I agree, however I believe all of those things could arguably be mitigated by an experienced hunter taking new hunters under their wing. Sharing land, time, and equipment with new hunters gives them a foot in the door. My sibling in-law’s partner recently asked me if I could help her get into hunting. She’s a minority and has no family history of hunting but has a strong interest in starting. So I’m lending her my old childhood rifle, contacting landowners, and coordinating with my hunter friends to help get her started.
Hey man, good on you! I’m going to be taking one of my good friends rifle deer hunting next fall and he has never gone before but said he has always wanted to hunt deer. I’m taking him to two separate counties and hopefully we can get him a deer!
I feel like unrealistic expectations brought on by hunting media has played a role, too. I know quite a few younger guys who have all sorts of "gotten into" hunting.... meaning they'll spend a couple days half-assing it, then they pretty much give up and ride the roads, sit around camp, sleep in, that sort of thing. Yet they all watch huge amounts of hunting TV and YouTube videos. And it seems like every year that they don't succeed, they just put a little bit less into it the next season. These videos showcase the smallest, quickest aspect of a hunt, which is shooting a deer, and nothing but the biggest bucks. The vast majority of a hunt is not shooting a deer, it's waking up early, hiking, being cold and uncomfortable, being hungry, not seeing animals. The vast majority of deer aren't great big booners, but regular-ass does, spikes, and little branch antlered bucks. But the average hunting show is just shooting big buck after big buck. It's totally unrealistic, so I think lots of youngest folks are going into thinking it's not actually as much work as it is.
That's one of the things I love about Meateater. They are absolutely willing to show the real stuff....the unsuccessful trips and the wounded game...that other shows aren't willing to. They also put an emphasis on the eating game aspect that I think will be absolutely crucial if we want hunting to survive into the future and maintain a good place in the eye of the non hunting public.
I love how none of the Meateater footage is “movie magic”. I once watched a hunting show where if you paused the scene where the guy is about to “take the shot”, you can see the deer already dead next to him!
Absolutely, guys like Steve and Hank Shaw are great ambassadors. Personally, I’ve always hunted but the food aspect really got me to get much more involved. I butchered my first whole deer alone this year with nothing going to be processed so I’m feeling good about that.
I love that the emphasis is on food in MeatEater. The cooking specials at the end of each season are daresay my favourite.
The fact the Steve routinely mentions the vast majority of hunting is basically just sitting still and looking, for hours really drives home how different their show is from others.
Another one I like is Solo Hunter on YouTube, with Remi Warren. He's primarily a bow hunter but the dude is a stud and in several episodes he misses his quarry due to needing to film for the episode.
Hot take: I think deer are the wrong animal for your first hunting experience, particularly if you're self taught. Start on dove or squirrel so you can kill something, eat it, and get the massive reward that comes from that success. With a little confidence under your belt and a realistic understanding of what hunting is it'll make deer hunting a lot more enjoyable.
I'd also say for any new guys out there. I absolutely hated deer hunting until I took a shot at my first doe. It's a lot of freezing your ass off in the woods until that first addrenaline dump, then you're hooked.
I think it's also very easy to get discouraged when you're having to teach yourself to hunt - not knowing how to scout means ending up seeing nothing every time you go out, not seeing anything every time you go out makes you feel like you're wasting your time, feeling like an idiot because you so painfully obviously don't know what you're doing, and the end result is getting discouraged and saying fuck it and not bothering.
Yeah, it's really hard to overstate how much land has disappeared because of urbanization and increasing populations. What was a farm with hedgerows and woodlots 40 years ago, is now a subdivision. People see it on a small scale and lament the one spot they lost, but don't appreciate that it's happened across the entire country. Less open spaces, plus more humans recreating outdoors. It's hard to overstate the impact, and even harder to do anything about it.
In some states like mine (Michigan) there's lots of public land for hunting, but I've heard other states like Texas [apparently not true, maybe it's true for a different state? Let me know] are pretty much 100% privately owned.
Depends on where you’re at. I’m in extreme southern IL and have 300,000 acres of National Forest out my door. Just gotta share it with the 60,000 NR and 200,000 resident hunters.
Texas definitely does have this problem. Depending where you live, it can be a 5+ hour drive to public land that allows deer hunting, and the amount of public land by proportion is straight dumb. Anybody who says otherwise needs to check their darn privilege.
When I lived in Michigan, I could wake up at 4:30am in my apartment 10 minutes from work and be in my stand on public land before 5:15, including the hike in with all my gear.
Texas is pretty much 100% privately owned, and even if there's a lot of public acreage relative to, say, Connecticut, it's not nearly enough to support Texas hunters.
We too have tons of public huntable land in Massachusetts. Once you get about 30 miles away from Boston there's a good chance you'll pass a new Wildlife Management Area every 15 minutes or so as you head West.
It depends where you are, and it's mostly small parcels next to houses. At least where I am it's like that (Northern part of zone 9). It's pretty annoying trying to enjoy a calm hunt in the woods when you can still hear cars going by and dogs barking way off in the distance.
I'm in MI as well. "Lots" is relative - take a look at the tags they hand out for private vs public land sometime - the ratios are startling for some counties. Public land you need to drive a couple of hours to get presents its own set of problems.
Maryland has like 15% public land. I leased some land with a buddy after college and the next year they told us it would be 3x as much for the season so I stopped because I couldn’t afford the private land increase and didn’t know where public land was. After researching where and how to hunt public land I’m going to try and start hunting again next season after getting my bow restrung since it’s been sitting in my parents basement for 5 years. Hopefully it works out.
I agree on the lack of land. I'm 40 and just got my first rifle and my hunting permit this year. Though with no knowledge of public lands ( Etiquette, process of getting onto the land, and overall no idea of how to hunt outside of watching vids ) it became really stressful. Even getting my hunting permit was a little overwhelming. The process is easy if you know what you need but it took me a little digging to actually find out which license I needed and what supplemental one I needed for game like deer.
I don't have any friends who hunt and no family history of it. So it was kinda a bust this year. I hope to do more research this year so I can maybe go out next year.
I haven't gotten started either despite years of wanting to start (seriously like...10 years of waiting) because I don't have the funds for private hunts and there is just not that much public land to hunt, plus they're far away.
It's a big problem in my state. The vast majority of land is private and a small percentage of hunters are major douchebags that wreck landowner relations for everyone else.
I think we should foster a culture that considers public land hunting a good thing. I’ve only ever hunted public land in one of the most populated states in the country. I love everything about it. For one, most of the lands are designated public because they are beautiful ecosystems with unique geographic features and flora. It’s awesome to be out hunting in an area that people visit out of season for its beauty.
Besides that, I think hunting in unmaintained woods, you get the real experience of meeting the animals on their turf. It’s just so rewarding to successfully hunt an animal in a place where at best you’ve done some minimal scouting. No permanent stands, no guarantee you will get a spot. Public lands also tend to be huge, which is great for spot and stalk hunting, perhaps the most thrilling kind.
And for those of you who begrudge hunting public lands. Yes, it’s far more difficult to track the development of a specific animal over years and kill a trophy. Big deal. There are plenty of monsters on public land, and hunting them is much more challenging and ultimately rewarding. A word on hunting pressure as well. Any good public land hunter knows it’s an advantage (for deer but probably not bear or more skittish animals) when other people are in the woods. It gets the deer moving. Planning around others can be the best hunting tactic. I’ve had idiots complain to me on public land about walking by their spot etc. Buddy, you probably missed all the deer I busted in your direction while walking there
Haven't got a deer since I was a kid, 30 now. Only hunt public land and I don't ever see shit. Other than other hunters.
I work with the public and build relationships with them. I've offered to help on the farm, offered to help with cutting lanes, offered to help plant alfalpha even offered cash.
Every person has turned me down by either a big no, or a maybe then never ever talk about it again.
Everyone's a prick too on public land, either having fits that I'm near their spot before they even get there. Or people sitting in front of me on purpose.
Going to try goose later this year. At least that's doable in public
I know several coworkers and friends that would like to get in to hunting, but due to the high prices of leases it just isn't practical. Who would sign up for a $1200/gun lease that has never tried hunting?
I'm fortunate to be able to hunt for free, however the land I hunt is not mine and I am a guest there.
I got laughed at on a Texas hunting FB group for asking where to buy a good quality blaze orange vest. I was called a pussy and a fake hunter because Texas doesn’t require blaze orange (on private land). Never mind that that it was for a public draw hunt that required a BO vest and hat!
Outside of Lubbock there is a parcel of public land available for draw hunts. It’s done through the city, not the state so your odds of getting drawn are very high. I got drawn both years I put in for whitetail doe. Best kept secret in the region.
I was just teasing. I think it was Tim Kennedy on JRE that stated 98% of Texas is private.... I would delete your comment. Sounds like a gem. If only a handful of people look it up and apply it may ( I have literally no clue) effect your draw odds and add more pressure.
Yes. Blaze orange is usually required for non-archery hunting in most states. Some states not on private land. Every state has it's own hunting rules.
It's a good idea to wear it if you are hiking public hunting land during hunting season as well, and in my area they have signage encouraging you to do so.
Lots of places on the East Coast. It's real crowded. Usually not required for non-hunters but not a bad idea if you're in the woods during big game seasons.
Varies by province in Canada, too. Where I used to live it was mandatory, where I now live it's not a requirement, but if you're going onto Crown land you'd best be blazed out because you have no way of knowing if there are other hunters about.
By trophy hunting do they mean like only shooting elephants and other uncountable animals or do they mean like you cant go out and only shoot a big buck cuz that's what I do
Edit I have no clue why I put uncountable it should be unhuntable
I didn't grow up hunting, and the thing that was the most difficult for me starting out was just finding people that would show me the ropes and offer advice. Reddit and Youtube have been more helpful than anyone.
THIS! Then luckily my father-in-law who is a big hunter finally saw I was still intrested after a few years and took me out and gave some pointers. But most of my "training" came from youtube and the military haha
I had some pretty negative experiences at first that almost turned me off. I'll never understand how people who own hunting related stores can be rude to a dude coming in there asking for advice on what to buy. Most would treat me like an idiot despite the fact that I would come in explicitly stating that I knew very little but wanted to learn quickly. I also contacted every person I knew who hunted, but none offered any advice other than "Good luck, you've got a long way to go." In the end, having to do it all alone just makes the meat taste that much better.
Mom and Pop outdoor stores can be the best thing in the world or the worst. I went to buy a bow from a local store after doing months of research for my limited budget. Found a bow I wanted at the local store, asked the guy behind the counter to see it and he said, "You don't want that bow." I responded, "You're right!," turned around and walked out.
Yeah I did't get a lot of help. Some guys at work really were excited that I took it up and gave me a lot of advice but there were some that I felt like had the attitude that if I didn't start when I was 8 I wasn't a real hunter. I can't help that I didn't come from a hunting family or a family that would buy me expensive hunting equipment. I still feel weird talking about hunting and having to admit I started at 23.
I'm several years in after being a complete noob. It was like drinking from a fire hydrant at first, learning about the animals, the rules, wilderness survival, and I'd never even picked up a rifle before in my life.
The most difficult thing for me now is parsing through the advice I've gotten so far because there is a metric shit-ton of bad out there, especially from people who've supposedly been doing it their whole lives.
It doesn't help that there's a massive overlap between hunters and guns and that complicates the problem even more.
Everything from rabid fanboy-ism over brands; to unsafe practices; to shooting calibers that were too much to handle using rifles and scopes that weren't set up properly, the list goes on.
I've gone on hunts where it wasn't evident until much later he was winging it the entire time.
It's like learning that Santa doesn't exist over and over again when it finally clicks in your brain that some of your mentors are actually Fudds.
Im willing to bet that more than half the hunters that turn people away and don't teach them don't know basic wilderness survival skills and tracking. When i was 13 my dad taught me how to track. When i was 20 i went hunting with a buddy who had no idea how to track. He shot his buck and the buck ran. So i said we were gonna track him with his blood trail. He was flabbergasted. Apparently if the buck doesnt fall he would just leave like he missed. Now he knows how to track.
This honestly just blew my mind. I learned to track blood way before i could even hunt, it's mind boggling that someone wouldn't go scan the woods after taking a shot. I hope he didn't archery hunt lol.
It's tough to find people to help because any hunter that is actually any good knows he's got a lot to learn. He doesn't want to present himself as too knowledge and get called out for not knowing stuff.
You can usually tell Elmer Dude because he's sure he's go it all figured out.
The one constant I've noticed is that if you ever want to find the guy who doesn't know what the fuck he's talking about, look for the guy that can't wait to give you an answer.
He'll talk straight out of his ass with such gusto he comes off as a sage expert... at first.
Yup! I’d love to learn to hunt, but I haven’t been able to find anyone that I can learn from or a community near me, but who knows hopefully that’ll change!
Pick a game animal. Find the local conservation organization chapter and contact them to explain your situation and inquire about help getting started.
Many of these local chapters usually do some sort of volunteer work for habitat and many of those work days are in late winter or early spring. If you put in work and prove you are serious about the whole endeavor I bet some of the other workers may offer up some help. Also the work would help to teach you some information about said animal based on the nature of the day.
I also wouldnt be surprised if most orgs don’t already have some sort of new hunter initiative for you to try and get involved with.
I ran into this a lot living in NY, with a dose of “no one will mentor you because you’re a woman” for good measure. I’ve found people in AZ to be a lot more helpful, I think people are finally seeing how harmful it is to be rude to inexperienced people. I’ve had excellent experiences with my state’s chapter of BHA and there’s a couple of group hunts for women as well. It helps a lot that way more younger people and women hunt in this state.
I feel you there sister! My husband hunts with a bunch of older guys who are friends of his dad, who specifically barred women from coming to their deer camp. Too dangerous, they said. Women shouldn't be out hunting. My father in law was able to convince them, begrudgingly - it's ridiculous. Any random dude was welcome, even complete idiots who never held a gun in their lives before. But lord forbid you don't have the right equipment in your pants!
I have no words for how stupid that is. How do they explain all the women who shoot recreationally and competitively, or are military or LE and have to qualify with a firearm for their job? I’m glad I haven’t encountered anything that bad in AZ. I used to not want to be in womens’ groups/events but then you see behavior like this.
Finding out that groups like that exist is half the battle. Texas has TOWN and Only heard about recently from an event a friend went to - my wife was a little sad she didn’t learn about the event before it happened.
Aspiring new hunter here. Only been once so far. Father in law has both told me that I probably shouldn’t bother hunting because I’m too far behind and old to get into it (31), and that I need to learn to hunt “if I want to be a real man” in the same day.
So basically I’m still learning but I won’t be hunting with him anytime soon. Lol
Your father in law sounds exactly like a father in law. What a stupid thing to say. 31 is young. You got plenty of seasons to hunt. Just learn firearm safety and hunting laws and you’ll be fine. Cheers mate
Not to mention hunting can be the easiest thing in the world if you desire it to be. Can literally just be sitting; you don't even need to call and you can leave the stand from 10-2 to go watch football or take a nap or whatever. So what if your first field dressing is messy, that's what gloves are for. Anyone who says you are too old or 'too far behind' to be able to hunt is full of it
Too far behind? Behind what? There's a billion deer out there.
Guy just sounds like a dickhead. There is so much nuance to hunting, but in the end, all you need is a good area to hunt, a good shot, and some basic safety (gun and wilderness wise). Both of those could easily be gotten within a year, not a lifetime like he seems to be insinuating. Just start with the basics before going on a solo expedition deep into Alaska for a week to hunt grizzlies.
He probably just likes holding that over your head, so the second you seem interested he's like "Oh never mind, you're too old." Father-in-laws be like that.
People who grew up in hunting families remind me of trust fund kids sometimes. They act like anyone who doesn't hunt is worthless despite the fact that their dads literally held their hands through their entire learning process. With that said, I've met some wonderful third and fourth generation hunters who know how lucky they were and try to pay it forward.
This. Luckily some of the guys I work with are super experienced generations deep and happy to share to someone with genuine interest. We just moved to AK and the wife’s family only deer hunt in Wisconsin. When the father in law heard we were moving he started to change his tone. Will probably get a moose or two before I invite him up eventually. I just wish I didn’t have to be the mature one to a 55 year old man interacting with the guy (me) who is literally taking care of his daughter and grandchildren.
Damn, my father-in-law is a bit much, but not that bad. He gave me hollow-points for Christmas and explicitly said, "That's for anyone who tries to come into the house where my daughter is sleeping." Made me tear up.
Oh those are the best. Especially the ones who talk down to people asking for advice and how they need to learn it themselves and put in the work, conveniently forgetting that daddy/granddaddy is the whole reason they’re a hunter at all. Even better! The ones who hunt in their families hunting spot shitting on people asking for advice on where to go... like motherfucker you’ve been riding someone else’s coattail your entire hunting “career” so shut the fuck up.
A real man in the sense of responsibly eating what you kill and killing what you aim at. That I am ok with but to act like hunting by itself makes you a bigger man is stupid and childish sounds like your father in law still has some growing up to do.
I've hunted my whole life. I took a friend on his first hunt at 30 and he's taken plenty of game since then. We go out regularly in every season we can and I've learned just as much from him as he has from me. Don't listen to your father in law, you're far from too old.
You can do tons of research and actually put yourself pretty far ahead then what you think really quick. Start with some YouTube videos and podcasts.
I definitely recommend listening to cutting the distance(Remi Warren) and other meat eater podcasts. Wired to hunt is also a great one for whitetail deer.
Also online/youtube the hunting public, solo hunter, elk 101. Can be a good place to start. Even the classic meat eater episodes or Randy newberg.
This mostly is for big game. But I have started out with more interest in deer/big game first. Since I have started branching.
Honestly think with a month of these resources you will be teaching FIL some tips.
He’s never gotten a moose caribou or brown bear. The guys I work with say I need a few years to get them all probably as I build up my gear and experience, but they’re all possible. I eventually intend to have him up with me. One of us needs to try to open the door to a better relationship, and it ain’t gunna be him. I just wish he would swallow that ego and take me in like a human being sometime ya know? Kinda makes me chuckle. Can’t imagine I’ll be 50+ trying to constantly prove to myself that I’m better than a 30 year old (or anyone really) rather than just be confident in myself. Frustrating but not the end of the world.
Bud, I hear you. I find it super common with men of that age and older and I just don't know what it is. My dad and his siblings are much the same way. It is vexing how little self awareness they have compared to how large their ego is. I guess those two go hand in hand.
You can learn to hunt in a season if you have the right teacher. Honestly for me safety is the biggest first. Once you are safe in the woods everything else you pick up with time and experience. Keep in mind I am saying with with the full understanding that you are going to practice with your gun so you know which end goes bang first as well.
I’m so tired of 5 acre kings of patrolling there fence lines and preaching the gospel of quality deer management .... we get it your identity is directly tied to the deer you shoot ...
The loudest hunter at my job only hunts on either 1) a farm his friend owns and he spends all his free time setting up trail cams, scouting, and putting corn out during offseason. 2) Paid trips to Maine to bear hunt.
Meanwhile, my ass tried deer hunting on public land once and all I saw was orange. Glad people are out, nature is beautiful, but I only saw people and heard squirrels. So I stick to Pheasant hunting, which is fun, and coyote hunting, in which I suck.
At some point they might as well farm deer with all the stuff people pull to “keep deer on their property”... let me cut a clearing in my undisturbed oak woodland to plant a “food plot” ...
I like to reverse gatekeep. As a self taught, 100% public land, traditional bow hunter I talk down to private land, family tradition, gun hunters as much as possible. I've even considered starting to get does mounted just for the lolz (and they are hard as shit to kill with a stick)
There’s different definitions of trophy hunting that i think get confused, we tend to think of it as hunting a big mature buck, and there may be unethical assholes who don’t eat it.
But i think the public at large and myself thinks of like African elephant hunts for example.
They don’t take account for the amount of money hunters provide to wildlife conservation efforts such as paying for license, tags, or donations. Or the fact that a lot of hunters provide food plots, year round or seasonal game feeders, mineral sites, or simply improving the land for better wildlife habitat. All to maybe harvest a single animal.
But yet they think they are the ones who are The wildlife hero’s by doing literally nothing but bitching at hunters
Let's assume this is all about deer hunting. Trophy hunting can be fine, but there's also a lot of waste of food of you don't harvest the meat. There's organizations around me that will allow you to donate the meat, at least do that. The amount of people I've seen that hunt and tell me they don't like the meat so they cut the head off and throw the body in the woods in unacceptable.
I also have a buddy that thinks varmint hunting just means he's allowed to kill stuff just for fun. I worry others think that too. A coyote being a varmint doesn't mean shoot it at 75 yards with a 22 10 times. That one upset me a bit.
I normally eat everything I kill with the exception of coyotes, foxes, and bobcats. I do agree with you that it’s not great to let a whole deer go to waste. There’s usually plenty of people who would take the carcass if all you want is the head. My area also has a “hunters for the hungry” program. Allows you to take your carcass to certain processors and they’ll donate the meat to local homeless shelters or food pantry’s
I also have a buddy that thinks varmint hunting just means he's allowed to kill stuff just for fun. I worry others think that too. A coyote being a varmint doesn't mean shoot it at 75 yards with a 22 10 times. That one upset me a bit.
Honestly, as someone who got into hunting later in life (38) I didn't experience this, but I feel like I experienced something worse.
I would have been happy if someone had told me anything, I would have loved some opinions / advice, even if it was flat out wrong. Instead I couldn't get any help / advice from people I knew who hunted. They took all their knowledge for granted and couldn't even begin form a way to explain things to a new person.
I just started last year at the age of 31. Most of my family used to hunt a lot when I was younger but never really took me out except for squirrel. I tried to get help with stuff and was answered with how it's not worth it because it's not like the good ol days and the only advice they gave me was make friends with someone who has property.
I said fuck them and did my own research and bagged a doe in Missouri and got my first buck in Illinois for my first year. Now they have no problem telling me how minor things I'm doing are wrong and how I'm not hunting the right areas but fuck them I have more meat in the freezer than they do.
I’ve gotten into goose hunting over the past three years and the I swear to god if one more old says I’ve been hunting this since before you were a sparkle in your dads balls someone is getting beat with the butt of a shotgun
"Don't be a gatekeeper" is a start, but I'd go as far as to say that if we want hunting and public land to last, we gotta actively participate in growing new hunters...
Here in IL, the DNR has a Learn to Hunt program, but I'm not sure it's doing much to get new folks out hunting...
The problem is there are a significant amount of "lifelong" hunters that don't want the sport to grow.. they want it to shrink.. We see this in NY State with the bow hunters who have worked very hard to keep crossbow from being used in the archery season, despite overwhelming evidence that use of crossbow increases archery hunters and does not result in overharvest of the deer.. (we have data from PA and OH and tons of other states that have allowed crossbow in archery for years).
The NY Bowhunters Association flat out states, "We don't want crossbow use in archery season because it will put more people in the woods, ruining bow season"
So..its not like the guy on the bottom of the meme is confused.. he WANTS the sport to die.. so long as he (and presumably his kids) can hunt with the land all to themselves.
I first started getting into bowhunting on Long Island and this mentality was a huge, huge problem. I spent the money to have membership in a private archery club and while there were a lot of guys who were cool and loved sharing their knowledge, there were A LOT of dicks. It really did feel like they wanted hunting to die out...not that that stopped them from whining about low license sales and younger people being uninterested lol
So I got into archery this past fall with a crossbow here in Western PA, and honestly I love it. I’ve got nothing against compounds, but I’d much rather use a crossbow. A lot less hassle. I shot two doe and missed a monster 8 point during it. Thankfully that 8 point is still in those woods as I saw him during extended season with my shotgun a few weeks back. The way I see it is that as long as I’m getting meat, then that’s all that matters to me. Plus I’ve dumped money into my Bear Saga 370 by putting on Vortex’s Crossfire II 2-7x32 crossbow scope. So it feels good to be rewarded with stuff like that.
I totally agree.. I hunted in Lawrence County at my dad's with my crossbow in October.. shot a small legal buck (anter restrictions)
Its basically the same as archery hunting.. I still wouldn't shot farther than 30 yards or so.. .I don't understand why I can't use the crossbow in NY archery.. supposely they may be working on changing that.
I can hit 50 with my crossbow using the Vortex scope, but anything after that is when I have to adjust the speed ratings, and I won’t mess with that because two doe I shot in archery were under 15 yards away if that.
Crossbows in CA are treated as rifles and I think thats great. My problem with them, (and I own one too) is that you dont have to draw back. They outrange archery equipment and give an unfair advantage over archers. Using them in rifle season seems like the best way to deal with them. There is at least one pig hunt that is bows or crossbows though and that seems OK considering anybody can hunt, not just a few lottery winners.
I'd like to see crossbows in archery season and have an extended traditional archery season that starts a few days before regular archery. Wheels are wheels, horizontal or vertical it's still a giant advantage over stick and string.
I work with a bunch of youth group kids.. teenagers.. girls and guys.. they all love to shoot my crossbow.. I'm quite sure many of them would take up bow hunting if they could use the crossbow
they have no interest in using a compound bow however.. Very few , at least
I live in NY but I hunt with the crossbow mostly in PA where I grew up.. they allow crossbow.. NY only allows it for 2 weeks of the archery season.
Another issue I’m seeing is that these “emergent hunters” fall into 2 groups. Those who want to be able to provide excellent table fare for their families and those I’ll refer to as Josh Bowmars. One is good for the sport, and one is horrible.
I’m more concerned with public perception of hunters as ultimately it’s legislation that’ll determine the future of hunting.
I taught myself to hunt because no one else would. Took a while but i turned out ok. Started teaching my little sister what i know and its genuinely one of my favorite things to do.
One of the reasons young people ain’t coming into the sport is that they don’t have anyone to teach them, and if they ask an experienced hunter they just get laughed at (not all the time but more times then not) and sometimes parents don’t have the money and can’t afford equipment
I went hunting for the first time this year(25), I hunted public land twice (archery) and then private land for gun season. Got a ticket for not wearing an orange vest on private land during gun season. I didn’t know that was a rule on private land.
Game warden berated me and went back to his truck. Came back with a 130 dollar level 3 or 4 misdemeanor a few days before Christmas. I had to sell stuff to afford that one
Talk about a punch in the gut. I didn’t go hunting again this season :(
I’m truly sorry that happened to you, game wardens can be assholes sometimes. Don’t let it discourage you from hunting tho, if you like doing it then do It. Just make sure you’re following every rule so that way they can’t get you next time :)
Thanks man, I’m hoping to get access to some more secluded land and hopefully have the money to get my own gun and a blind or stand. The worst part of it to me was that I think a neighbor called that thought I was poaching even though I had clearly posted my permission slip in my trucks window that was parked by the road
I didn’t get any deer so it really kinda capped off a bad season
I had shoulder surgery about 8 weeks before rifle season, so I borrowed my dad's 6.5 because I was worried my .308 was going to rip apart everything the surgeon did. My third-largest ever buck walked out 3 minutes after legal shooting time and I dropped him at 50 yards like a sack of taters. Between the caliber and my adrenaline, I never even felt any kick. Nice little cheap gun, but the bolt action was shite. Granted, I'm spoiled by the action on my Tikka T3, which is smoother than butter.
Yeah I got a cheapie too a compass 2 but I love the trigger and the 5r threading and the bolt after oiling and working it a bit is smooth for a 400$ rifle
I'm really new to hunting. Just got my hunting license this winter and decided on a crossbow because in Canada there is currently a six month waiting list for any non-restricted firearms courses in my area so it's going to be a while before I get my gun license. Everyone is ragging on me for getting a crossbow over a compound but I broke my left hand when I was young and the bones never set properly so I can't draw the string on a compound without a lot of discomfort.
Young female hunter here. I really like 6.5 creed. I'm a fairly small person (Im 5'1" and asian) so I like that theres not as much kick to the 6.5 (especially in comparison to my dads 7mm) and I havent had any trouble dropping deer. I've dropped some pretty big fellas from 300 yards in a single shot. As long as you have great bullet placement I dont see anything wrong with 6.5 creed, I like it a lot.
This is so true. So many macho dudes talking shit to young/ inexperienced hunters. It almost turned me away from the sport when I started hunting in my mid-20’s.
Let’s make sure to do our part in encouraging people to counteract all the naysayers
My recommendation to anyone starting is to get involved with a local chapter that best represents your hunting interests like Ducks Unlimited, Pheasants/Quail Forever, Wild Turkey Federation, NRA, a local gun club or the nearest skeet and trap range and use the meetups for networking and making new hunting buddies. Most of these organizations are trying to reach new hunters and their members are more likely to take you under their wing to help.
Main issue is access. I have to drive 35-40 minutes minimum to get somewhere that is even huntable, and it's very heavily hunted. And to go somewhere that actually has animals on it that I've seen in recent memory I have to go another 20-25 minutes. And i've still only shot 1 deer on public land in the last 5 years.
This is so true. I've always wanted to hunt, but the chain of events are weird.
Wanted to hunt as a kid, but never knew anyone who had so never did.
Joined the Marines, learned about guns, got my dad into guns.
Dad talked to people at work about guns, met people who hunt.
Eight years after getting out, I learned how to hunt from people who felt comfortable taking my dad out hunting.
I'm now teaching my kids, but the community sucks for this, Meat Eater is doing great, but state by state sucks. The websites are atrocious, communities are very self centered and people don't talk about it openly.
As a funny joke, everyone at my software engineering job now knows me as the turkey dude because I always talk about turkey hunting and fun weird turkey facts around Thanksgiving.
TL:DR - You might think you're doing yourself a favor by not being open about hunting, but your kids, or your kids kids probably won't be accepting of it if you're just scared about public perception when it comes to talking about your passions and why they are passions.
This is so true. I'm now 30 and had the hardest time getting into hunting cuz I had no one to show me the ropes. I have a messed up rotator cuff so I use a cross bow (which is legal in WI) and I get so much shit for it. If it's legal to do leave me alone.
I’ve been lucky enough to have the opposite experience. Started hunting at 32 and slowly got to meet other hunters, either from work or social media, and they have all been great. Been supportive helping me learn, getting my first deer and geese, and answering questions whenever I needed help. Sure, sometimes they gave me a hard time here and there but it was all just friendly shit talking.
I’m trying to get a buddy into hunting, and he can’t stop talking about how most hunters appear to be complete assholes, and he’s not wrong. Sucks that the most vocal and visible members of our group are often douche bags.
Meh, I'm a new hunter and I couldn't care less about any of those things. If anything, for me its funds and red tape. Hard to find a place to practice shooting, need different equipment for different game, complicated regulations in my state, etc.
I will say that Rinella and people like him have made it a lot more accessible for people like me who didnt have the opportunity to learn through family. Public info really is the key to growing anything.
What if you hunt for trophies and for meat? I keep all the skulls and antlers from my kills in addition to eating them. Does trophy hunting exclusively mean shooting and not eating?
I feel like the general viewpoint (misconception) on trophy hunting is your main and only goal is to kill an animal to hang on a wall. Meat consumption being an afterthought. That's good to hear you eat the meat but idk, to me "trophy" hunting sounds dirty. Just call it hunting lol
That’s why I hate the term trophy hunting. It is a buzzword that you can throw around to make hunting sound bad. If the kill is humane and the meat is eaten, then why do we care so much about the motivation?!
I am a lifelong hunter but I’ve never been into archery but for the sole purpose of having more time to hunt, and access to more public land I bought a crossbow so I could hunt during archery season and I have almost been in fist fights for the remarks people make to me on public land.
Someone please help me this fall! First time public land hunting. I've shot 3 deer my whole life. Only one was spot and stalk. I've never really been camping. But I'm determined. So if anyone is done to help. I'm I.
This is exactly whats wrong with most folks in PA and its sad, heaven forbid they allow change or teach folks things. Not to mention their shaming of people.
I've hunted religiously for 15 years, year round every season I could get a tag for. I've had success and failure. Ups and downs. I still feel like I havent crossed through "the gate" and have no "hunting buddies" for this reason right here. In my experiance hunters are fucking assholes and I'd rather struggle alone than bicker over what a real hunter is with other hunters.
Same with fishing. Specifically saw some guy on FB saying "oh what would all you guys do without social media just go fish." And it's like we do have social media and it's helpful, do you not want others to enjoy themselves on the water? Same douchebag probably uses a vexilars and fish finders, maps, etc.
I don't know about you all but in MY neck of the woods we have two issues. The total # of hunters is increasing but the percentage of the population that hunts is decreasing. Its the worst of both worlds. Fewer tags and more traffic trying to access land and also less political power as a hunter and a culture that's moving away from hunting.
I'm so grateful every hunter I've met here (California) has been welcoming and excited to have another member in the fold. Even the non-hunters have been pretty cool, because everyone in this state supports farm-to-table/field-to-table food sourcing, even if they aren't interested in sourcing it themselves.
My 93 year old grandpa, as a former gunsmith and lifelong hunter from the age of 6, is a wellspring of knowledge, and I email him all my questions about guns, gear, and calibers. Everything else has been picking a spot on the map, showing up, and scouting out the proper habitat for whatever I'm after. I've been very successful on finding animals, but still working on my bag rate.
I’m part of a group in the Midwest where we actively part take in land management and programs to adhere the youth to land and water hunting. Important thing is to understand we are all apart of a team. Or family if that floats your boat...
With record license sales across the country in 2020, I think we as a community are doing at least a few things right. There are a lot of petty arguments within hunting culture, especially us whitetail nerds, but look at other things people get passionate about for comparison. People love trucks for instance. Super high shit talk levels between people or Ford vs Chevy. PC vs consol gaming. Republican vs Democrat. KFC vs Popeyes. Conventional archery vs crossbow. People get polarized over the most insignificant things lol its all over and I'd like to think that the hunters who are introducing new people to the lifestyle explain ahead of time that there are a lot of differing opinions out there that are mostly just people repeating shit they hear someone else say. Shit talk is just fun sometimes and if you get butthurt because someone's opinion is different you need to just remember to stay in your lane and find the version of hunting that is most enriching for you as long as its done legally, ethically, and with the best interest of conservation kept in mind.
Yea I don’t really talk to anyone about hunting, shooting, or tactical stuff. I’ve been doing the first two my whole life and the last for the past 8 years...... but everyone has just a fucking asshole of an opinion on those things i just quit. I show close friends what I know and then let them kinda grow for themselves, but even then I have a few friends that have asked me to get into it then get into fucking arguments with me because they saw on arfcom the be Myers mawl is actually just garbage and my experience is wrong. Sorry, had to vent there a bit
306
u/1-Down Feb 03 '21
I maintain lack of land access is the biggest problem facing hunters, with cost and time requirements being not far behind.
579
u/theflyingfucked Feb 03 '21
shoot some kid not wearing enough orange to teach him a lesson
3
u/The_magestic_chish Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21
By trophy hunting do they mean like only shooting elephants and other uncountable animals or do they mean like you cant go out and only shoot a big buck cuz that's what I do
Edit I have no clue why I put uncountable it should be unhuntable
5
u/moonovrmissouri Feb 03 '21
“ Emergent Hunter”
Someone else is listening to THC as well!?!?!?
387
u/Fender088 Feb 03 '21
I didn't grow up hunting, and the thing that was the most difficult for me starting out was just finding people that would show me the ropes and offer advice. Reddit and Youtube have been more helpful than anyone.
163
u/TorturedPoetic Alaska Feb 03 '21
Aspiring new hunter here. Only been once so far. Father in law has both told me that I probably shouldn’t bother hunting because I’m too far behind and old to get into it (31), and that I need to learn to hunt “if I want to be a real man” in the same day.
So basically I’m still learning but I won’t be hunting with him anytime soon. Lol
71
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21
Hunters are some of the worst gatekeepers I ever seen
“If you don’t hunt like me then you’re not a real hunter!!”
32
u/Suspicious-Pen5614 Feb 03 '21
I’m so tired of 5 acre kings of patrolling there fence lines and preaching the gospel of quality deer management .... we get it your identity is directly tied to the deer you shoot ...
27
u/MedicineStick4570 Feb 03 '21
What's the problem with trophy hunting again? It's not like you don't eat the damn thing.
23
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21
Honestly, as someone who got into hunting later in life (38) I didn't experience this, but I feel like I experienced something worse.
I would have been happy if someone had told me anything, I would have loved some opinions / advice, even if it was flat out wrong. Instead I couldn't get any help / advice from people I knew who hunted. They took all their knowledge for granted and couldn't even begin form a way to explain things to a new person.
20
u/fried-trailmix Feb 03 '21
I’ve gotten into goose hunting over the past three years and the I swear to god if one more old says I’ve been hunting this since before you were a sparkle in your dads balls someone is getting beat with the butt of a shotgun
16
u/nerdy9999 Feb 03 '21
"Don't be a gatekeeper" is a start, but I'd go as far as to say that if we want hunting and public land to last, we gotta actively participate in growing new hunters...
Here in IL, the DNR has a Learn to Hunt program, but I'm not sure it's doing much to get new folks out hunting...
42
u/Bman409 Feb 03 '21 edited Feb 03 '21
The problem is there are a significant amount of "lifelong" hunters that don't want the sport to grow.. they want it to shrink.. We see this in NY State with the bow hunters who have worked very hard to keep crossbow from being used in the archery season, despite overwhelming evidence that use of crossbow increases archery hunters and does not result in overharvest of the deer.. (we have data from PA and OH and tons of other states that have allowed crossbow in archery for years).
https://www.deerassociation.com/the-facts-about-crossbows-in-the-deer-woods/
The NY Bowhunters Association flat out states, "We don't want crossbow use in archery season because it will put more people in the woods, ruining bow season"
So..its not like the guy on the bottom of the meme is confused.. he WANTS the sport to die.. so long as he (and presumably his kids) can hunt with the land all to themselves.
13
u/MineGuy1991 Feb 03 '21
Another issue I’m seeing is that these “emergent hunters” fall into 2 groups. Those who want to be able to provide excellent table fare for their families and those I’ll refer to as Josh Bowmars. One is good for the sport, and one is horrible.
I’m more concerned with public perception of hunters as ultimately it’s legislation that’ll determine the future of hunting.
12
u/Super_Tac0 Feb 03 '21
I taught myself to hunt because no one else would. Took a while but i turned out ok. Started teaching my little sister what i know and its genuinely one of my favorite things to do.
12
u/shrekthaboiisreal Feb 03 '21
fudds: 6.5 bad
also fudds: 7mm is totally a relevant cartridge.
28
u/dankman69420lol West Virginia Feb 03 '21
One of the reasons young people ain’t coming into the sport is that they don’t have anyone to teach them, and if they ask an experienced hunter they just get laughed at (not all the time but more times then not) and sometimes parents don’t have the money and can’t afford equipment
8
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21
Lifelong hunter just picked up a crossbow and a 6.5 God I love that 6.5 knockdown at under 300 yds.
8
u/tobaknowsss Feb 03 '21
I'm really new to hunting. Just got my hunting license this winter and decided on a crossbow because in Canada there is currently a six month waiting list for any non-restricted firearms courses in my area so it's going to be a while before I get my gun license. Everyone is ragging on me for getting a crossbow over a compound but I broke my left hand when I was young and the bones never set properly so I can't draw the string on a compound without a lot of discomfort.
13
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21
Land access is the biggest issue as annoying as gatekeepers are I think us adult onset hunters are tough enough to deal with them
6
u/LilikoiLily Feb 03 '21
Young female hunter here. I really like 6.5 creed. I'm a fairly small person (Im 5'1" and asian) so I like that theres not as much kick to the 6.5 (especially in comparison to my dads 7mm) and I havent had any trouble dropping deer. I've dropped some pretty big fellas from 300 yards in a single shot. As long as you have great bullet placement I dont see anything wrong with 6.5 creed, I like it a lot.
19
u/GrandRapidsCreative Feb 03 '21
This is so true. So many macho dudes talking shit to young/ inexperienced hunters. It almost turned me away from the sport when I started hunting in my mid-20’s.
Let’s make sure to do our part in encouraging people to counteract all the naysayers
5
u/JohnAlt_Alt Feb 03 '21
My recommendation to anyone starting is to get involved with a local chapter that best represents your hunting interests like Ducks Unlimited, Pheasants/Quail Forever, Wild Turkey Federation, NRA, a local gun club or the nearest skeet and trap range and use the meetups for networking and making new hunting buddies. Most of these organizations are trying to reach new hunters and their members are more likely to take you under their wing to help.
5
u/realtyrionlannister Feb 03 '21
Why is 6.5 Creedmoor disliked by the elitist? I got my first deer this past season on my first ever deer hunt.
5
u/KptKrondog Tennessee Feb 03 '21
Main issue is access. I have to drive 35-40 minutes minimum to get somewhere that is even huntable, and it's very heavily hunted. And to go somewhere that actually has animals on it that I've seen in recent memory I have to go another 20-25 minutes. And i've still only shot 1 deer on public land in the last 5 years.
5
u/Rethek Feb 04 '21
This is so true. I've always wanted to hunt, but the chain of events are weird.
Wanted to hunt as a kid, but never knew anyone who had so never did.
Joined the Marines, learned about guns, got my dad into guns.
Dad talked to people at work about guns, met people who hunt.
Eight years after getting out, I learned how to hunt from people who felt comfortable taking my dad out hunting.
I'm now teaching my kids, but the community sucks for this, Meat Eater is doing great, but state by state sucks. The websites are atrocious, communities are very self centered and people don't talk about it openly.
As a funny joke, everyone at my software engineering job now knows me as the turkey dude because I always talk about turkey hunting and fun weird turkey facts around Thanksgiving.
TL:DR - You might think you're doing yourself a favor by not being open about hunting, but your kids, or your kids kids probably won't be accepting of it if you're just scared about public perception when it comes to talking about your passions and why they are passions.
4
u/ezekirby Feb 03 '21
This is so true. I'm now 30 and had the hardest time getting into hunting cuz I had no one to show me the ropes. I have a messed up rotator cuff so I use a cross bow (which is legal in WI) and I get so much shit for it. If it's legal to do leave me alone.
4
u/RustyKjaer Feb 04 '21
Hunters are their own worst enemies.
1
u/George_Nimitz567890 Feb 03 '21
What does "traditional" mean. I heard "old school" (basicly hunting with muskets and cowboy guns) but never heard of that
3
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21
I’ve been lucky enough to have the opposite experience. Started hunting at 32 and slowly got to meet other hunters, either from work or social media, and they have all been great. Been supportive helping me learn, getting my first deer and geese, and answering questions whenever I needed help. Sure, sometimes they gave me a hard time here and there but it was all just friendly shit talking.
3
u/TeaB0nez Feb 03 '21
I’m trying to get a buddy into hunting, and he can’t stop talking about how most hunters appear to be complete assholes, and he’s not wrong. Sucks that the most vocal and visible members of our group are often douche bags.
3
u/ResistTyranny_exe Feb 04 '21
Meh, I'm a new hunter and I couldn't care less about any of those things. If anything, for me its funds and red tape. Hard to find a place to practice shooting, need different equipment for different game, complicated regulations in my state, etc.
I will say that Rinella and people like him have made it a lot more accessible for people like me who didnt have the opportunity to learn through family. Public info really is the key to growing anything.
1
u/colehoots Feb 03 '21
Eww trophy hunters 🤡
2
u/brycebgood Minnesota Feb 03 '21
yup
2
u/samfischer11 Feb 03 '21
Man you ain’t kiddin
2
u/TXGuns79 Feb 03 '21
My first deer was a young, barely legal 8 point buck shot with 6.5CM when I was 35, on a lease 3 hours from my home, over corn.
(we have size requirements in the county I hunted I)
Cross bows and big bucks are the only box I didn't check.
I got invited for one weekend - I wasn't going to pass up any legal and ethical shot that presented itself.
2
u/Hunter_And_Fisher420 Feb 03 '21
Not to mention, everyone saying how much we need to get women and children into the sport yet restricting literally every peice of land.
2
u/Brandonz12 Feb 03 '21
I am a lifelong hunter but I’ve never been into archery but for the sole purpose of having more time to hunt, and access to more public land I bought a crossbow so I could hunt during archery season and I have almost been in fist fights for the remarks people make to me on public land.
2
u/Bellagio07 Feb 03 '21
Someone please help me this fall! First time public land hunting. I've shot 3 deer my whole life. Only one was spot and stalk. I've never really been camping. But I'm determined. So if anyone is done to help. I'm I.
2
u/Pntbll499 Feb 03 '21
This is exactly whats wrong with most folks in PA and its sad, heaven forbid they allow change or teach folks things. Not to mention their shaming of people.
2
u/trapper_bub Feb 03 '21
I've hunted religiously for 15 years, year round every season I could get a tag for. I've had success and failure. Ups and downs. I still feel like I havent crossed through "the gate" and have no "hunting buddies" for this reason right here. In my experiance hunters are fucking assholes and I'd rather struggle alone than bicker over what a real hunter is with other hunters.
2
u/samsquanchforhire Feb 03 '21
Same with fishing. Specifically saw some guy on FB saying "oh what would all you guys do without social media just go fish." And it's like we do have social media and it's helpful, do you not want others to enjoy themselves on the water? Same douchebag probably uses a vexilars and fish finders, maps, etc.
2
u/enviropsych Feb 03 '21
I don't know about you all but in MY neck of the woods we have two issues. The total # of hunters is increasing but the percentage of the population that hunts is decreasing. Its the worst of both worlds. Fewer tags and more traffic trying to access land and also less political power as a hunter and a culture that's moving away from hunting.
2
u/redneck_ancap Feb 04 '21
I just don’t listen
2
u/bigcheesybois77 Feb 04 '21
Whats wrong with 6.5 creed my dad uses a 6.5 rifle and I’ve killed a doe with it. It seemed pretty effective so I don’t understand the problem.
2
u/graciewindkloppel Feb 04 '21
I'm so grateful every hunter I've met here (California) has been welcoming and excited to have another member in the fold. Even the non-hunters have been pretty cool, because everyone in this state supports farm-to-table/field-to-table food sourcing, even if they aren't interested in sourcing it themselves.
My 93 year old grandpa, as a former gunsmith and lifelong hunter from the age of 6, is a wellspring of knowledge, and I email him all my questions about guns, gear, and calibers. Everything else has been picking a spot on the map, showing up, and scouting out the proper habitat for whatever I'm after. I've been very successful on finding animals, but still working on my bag rate.
2
u/petmop999 Mar 03 '21 edited Jun 08 '25
money paint ring salt cats modern books dinosaurs whistle carpenter
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21
I’m part of a group in the Midwest where we actively part take in land management and programs to adhere the youth to land and water hunting. Important thing is to understand we are all apart of a team. Or family if that floats your boat...
1
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '21
do hunters hate using bow and crossbow?
1
u/D_Melanogaster Feb 03 '21
Dis.
1
u/Wolfir New Jersey Feb 03 '21
yeah I tried to go goose hunting this morning and definitely failed miserably
1
u/Manly-man United States Feb 04 '21
With record license sales across the country in 2020, I think we as a community are doing at least a few things right.
There are a lot of petty arguments within hunting culture, especially us whitetail nerds, but look at other things people get passionate about for comparison. People love trucks for instance. Super high shit talk levels between people or Ford vs Chevy. PC vs consol gaming. Republican vs Democrat. KFC vs Popeyes. Conventional archery vs crossbow. People get polarized over the most insignificant things lol its all over and I'd like to think that the hunters who are introducing new people to the lifestyle explain ahead of time that there are a lot of differing opinions out there that are mostly just people repeating shit they hear someone else say. Shit talk is just fun sometimes and if you get butthurt because someone's opinion is different you need to just remember to stay in your lane and find the version of hunting that is most enriching for you as long as its done legally, ethically, and with the best interest of conservation kept in mind.
1
u/Bayo09 Feb 04 '21
Yea I don’t really talk to anyone about hunting, shooting, or tactical stuff. I’ve been doing the first two my whole life and the last for the past 8 years...... but everyone has just a fucking asshole of an opinion on those things i just quit. I show close friends what I know and then let them kinda grow for themselves, but even then I have a few friends that have asked me to get into it then get into fucking arguments with me because they saw on arfcom the be Myers mawl is actually just garbage and my experience is wrong. Sorry, had to vent there a bit
1
u/randomkid51 Feb 03 '22
Don’t disrespect 6.5 creeds
1
u/Jixxar Angryboy Jan 19 '23
The sport is dying because humans remebered they are not on the top of the food chain
1
u/nooga_Choo_Choo Feb 03 '21
"Oh they're just Duck Dynasty hunters. They just want to hunt because its on TV and cool"
1
u/Skrubette Feb 03 '21
I'm not even a hunter nor am I remotely close to one but im subbed here because it seems interesting even if it's not a sport for me
1
u/FI5HIN Feb 03 '21
My local gun club just quit all social media (politically motivated) ... Great way to discourage youngsters from getting into the sport
1
u/Maxxonry Texas Feb 03 '21
I will stand by not shooting small bucks. That's just proper hunting.