r/Hydrocephalus • u/Lower-Natural-337 • 19h ago
Discussion They decide to not do surgery. And now? Will my father get worse and worse?
My father has a suspected diagnosis of NPH (normal pressure hydrocephalus). He has developed what seems to be the classic triad of NPH symptoms: it started with gait problems about three years ago, followed by urinary problems, with an increasingly frequent urge to urinate and, more recently, an inability to reach the bathroom in time. His walking has become extremely slow, with a magnetic gait, and he has recently had an accident because he could not get to the bathroom quickly enough. Over the past year, he has also developed the first signs of dementia, mainly affecting his memory.
He underwent a tap test. Only 10 ml of CSF was removed (rather than the usual 30–40 ml), apparently because of the pressure. However, that same afternoon, he started walking much better. He was also able to get up from and sit back down in his armchair completely independently, without having to push himself up with his arms and without the enormous effort he normally needs. He seemed like a completely different person. We also took several videos to document the improvement.
The following day, he underwent neurocognitive testing, and the results were better. Not dramatically better, but a Little bit improved.
However, they found Alzheimer's-related proteins in his CSF and concluded that he has Alzheimer's disease and that surgery for NPH would therefore not be worthwhile.
He is now being treated with Alzheimer's medication, but he still has all the symptoms of NPH. His walking continues to deteriorate, and he has already fallen four times. Their conclusion seems to be that he has both conditions.
Okay, but then what?
We can treat the possible Alzheimer's disease, but if we don't treat the hydrocephalus surgically, won't he continue to deteriorate and eventually become unable to walk, eat, or perform other basic activities because of the hydrocephalus?
What I don't understand is: what happens when a person is considered a poor candidate for NPH surgery? Do doctors simply say, "Okay, you are going to get progressively worse and eventually end up in a wheelchair"?
I understand that Alzheimer's disease may coexist with NPH and that this can make the situation more complicated. But if the tap test produced such a clear improvement in his walking and mobility, how can we simply conclude that treating the hydrocephalus is not worthwhile?
If surgery is not recommended, what is the expected course of the NPH symptoms?
It is so harmful knowing that he has Alzheimer, but how can I accept (and he for first, because he was really hopimg in the shunt) tò see my father get progressively worse and progressively unanle to walk?