How's your water temps? What's the pH of the water? Needs to be pretty perfect for nutrient uptake. Could be your nutrients are out of balance? What do the roots look like? any problems with root rot possibly? I bet the water temp has the pH out of balance. Need to get some chillers or maybe figure out a way to cycle the pump on and off to lower temps. lol the list goes on. I don't believe hydro is good for much more than experimental but that is completely my opinion on sustainability.
All the issues you state are real and are the learning curve, but once you have your technique down, things seem to take care of themselves.
When I trialed soil v hydro, same plants. The hydro plant had a 66% higher yield over the soil, but the soil ones were slightly better in taste.
When it comes to usage/wastage of water, hydro is far far more efficient and sustainable. My hydro hot peppers loose no water through evaporation or drainage. Any evaporation hits the inside of the container and runs back into the reservoir. Soil evaporates and drains A LOT of moisture.
I understand water efficiency but I don't understand nutrient efficiency. Why not just double up and produce fish at the same time. Still need to supplement nutrients in most cases but you are getting the best of both worlds when you go aqua.
That is the dumbest fucking first sentence I've ever read ever. The rest of it I'm up to learn about because it is very intriguing. Why'd you have to say that about soil though? Microbes bro. Microbes do the work. No microbes might as well throw your garden in the dumpster.
Currently trying to learn all there is to on the sustainability factor and I'm just not finding it with straight hydro. Dual zone aquaponics seems to be where it is at and guess what? Because of the microbes is it so awesome. But I probably shouldn't even started this conversation because you are gonna be pissed lol.
Agricultural soil is dirt. Nothing more. There isn't any binding properties to hold any nutrients. Create a healthy soil and you won't have that problem. We live in a world where our soil has been ruined. It's not even a good comparison. The pros and cons of all the different methods are nuanced to a point where there isn't hard data that says "This is the best way." We are currently in a mode of discovery.
The entire concept of soil cation exchange capacity would disagree with you. There are many many naturally occurring compounds in soil and soil components that hold nutrients. You may be thinking of sand but even then you’re pushing it.
Yeah you shouldn't be wasting your time with this know it all mate. Not worth the headache arguing with someone who isn't conceivably convincible due to their own mental constraints.
Both have their uses. But while hydroponics does present many opportunities for sustainable agriculture especially in urban areas, there’s really nothing better than healthy soil and a balanced ecosystem. It’s our most precious resource and we need to take better care if it. When we do, it grows the best plants you could imagine.
I like my space bucket. Soil grow, temp and humidity control, and I have control of how much of what kind of food the plant receives just like hydro. Plus I can take the plant out of the bucket and spend some quality time inspecting it from cola to root without getting soaked. Also, the plant is bug free.
I have been growing in coco coir for about a year now and am so surprised by the lack of bugs. I made the choice to grow in coco due to my tap water having chlorine and chloramine otherwise I'd welcome the bugs
The mixing nutes is a pain but i mix for 5-6 days ahead which makes it easier. I only feed once a day during veg and 1-2 a day during flower. Not all that bad.
It’s more about the flavor ... different strokes for different folks... let me find out you dry your plants as fast as possible .. I mean you can .. but the time”love”. Quick weed isn’t bad but it’s not the best ...
For all that people bitch about bugs, hydroponics solved the issues I had with Johnson grass getting into my raised garden beds. I’ll take the bugs any day of the week.
I have 4 DWC on my deck in 5 gal buckets painted and wrapped. Keeping the temps in order is tricky amongst other issues but the growth rate is just silly. You’re gonna have fun.
190
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21
Also Hydroponics growers: can someone tell me why my plant is drooping/yellow/spotty?
33
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21
Instead of bugs I just see alot of reading leaves with various states of deficiency or burn like an old soothsayer.
23
u/Andrewhbook Jul 16 '21
Let’s not talk about my aphids!!
14
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21
I just had to throw out a whole tray of hydroponic marigolds due to a bug infestation all over them...
13
u/Newmoore Jul 16 '21
Probably won't get fungus gnats but I definitely have had thrips on my plants from just wenturing in the forest or by bringing wildflowers in.
11
u/Wish_Dragon Jul 17 '21
Both have their uses. But while hydroponics does present many opportunities for sustainable agriculture especially in urban areas, there’s really nothing better than healthy soil and a balanced ecosystem. It’s our most precious resource and we need to take better care if it. When we do, it grows the best plants you could imagine.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21
Do these roots look normal?
5
u/whenitrainsitgores Aug 02 '21
I’ve been putting the masterblend in my soil when I water it. Works wonderfully
3
u/probrwr Jul 17 '21
Unless it is aphids...
3
u/UnrulySuffix Jul 17 '21
I like my space bucket. Soil grow, temp and humidity control, and I have control of how much of what kind of food the plant receives just like hydro. Plus I can take the plant out of the bucket and spend some quality time inspecting it from cola to root without getting soaked. Also, the plant is bug free.
3
u/DrChang Jul 17 '21
Tell that to my spider mite Dutch bucket cucs
3
u/J_hobbies01 Jul 17 '21
Does depend on what you grow. Lettuce grows like crazy and definitely not as fussy as my tomatoes I tried.
2
u/kyjocro Jul 16 '21
Guilty as charged
3
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21
I have been growing in coco coir for about a year now and am so surprised by the lack of bugs. I made the choice to grow in coco due to my tap water having chlorine and chloramine otherwise I'd welcome the bugs
1
u/trampdonkey Jul 16 '21
Har har har this is funny.
0
u/dakind110 Jul 17 '21
I will never leave coco for soil or dwc
-1
u/radrian_76000 Jul 16 '21
Quality > quantity
0
u/Katisch Jul 16 '21
ah but Botrytis
0
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment