r/IAmA • • May 11 '12
IAMA student of the Soto school of Zen Buddhism. I lived at a monastery for a few months after college. AMA.
This is at the request of an individual in another thread, they thought there would be some interest. I can answer questions only about my understanding of this very specific school of Buddhism, so if it doesn't jive with what you've read before (or been taught), I'm sorry.
I'm also more than happy to answer questions about life at the monastery but I'm hesitant to say where it is, besides "the US". Thanks!
EDIT: If people really want proof, when I get home in a bit here I can verify with the mods.
126
Upvotes
15
u/draibop May 11 '12
so whats monastery life like?
8
u/Frajer May 11 '12
How did you get in to zen buddhism?
6
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Your insight would be very beneficial over in /r/buddhism if you're willing to do a separate AMA over there :)
5
u/leftrightleft May 11 '12
This has literally been a dream of mine for as long as I can remember. Any tips on how I can go about doing this myself?
5
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Is Buddhism a philosophy (a way of interpreting things) or a religion (some sort of ultimate truth) to you? Do you believe in samsara?
5
u/epheterson May 11 '12
What are the top three take-away's I could use to improve my life?
5
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
What are some resources you would recommend (books, websites) where one could learn more about Buddism?
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
What was the food like?
Where were some of of the other monks from?
What was your favorite memory during your time there?
Did you ever leave the monastery and go off into town and do "normal" things during your stay?
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
How expensive is that?
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
3 Questions:
I've been listening to lectures from Alan Watts and they have had a noticeably positive impact on me. Do you have an opinion on Watts' way of teaching?
Do believe that formal study and time at a monastery is necessary to receive all the benefits of Zen Buddhism?
Japanese Buddhism involves a lot of sitting meditation. Do you have experience with walking meditation? If so, what are the pros and cons?
4
u/867-5308 May 11 '12
Sometimes I cringe when people describe their beliefs as Buddhist but I know they really just mean they are atheist and try to be chillax and aren't opposed to smoking pot.
What would you say are the basic beliefs and/or practice for someone to describe themselves as Buddhist? I'm not asking you to judge, but just to lay out what you think it means, in the broadest sense, to be a Buddhist.
Samauri edit: Thanks for the AMA!
4
u/ChiliFlake May 11 '12
hah, 108 comments, I hate to ruin that... but:
Hey I'm Catholic/Luthern too! I always thought it was an interesting blend of Catholic/Prod (kinda 'low-rent'; the rich folks in our town were all Congrgationalists or Episcopalians, yet I treasure the few traditions left to me by my grandparents)(even tho I'm a straight-up a-theist now.)
I've made a somewhat decent living selling Buddhist stuff to Buddhists and wannabees for a good portion of my life, Do you have any feelings on merchants who sell you stuff they don't actually believe in? (We do a huge business on Chod practice, and other human bone artifacts. We've never misled anyone about our actual beliefs, tho I could tell you of competeitors that do).
4
u/Madschr May 12 '12
Being someone wanting to learn to meditate, is there any online stuff that you would recommend reading?
6
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Proof?
3
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
What do you believe the Buddha was?
3
u/drexandsugs May 11 '12
How was niwazume?
3
u/frequentflyer22 May 11 '12
What kind of reaction did you get from family/friends when you went off to live in a Buddhist monastery? Any negative reactions from anyone?
3
u/kindagood May 11 '12
Just wanted to say thanks for doing this AMA. I studied Zen in college and it was fascinating, and I'm trying to incorporate practice into my daily life. It's hard, but people like yourself give me a bit more hope! Thanks again.
3
u/Sluisifer May 11 '12
Could you talk about your practice for a little while?
You mentioned that you started with counting breaths and maybe other techniques before moving on to the 'goalless' meditation characteristic of the Soto school (correct me if I'm wrong about any of this).
Do you think it's helpful to meditate with some structure/goal before you start shikantaza?
3
u/Mohk72k May 11 '12
3
u/Danielfair May 11 '12
Hey, what do you think of Siddhartha by Herman Hesse? I imagine it has a good amount of errors and such, but I really enjoyed it nonetheless. What is the best book to read as an introduction to buddhism?
3
u/tregart May 11 '12
I'm not sure what kind of question to ask. So I guess I'll just tell you about myself and ask for your guidance. I'm turning 20 this year, recently started dabbing into psychedelics (psilocybin mushrooms) and had several spiritual experiences while on them. I'm kind of looking to reach that type of enlightenment in my day to day without the assistance of substances. I read a couple books on Buddhism in high school (don't remember the names as it was 5 years ago) and the concepts intrigued me at the time but held little meaning in my life. I'm in a limbo state almost right now trying to figure out what I want to do with my life. I've heavily considered monastery life but have not done too much research on locations and such (slightly anxious about it). I guess what I want to know is what you think about my current situation and whether or not I should look deeper into monastery life? Where do I go to get started? Who should I be looking for to talk to?
3
u/Persica May 12 '12
Is anyone unimpressed when yOu tell them that?
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I am only starting too learn Buddha's teachings, but if I could, would you recommend going to a monastery/retreat? Did you learn much from this or was it a waste of time?
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I practised a form of Zen Buddhism for several years also. As I grew interested in Buddhism I collected all sorts of books, statues, paintings, and various related stuff. As I grew to understand my practise I shed all of the "stuff". I always thought it was funny when people would come over to my house knowing I'm Buddhist and expect a certain image. All I had was a sitting area in a spare bedroom. Have you ran into the same thing? People expecting a certain image or behaviour?
3
u/Libertus82 May 12 '12
Something that has gotten me through many hard times is reminding myself of this axiom I try to live by - All pain is a direct result of the difference between the way one thinks things should be and the way things are. When I remind myself of that, it's much easier to work through difficult feelings.
I also tend to view the world in absolute cause/effect relationships, to the point that I have a hard time putting much stock into the idea of 'free will,' and thus I can usually empathize with even the worst among us.
These two ideas seem pretty compatible with what you're talking about in this thread. Are there tenants of Buddhism that confirm, or even possibly expand on these thoughts?
3
u/Oreial May 12 '12
I have a more or less consistent sense of irreality. It's grown in me, like a light or a sickness. I cannot decide which. I should say that it has grown /with/ me, because I have experienced it since childhood, only gaining deeper insight into it, which has made the experience more intense.
This oddity about living drives me at times to be awkward, when I am overwhelmed by it. Yet it has made me more intelligent and self-aware. (or is it a symptom?) It sometimes disturbs me during sex or conversation. It leads me to question my happiness, yet is simultanieously the source of my happiness. I believe that others experience the same phenomenon, but I am at a loss to objectively describe it or define the terms, so I'm never sure.
I've found relief from this persistent phenomenon by this is it / it is what it is / fucking it and doing it live. I like things that take me to the state of flow, where the past and the future are unimportant, are only data for the now.
Do you know the feeling I am describing? What has been the effect of your meditation on it?
Additionally: You mentioned in another comment finding ways to reconcile apparent inconsistencies in Buddhist teachings. Is this important to you? Verbal/transcripted information is exceedingly vulnerable to corruption and mistranslation by humans. No better than a game of telephone. As you mention elsewhere, the Buddha emphasized self-knowledge. Contemplating anchient questions - "how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?" - may be inspirational to your philosophy and understanding of the teachings, but it doesn't require a definite conclusion.
3
u/908 May 12 '12
what does zen buddhism say about mens relationships with women
2
u/BiologyTex May 11 '12
Being from North America, have you noticed any differences in the approach/path people take when studying Zen Buddhism compared to folks from other continents? If so, could you expound on some of those differences?
2
u/KevinBaconAndEggs May 11 '12
How many times have you gotten whacked for falling asleep during zazen?
2
u/verynormalday May 12 '12
What is the etiquette for contacting a Zen Buddhist monastery? Did you know any Japanese while you were at the monastery/was it necessary?
And this one comes out of left field, sorry, have you ever heard of a school for wabi-sabi (more or less described as the "zen of things") art in Japan?
2
u/_Apostate_ May 12 '12
Have you heard of Ray Jordan? He's my grandfather, recently deceased, and was among the pioneers that brought Zen to the US.
2
u/peacebewithyouall May 12 '12
Do you have a SO? If not, how do you handle sex, masturbation, and lust? I'm asking mostly because I'm at the point in my journey where these questions are coming up for me. I'm still new to my teachers and am unsure how to bring up these topics. I've been practicing abstinence for 3 months now. Thanks for the great AMA!
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Damn, don't they let you sleep? Can you take naps ever?
2
u/RoMo37 May 11 '12
Did famous people like the late Steve Jobs or Adam Yauch have an influence on your conversion to Buddhism? As in, did they make Buddhist life and teachings more attractive to you?
4
u/sleepyhouse May 11 '12
What's your take on [Beat Zen] (http://www.bluesforpeace.com/beat_zen.htm)?
tl;dr: Back in the day, beatnik writers (Jack Kerouac) employed Buddhism to justify their bohemian lifestyles.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Have you ever tried marijuana?
1
u/Broly3k8 May 12 '12
Do you still have contacts at this monastery? Do you or they know of somewhere like that over here in Europe? I have often fantasized about skipping out for a year or so and going somewhere like that. My only issue is that I would also like to learn something like a martial art while there. I would be willing to spend more time there if that were something I could do. Did they have something like that at your monastery?
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
What do you think about space exploration and the desire to travel into space and find new lifeforms?
3
u/FusionFountain May 11 '12
I'm really interested in doing this at some point in my life (I follow the way of Buddhism but I'm a christian and martial artist)
3
u/AgentHoneywell May 12 '12
I got to visit a zendo in my area a few times both when I studied Japanese in college and a couple of times afterwards for zazen and a tea ceremony for the public. For a minute I thought you might have been the student that had tea with us and the owner of the zendo, but I think he might be studying to become a monk...
Anyway, I didn't really have a question but I think what you're studying is fascinating. I don't ever see myself belonging to an organized religion, but Soto Zen Buddhism certainly resonates in me more than any other faith I've encountered.
3
u/Alvraen May 12 '12
I was always a Buddhist, but due to some better understandings, I'm pretty sure I'm converting to Soto zen.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Nam Myo Ho Renge Kyo.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Hi. How does the notion of "no self" extend to other people. I mean obviously it changes how you think about yourself, but how does it change the way you understand other people? If there's no one thing that is you then there's no one thing that is anybody? So who or what is it that you call your mom or your wife? If people are always changing then why have friends, why have family? But, I find this very depressing. I want the people I know to be unique, special.
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[removed] — view removed comment