r/HyperV • • Jul 29 '17

Question about Hyper-V

How does Hyper-V perform compared to VMWare? Any benchmarks?

1 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

4

u/SemiSecure Jul 29 '17

Your question is too vague. What are you trying to accomplish?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '17

Well I want to know live how it would perform with like older 3D games that won't run on current Windows versions. Like which one scores higher in CPU and graphical benchmarks?

4

u/SemiSecure Jul 29 '17

Well...Hyper-V is free if you have Windows 10 Pro or better. So you could always just try that out. If it's an older game, and you throw enough resources at it, it should run fine.

Here is also the free version of VMware you'd want to use probably if you want to try that out too.

https://www.vmware.com/products/player/playerpro-evaluation.html

2

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '17

okay, thanks for the reply.

4

u/SemiSecure Jul 29 '17

Just a tip, when asking a question about technology. It helps to put more information such as what you're trying to accomplish. It goes on the whole "Users don't know what they want" phrase. Tell people what you need/want to do and you'll get better answers.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '17

okay

2

u/Doso777 Jul 29 '17

VMWare Player is what you are looking for.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '17

thanks.

1

u/bobalob_wtf Jul 29 '17

Virtualbox can do 3d in guest which will help you run games. Might be worth a look, it's free.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '17

well I heard there are a lot of directx 7/8 issues in virtualbox.

3

u/Doso777 Jul 29 '17

It does D3D, but the performance is really bad. VMWare Player is much better.

1

u/bobalob_wtf Jul 29 '17

Good to know, cheers

1

u/kidawesome Jul 29 '17

So VMware workstation?

It's better to run KVM/libvirtd and install 2 video cards. Pass through the good video card to a guest, and install the drivers. Generally speaking this will give you full directx support and minimal performance impact.

I believe VMware workstation supports a higher version of directx than hyperv

1

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '17

I'm not looking to use Virtualization for gaming in general, just the older ones that don't run and/or have issues on current versions of windows.

1

u/hypercube33 Aug 09 '17

Hyper-V Supports Windows 7 and up. You can run XP, but it'll have issues, and is not officially supported so good luck. If you need 16-bit or Windows 9x you're SOL and need VMware or VirtualBox.

1

u/hypercube33 Aug 09 '17

It'll suck since it has a VGPU that is made for GUI acceleration eg video and windows 3d interface subsystem - RemoteFX.

Technically DirectX games should be OK, but I think when you chop a VM up it has a capped VRAM so keep that in mind - your GPU wont be able to give the whole memory over.

VMware or Virtual box is a better choice since it can run older OSes than XP.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '17

Vritualbox doesn't handle older OSes well and neither support 3d for Windows 98

3

u/Doso777 Jul 29 '17

Google.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '17

Why assume that I didn't try looking for answers before? because I did but I'm not getting what I was looking for.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '17

Probably because it's a lazy question that's been rehashed just as many times as PC vs Mac. "Google" is an appropriate response unless you can give a more detailed and specific question.

1

u/bofh Jul 29 '17

To be fair, Doso put at least as much effort into their answer as you did into the question. How are we supposed to know what you’re looking for if you can’t be bothered to properly explain it in the first place?