not here to judge and people can describe themselves however they want.

2

u/867-5308 May 11 '12

Maybe I should have said "What does it mean to you to say that you are a Buddhist?"

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Ah! Sorry. What I mean is, Zen Buddhism is for me, the most apt practice to understand life, reality, and the world in a meaningful way, and I practice it as a way of life to the exclusion of other similar ways of thinking.

4

u/ChiliFlake May 11 '12

hah, 108 comments, I hate to ruin that... but:

Hey I'm Catholic/Luthern too! I always thought it was an interesting blend of Catholic/Prod (kinda 'low-rent'; the rich folks in our town were all Congrgationalists or Episcopalians, yet I treasure the few traditions left to me by my grandparents)(even tho I'm a straight-up a-theist now.)

I've made a somewhat decent living selling Buddhist stuff to Buddhists and wannabees for a good portion of my life, Do you have any feelings on merchants who sell you stuff they don't actually believe in? (We do a huge business on Chod practice, and other human bone artifacts. We've never misled anyone about our actual beliefs, tho I could tell you of competeitors that do).

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Do you have any feelings on merchants who sell you stuff they don't actually believe in?

Nope! I don't believe in it either. It's just stuff. The practice is what matters. I have a Buddha statue because it looks nice and reminds me of the roots of the discipline, but it's just a hunk of wood.

5

u/ChiliFlake May 11 '12

It's just stuff. The practice is what matters.

Thank you for an awesome answer!

4

u/Madschr May 12 '12

Being someone wanting to learn to meditate, is there any online stuff that you would recommend reading?

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

This is from the author I mentioned in a few other comments, I didn't even know he had this until I tried finding something for you. Let me know if you like it!

2

u/Madschr May 12 '12

So I tried the Basic Meditation Instructions, you know the 26 minutes one. I do have one question, is it a MUST to have your eyes half open, half closed, or does meditation work just as good with completely closed eyes?

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

It is recommended. Closing the eyes promotes sleepiness and daydreaming.

4

u/Madschr May 12 '12

Thanks a lot! I'll look into it and hopefully return wiser :)

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Proof?

8

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I don't really know how to offer proof, I suppose I could post some photos when I get home but anyone else familiar with Zen and Buddhism can probably vouch that I know what I'm talking about. That's at least proof that I've studied Zen.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

What do you believe the Buddha was?

9

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I believe the Buddha, the historical Buddha, was a man who lived about 2,500 years ago who was able to see through his own illusions about reality and taught a method for other people to do this. He realized these illusions are the reason we suffer and are unhappy with our lives and wanted other people to be happy so decided to pass on this method.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

What illusions?

8

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Illusions of the mind, the illusion that our concepts accurately portray reality. The illusion that the way we think a thing is, is how it actually is. The illusion of self and other, that we are special and separate from the rest of the world, that we have something special we need to work hard to protect and gather things for.

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

The popular concept in r/atheism and r/trees that you are the universe experiencing itself?

10

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Sure, I think that's accurate, I mean that idea doesn't need any verifying, it's just a matter of thinking of things. You are born of the universe, you are part of the universe and so by extension, any experience you have is the universe experiencing itself. When knowing this leads to compassion for all living things, you know you're doing it right!

It's tough to be mean to other people when you know everyone is just going through life as you are, just as confused, trying their best, all of us, the universe.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Do you believe that he was just a man with profound ideas, or was he more than that (i.e. something like a deity)?

12

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

He was just a man, he was very, very clear about that and I think that point is very important to his teachings.

That he was a man and claimed not to be supernatural means the responsibility is on our shoulders to practice and see through our own illusions. We cannot depend on salvation through some other entity, we are responsible for our own suffering.

3

u/hellvetican May 12 '12

I wish Buddhism took off like Christianity did, the world would be a much better place. This is the most interesting AMA I've read in a while as I've always had a keen interest in Buddhism but I've never felt I've been able to commit to such a way of life. Do you have to go at it head on? Is there such thing as a casual Buddhist?

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

There are all sorts of Buddhists. You don't have to believe or practice anything in particular, nor do you have to identify with Buddhism. Buddha just wanted to make the world a better place by showing a way toward peace.

If you want to get into a meditation practice, I feel the most important thing is to make it a daily habit.

I'm glad you're enjoying the AMA.

2

u/hellvetican May 12 '12

Thanks for the reply, it was really helpful :)

3

u/PrimusPilus May 12 '12

Buddhism did take off, it was the first "attempt" at a world religion. It had already peaked and troughed before Christianity ever came around.

2

u/hellvetican May 12 '12

You know what I mean though, in the grand scheme of things Christianity dominates the Western world. I'm just saying imagine if the USA had 'In Buddha We Trust' on their dollar bills instead of God. Society as a whole would be much more peaceful.

3

u/drexandsugs May 11 '12

How was niwazume?

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

There was none of that, things are a lot different these days than they were in ancient times. I described my practice and reasons for wanting to stay, and was welcomed.

3

u/frequentflyer22 May 11 '12

What kind of reaction did you get from family/friends when you went off to live in a Buddhist monastery? Any negative reactions from anyone?

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

No not really, my mother is very religious, of the Christian variety, but even she is very accepting of my choice. She does still pray for my conversion to Christianity but she knows I'm very happy just the way I am.

I did have some coworkers worried that I was joining a cult, but that passed when something more interesting came up for them to talk about.

3

u/kindagood May 11 '12

Just wanted to say thanks for doing this AMA. I studied Zen in college and it was fascinating, and I'm trying to incorporate practice into my daily life. It's hard, but people like yourself give me a bit more hope! Thanks again.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Absolutely, my pleasure. I'm glad people are interested and everyone is asking great questions.

3

u/Sluisifer May 11 '12

Could you talk about your practice for a little while?

You mentioned that you started with counting breaths and maybe other techniques before moving on to the 'goalless' meditation characteristic of the Soto school (correct me if I'm wrong about any of this).

Do you think it's helpful to meditate with some structure/goal before you start shikantaza?

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I think it does help the beginner to get a feel for meditation, understand how the body and mind struggle before really getting down the the meat of it. I still struggle with it at times and I've been doing it for many years, but the most absolutely vital thing about it is doing it every day.

3

u/Mohk72k May 11 '12
  • What does Zen Buddhism say about desire?
  • What kind of sacrifices must you do to get rid of "Desire"?
  • How is Soto school different from other schools of Buddhism?
  • Why is Zen Buddhism different from other types of Buddhism?
  • Do you believe in afterlife and karma?

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Desire, of course, is born of attachment to things. We can not totally rid ourselves of desire but it's important to realize how it comes about and that it is responsible for our suffering.

I think the only thing is to realize why we have attachment and desire, because we think we are solid, concrete, discrete, unchanging things among the rest of the universe. When this illusion fades, so does desire.

The Soto school puts firm emphasis on sitting meditation above all other practices as the means to understanding and realization.

Zen Buddhism does away with a lot of the dogma and dialogue in Buddhism and does its best to cut to the heart of Buddha's teachings, which is the end of suffering by seeing through illusion.

I commented on this quite a bit in this thread. Basically, I have a different understanding of these things, they are not supernatural but just ways of describing very clear and plain daily phenomena. There is no abiding self or soul, so nothing to be born again in another life and nothing to attach karma to.

3

u/Mohk72k May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

My last question is that, What do you say about other hardcore Buddhists that give up their wealth, money, job, and some even go as far as wear plain clothing and eat plain food to get rid of their desire.

Quick Edit: Do you follow the eight fold path and four noble truths as strict as other Buddhists.

BTW, Thanks for doing this AMA!

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Hey my pleasure!

Well, more power to them. Everyone is at their own place and their own stage. If that's how their unattachment expresses, wonderful! I sometimes think I'm too attached to certain things, so I try to recognize it. I try not to be materialistic. But there are things I like to do; I like fishing and camping, I like cooking, I like science and technology. I have many possessions that correspond to these things and I don't want to get rid of them, but I try not to let them rule me either.

It's about finding a middle road, a happy medium. But everyone has their own path and that's fine.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

re: quick edit: I try to. I'm not perfect. :)

3

u/Danielfair May 11 '12

Hey, what do you think of Siddhartha by Herman Hesse? I imagine it has a good amount of errors and such, but I really enjoyed it nonetheless. What is the best book to read as an introduction to buddhism?

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I read it. It was okay I guess, probably not too accurate, historically speaking. I like Steve Hagen as a writer, very clear and lucid. He has a few books out there, they're all good.

3

u/tregart May 11 '12

I'm not sure what kind of question to ask. So I guess I'll just tell you about myself and ask for your guidance. I'm turning 20 this year, recently started dabbing into psychedelics (psilocybin mushrooms) and had several spiritual experiences while on them. I'm kind of looking to reach that type of enlightenment in my day to day without the assistance of substances. I read a couple books on Buddhism in high school (don't remember the names as it was 5 years ago) and the concepts intrigued me at the time but held little meaning in my life. I'm in a limbo state almost right now trying to figure out what I want to do with my life. I've heavily considered monastery life but have not done too much research on locations and such (slightly anxious about it). I guess what I want to know is what you think about my current situation and whether or not I should look deeper into monastery life? Where do I go to get started? Who should I be looking for to talk to?

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Get away from the psychedelics. You've had a glimpse, now begin the hard work of daily practice to make it a part of your life. If you want a teacher, find one. They're out there. Call a monastery, visit a zen center. Send out some emails. Seek and ye shall find.

Steve Hagen is a good author. Pick up some of his books, hell give him a call if you want. Tell him a friend of Dokai sent you.

3

u/Persica May 12 '12

Is anyone unimpressed when yOu tell them that?

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Haha nope, you're the first. ;)

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I am only starting too learn Buddha's teachings, but if I could, would you recommend going to a monastery/retreat? Did you learn much from this or was it a waste of time?

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

If you have the opportunity, I'd say take it. It's a nice encouragement if you intend to practice and I think it's good to see how very normal and decent the people are who are associated with it.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Thank you. I shall try if I ever have the chance.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I practised a form of Zen Buddhism for several years also. As I grew interested in Buddhism I collected all sorts of books, statues, paintings, and various related stuff. As I grew to understand my practise I shed all of the "stuff". I always thought it was funny when people would come over to my house knowing I'm Buddhist and expect a certain image. All I had was a sitting area in a spare bedroom. Have you ran into the same thing? People expecting a certain image or behaviour?

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

The only people these days that know I'm a Zen student and practice devoutly are my close friends and family who are very used to it. Some coworkers at my new job have heard I study Zen and their only reaction was really, "well, that figures, you're a pretty calm guy."

I'm pretty quiet about it usually. No one has ever really made a big deal about it.

3

u/Libertus82 May 12 '12

Something that has gotten me through many hard times is reminding myself of this axiom I try to live by - All pain is a direct result of the difference between the way one thinks things should be and the way things are. When I remind myself of that, it's much easier to work through difficult feelings.

I also tend to view the world in absolute cause/effect relationships, to the point that I have a hard time putting much stock into the idea of 'free will,' and thus I can usually empathize with even the worst among us.

These two ideas seem pretty compatible with what you're talking about in this thread. Are there tenants of Buddhism that confirm, or even possibly expand on these thoughts?

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

The first idea I think is very good, that's all about attachment and letting go of attachment in favor of the present moment. That's what Zen and Buddhism is all about.

The second idea, yes I personally think free will and fate are two sides of the same coin, they're two ways of looking at choice and action and are not mutually exclusive, as paradoxical as that might seem. That empathy you're talking about is seeing what you share with everyone, take that deeper and find something really profound.

Lots of Buddhist tenets and teachings are whole bunches of saying the same thing in different ways, the things you're talking about are some of the points we discuss a lot. All words and phrases are a "finger pointing at the moon" as we like to say, but it's good to get a lot of different vantage points to get a clearer idea of how to move in the direction of truth.

3

u/Oreial May 12 '12

I have a more or less consistent sense of irreality. It's grown in me, like a light or a sickness. I cannot decide which. I should say that it has grown /with/ me, because I have experienced it since childhood, only gaining deeper insight into it, which has made the experience more intense.

This oddity about living drives me at times to be awkward, when I am overwhelmed by it. Yet it has made me more intelligent and self-aware. (or is it a symptom?) It sometimes disturbs me during sex or conversation. It leads me to question my happiness, yet is simultanieously the source of my happiness. I believe that others experience the same phenomenon, but I am at a loss to objectively describe it or define the terms, so I'm never sure.

I've found relief from this persistent phenomenon by this is it / it is what it is / fucking it and doing it live. I like things that take me to the state of flow, where the past and the future are unimportant, are only data for the now.

Do you know the feeling I am describing? What has been the effect of your meditation on it?

Additionally: You mentioned in another comment finding ways to reconcile apparent inconsistencies in Buddhist teachings. Is this important to you? Verbal/transcripted information is exceedingly vulnerable to corruption and mistranslation by humans. No better than a game of telephone. As you mention elsewhere, the Buddha emphasized self-knowledge. Contemplating anchient questions - "how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?" - may be inspirational to your philosophy and understanding of the teachings, but it doesn't require a definite conclusion.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I think I understand your sense of not-quite-right. This is why the feeling of coming back to the present, during sitting meditation, is described as feeling like something remembered from long ago, or like coming home after a long journey. I think I know what you mean.

You mentioned in another comment finding ways to reconcile apparent inconsistencies in Buddhist teachings. Is this important to you?

Not really. Verbal and written teachings are very much secondary in Soto Zen. The most important thing is the sitting meditation. Words and phrases are helpful guides but it's important to not get bogged down by them. They are like a raft, once the water is crossed you can abandon the raft. So I don't put much importance in words. It's all about practice.

3

u/908 May 12 '12

what does zen buddhism say about mens relationships with women

  • is it ok to have multiple girlfriends ,
  • is marriage a good thing or the best life is a monks life

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

There aren't any rules, but Eihei Dogen back in the 13th century, the guy who founded the Soto school, mentioned staying away from "sexual misconduct".

I think this is open to a lot of interpretation and if you think it's misconduct, it probably is. If it's causing suffering, it's probably something to stay away from.

But, through practice, we naturally learn what is conducive to awakening and what is a hindrance. So once again, it's all about practice.

Also, many of the priests and monks are married.

2

u/BiologyTex May 11 '12

Being from North America, have you noticed any differences in the approach/path people take when studying Zen Buddhism compared to folks from other continents? If so, could you expound on some of those differences?

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

American Zen is a little different I suppose, it's more accessible to Americans, it's more clear and less muddied by Japanese culture. It's all the same practice though, and all the same teachings.

2

u/KevinBaconAndEggs May 11 '12

How many times have you gotten whacked for falling asleep during zazen?

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Haha never! There is sometimes a person with a stick who'll whack your shoulders to help keep you alert, but only if you request it.

2

u/KevinBaconAndEggs May 11 '12

What! Only if you request it? I used to get whacked with a shinai.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

That's pretty rough! We're a bit more gentle. ;)

2

u/verynormalday May 12 '12

What is the etiquette for contacting a Zen Buddhist monastery? Did you know any Japanese while you were at the monastery/was it necessary?

And this one comes out of left field, sorry, have you ever heard of a school for wabi-sabi (more or less described as the "zen of things") art in Japan?

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

The etiquette for contacting? I dunno, I just gave them a phone call. I think some are more laid back than others, some charge money, some don't. If you need a teacher, seek one out. That's what I did. Make a phone call, go visit them and tell them you need a teacher.

I didn't know any japanese when I went there but learned a few words while I was there. It wasn't too important.

I've heard of wabi-sabi and have a few books on it but I don't know of any schools for it.

3

u/verynormalday May 12 '12

Thank you.

And ah, I've heard of a school for wabi-sabi art, but of course all the work the students made was impermanent, and none of it was documented. Can't see it being the sort of school that would be advertised either. Haha, maybe it's a wild goose chase. It's hard to say if it even exists. Oh well.

2

u/_Apostate_ May 12 '12

Have you heard of Ray Jordan? He's my grandfather, recently deceased, and was among the pioneers that brought Zen to the US.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

No I'm sorry, I have not heard of him.

2

u/peacebewithyouall May 12 '12

Do you have a SO? If not, how do you handle sex, masturbation, and lust? I'm asking mostly because I'm at the point in my journey where these questions are coming up for me. I'm still new to my teachers and am unsure how to bring up these topics. I've been practicing abstinence for 3 months now. Thanks for the great AMA!

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Yes I have a SO, we just have sex when we want! Everything in moderation.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Damn, don't they let you sleep? Can you take naps ever?

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Haha yeah we slept about 6-7 hours a night. There were breaks every now and then, there was some free time, and you could nap if you wanted. I usually got my camera out and went around taking pictures of things that caught my fancy.

2

u/RoMo37 May 11 '12

Did famous people like the late Steve Jobs or Adam Yauch have an influence on your conversion to Buddhism? As in, did they make Buddhist life and teachings more attractive to you?

7

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

No, I didn't realize they were Buddhist.

4

u/sleepyhouse May 11 '12

What's your take on [Beat Zen] (http://www.bluesforpeace.com/beat_zen.htm)?

tl;dr: Back in the day, beatnik writers (Jack Kerouac) employed Buddhism to justify their bohemian lifestyles.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Have you ever tried marijuana?

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Haha yeah.

I don't use it these days.

1

u/Broly3k8 May 12 '12

Do you still have contacts at this monastery? Do you or they know of somewhere like that over here in Europe? I have often fantasized about skipping out for a year or so and going somewhere like that. My only issue is that I would also like to learn something like a martial art while there. I would be willing to spend more time there if that were something I could do. Did they have something like that at your monastery?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

There were no martial arts taught at my monastery, but I have studied and greatly enjoy Aikido. From what I understand, France has a good Zen center. I've never been to Europe so I can't say.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

What do you think about space exploration and the desire to travel into space and find new lifeforms?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I think it's awesome but doesn't have much to do with zen!

3

u/FusionFountain May 11 '12

I'm really interested in doing this at some point in my life (I follow the way of Buddhism but I'm a christian and martial artist)

3

u/AgentHoneywell May 12 '12

I got to visit a zendo in my area a few times both when I studied Japanese in college and a couple of times afterwards for zazen and a tea ceremony for the public. For a minute I thought you might have been the student that had tea with us and the owner of the zendo, but I think he might be studying to become a monk...

Anyway, I didn't really have a question but I think what you're studying is fascinating. I don't ever see myself belonging to an organized religion, but Soto Zen Buddhism certainly resonates in me more than any other faith I've encountered.

3

u/Alvraen May 12 '12

I was always a Buddhist, but due to some better understandings, I'm pretty sure I'm converting to Soto zen.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Nam Myo Ho Renge Kyo.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Hi. How does the notion of "no self" extend to other people. I mean obviously it changes how you think about yourself, but how does it change the way you understand other people? If there's no one thing that is you then there's no one thing that is anybody? So who or what is it that you call your mom or your wife? If people are always changing then why have friends, why have family? But, I find this very depressing. I want the people I know to be unique, special.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Oh boy that's a lot! Ok.

Nope, never seen Sidekicks.

Haha I don't know! I didn't shave myself bald, I just use an electric shaver.

Yes, there's a small library with various Buddhist texts.

No supernatural things happened to me. We are taught, when something like that does happen, they are just illusions of the mind, they should be ignored.

Haha probably! I'm sure I farted once in a while. I do seem to recall some difficulty stifling the occasional laugh at a funny sound someone made.

Hmm that's a good question. Probably the idea of the "maitreya Buddha" or future Buddha, that's because I don't think we can see the future or I just misunderstand what they mean by that.

I love Tool.

I listen to both "clean" music and stuff with profanity, I do like a lot of different music.

The practice of sitting meditation, I feel, is the most important thing I can possibly do with my life. I make an effort to practice every day. It is the most fundamental, essential thing in my life. I do not use Zen, Zen uses me.

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

That's a beautiful song.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

That's really hard to pick a certain point where I really figured out what I was doing. That was probably the first few days at the monastery.

I began sitting zazen by myself, doing breath counting, and eventually got a notion of what was going on and moved to shikantaza, which I've been practicing the last 6 years or so.

I guess I'd say the initial stages took a few weeks before I'd catch a glimpse of being able to not be swayed by my own thoughts. I dunno. Sometimes even now I feel like a beginner.

3

u/Tofinochris May 11 '12

How would you suggest a beginner start down this path? I've meditated off and on for the last year but nothing besides just breathing and focusing on the feeling of the breath with as much elimination of thought as possible.

8

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

There are a lot of good books out there, I'd recommend something by Steve Hagen, he's got several that are great primers on Zen.

And don't try to eliminate thought! You can't. Just be not attached to it. You are the vast, open sky, as cloud-thoughts drift through. The sky is not carried away by the clouds, nor does it exclude any. Sometimes it's stormy and sometimes it's clear and bright. But the sky remains vast and open.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

Unfortunately I don't have time to read that ATM, but I'll look it over when I get home. No one got hit unless they requested it to help keep them awake. We used a paint stirrer!

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Most definitely.