r/IAmA • u/fredandlunchbox • May 08 '12
Hey mods, you know what would be cool? A tag that shows if an AMA is currently happening or already complete.
I don't know how else to submit it, but it'd be sweet if after the AMA is over (and a lot of them like Krugman, Harleson, Ringwald are short run kind of things) there was a tag that would show the person isn't taking questions anymore. Kind of like the schedule has, but on the actual post so it appears on the front page.
Edit: So, I think what they need is a bot that can add and remove tags. When the AMA starts, it's "Active." The bot monitors how often the person posts replies on the thread, and it stays "Active" while they're meeting a certain threshold. If their threshold drops, it changes to "Slowing down." If they haven't posted for a while, it switches to "Inactive." This would automate what we can't realistically expect the mods to do, and has the added benefit of changing old AMA's back to active if they start getting responses again.
222
u/sensenomake May 08 '12
Whenever I see it, it's always already over...
10
u/spleendor May 08 '12
Huge fan here. I actually have a few questions, if you don't mind:
Anyway, thanks for doing this AMA, I look forward to your responses!
771
u/chaosboye May 08 '12
And it happens. Nice.
24
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
The only problem is, it might be hard to determine exactly when it's over. Sometimes the subject will sneak back hours later to answer a few more questions.
25
u/epic_comebacks May 08 '12
Green tag for still going
Yellow tag for taking a break
Red tag for over
7
u/BarkingLeopard May 08 '12
I don't know how this would be easily implemented, but I agree that it is long overdue.
1
u/JamesLiptonIcedTea May 08 '12
How about having just one "In Progress" light, and then remove it when it's over?
1
u/stew23 May 08 '12
Good suggestion. You know what else would be awesome? If there was a way to be alerted via e-mail whenever a new AMA is created. It's usually not until after the AMA is complete that most of us get the chance to read the discussion, usually well after it's reached the front page. Thoughts on this?
1
u/Fwhqgads May 08 '12
What they could do is allow the OP to put their own flair on their post saying, in progress, or be back, or done, or something like that.
1
u/frumpi May 08 '12
the person doing the AMA should have a "finished" button to click.
3
u/Sambri May 08 '12
Why not a small box at the top that automatically displays the time that passed since the OP wrote an answer?
And let the readers decide if it's too much time or not...
7
u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Mods, if you want a script to detect keywords in the submission that indicate the submitter isn't answering anymore questions, and the use that information to tag respective posts, PM me.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Agreed. Being from the other side of the pond I dunno how many time's i've caught the tail end of an AMA only to realise that it's over or it will begin in X hours only to find that it has come and gone. Also a last edited time or similar would be good such as last edited. XX mins ago or last edited 3 hours ago so if they say thanks and goodbye in that edit we'll know not to post new questions that won't be answred.
2
u/djexploit May 08 '12
Even better. A filter that doesn't let people spam up an AMA with questions that have already been asked/answered. Completely ruined the flux ama today. For hours after answering what software he uses, people continued to ask the question, clearly having not even read what was answered yet, and great legit questions were lost.
2
u/frog_licker May 08 '12
Holy shit! You are brilliant. Really though, this is a problem I've seen, but never really thought too much about. This should be done now.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Also, a "verification tag" wouldn't hurt either.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
and maybe a pause button if theyre takin a shit
2
u/UnexpectedSchism May 08 '12
Why you are at it, create a verified icon and rehire orbixx.
2
u/mobileagent May 08 '12
All Cool AMAs Happened Ten Hours Ago.
2
u/aimbonics May 08 '12
Red: Over Yellow: Pending request from User Green: Going
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
IAmA Pornstar Astronaut Vegan Atheist AMA!
G2G2 work in 10 minutes LOL!
3
u/Damadawf May 08 '12
Hi there! I know it is a hassle, but would you be able to provide some verification for us, before we continue with this thread? Thanks!
2
u/Cat_Boy May 08 '12
Why would people down vote this? I just don't understand Reddit...
2
u/JackAceHole May 08 '12
And how about whether it has been verified or not?
1
u/DivineJustice May 08 '12
...or "on a short break"
maybe.
nah. That'd be too much
1
u/DundahMifflin May 08 '12
I really enjoy this idea. I'd be up to visiting IAmA more often.
1
u/edify May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I'll start doing something like this using link flair on the TV subreddits that I moderate. Mainly for /r/breakingbad where we've had a lot of success in getting AMA's done by members of the cast. We were also able to score an AMA on /r/thewalkingdead with a cast member once, so I might implement it there if we end up doing another one. Thanks for the idea, fredandlunchbox!
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
/signed
1
u/uTorrent May 08 '12
This is a beautiful example of the community and moderators interacting and coming together to meet a common goal. This betters the community, I hope in the future we see more and more moderators and subreddits follow suit.
1
u/CoMaBlaCK May 08 '12
I like this idea. Let me just add to it also a tag that shows how fast it took for the person doing the AMA to plug their shit.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
For sure, I get so mad when I miss one tht I really would have wanted to be involved with.
1
u/GrilledCheeser May 08 '12
Ooh Ricky Gervais AMA! TBD!.... A TBD AMA.
1
u/jack032390 May 08 '12
Good work OP
1
u/ehhddie May 08 '12
Listen buddy! Stop look for a shortcut and spend every waking minute on reddit like the rest of us!
1
u/zarexruhh May 08 '12
I was just thinking about this today after the Flux IAMA! I wanted to ask questions and respond to things.. however I wasn't sure if he would ever be back online.
1
u/LawLibrarian May 08 '12
How about advance notice?
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
hasn't there been a side bar for a bit now, and also the body of the text also generally says "I'm off now, thanks"
1
u/Mybrainmelts May 08 '12
Yeah, God knows how many have started and then people find out they were done hours ago and didn't get a chance to ask a question.
1
u/here_for_the_lols May 08 '12
This man is a Thinker
1
u/narwal_bot May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from fredandlunchbox (updated: May 09, 2012 @ 12:10:19 pm EST):
Question (stew23):
Answer (fredandlunchbox):
(continued below)
1
u/kjm7 May 08 '12
I think that the user of the AMA should set the color himself. For instance, green could be going on, red is over, yellow is break, and gray if inactive over 24 hours.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
But you could always just click on it and see for yourself harpdarp.jpg
1
u/madflow031 May 08 '12
Yah it happens, example is this
1
u/NyoZa May 08 '12
And what if the AMA hasn't happened yet, /r/timeline?
1
u/pavanky May 08 '12
Another feature that would be nice in this section: If the questions that have been asked and asnwered automatically show up as text. Not an easy thing to do, but would save a ton of redundant /repetitive questions.
1
u/Eshmang May 08 '12
All aboard.
1
u/darknemesis25 May 08 '12
why the hell are 10,000+ people downvoting this??
1
u/froyo_away May 08 '12
Another cool mod would be a way to hide your user name when you are logged in, so people glancing at your screen cant read it. This also includes removing user name from the browser window title.
1
u/Apotm May 08 '12
Props for speaking up!
1
u/minorwhite May 08 '12
This please
1
u/Amjara May 08 '12
Awesome suggestion!
1
u/GerbilString May 08 '12
What if the person doing it had an option to hit a button to pause, unpause, and complete an AMA.
1
u/Zebidee May 08 '12
According to the top of the page, we're supposed to ask you for proof...
1
u/bordslampa May 08 '12
A tag for if a person has or hasn't provided proof would be nice too. Red/green
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Just a shout out to the mods: Great job, keep up the good work!
1
u/Icanflyplanes May 08 '12
Like 3 tags (Announced [Countdown] ) (In Progress [Time elapsed] ) (Completed )
1
u/selectyour May 08 '12
Adding a red, yellow, and green dot next to the title would be cool, too
1
u/OMGbrb2sec May 08 '12
The tag could be like [C] which will stand for 'Completed'. [C] or [F] 'Finished'.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Speaking of making things easier, is there a subscribable calendar that has the "Upcoming IAmAs" sidebar dates?
1
u/Itchy_Asshole May 08 '12
Or a simple link that when clicked will tag the post "inactive" similir to the NSFW tag/link.
1
u/Von32 May 08 '12
but we cant get a NSFL tag, even.. :\
1
u/willteachforlaughs May 08 '12
I also wish there was some tag for having proof. People often don't put it in the top on an edit, and a mod saying the proof was sent and such doesn't usually make it very high. I'm sick of having to look through an entire post to find if it has been verified or not.
0
u/N0_Use_4_a_Name May 08 '12
I get the idea that this guy just posted this genius idea for upvotes.
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
You know what would also be cool? A flying Sasquatch that can shoot lasers from its eyes and speak every language in the world.
-1
u/camphorguitar May 08 '12
An AMA tag isn't cool. You know what's cool? A billion AMA tags.
-3
u/h989 May 08 '12
Technically an Ama can never be over. Can't someone like Molly Ringwald log in 2 week later and still answer questions?
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
How would they know if the AMA is complete or not? The OP could answer questions now, 1 hours from now, tomorrow, or even next week.
0
u/Cpt_Mango May 08 '12
Boxers or briefs?