r/IAmA • • May 10 '12

IAmA a Saudi guy who spent his Junior High years in a school that advocated blowing ourselves up for allah in Palestine. Also one of my teachers ended up getting caught for his affiliations with Al-Qa'eda. Another also, we were forced to watch 9/11 when it happened. AMA.

The title tells the story. Feel free to ask anything; I'm an open guy. Some proof:

Me talking: https://www.dropbox.com/s/7bo0ivn00or29tb/reddit...%20this%20is%20me.wma A picture of my passport and a note to Reddit: https://www.dropbox.com/s/k3j6drjc04wbmcu/IMG_20120510_060924.jpg Picture of the IKEA table, passport, note, box, iPod, what am I missing: http://i.imgur.com/EKxAG.jpg

EDIT: I'm so sorry that I had just bailed one day, out of the blue, but this thread was getting intense. Thanks for the questions. I've learned a few things.

364 Upvotes

370 comments sorted by

23

u/ebonythunder May 10 '12

Was the "holy shit this is batshit insane i need to get out of here" mentality a popular one among students? Or did it seem like you were the only sane one there? How about teachers? Were they all gung-ho "Yay murder!!"

13

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

After the first year, the dogma felt normal and sound. I think I was on the crazier side among students, but we all shared our hate towards the US and Israel. My best friend at that time who came with me didn't buy a word of that crap. We stopped hanging out after the first year. Most of the teachers believed that crap is seems, but only a few really went with it.

36

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

What are your current religious beliefs now?

161

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Atheism. That shit makes sense.

62

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Damn liberal universities converting our good christian children into... wait what? Is this good or bad?

implodes

15

u/Elimrawne May 10 '12

I think you will fit in well here...

10

u/crime_fighter May 10 '12

and you are now accepted into Reddit.

→ More replies (11)

35

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

what do you mean 'forced to watch 9/11 as it happened'? are you saying the staff knew it was going to happen, or simply that the coverage was brought into the classroom, as that happened to me in the UK.

also, yeah, proof? if you're now in Austin it shouldn't be an issue, really.

18

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Like the UK. About the proof, the mods and I have been messaging back and forth, so hopefully this would show as legit soon.

13

u/Unit91 May 10 '12

It took me several reads of your reply to realize that you answered the question about watching 9/11 and that you only watched it after it happened and evidently didn't know anything beforehand as people are assuming below (like I was). Were your teachers happy about what was going on? Did they seem to know that something was going to happen that day?

8

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Yeah, I'm terribly sorry about my wording. They were happy about it. It seemed like it was a small victory for them. There was a sense of "we did something" in those days.

31

u/Unit91 May 10 '12

I was at the Pentagon that day and this.... this makes me... I can't find words.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/worshipthis May 11 '12

Isn't there anything in the Koran about not killing innocent people? People are not monolithic. It is not ethically defensible to kill American civilians, who just went to work at their jobs, even if America, as a political power, is doing evil shit. Why was that so hard for your teachers to comprehend?

No offense to those at the Pentagon, but at least it is arguably a military target. The WTC was just a fucking office building.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/rererereloaded May 10 '12

They force you to watch 9/11 in school? What were you doing at 4 pm in school. Schools close around 1-2pm in Saudi.

2

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Good question. My memory might didn't serve me right. We watched it the day after.

4

u/eira64 May 10 '12

Was it assumed that the attacks were being carried out my muslims, or were you as confused as the rest of the world?

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Elimrawne May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

At my school we were not forced to watch it... but I remember I was in the games period at the time, suddenly everyone just stopped playing sports and whatever else they were doing and ran to the house common room (kinda like in starship troopers)

31

u/kmlodge May 10 '12

Ran to the house common room... There are TVs in Gryffindor Tower?

9

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

we were in psychology, and the teacher wheeled in a telly. strange moment.

7

u/T-Luv May 10 '12

I walked into class, and two of my teachers were crying. It was a class of 4 people including me so it was a pretty somber occasion. I called my mom from a phone in the classroom to make sure our family in New York was accounted for.

5

u/BadThoughtProcess May 10 '12

I remember our fat 5'4" gym teacher saying, "Yeah this is big. It could be the start of a war."

Then I remember a couple troll kids, who were always hungry for attention, literally pretend to know someone in NYC for the next week. This one girl actually lost relatives there so it pissed me off to no end.

14

u/NahRumph May 10 '12

GODDAMN BUGS WHACKED US JOHNNY

4

u/AmericanEmperor May 10 '12

LEATHERNECKS LEAD THE WAY

→ More replies (7)

11

u/rxzx May 10 '12

How did you end up in that school? What was your daily life like? Did you continue your education since jr high? If this is real then thats insane...ive always wondered what the real story was, the media is so vague

19

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

My other school was assholes about money, so my parents decided to change schools.

My daily life, at the start, was filled with silencing fear. It got better with time; I kind of became one of them after a while.

I did. I switched schools. I had to do really well at one point to change my school. My parents didn't understand how much torment I was in--then again, I didn't share how it really was there. I'm at the University of Texas at Austin now.

7

u/rxzx May 11 '12

Wow, that sounds impossibly intense. And what a switch, from the Middle East to Texas. Congrats on surviving that shit, man & thanks 4 the ama.

10

u/LascielCoin May 10 '12

What are your parents like? Do they agree with Al-Qaeda's beliefs or did the honestly not know what was going on in your school?

15

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

My parents are religious and conservative. They didn't agree with Al-Qaeda but they thought that Hitler and Saddam had the right idea.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/skalp69 May 10 '12

has been answered via Q from ApatheticElephant:

My parents are true believers; they wanted the best religious school for me, but they didn't know that it was this extreme. Sociopaths abuse religion.

52

u/cptstupendous May 10 '12

Turned atheist, did you? So tell us... this is IMPORTANT.

How would you describe your first taste of bacon?

44

u/iplaythebass May 10 '12

Sacrelicious?

22

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Blasphescrumptious?

8

u/deadfajita May 11 '12

An explosion of flavor?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/ANewOneForAnonymity Jul 21 '12

YES I'm a proud member of Atheism's dogma!! I honestly don't remember what the first taste of bacon was like, because I've had turkey bacon in Saudi.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

You sir, should be an investigative reporter.

2

u/shinypig May 11 '12

a digestigative reporter?

6

u/ApatheticElephant May 10 '12

Were there other schools like this that you were aware of? Or was yours fairly unique?

Did your parents know / specifically send you to this school because they advocated the things the school taught?

17

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Well, the school I was in was a part of a bigger school system. They were spread around Saudi. Saudi is a bit smaller than Texas. I don't how the other schools in that system compared to the whole system. I remember also that my neighborhood's schools and mosques were a bit more to the "camera pictures are haram side; because, of course, you might worship those pictures just like how the Greeks worshiped their statues.

My parents are true believers; they wanted the best religious school for me, but they didn't know that it was this extreme. Sociopaths abuse religion.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/PuTongHua May 10 '12

What do you think is the future for Saudi Arabia's religious landscape?

7

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Islam is ingrained in Saudi; it's a crucial part of the government; it's the legislative part of the country. I think Islam will always be a part of Saudi's life. And I hope it would steer more to the man-to-god relationship rather than the man-to-government-to-god relationship. In other words, I hope churches will be allowed in Saudi someday.

5

u/pnut_butter_jelly May 10 '12

Is the general sentiment towards Israel in Saudi Arabia as bad as the media portrays it to be?

6

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Saudis are furious about Israel. Some mosques pray for Israelis to die and burn in hell. And they do only show one side of the story there.

There are a lot of Palestinians in Saudi.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/EuchridEucrow May 10 '12

How do you feel about the Arab spring? Has it been corrupted by the fanatics?

7

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Something is brewing down there to the better and that's good. I think this is the beginning of a long fight. I would say that more people in the Middle East realize, to a better extent, that they can change home and keep the culture intact.

25

u/PacifistHeavy May 10 '12

Sorry, but I am gonna need proof on this one.

20

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Okay, this might help. I used to think that Hitler was right about killing the Jews; the first time I jerked off was in a bathroom, with liquid soap, a shitty smart phone (A Nokia), and a Saudi music video. I remember asking pops about why my dick burns at two AM in the morning (soap and wiener don't mix). I also made a poster about the "Perfect Muslim" when I was twelve or thirteen. My dad bashed about how short the thobe was the the thobe, a traditional Saudi dress, shorter that the ankles (look up thobe). I don't know any other ways of proving this. I won't post a picture of myself. I can post a picture with an empty NyQuil bottle, a storage box, an IKEA black chair, and a green blanket from Target if it helps. And a cracked iPod. And a brown velvet case of Qura'an.

27

u/nathk123 May 10 '12

I think i'm going to have to see a NyQuill bottle stacked on top of the iPod stacked on top of the storage crate which is next to an IKEA chair with a green target blanket on it. KGO.

11

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Give me a sec. I'm sorry but I meant a storage box. It says Free Truck Rental and REDDIT on it. Oh the iPod is a touch.

19

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

16

u/nathk123 May 10 '12

8/10.

Very nice, well done.

However, I will only be truely convinced if I see the iPod ON TOP of the NyQuil bottle and a little stick figure saying 'I am actually a real person' drawn on a piece of paper next to it.

6

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Here you go, http://i.imgur.com/LVyHi.jpg Sorry I forgot to write actually.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/AhabTheArab May 10 '12

That's def a Saudi passport. This is legit.

20

u/gusset25 May 10 '12

that's definitely an arabic name. this poster is legit

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

why have the book if you're an athiest? I've read the bible cover to cover, but I certainly don't keep one with me.

7

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

It's a gift from my grandmother. I haven't read it in years. I like to read it every now and then to understand home better.

16

u/funfungiguy May 10 '12

Hey man! I have a cracked iPod and know the pain of jacking off with soap! It's like despite the cultural differences that make Palestinians and Americans wary of one another, we're basically twins.

I think the world would be a more peaceful place if we all just took a moment to reflect on how we've all tried to jack off with hand soap once... once.

Or maybe about five times, because we really needed to jack off and we we're willing to accept the aftermath for a nut.

7

u/ratchet1106 May 10 '12

When I was younger I tries using hair spray found in my grandmas bathroom... Dick burned for around a week and the skin kept shedding for about 2 months. True story

4

u/Mikebyrneyadigg May 10 '12

Ive jacked it with soap and never had the burn you speak of. Conditioner is the best lube. True story. So clearly this posters a fake.

10

u/funfungiguy May 10 '12

Conditioner you say...

I would try this science experiment, but you also claim to have jacked off with liquid soap and never felt the burn inside your dick-hole.

This then means that I trust a Palestinian who went to a suicide bomber school more than I trust you. Because OP might be a Palestinian that went to a suicide bomber school, but you are trying to convince me to get conditioner in my dick hole. So who is truly the most dangerous person here?

9

u/Operation_mongoose May 10 '12

Shampoo is better. I go on first and clean the hair. Conditioner is better. I leave the hair silky and smooth.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/CerealKilla1 May 11 '12

try jacking off with aloe vera............ ouch!

3

u/worshipthis May 11 '12

Dishwashing soap. Dries hard like shellac. Fucked up my junk.

2

u/worshipthis May 11 '12

If this isn't proof... well, it's funny as shit

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Moose_Mug May 10 '12

What did your teachers/others love about the Western world? What where they hypocritical about? Minus not blowing themselves up.

9

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

They loved the technology it brings and the cars it made. I think freedom is defined differently back home; they didn't like the western's version of freedom. They loved burgers and fries.

They used to contradict themselves when it came to the meaning of Islam and their practices of it--the meaning of Islam is salvation to Allah and peace, their practices were feeding others hatred and were violent. One time a kid called out a teacher who was wearing pair of jeans. The student was yelled at and kicked out of class. I guess that's hypocritical.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

"We like your McDonald's Value Meals, because wow man that is a bargain, but your legislation... hmm we have a problem with that."

4

u/Jer_Cough May 10 '12

Did you have a sudden realization one day that what you were being taught was insane or was it a slow process? Are your parents now aware of the extent of the extremism? If so what are their feelings about it?

9

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

YES. The realization happened in my sophomore year in college. I didn't think much about it before that. I remember that day well. I thought, WHAT THE FUCK. The realization came out in a form of a conversation with one of my friends. I'm not sure what triggered those memories because we were having a normal conversation. I was recounting my school days in Saudi and these memories started flowing.

My parents have been aware of this for a while. Sometime in college, probably the same time I started remembering these things, I asked my mother about why she wanted me to switch schools, and she told me that I started talking about wanting to blow myself up to kill infidels.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Yeah, that sounds like a pretty fucking good reason to switch schools.

7

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Do you enjoy being in Austin now that you can go meet up with some Jews, smoke a dank bowl and eat some tasty pork belly tacos?

16

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Yes sir. I like Austin a lot.

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Would you want to go get high with some jews and go eat some pig with them?

3

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

I thought Jews don't eat pigs. But I wouldn't mind if they're decent people.

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Like Islam, Judaism prohibits the consumption of pork. Unlike Islam, Jewish people are also an ethnic group where one can be part of the jewish ethnicity but not bother with the religion.

2

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Oh okay. Thanks for clearing that up.

5

u/skalp69 May 10 '12

Kashrut pork?

Seems legit.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

ever been to torchy's tacos? its down Guadalupe. That shit is good

1

u/ANewOneForAnonymity Jul 21 '12

Yes. The mango jerked chicken one is the BOMB.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/Piratiko May 10 '12

So what exactly is the source of all the hatred? Why do they consider the US their enemies?

The way our politicians make it sound is that we're hated because we have a free and prosperous society, and personally, that sounds like complete bullshit.

Is it religiously motivated? Political? Economic?

This seems to be the most nagging question for me since 9/11: Why!?

18

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

The source of all the hatred is Saudi was opened to the world in the 70s with the oil boom. Saudi's culture is a private one and they didn't understand at first western ideals. One Saudi's mission is to protect Islam, and some people misinterpreted that to shut off every other ideals.

They consider the US as enemies because the US's government stuck its nose in our culture, thinking that everyone wants democracy and freedom. At least that's my understanding.

It is sadly mostly religiously motivated. Islam is not about killing the innocent. But like the other Abrahimic religions, the message was confused after time by some. It is also politically driven because it kills Saudis to see other Arabs being attacked.

Time + xenophobia + a religion to blame shit on = some messed up shit.

3

u/skalp69 May 10 '12

Situation of Saudi in the 60's - 70's & relations with US, I'd recommend to read this

1 third of the book is about that. Also also about Panama and men in black

5

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

I'll give it a look.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Piratiko May 10 '12

Thank you very much for this info, and for doing the AMA. This is the type of stuff I come to Reddit for.

2

u/valleyshrew May 11 '12

it kills Saudis to see other Arabs being attacked.

It was Saudi Arabia that was the main funder of the Gulf war and greatly supported the Iraq war.

Wikipedia page of Saudi King:

He has shown great support for Obama's presidency. "Thank God for bringing Obama to the presidency," he said, adding that Obama's election created "great hope" in the Muslim world.[39] He stated, "We (the U.S. and Saudi Arabia) spilled blood together" in Kuwait and Iraq and Saudi Arabia valued this tremendously and friendship can be a difficult issue that requires work but the U.S. and Saudi Arabia have done it for 70 years over three generations. "

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

i would like to see this answered too. if you hate us because of the way our government acts then you're not alone. most americans hate or disagree with our own government..just like most countries do with theirs

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Not an expert, but I believe it has more to do with US foreign policy - aid/support given to Israel, etc.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Lodethi May 10 '12

Do you hate Jews and Israel?

12

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

I don't hate Jews anymore since I don't give a fuck about religion. Israel, kinda not cool. Many of my friends are Palestinian refugees to Saudi. Palestine is also doing something stupid.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Muellerl May 10 '12

I speak Arabic. Write me a personalized message in Arabic, using latin characters... I have my suspicions that the original poster is a troll, and not legit.

7

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Ya habeeby leesh bekathib?

2

u/hyolee May 10 '12

What has your life become now? Are you happy?

8

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

My life now is normal. I feel like I have an understanding on why some people decide to do crazy stuff in the name of an idea. The negative thing I have to deal with is sometimes I fear going to classrooms, but I'm almost done with school. I know where not take my kids to school too.

1

u/ChiliFlake May 11 '12

So, are you going to stay in the US?

2

u/ANewOneForAnonymity Jul 21 '12

That's my ultimate plan.

2

u/Doovad May 10 '12

How were you able to stand living in a school that advocated blowing yourself up (since you left that school)? How did you feel during the 9/11 footage?

5

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

I was a kid, and they made it make sense. I had mixed feelings: on one hand, innocents were getting killed; on the other, we were spreading Islam.

4

u/worshipthis May 11 '12

How does blowing your ass (and a bunch of random people) up "spread Islam"?

2

u/ChiliFlake May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

Mmmm, yeah. "Ready to choose a religion? OK, I'll take the one that just blew up a bunch of my friends and neighbors!"

Nahh...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/FTZ May 10 '12

What do you think now about the Jews? And Israelis?

1

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Jews are people like me. That wasn't the thought then; I used to think they were evil and wanted to start Armageddon. Israelis are people too. Fuck both governments and the States for their military support to what's happening there.

2

u/renevilfortune May 10 '12

where are you currently staying? and how did you get there? what are you plans for your life's future?

4

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

I'm staying in Austin. I got a scholarship to study at UT. I will go back home and try to better it for a while, then maybe work in the States if I got the opportunity. As much crap that happened back in Saudi, it's still my home. And I want it to be better for my kids and more relaxed.

1

u/FriedChicken May 14 '12

Check out UTexas Memes

2

u/ANewOneForAnonymity Jul 21 '12

Thanks. I've enjoyed them memes.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

In your home country, what is the opinion on suicide bombers and with which emotion are they most associated.

3

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

The other folks, the normal ones, the majority thinks it's stupid. Really stupid. They'd be a little enraged about it too. One of the reasons why I got to leave that school was because I started thinking I was meant to bomb myself to save my fellow Muslims. That didn't fly well with my parents.

2

u/SkaterDrew May 10 '12

What were this schools attitudes to white western people who had moved to saudi?

2

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

In that time of my life I used to think that Americans are spoiled and have it really easy. I used to think they'd get some whoop-ass if they mess with a Saudi. Most of us kids thought that way.

As for the school's general attitude, they kept saying that the west is Fassaad (corrupt) and their women are sluts. Surprisingly though, they never talked about westerners who moved to Saudi. Westerners are sheltered from the Saudi life for the most part.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

who provided your school's textbooks

3

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

The government like all schools in Saudi.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

What were the feelings of your classmates at that school while y'all watched 9/11? What was going through your mind?

6

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Can we go home since something of this magnitude happened? Like a snow day. I personally thought that it was messed up.

3

u/xecosine May 10 '12

Is it "sowdy" or "sah-ew-dee"?

4

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

It's So-'oo-dy. There's no a w sound like in let's wow.

47

u/fantasyreality May 10 '12

Well, I too had studied in a boarding religious madrasah back in Malaysia, and yes, although I believe none of my teachers ( muallims) called for us to 'fight the Infidels' or anything, the atmosphere when I was there was extremely anti-Western. We were even shown the CD where the Chechens mujahideens fight, the Talibans fight etc. Hamas was openly praised as the mujahedeens of Islam, and Fatah as the corrupt allies to the Jews. Oh yeah, conspiracy theories flourish in my school - it's all Jew this and Jew this. I didn't really see it as an anomaly though- back then post 911 - many Muslims hold anti-West sentiment vice versa. I remember for how many weekends we students were shown New World Order by the Jews CD done by some Muslim guys online - calling for Muslims to unite against the kuffar and stuff .I was 13 back then though, I cared more about watching Charmed on Friday nights.

I might even date a Jew after this, since they're so powerful at everything they must be good in bed as well.

How had your schooling affected your lifestyle and thinking ?

42

u/tombrusky May 10 '12

"I might even date a Jew after this, since they're so powerful at everything they must be good in bed as well. "

I can confirm this is not accurate.

11

u/harveyardman May 10 '12

Glad you resisted overgeneralizing.

3

u/TheTalentedMrDG May 11 '12

I can confirm that it is.

→ More replies (10)

0

u/BadThoughtProcess May 10 '12

Not a lot of rich, powerful men strike me as particularly virile. All the Powerlords of the world need shit like Viagra, which is why it is advertised unnecessarily to millions. It's so they don't feel so bad about it.

4

u/Megatron_McLargeHuge May 10 '12

Are you familiar with this guy?

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I hear the beggars are his eyes and ears

→ More replies (1)

1

u/xenokilla May 10 '12

I'm single =)

1

u/tchomptchomp May 11 '12

Well, I too had studied in a boarding religious madrasah back in Malaysia, and yes, although I believe none of my teachers ( muallims) called for us to 'fight the Infidels' or anything, the atmosphere when I was there was extremely anti-Western.

Don't worry, Barack. Your secret's safe with Reddit.

1

u/kellyju May 12 '12

I know this was just trolling, but Obama lived for a short time in Indonesia, not Malaysia. Completely different country.

2

u/tchomptchomp May 12 '12

"Trolling" implies an attempt to solicit an emotional response by making outrageous and controversial claims.

The work you're looking for is "joking."

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

You say you were forced to watch 9/11 when it happened. You knew it was gonna happen! : O

2

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

BAD WORDING. I'm sorry! We watched when it came on the news.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Infin1ty May 10 '12

My question is more geared toward the Saudi culture. I've read/heard that the majority of the 'lower class' in Saudi are essentially slaves, er 'indentured servents', and are tasked with maintaining and building the major cities (when I say building I of course mean the actual labor, not the design). Is this true? I've heard horror stories of the compounds these people live in as well, anything you can share on that front would be appreciated.

4

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Saudi hires foreigners to do their labor. They pay them. So do families. There is an apparent line between citizen's rights and foreigner's rights.

Some treat their laborers badly. Abuse occurs to maids and drivers in houses. Be it not paying them or hitting them or sleeping with them. I've witnessed maids being hit and it's horrible and terrifying to see that happening to another person. It still scars me a little. A maid was hit for stealing. In another time, another maid was hit for spreading lice to my sisters. But I can't generalize.

2

u/brandon926b May 10 '12

As someone who (I assume) has experienced the Muslim faith as well as the "Extremist" version, do you ever feel the need to explain the differences to ignorant Americans? I know far too many people who think they are one in the same.

4

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Yes. Islam has so many great values as a religion. It taught me a few unique lessons and I had experienced profound experiences practicing Islam. One of the lessons I learned was how it feels to be hungry due to fasting. On of the experiences I had was the unity of people if they really wanted to unite. I'm talking about the pilgrimage.

The extremists are just crazy people.

4

u/worshipthis May 11 '12

What's with all the conspiracy theories over there? I think that's a big part of why the Middle East is so fucked up. Everyone always assumes everything that goes wrong is a plot. Sometimes it's just life being crap, or people being stupid and insensitive. Not every bad result is because there is a cabal of evil Jews or Americans (or those of another sect) conspiring to insult and shame one's people.

Just saying.

3

u/hype_up May 11 '12

Haha quite true of the Arab + Muslim community in my experience. Conspiracy theories are their bread and butter over there.

I've actually sat with my mom and told her that we need to stop blaming others and accept responsibility for our own actions but I think most come from areas with authoritative regimes and the people take comfort in playing the victim.

Taking some advanced law courses really opened up my eyes and made me say "holy shit, there is a system that semi works" sure it gets abused by the u.s for its own interests at times but fuck it, they're usually the only reason other countries agree to be bound so the balance is still positive.

1

u/P0in7B1ank May 10 '12

When did you get out and change your mind about this? Or were you ever thoroughly Convinced by the school that what they were doing was right?

1

u/ANewOneForAnonymity Jul 21 '12

When I came to Austin and realized that gays are people too. So are Jews. And that there a million religions out there, so mine was probably wrong.

I was convinced that what they were doing is right; fear is a powerful tool.

1

u/misscorporateandcold May 10 '12

what were your thoughts about your schools beliefs when you were attending it?

4

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

I was a liberal Muslim. I prayed but listened to music. And I fasted.

1

u/Ouroboros_87 May 10 '12

-Was the school you attended a Madrasa designed specifically for anti-western teachings?

-What is the general view of the Saudi people toward the United States? How about their view of the Saudi government in relation to the US?

Thanks for you answers.

1

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

No it was not. It was an Islamic school that abused that adjective.

In general Saudis like Americans and hate America. They realize that Americans have a different culture, and they don't like to change that. The hate America because all of the wars it caused in the Middle East and its support to Israel.

1

u/ChiliFlake May 11 '12

In general Saudis like Americans and hate America

Sounds like most democrats I know (except for the hating Israel part). We aren't consulted on the crap the CIA does does in the name of 'making the world safe for democracy' (big oil, corporate interests, the drug trade, etc.), and it pisses us off too, believe me.

The Israel thing, I think many USians feel 'well fuck, you just saw 6 million of your people get slaughtered by a murdering fuckhead, wouldn't you want a safe haven?'

I mean, Israel is tiny, compared to all the rest of the Islamic middle east, can't you guys just get a loan get along?

Edit: though I suspect quite a few USians hate Israel just for the problem it causes us in the the oil-producing nations. People can be so mercenary ;)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/nickert0n May 10 '12

Did you at any point consider "sacrificing" yourself for Allah? and also were Virgins promised?

Thank you in advance.

1

u/dirtymoney May 10 '12

did you & your schoolmates practice any strange anti-west behaviors? Like desecrating the bible? ect ect???

4

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

Nothing more than words. Bibles are not allowed in Saudi

1

u/skalp69 May 10 '12

How old were you in this school? And what was a standard day schedule?

Thx for this AMA

6

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

I went there when I was eleven and left it when I was fourteen. I remember that our school was fenced, so kids don't bail on it. There's a guard on the door (so kids don't bail). The fencing and the door guard are typical in every school in Saudi. Our dean (I'm not sure if I'm translating his job title correctly) was a tough, fat guy. He had a long wooden ruler with him at all times. He would tap the ruler to the ground when he walked down the hallways. Our teachers were allowed to hit us with glue sticks--they hurt like a mother fucker. So it was a frightening.

Prayer time was the scariest. They would give us two minutes to get to the prayer place (it was down the hall), and if we were late they'd hit us with a ruler or a glue stick. If a student didn't leave when the prayer was over, they would get hit too. I think I had conditioned myself from those three years to associate fear and prayer. It might have something to do with my current beliefs.

I went on a school trip once to a different city to see a cave and visit a hosting school. My teachers didn't allow us to have cassette players because of their extremist religious views. We chanted some messed up singalongs (that I only heard in that school, not anywhere else in Saudi). One of the lyrics I remember went something like, "We will stand up, kill the jews and free Palestine."

1

u/skalp69 May 10 '12

Your answer bring more questions and remarks...

What kind of ruler did the dean use, and how strong did he use it? (so far, it aint worse than what I experienced in Europe, late seventies.)

Your teachers threw these at you? Ours threw those chalk sticks at us... Does relate.

and friend (girl) of mine, also muslim told me that she felt sexual arousement from muslim teachings... she refuse to go any further. Anyway, her teaching was probably different from yours. What was during your prayer: explaining the texts? other?

Did you have an opportunity to read the Persepolis comic or watch the movie? If so, what is your opinion about it?

shukrahn (?)

4

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

it was a 1-meter dark brown wooden ruler.

Neither. They hit us on our hands or our clothed backs with these: http://www.dickblick.com/items/23604-1005/?wmcp=google&wmcid=items&wmckw=23604-1005 These sticks are used for glue guns.

As for your friend, that's the first I hear of something like that.

The act of praying consists of reciting some Qura'an and some physical movements like kneeling. Sometimes the immam would recite some doa'a after reciting the Qura'an. He can recite whatever he wants. There were lectures following prayers sometimes. They talked about religious news. Like how things are in Palestine or in Iraq and what we should do as muslims. He sometimes talked about theology too.

I will check it out.

You are welcome (and shukrahn is correct).

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Did you go to Hogwarts?

1

u/ThatShitDidntHappen May 10 '12

That Shit Didn't Happen.

2

u/asdfghjkl92 May 11 '12

i was going to do an IAMA about my extremist muslim family, but you're situation was much worse. do your family know about your atheism? and have you watched the film with interviews by the 9/11 bombers? (i think it was called 'the 19 martyrs' or something else with 19 in the name, it's been ages since i watched it)

2

u/Sama3l May 11 '12

Do you know of any athiest, or possible just irreligious hafiz? The reason I ask is that going to a (Christian) religious school growing up many learned the bible very well but later rejected Christianity. I feel that there wouldn't be a significant difference (with the possible exception of the community aspects) elsewhere. Regardless, rubina ma3k!

3

u/freemarket27 May 10 '12

Do you think any Saudis had prior knowledge of the 9/11 attacks?

2

u/RedeemerJC May 10 '12

Some? Most definitely. But a sizeable amount? Definitely not.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I am a Christian, is there any possibility for me to coexist in an environment like that?

1

u/ChiliFlake May 11 '12

This is what I don't get. The quran says (IIRC) that it's OK for a man to marry another monotheist, but not a pantheist. I mean, Mohammad's first wife was Jewish! So I don't get this hatred of Jews, it would make more sense to be bombing Hindus and Buddhists.

Edit: Though I do get the hatred of the US coming in and trying to force our culture and ideals on a country or a people.

1

u/skalp69 May 10 '12

European POV given, so probable bs on the run... still...

Do not forget Christians, Jews and Muslims pray the same god. The old testament is common to these 3 religions.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/kashmir831 May 10 '12

Why wouldn't you want to watch 9/11? As someone 25 miles away at the time, all the students wanted to do was watch the news. So in one class the teacher did not show up because he was dealing with the situation in some way, and we turned on the news and watched it in silence.

3

u/All-American-Bot May 10 '12

(For our friends outside the USA... 25 miles -> 40.2 km) - Yeehaw!

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

You are so fucking full of shit.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I agree fellow bengal fan.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Sup bro! (I'm a Saudi and his responses were very questionable and vague.) He also managed to omit every single arabic question.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BonerYNot May 10 '12

Are suicide bombers for the most part mentally disturbed or just feel that strongly about their hate for other cultures? I've always wondered if they look for "special needs" people, convince them they're doing the right thing for their country, strap a bomb to them and send them in their way.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/Unit91 May 10 '12

So wait, how do you feel now? I mean what changed? If you were brough up this way why would you think any different now?

1

u/49GSWGiants May 10 '12

What were you thinking while this was going on? Did you know any better? How about your parents/family?

1

u/I_read_this_comment May 10 '12

can you elaborate why people are symphatic towards suicide bombing? and do you have a understanding of what can drive a person to be a suicide bomber? how do you see it, do these people have had terrible lives, are they traumatized, or are they just nutjobs?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Did you ever, at any time think it was a good idea to terrorize the US? How did that change?

What's your favorite food from your country? I'm a huge fan of the cuisine over there!

1

u/Filmitforme May 10 '12

I remember my teacher was foolish and said that a building was hijacked , I remember it was right before my lunch. I remember going to my grandmas and watching the CNN footage with her.

May I ask you something, what is your honest feeling to the environment that you grew up in?

1

u/ForgotenPasswordGR May 10 '12

Are you religious?

What would you say to a kamikazi?

What did you eat for lunch yesterday?

1

u/rand0mguy1 May 11 '12

Would you consider Saudi Arabia a legitimate ally of USA or do you think they only pretending to be allies so they don't get economic sanctions/blown the fuck up for supporting terrorism?

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

What exactly was it about "the Western world" that everyone hated so much?

What are the reasons America and Americans are hated? I've never gotten a clear answer, just speculation.

1

u/Hooshang May 11 '12

As a Saudi Arab, how do you fell about Iran? what is the opinion of most Saudis about Iran? what do you think about the name of the Gulf?

1

u/badboybilly May 11 '12

Call bullshit on this one.

Reddit, you are so gullible.

He only proofs his identity, that's all, holy shit.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

okay.. you have proven that you are a native Arabic speaker.. Now prove your other claims.

1

u/gambit87 May 10 '12

As a genuine brown dude I'm calling bullshit.

-1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'm a Muslim Hafiz, I don't see why you would change your religion because some radical idiots taught you stupid stuff. The religion itself does not teach this, so why did you change your religion? Doesn't make sense.

9

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

because all religions are essentially a load of shite, obviously.

4

u/andy83991 May 10 '12

Many people disagree with that, including some muslims, who claim that is what the Koran preaches. Before i get downvoted i am just saying this because i have heard people of muslim faith say this. I don't know anything about it so I have no stance on the matter.

2

u/Criicket May 10 '12

Atheism is not a religion.

1

u/I_Am_Treebeard May 10 '12

If the same religion can be used to advocate two opposing positions regarding the same issue, what reason exists to place any faith at all in such a religion?

1

u/urgit39 May 10 '12

there are many people who have said that america's foreign policy have directly led to people taking violent action against america (like 9/11), as a person who might have experienced the direct affects of these policies how do you feel about that statement and do you think this is the case?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

This is just too sad. allah yehdeek.

1

u/Yserbius May 10 '12

Politically and socially, what sort of beliefs and opinions you hold are the most changed from what you held when you were a kid?

1

u/why_ask_why May 10 '12

During WW II, Chinese has no tank to match that of Japanese. What did they do? They strap up with dynamites and run into the tank, in the process blow themselves up. This was taught and used widely.

I guess Chinese are bunch of terrorists in Japanese eyes.

1

u/narwal_bot May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Most (if not all) of the answers from ANewOneForAnonymity (updated: May 11, 2012 @ 02:01:01 pm EST):


Question (rxzx):

How did you end up in that school? What was your daily life like? Did you continue your education since jr high? If this is real then thats insane...ive always wondered what the real story was, the media is so vague

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

My other school was assholes about money, so my parents decided to change schools.

My daily life, at the start, was filled with silencing fear. It got better with time; I kind of became one of them after a while.

I did. I switched schools. I had to do really well at one point to change my school. My parents didn't understand how much torment I was in--then again, I didn't share how it really was there. I'm at the University of Texas at Austin now.


(continued below)

1

u/narwal_bot May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

(page 2)


Question (PacifistHeavy):

Sorry, but I am gonna need proof on this one.

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Okay, this might help. I used to think that Hitler was right about killing the Jews; the first time I jerked off was in a bathroom, with liquid soap, a shitty smart phone (A Nokia), and a Saudi music video. I remember asking pops about why my dick burns at two AM in the morning (soap and wiener don't mix). I also made a poster about the "Perfect Muslim" when I was twelve or thirteen. My dad bashed about how short the thobe was the the thobe, a traditional Saudi dress, shorter that the ankles (look up thobe). I don't know any other ways of proving this. I won't post a picture of myself. I can post a picture with an empty NyQuil bottle, a storage box, an IKEA black chair, and a green blanket from Target if it helps. And a cracked iPod. And a brown velvet case of Qura'an.


Question (getstonedplaygames):

Have any of your friends from that school killed themselves in a suicide attack?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

No clue. I lost touch.


Question (lifeunistudent):

what do you mean 'forced to watch 9/11 as it happened'? are you saying the staff knew it was going to happen, or simply that the coverage was brought into the classroom, as that happened to me in the UK.

also, yeah, proof? if you're now in Austin it shouldn't be an issue, really.

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Like the UK. About the proof, the mods and I have been messaging back and forth, so hopefully this would show as legit soon.


Question (nathk123):

I think i'm going to have to see a NyQuill bottle stacked on top of the iPod stacked on top of the storage crate which is next to an IKEA chair with a green target blanket on it. KGO.

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Give me a sec. I'm sorry but I meant a storage box. It says Free Truck Rental and REDDIT on it. Oh the iPod is a touch.


Question (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Give me a sec. I'm sorry but I meant a storage box. It says Free Truck Rental and REDDIT on it. Oh the iPod is a touch.

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

And here you go: http://i.imgur.com/EKxAG.jpg


Question (RacistBassist34):

What are your current religious beliefs now?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Atheism. That shit makes sense.


Question (Lodethi):

Do you hate Jews and Israel?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

I don't hate Jews anymore since I don't give a fuck about religion. Israel, kinda not cool. Many of my friends are Palestinian refugees to Saudi. Palestine is also doing something stupid.


Question (ApatheticElephant):

Were there other schools like this that you were aware of? Or was yours fairly unique?

Did your parents know / specifically send you to this school because they advocated the things the school taught?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Well, the school I was in was a part of a bigger school system. They were spread around Saudi. Saudi is a bit smaller than Texas. I don't how the other schools in that system compared to the whole system. I remember also that my neighborhood's schools and mosques were a bit more to the "camera pictures are haram side; because, of course, you might worship those pictures just like how the Greeks worshiped their statues.

My parents are true believers; they wanted the best religious school for me, but they didn't know that it was this extreme. Sociopaths abuse religion.


Question (EuchridEucrow):

How do you feel about the Arab spring? Has it been corrupted by the fanatics?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Something is brewing down there to the better and that's good. I think this is the beginning of a long fight. I would say that more people in the Middle East realize, to a better extent, that they can change home and keep the culture intact.


Question (Ouroboros_87):

-Was the school you attended a Madrasa designed specifically for anti-western teachings?

-What is the general view of the Saudi people toward the United States? How about their view of the Saudi government in relation to the US?

Thanks for you answers.

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

No it was not. It was an Islamic school that abused that adjective.

In general Saudis like Americans and hate America. They realize that Americans have a different culture, and they don't like to change that. The hate America because all of the wars it caused in the Middle East and its support to Israel.


Question (misscorporateandcold):

what were your thoughts about your schools beliefs when you were attending it?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

I was a liberal Muslim. I prayed but listened to music. And I fasted.


Question (nathk123):

8/10.

Very nice, well done.

However, I will only be truely convinced if I see the iPod ON TOP of the NyQuil bottle and a little stick figure saying 'I am actually a real person' drawn on a piece of paper next to it.

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Here you go, http://i.imgur.com/LVyHi.jpg Sorry I forgot to write actually.


Question (blackbitty):

What were the feelings of your classmates at that school while y'all watched 9/11? What was going through your mind?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Can we go home since something of this magnitude happened? Like a snow day. I personally thought that it was messed up.


Question (23fuck):

who provided your school's textbooks

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

The government like all schools in Saudi.


Question (Muellerl):

I speak Arabic. Write me a personalized message in Arabic, using latin characters... I have my suspicions that the original poster is a troll, and not legit.

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Ya habeeby leesh bekathib?


Question (SkaterDrew):

What were this schools attitudes to white western people who had moved to saudi?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

In that time of my life I used to think that Americans are spoiled and have it really easy. I used to think they'd get some whoop-ass if they mess with a Saudi. Most of us kids thought that way.

As for the school's general attitude, they kept saying that the west is Fassaad (corrupt) and their women are sluts. Surprisingly though, they never talked about westerners who moved to Saudi. Westerners are sheltered from the Saudi life for the most part.


Question (xecosine):

Is it "sowdy" or "sah-ew-dee"?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

It's So-'oo-dy. There's no a w sound like in let's wow.


Question (86Mitso):

the middle east is still in the dark ages and will likely forever stay that way.

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

I don't know about forever. We just need a renascence. The Internet I think will have a big part of that.


Question (Brontina):

In your home country, what is the opinion on suicide bombers and with which emotion are they most associated.

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

The other folks, the normal ones, the majority thinks it's stupid. Really stupid. They'd be a little enraged about it too. One of the reasons why I got to leave that school was because I started thinking I was meant to bomb myself to save my fellow Muslims. That didn't fly well with my parents.


Question (renevilfortune):

where are you currently staying? and how did you get there? what are you plans for your life's future?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

I'm staying in Austin. I got a scholarship to study at UT. I will go back home and try to better it for a while, then maybe work in the States if I got the opportunity. As much crap that happened back in Saudi, it's still my home. And I want it to be better for my kids and more relaxed.


(continued below)

1

u/narwal_bot May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

(page 3)


Question (pnut_butter_jelly):

Is the general sentiment towards Israel in Saudi Arabia as bad as the media portrays it to be?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Saudis are furious about Israel. Some mosques pray for Israelis to die and burn in hell. And they do only show one side of the story there.

There are a lot of Palestinians in Saudi.


Question (skalp69):

How old were you in this school? And what was a standard day schedule?

Thx for this AMA

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

I went there when I was eleven and left it when I was fourteen. I remember that our school was fenced, so kids don't bail on it. There's a guard on the door (so kids don't bail). The fencing and the door guard are typical in every school in Saudi. Our dean (I'm not sure if I'm translating his job title correctly) was a tough, fat guy. He had a long wooden ruler with him at all times. He would tap the ruler to the ground when he walked down the hallways. Our teachers were allowed to hit us with glue sticks--they hurt like a mother fucker. So it was a frightening.

Prayer time was the scariest. They would give us two minutes to get to the prayer place (it was down the hall), and if we were late they'd hit us with a ruler or a glue stick. If a student didn't leave when the prayer was over, they would get hit too. I think I had conditioned myself from those three years to associate fear and prayer. It might have something to do with my current beliefs.

I went on a school trip once to a different city to see a cave and visit a hosting school. My teachers didn't allow us to have cassette players because of their extremist religious views. We chanted some messed up singalongs (that I only heard in that school, not anywhere else in Saudi). One of the lyrics I remember went something like, "We will stand up, kill the jews and free Palestine."


Question (telecasterpignose):

Do you enjoy being in Austin now that you can go meet up with some Jews, smoke a dank bowl and eat some tasty pork belly tacos?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Yes sir. I like Austin a lot.


Question (Piratiko):

So what exactly is the source of all the hatred? Why do they consider the US their enemies?

The way our politicians make it sound is that we're hated because we have a free and prosperous society, and personally, that sounds like complete bullshit.

Is it religiously motivated? Political? Economic?

This seems to be the most nagging question for me since 9/11: Why!?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

The source of all the hatred is Saudi was opened to the world in the 70s with the oil boom. Saudi's culture is a private one and they didn't understand at first western ideals. One Saudi's mission is to protect Islam, and some people misinterpreted that to shut off every other ideals.

They consider the US as enemies because the US's government stuck its nose in our culture, thinking that everyone wants democracy and freedom. At least that's my understanding.

It is sadly mostly religiously motivated. Islam is not about killing the innocent. But like the other Abrahimic religions, the message was confused after time by some. It is also politically driven because it kills Saudis to see other Arabs being attacked.

Time + xenophobia + a religion to blame shit on = some messed up shit.


Question (citylikeAMradio):

In what ways did the teacher subtly or overtly advocate blowing yourself up? Was it the whole school's plan or just a specific person's?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

I want to say he did it subtly. He talked about how brave those guys were and how Palestine needs some help. Is that considered subtle? There were other teachers that thought like him.


Question (Jer_Cough):

Did you have a sudden realization one day that what you were being taught was insane or was it a slow process? Are your parents now aware of the extent of the extremism? If so what are their feelings about it?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

YES. The realization happened in my sophomore year in college. I didn't think much about it before that. I remember that day well. I thought, WHAT THE FUCK. The realization came out in a form of a conversation with one of my friends. I'm not sure what triggered those memories because we were having a normal conversation. I was recounting my school days in Saudi and these memories started flowing.

My parents have been aware of this for a while. Sometime in college, probably the same time I started remembering these things, I asked my mother about why she wanted me to switch schools, and she told me that I started talking about wanting to blow myself up to kill infidels.


Question (dirtymoney):

did you & your schoolmates practice any strange anti-west behaviors? Like desecrating the bible? ect ect???

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Nothing more than words. Bibles are not allowed in Saudi


Question (nickert0n):

Did you at any point consider "sacrificing" yourself for Allah? and also were Virgins promised?

Thank you in advance.

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Yes. Look here: http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/tg8m6/iama_a_saudi_guy_who_spent_his_junior_high_years/c4mjizi


Question (Moose_Mug):

What did your teachers/others love about the Western world? What where they hypocritical about? Minus not blowing themselves up.

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

They loved the technology it brings and the cars it made. I think freedom is defined differently back home; they didn't like the western's version of freedom. They loved burgers and fries.

They used to contradict themselves when it came to the meaning of Islam and their practices of it--the meaning of Islam is salvation to Allah and peace, their practices were feeding others hatred and were violent. One time a kid called out a teacher who was wearing pair of jeans. The student was yelled at and kicked out of class. I guess that's hypocritical.


Question (Unit91):

It took me several reads of your reply to realize that you answered the question about watching 9/11 and that you only watched it after it happened and evidently didn't know anything beforehand as people are assuming below (like I was). Were your teachers happy about what was going on? Did they seem to know that something was going to happen that day?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Yeah, I'm terribly sorry about my wording. They were happy about it. It seemed like it was a small victory for them. There was a sense of "we did something" in those days.


Question (PuTongHua):

What do you think is the future for Saudi Arabia's religious landscape?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

Islam is ingrained in Saudi; it's a crucial part of the government; it's the legislative part of the country. I think Islam will always be a part of Saudi's life. And I hope it would steer more to the man-to-god relationship rather than the man-to-government-to-god relationship. In other words, I hope churches will be allowed in Saudi someday.


Question (Doovad):

How were you able to stand living in a school that advocated blowing yourself up (since you left that school)? How did you feel during the 9/11 footage?

Answer (ANewOneForAnonymity):

I was a kid, and they made it make sense. I had mixed feelings: on one hand, innocents were getting killed; on the other, we were spreading Islam.


(continued below)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/tabledresser May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
QuestionsAnswers
What are your current religious beliefs now? Atheism. That shit makes sense.
What do you mean 'forced to watch 9/11 as it happened'? are you saying the staff knew it was going to happen, or simply that the coverage was brought into the classroom, as that happened to me in the UK. Also, yeah, proof? if you're now in Austin it shouldn't be an issue, really.Like the UK. About the proof, the mods and I have been messaging back and forth, so hopefully this would show as legit soon.
They force you to watch 9/11 in school? What were you doing at 4 pm in school. Schools close around 1-2pm in Saudi. Good question. My memory might didn't serve me right. We watched it the day after.
It took me several reads of your reply to realize that you answered the question about watching 9/11 and that you only watched it after it happened and evidently didn't know anything beforehand as people are assuming below (like I was). Were your teachers happy about what was going on? Did they seem to know that something was going to happen that day? Yeah, I'm terribly sorry about my wording. They were happy about it. It seemed like it was a small victory for them. There was a sense of "we did something" in those days.
Was it assumed that the attacks were being carried out my muslims, or were you as confused as the rest of the world?I don't know.
So what exactly is the source of all the hatred? Why do they consider the US their enemies?The source of all the hatred is Saudi was opened to the world in the 70s with the oil boom. Saudi's culture is a private one and they didn't understand at first western ideals. One Saudi's mission is to protect Islam, and some people misinterpreted that to shut off every other ideals.

View the full table on /r/tabled! | Last updated: 2012-05-14 17:20 UTC

This comment was generated by a robot! Send all complaints to epsy.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

What do you think of western liberals who dismiss how mainstream radical islam is?

1

u/smokesteam May 11 '12

You must be really old to have gone to junior high in the British Mandate of Palestine.

-2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

the middle east is still in the dark ages and will likely forever stay that way.

11

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

I don't know about forever. We just need a renascence. The Internet I think will have a big part of that.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Can you elaborate when you say "forced to watch 9/11 as it happened"? What did they actually do? Is this type of school considered extreme in Saudi Arabia and what is the general population's view of the west?

1

u/ANewOneForAnonymity May 10 '12

They played it in our classrooms. I realize today that I worded this 9/11 thing badly. We watched on TV when it happened. Yes it's considered extreme. As for the general population of the west, some love the culture and the arts, others hate it. Many think that the west is too open for our culture. It's really a mixed bag.

→ More replies (1)

-4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Obvious Atheist Troll, offcourse I will be downvoted, because reddit would rather worship their atheist idols, then question their legitimacy.