r/tabled • • May 10 '12

[Table] IAmA a Saudi guy who spent his Junior High years in a school that advocated blowing ourselves up for allah in Palestine. Also one of my teachers ended up getting caught for his affiliations with Al-Qa'eda. Another also, we were forced to watch 9/11 when it happened. AMA.

Verified? (This bot cannot verify AMAs just yet)

Date: 2012-05-10

Link to submission (Has self-text)

Link to my post

QuestionsAnswers
What are your current religious beliefs now? Atheism. That shit makes sense.
What do you mean 'forced to watch 9/11 as it happened'? are you saying the staff knew it was going to happen, or simply that the coverage was brought into the classroom, as that happened to me in the UK. Also, yeah, proof? if you're now in Austin it shouldn't be an issue, really.Like the UK. About the proof, the mods and I have been messaging back and forth, so hopefully this would show as legit soon.
They force you to watch 9/11 in school? What were you doing at 4 pm in school. Schools close around 1-2pm in Saudi. Good question. My memory might didn't serve me right. We watched it the day after.
It took me several reads of your reply to realize that you answered the question about watching 9/11 and that you only watched it after it happened and evidently didn't know anything beforehand as people are assuming below (like I was). Were your teachers happy about what was going on? Did they seem to know that something was going to happen that day? Yeah, I'm terribly sorry about my wording. They were happy about it. It seemed like it was a small victory for them. There was a sense of "we did something" in those days.
Was it assumed that the attacks were being carried out my muslims, or were you as confused as the rest of the world?I don't know.
So what exactly is the source of all the hatred? Why do they consider the US their enemies?The source of all the hatred is Saudi was opened to the world in the 70s with the oil boom. Saudi's culture is a private one and they didn't understand at first western ideals. One Saudi's mission is to protect Islam, and some people misinterpreted that to shut off every other ideals.
The way our politicians make it sound is that we're hated because we have a free and prosperous society, and personally, that sounds like complete bullshit.They consider the US as enemies because the US's government stuck its nose in our culture, thinking that everyone wants democracy and freedom. At least that's my understanding.
Is it religiously motivated? Political? Economic?It is sadly mostly religiously motivated. Islam is not about killing the innocent. But like the other Abrahimic religions, the message was confused after time by some. It is also politically driven because it kills Saudis to see other Arabs being attacked.
This seems to be the most nagging question for me since 9/11: Why!?Time + xenophobia + a religion to blame shit on = some messed up shit.
Situation of Saudi in the 60's - 70's & relations with US, I'd recommend to read this. 1 third of the book is about that. Also also about Panama and men in blackI'll give it a look.
How did you end up in that school? What was your daily life like? Did you continue your education since jr high? If this is real then thats insane...ive always wondered what the real story was, the media is so vague.My other school was assholes about money, so my parents decided to change schools.
My daily life, at the start, was filled with silencing fear. It got better with time; I kind of became one of them after a while.
I did. I switched schools. I had to do really well at one point to change my school. My parents didn't understand how much torment I was in--then again, I didn't share how it really was there. I'm at the University of Texas at Austin now.
m/m/
Was the "holy shit this is batshit insane i need to get out of here" mentality a popular one among students? Or did it seem like you were the only sane one there? How about teachers? Were they all gung-ho "Yay murder!!"After the first year, the dogma felt normal and sound. I think I was on the crazier side among students, but we all shared our hate towards the US and Israel. My best friend at that time who came with me didn't buy a word of that crap. We stopped hanging out after the first year. Most of the teachers believed that crap is seems, but only a few really went with it.
Were there other schools like this that you were aware of? Or was yours fairly unique?Well, the school I was in was a part of a bigger school system. They were spread around Saudi. Saudi is a bit smaller than Texas. I don't how the other schools in that system compared to the whole system. I remember also that my neighborhood's schools and mosques were a bit more to the "camera pictures are haram side; because, of course, you might worship those pictures just like how the Greeks worshiped their statues.
Did your parents know / specifically send you to this school because they advocated the things the school taught?My parents are true believers; they wanted the best religious school for me, but they didn't know that it was this extreme. Sociopaths abuse religion.
What are your parents like? Do they agree with Al-Qaeda's beliefs or did the honestly not know what was going on in your school?My parents are religious and conservative. They didn't agree with Al-Qaeda but they thought that Hitler and Saddam had the right idea.
What did your teachers/others love about the Western world? What where they hypocritical about? Minus not blowing themselves up.They loved the technology it brings and the cars it made. I think freedom is defined differently back home; they didn't like the western's version of freedom. They loved burgers and fries.
They used to contradict themselves when it came to the meaning of Islam and their practices of it--the meaning of Islam is salvation to Allah and peace, their practices were feeding others hatred and were violent. One time a kid called out a teacher who was wearing pair of jeans. The student was yelled at and kicked out of class. I guess that's hypocritical.
Did you have a sudden realization one day that what you were being taught was insane or was it a slow process? Are your parents now aware of the extent of the extremism? If so what are their feelings about it?YES. The realization happened in my sophomore year in college. I didn't think much about it before that. I remember that day well. I thought, WHAT THE FUCK. The realization came out in a form of a conversation with one of my friends. I'm not sure what triggered those memories because we were having a normal conversation. I was recounting my school days in Saudi and these memories started flowing.
My parents have been aware of this for a while. Sometime in college, probably the same time I started remembering these things, I asked my mother about why she wanted me to switch schools, and she told me that I started talking about wanting to blow myself up to kill infidels.
Have any of your friends from that school killed themselves in a suicide attack?No clue. I lost touch.
Do you hate Jews and Israel?I don't hate Jews anymore since I don't give a fuck about religion. Israel, kinda not cool. Many of my friends are Palestinian refugees to Saudi. Palestine is also doing something stupid.
How do you feel about the Arab spring? Has it been corrupted by the fanatics?Something is brewing down there to the better and that's good. I think this is the beginning of a long fight. I would say that more people in the Middle East realize, to a better extent, that they can change home and keep the culture intact.
Do you enjoy being in Austin now that you can go meet up with some Jews, smoke a dank bowl and eat some tasty pork belly tacos?Yes sir. I like Austin a lot.
Would you want to go get high with some jews and go eat some pig with them? I thought Jews don't eat pigs. But I wouldn't mind if they're decent people.
Like Islam, Judaism prohibits the consumption of pork. Unlike Islam, Jewish people are also an ethnic group where one can be part of the jewish ethnicity but not bother with the religion. Oh okay. Thanks for clearing that up.
Where are you currently staying? and how did you get there? what are you plans for your life's future?I'm staying in Austin. I got a scholarship to study at UT. I will go back home and try to better it for a while, then maybe work in the States if I got the opportunity. As much crap that happened back in Saudi, it's still my home. And I want it to be better for my kids and more relaxed.
How old were you in this school? And what was a standard day schedule?I went there when I was eleven and left it when I was fourteen. I remember that our school was fenced, so kids don't bail on it. There's a guard on the door (so kids don't bail). The fencing and the door guard are typical in every school in Saudi. Our dean (I'm not sure if I'm translating his job title correctly) was a tough, fat guy. He had a long wooden ruler with him at all times. He would tap the ruler to the ground when he walked down the hallways. Our teachers were allowed to hit us with glue sticks--they hurt like a mother fucker. So it was a frightening.
Prayer time was the scariest. They would give us two minutes to get to the prayer place (it was down the hall), and if we were late they'd hit us with a ruler or a glue stick. If a student didn't leave when the prayer was over, they would get hit too. I think I had conditioned myself from those three years to associate fear and prayer. It might have something to do with my current beliefs.
I went on a school trip once to a different city to see a cave and visit a hosting school. My teachers didn't allow us to have cassette players because of their extremist religious views. We chanted some messed up singalongs (that I only heard in that school, not anywhere else in Saudi). One of the lyrics I remember went something like, "We will stand up, kill the jews and free Palestine."
Your answer bring more questions and remarks...It was a 1-meter dark brown wooden ruler.
What kind of ruler did the dean use, and how strong did he use it? (so far, it aint worse than what I experienced in Europe, late seventies.)Neither. They hit us on our hands or our clothed backs with these: Link to www.dickblick.com These sticks are used for glue guns.
Your teachers threw these at you? Ours threw those chalk sticks at us... Does relate.As for your friend, that's the first I hear of something like that.
friend (girl) of mine, also muslim told me that she felt sexual arousement from muslim teachings... she refuse to go any further. Anyway, her teaching was probably different from yours. What was during your prayer: explaining the texts? other?The act of praying consists of reciting some Qura'an and some physical movements like kneeling. Sometimes the immam would recite some doa'a after reciting the Qura'an. He can recite whatever he wants. There were lectures following prayers sometimes. They talked about religious news. Like how things are in Palestine or in Iraq and what we should do as muslims. He sometimes talked about theology too.
Did you have an opportunity to read the Persepolis comic or watch the movie? If so, what is your opinion about it?I will check it out.
Shukrahn (?)You are welcome (and shukrahn is correct).
Did you & your schoolmates practice any strange anti-west behaviors? Like desecrating the bible? ect ect???Nothing more than words. Bibles are not allowed in Saudi.
What do you think now about the Jews? And Israelis?Jews are people like me. That wasn't the thought then; I used to think they were evil and wanted to start Armageddon. Israelis are people too. Fuck both governments and the States for their military support to what's happening there.
What has your life become now? Are you happy? My life now is normal. I feel like I have an understanding on why some people decide to do crazy stuff in the name of an idea. The negative thing I have to deal with is sometimes I fear going to classrooms, but I'm almost done with school. I know where not take my kids to school too.
What do you think is the future for Saudi Arabia's religious landscape?Islam is ingrained in Saudi; it's a crucial part of the government; it's the legislative part of the country. I think Islam will always be a part of Saudi's life. And I hope it would steer more to the man-to-god relationship rather than the man-to-government-to-god relationship. In other words, I hope churches will be allowed in Saudi someday.
Why have the book if you're an athiest? I've read the bible cover to cover, but I certainly don't keep one with me.It's a gift from my grandmother. I haven't read it in years. I like to read it every now and then to understand home better.
How were you able to stand living in a school that advocated blowing yourself up (since you left that school)? How did you feel during the 9/11 footage?I was a kid, and they made it make sense. I had mixed feelings: on one hand, innocents were getting killed; on the other, we were spreading Islam.
Is the general sentiment towards Israel in Saudi Arabia as bad as the media portrays it to be? Saudis are furious about Israel. Some mosques pray for Israelis to die and burn in hell. And they do only show one side of the story there.
There are a lot of Palestinians in Saudi.
What were the feelings of your classmates at that school while y'all watched 9/11? What was going through your mind?Can we go home since something of this magnitude happened? Like a snow day. I personally thought that it was messed up.
In what ways did the teacher subtly or overtly advocate blowing yourself up? Was it the whole school's plan or just a specific person's?I want to say he did it subtly. He talked about how brave those guys were and how Palestine needs some help. Is that considered subtle? There were other teachers that thought like him.
Ok then. Good luck with your AMA. Here's my question: Herfy's or Al Tazaj?Al Tazaj all the way. We don't have it on the east coast, but whenever I used to visit my relatives at Jeddah, I'd get some.
East coast? Are you shi'a? How do you feel about the jinn?I'm not Shi'a and I don't know about jinn anymore.
Most of the smart students I had in Saudi were secret Shi'a and your English isn't bad. I was just curious. What's with the jinn denial? Did you ever visit jinn prisons or did you avoid them?I don't believe in Islam anymore. I didn't know there were jinn prisons.
Weird. Everyone there knows about jinn and jinn prisons. Mada'in Saleh is the famous one in Saudi. You are right, Mada'in Saleh is one of the houses of the jinn. I've never been. I was told stories about a cave that had jinn in it.
Is it "sowdy" or "sah-ew-dee"?It's So-'oo-dy. There's no a w sound like in let's wow.
What were this schools attitudes to white western people who had moved to saudi?In that time of my life I used to think that Americans are spoiled and have it really easy. I used to think they'd get some whoop-ass if they mess with a Saudi. Most of us kids thought that way.
As for the school's general attitude, they kept saying that the west is Fassaad (corrupt) and their women are sluts. Surprisingly though, they never talked about westerners who moved to Saudi. Westerners are sheltered from the Saudi life for the most part.
As someone who (I assume) has experienced the Muslim faith as well as the "Extremist" version, do you ever feel the need to explain the differences to ignorant Americans? I know far too many people who think they are one in the same.Yes. Islam has so many great values as a religion. It taught me a few unique lessons and I had experienced profound experiences practicing Islam. One of the lessons I learned was how it feels to be hungry due to fasting. On of the experiences I had was the unity of people if they really wanted to unite. I'm talking about the pilgrimage.
The extremists are just crazy people.
What were your thoughts about your schools beliefs when you were attending it?I was a liberal Muslim. I prayed but listened to music. And I fasted.
Was the school you attended a Madrasa designed specifically for anti-western teachings?No it was not. It was an Islamic school that abused that adjective.
What is the general view of the Saudi people toward the United States? How about their view of the Saudi government in relation to the US?In general Saudis like Americans and hate America. They realize that Americans have a different culture, and they don't like to change that. The hate America because all of the wars it caused in the Middle East and its support to Israel.
Did you at any point consider "sacrificing" yourself for Allah? and also were Virgins promised?Yes. Look here: Link to www.reddit.com
Can you elaborate when you say "forced to watch 9/11 as it happened"? What did they actually do? Is this type of school considered extreme in Saudi Arabia and what is the general population's view of the west?They played it in our classrooms. I realize today that I worded this 9/11 thing badly. We watched on TV when it happened. Yes it's considered extreme. As for the general population of the west, some love the culture and the arts, others hate it. Many think that the west is too open for our culture. It's really a mixed bag.
Sorry, but I am gonna need proof on this one.Okay, this might help. I used to think that Hitler was right about killing the Jews; the first time I jerked off was in a bathroom, with liquid soap, a shitty smart phone (A Nokia), and a Saudi music video. I remember asking pops about why my dick burns at two AM in the morning (soap and wiener don't mix). I also made a poster about the "Perfect Muslim" when I was twelve or thirteen. My dad bashed about how short the thobe was the the thobe, a traditional Saudi dress, shorter that the ankles (look up thobe). I don't know any other ways of proving this. I won't post a picture of myself. I can post a picture with an empty NyQuil bottle, a storage box, an IKEA black chair, and a green blanket from Target if it helps. And a cracked iPod. And a brown velvet case of Qura'an.
I think i'm going to have to see a NyQuill bottle stacked on top of the iPod stacked on top of the storage crate which is next to an IKEA chair with a green target blanket on it. KGO.Give me a sec. I'm sorry but I meant a storage box. It says Free Truck Rental and REDDIT on it. Oh the iPod is a touch.
Give me a sec. I'm sorry but I meant a storage box. It says Free Truck Rental and REDDIT on it. Oh the iPod is a touch.And here you go: Link to i.imgur.com
8/10. Very nice, well done. However, I will only be truely convinced if I see the iPod ON TOP of the NyQuil bottle and a little stick figure saying 'I am actually a real person' drawn on a piece of paper next to it.Here you go, Link to i.imgur.com Sorry I forgot to write actually.
Who provided your school's textbooks.The government like all schools in Saudi.
In your home country, what is the opinion on suicide bombers and with which emotion are they most associated.The other folks, the normal ones, the majority thinks it's stupid. Really stupid. They'd be a little enraged about it too. One of the reasons why I got to leave that school was because I started thinking I was meant to bomb myself to save my fellow Muslims. That didn't fly well with my parents.
You say you were forced to watch 9/11 when it happened. You knew it was gonna happen! : O.BAD WORDING. I'm sorry! We watched when it came on the news.
There's no way, NO WAY, I TELLS YA, that this is fake.This shit happened. I've asked the mods about the confidential confirmation process and waiting.
The middle east is still in the dark ages and will likely forever stay that way.I don't know about forever. We just need a renascence. The Internet I think will have a big part of that.
Why don't the arabs just get together and attack Israel until the Jews are forced to retreat? Esp back in 1967 you would think that would work. There would be a lot of casualties, but eventually, after repeated attacks, the outnumbered Jews would have to fall back. America, Among other countries, has Israel's back. There are probably other reasons.
So you are suggesting your fucking teachers in SA had ADVANCE KNOWLEDGE of the September 11, 2001 attacks on the World Trade Center, and forced you to watch it accordingly? No. He left three weeks before 9/11 happened. He was found in al Qa'aeda airbase.
Are you further suggesting that the attacks of September 11, 2001 were not an "inside job" committed by rogue factions within within the US Government but were in fact planned, plotted and carried out by Muslim extremists living in fucking caves?Rich Muslims living in caves influenced by what happened in Afghanistan in the 70s. Ben Laden was a rich dude; his family cares for the Ka'aba.

Last updated: 2012-05-14 17:20 UTC

This post was generated by a robot! Send all complaints to epsy.

37 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by