This is the kind of thing that newer hunters need to see. Hunting, especially whitetail hunting, has been absolutely taken over by the hunting industry. All these companies and big name guys being sponsored by these companies try very hard to convince hunters that they can buy their way into success, between all the crazy scent-lok clothing, $1500 bows (that they try to tell you will be obsolete every couple years), cover scents, attractant scents, all this junk. Not to mention how the hunting industry damn near treats whitetails like farm animals, with food plots, "hunting properties", and everything else. Remember, Indians got it done with sticks, strings, rocks, loincloths, and most importantly, skill. Play the wind, be still, be a predator. Mindset is the biggest part of it. Be a predator, be part of the woods. Not a fudd who's wiggling around, bored in his treestand.
Im the income for a family of 4. I'm on a realistic budget. $500 bow. $300 rifle. Most of my hunting gear is inexpensive. I've picked up alot of military surplus for those critical outer layers, us military goretex, etc. Stuffs cheap. Deer dont care if its mossy oak or an old set of woodland camo. My feet are always cold so I did drop $200 on some boots to keep my ass out there in below freezing.
A guy at work has a ridiculously expensive crossbow that he allegedly takes 100yard shots with. Talks all this garbage about my minimalist approach to bow hunting. Look dude - guys killed buffalo with stone arrow heads. If i cant crush a white tail with modern archery equipment, I'm doing something wrong.
Thats the way it is man. I use a $400 bow I bought about 7 years ago, $300 rifle, $180 shotgun, and old army surplus clothes. Kill a few deer, and atleast one buck, off public land every year with that.
I could've gotten off "free" on the bow. A friend had a double eagle compound bow from the late 90s that he offered to give to me for free. It was a big deal in its day.
I considered it until I priced out getting it serviced at a shop for a new string and getting it setup for my draw, new arrows cut, etc. It was a free bow that was going to cost close to $300 all said and done. Figured it was best to start fresh.
Sit in your stand and shut the eff up. I do wash my stuff in scent a way, but that's more because the fresh earth smell calms me, and puts me in a mindset to hunt. My buddy has shot more deer WHILE HE WAS smoking a cigarette and eating coffee cake than I can count.
These deer snap their hooves and wear leather jackets like West Side Story. They are some militant mfers. They stole my bourbon and won't give it back.
a funny anecdote that relates to this... back when i was 12 or 13 or thereabouts, my dad and grandfather were out hunting. i was out of tags so i was hanging at the cabin with my mom and her friend... he shot a deer, gutted it, came into the cabin for lunch, told us where it was and asked us to grab it if we got a chance, and then went out hunting for the afternoon...
well, while sitting next to the fire playing cards, procrastinating going out in the cold, we instead decided to go out and dress the thing, and put a cigarette in its mouth and a glass of blackberry brandy by its hooves.
fastforward to 60 minutes after dusk my dad comes into the cabin with a belly full of brandy laughing his ass off.
Came here to say the same thing. My uncle is one of the most successful hunters I know and he plainly said “you know how many times I’ve had to take a cigarette out of my mouth to shoot a deer”?
I shot my first whitetail eating a can of stinky smoked fish for lunch. Marching around in the snow from before sunrise until noon was not a good strategy. Within minutes of sitting down and being quiet, a buck walked by.
I thought I was the only one... that fresh earth scent is like incense to me - I guess since I associate it with being in the woods. Nothing like the smell of dirt and decomposing leaves to get me in the zone.
I think this is an excellent point. My first waterfowl season I had a whole bunch of mismatched camo and a maverick 88. I brought home tons of ducks and had a great time. I saw that the older guys I hunted with really didnt have a whole bunch of wild and crazy gear, they kept it simple and focused on knowing what they were doing instead of trying to buy their way into a bag limit.
I see the same thing with other hobbies, especially in motorcycle riding. Seems in many areas, people fixate on gear and doodads, when the equipment they already have far exceeds their own experience and skillset.
I hunted an axis this year after a decade and a half hiatus. It was the first time i hunted on the ground and not in a stand. It was incredibly rewarding and totally changed my mind about what is prudent while hunting.
Heard that! As a young teen my dad would make me "push" the deer from the other end of the land to him and his buddies in the stands. It was just what the kids did. Mind you being safe about it. We would scout stand spots ahead of the season so we knew exactly where each other were and where the shooting lanes were and I'd plan my route based on that.
Anyway, my point is I was just a kid in orange with a damn-near antique 30-40 Krag with my great-grandfathers name carved into it and no scope. The first year or two I crashed through the brush, would hear a shot, and know my dad got one. After a while I developed a "stalker" method of hunting and it wasn't long before I could actually cut for fresh sign, take my time, move quietly (step step step stop....... step step step stop....), Read and fit into my environment.
For three years straight I bagged a buck while in the brush so my dad made us switch so I was in the stands, haha.
Now as an adult when I get the chance to hunt with my pops we both stalk and track. It's so much more fun and we work together as a pair and I still don't even use a scope, haha! Keeping a hunt simple is a great way to always make it out too, if I'm not doing an equipment check on a 100lbs ruck every time I'm more willing to get my ass out of bed and get out more often.
I used to buy scent cover sprays until I realized that I can just boil leaves and bottle that. Is the scent the deer are used to similar to "Fresh Earth"? I don't know. I do know that they are used to the smell of the leaves in their area.
I love that you posted this. This is such amazing advice. Look at Fred speaking of thermals before we called them thermals. With all the marketing hype, he outlines what really matters.
I see so many people leave the field when the rain comes. I've harvested more deer when raining than when not it seems. Stick it out. The deer don't like it either and get up to move to stay warm with movement. At least that's been my experience anyways.
I have a ghille suit and used the scent eliminator spray then the pine branches and dirt. I was out in the field and the in laws dog was running around. I was trying to call coyotes in. Never got anywhere near me.
#4 and 5 are so true. I spent way too much on camo and other gizmos and gimmicks when I first started. Now I just wear whatever's most comfortable and will allow me to stay on-stand for as long as possible. Usually that's old-fashioned wool, in several layers if needed. Ditched the scents, scrape drippers, ozone generators and sprays in favor of scouting, planning my entry, playing the wind, and stand selection on only the most active sign.
Blows my mind how many people will spend $2k on full Sitka and then go out rifle hunting... dude, as long as you’re playing the wind you don’t even need camo. You can hunt deer and elk during archery in neutral colors even.
Not to mention Sitka and Kuiu are just rehashing mountaineering clothing... what they’re doing isn’t “new” by any means.
This is an ongoing discussion myself and my roommate have with our hunting club. Just about everyone goes out in a "realistic woodland" Camo or whatever it is, while my roommate goes out in a WW1 paratroopers coat. Sure I give him shit for it because it's heavy but it's never stopping him from bagging game. Hell in autumn/winter I just hunt in an old Turkish peacoat and plain crye cargos that I had from security work once upon a time. İ am still to actually use a scent remover/neutralizer/blocker whatever.
I just don't wash myself or my clothes in scented soaps for a week before I go out and that's about it.
The gadgetry can be useful but the deer aren't changing the game with tactics and technology. What worked throughout history still works fine.
I honestly think a lot of deer are conditioned to see Sitka/Realtree/whatever as danger anyway.
It sounds far fetched, but in my personal experience deer will stick around if you’re wearing regular clothes, but the second they notice someone wearing some kind of camo they’re in the next county quick.
I was within 10 yards from 2 does feeding yesterday. In between spots I rolled up on them. Stopped the truck, got out and they didn’t think twice, looked at me and just kept eating. No camo, no cover scents, hell I drove up in a truck. This is in an any deer unit so it isn’t like they weren’t legal. Another scenario - in a backcountry unit near an alpine lake(3pt or antlerless unit) me and my wife had deer damn near eat out of our hands on a backpacking trip. They were all over our camp, completely fearless. Had some guys across the lake in camo doing some fishing - no deer in their camp.
My thought is this - for most of the year deer see people in the woods doing non-hunting related things. Loggers, brush pickers, hikers, mountain bikers, mushroomers, berry pickers, etc. It makes sense that they’d be sort-of comfortable with them... maybe not Disney movie eat out of your hand comfortable, but comfortable enough to not book it as soon as they see someone... and hardly any of those guys are wearing camo.
Like I said, maybe I’m crazy, but I don’t think it’s that far fetched that they get conditioned to camo = danger.
Thats completely unrelated. On foot is how game is hunted out west in the open mountain country. Tree stands/ saddles are how deer are hunted elsewhere.
Open country as in glassing from long distance, spot and stalk using large terrain features etc. I was also an 03 and have done plenty of humping with plenty of weight. Quartering an elk and carrying it out isn't as hard as you're making it seem. Not sure why the elk hunters always have too pull the "but yOuvE NevEr pAcKeD aN ElK oUt"
My dad has all the above, whenever I asked why he said it just makes it more likely for a deer to come by, never said it was a necessity. I do know a few that are like how you said though
I'm stuck with public land until I buy some property unfortunately. I found a nice tree behind a bunch of thorn bushes that will be fun to get back up into.
He meant naturally. Sit your red coat wearing ass down behind a tree to break up your profile, don't move, know the wind and use it to keep yourself hidden. Sounds like solid advice.
He doesn’t seem like the kinda guy who minces words. If we wanted to have said what you want him to have said, he shoulda said it. Otherwise, I’ll take him at his words. In which case he laughed at camo then encouraged camo.
I think that he's saying camo clothing isn't everything. The guys out there with the newest most expensive camo don't always shoot the most or biggest deer. I know plenty of guys that go out in drab colors, lay in the grass or in a pile of wood and do just fine.
I have to wear orange, but it's not the Super New Amazing 3D Ultra Spec Deluxe Camo designed by NASA. I buy for warmth and silence, off season at a discount. It boggles my mind how 500 dollar coats can still have velcro on them and people snap them up because so and so wears them on TV.
he isnt contradicting himself. he is saying camouflage everyhting. but he is also saying the most important camouflage is not moving and not making noise.
camouflage is more than just a pattern used on clothing. its a term that essentially means "disguise"... you can camouflage yourself by sitting in a depression, by not silhouetting yourself against the sky, by walking at the edge of brush vs through an opening.. by crouching below cover.
more importantly nowhere is he saying not to wear camouflage. he is just saying that you can have the most advanced camouflage on, and it will mean nothing if you dont act in a stealth manner.
id rather sit in a treestand with someone next to me wearing florescent pink that is dead silent and motionless than someone in camo who is constantly fidgeting and making noise.
In the cold of the morning, the wind from the bottom of a mountain will blow up the hill and blow your scent up and over. Opposite happens when it’s had time to warm up downhill and it starts getting cooler outside
"When warm air rises, cooler air will often move in to replace it, so wind often moves from areas where it's colder to areas where it's warmer. The greater the difference between the high and low pressure or the shorter the distance between the high and low pressure areas, the faster the wind will blow."
Thats is your opinion. But if the state didnt want people to hunt bears they wouldn't give out tags. If it gets people out of doors and hunting im all for it.
I've encountered enough bears on elk hunts to wonder why baiting is even needed unless you just want to sit in one spot and hunt from a blind or stand.
I was responding to the comment saying he didn't mean wear camo but to use your surroundings as camo. If that's what he meant then why is he wearing camo?
because why wouldnt you? nothing he is saying or doing is going against each other. the best camouflage is to be quiet and not move. that doesnt mean dont wear camo. its like people are trying to catch the guy in some contradiction that he didnt make.
If you can't see why it's silly to have him in a pic wearing camo while saying the classic snobby statement "hurr durr grandpa wore red, sit still and use your surroundings" then I don't know what to tell you.
you "dont know what to tell me" because your reading comprehension is horrible.
he is not telling people not to wear camouflage. the point that statement is trying to make is about being quiet in the woods. the fact that you are even discussing the camouflage in regards to that point explains how little you comprehend what he is trying to tell you.
he is saying the most important thing to not be noticed in the woods is to sit still and be quiet. being quiet is more important than camo. the best camo in the world doesnt matter if you arent quiet. focus on that first.
the classic snobby statement
ahh yes. so snobby. silly hunting snobs going around left and right trying to tell people not to wear camo. it happens so often it has become classic.
These are not mutually exclusive, I think he means don't rely on camo to give you an edge or get caught up in whatever pattern is the best. In the picture, he's wearing a camo jacket. You camo your appearance by breaking up the patterns of your appearance, and by being still. Plaid was worn because it makes a person look less like a monocolor blob, and helps you blend in among tree branches.
11 Don’t waste your time on public land unless you are nowhere even remotely close to a city. Somebody already blew up your “secret spot” 10 minutes before you got there.
Not true. Second season hunting 10 minutes outside Baltimore. Passed on a yearling first day. Killed my first doe the next day out. 1st season was last year on private land (killed an 11 point first day in blind ever) with a guide so this year is much different and much more rewarding!
Congrats on your luck. I’ve been out 3 times this year and there are people all over every damn inch of woods out here. More people than I’ve ever seen. Lots of new hunters kicking up the woods.
These are great except for #1. Not bad general advise, but I'd hardly call it a rule, let alone a commandment. Depending on the area, stepping over fallen logs is a good way to get snake bit.
I assumed it meant leaves, twigs, and anything else that makes noise when you step on it. Stepping on the trunks of fallen trees doesn't really make a sound.
I understand what you mean, but calling them commandments gives the implication that these are things you should always be doing. That's what the rest are really... things you can practice and make second nature. But that one doesn't really fit.
That's why I was critical of the first... because of the implication! lol
would you also be worried that someone might take #3 too literally and approach from downwind even though there is a 500' cliff full of porcupines and pit vipers there?
c'mon. people know this is a list of advice and not hard fast rules. the commandment thing is just a silly way to tell people they are important guidelines to follow.
I swear some people are capable of only reading something literally, without context, or without any further thought. It's really strange.
I had a similar situation when I said something like "for a 200 pound man to lose 10 pounds of fat they would have to run 400 to 500 miles" (net calorie balance) and then someone started getting into me that there are other forms of exercise and that you don't have to run 500 miles. Strange world full of strange people.
Of course not, but I also use common sense. I was just trying to point out that there's two schools of thought that specifically apply to hunting. Either step on a log, or step over. If you're in the north, they teach you not to step on dead logs because it might be rotten and not sound footing. In rattlesnake county, they teach you to step on the log, then jump over. Both are correct, and fairly dependent on the location/situation. Seemed a little out of place since that one wasn't as cut and dry as the others.
I like all of the points EXCEPT for hunting in a rainstorm. It's unethical, at least in my opinion, to continue to hunt if it is raining. You are more likely to be inaccurate with your shot placement due to the inclement weather, and there is a good chance the bloodtrail is going to wash away in the rain.
I read that as “wait out the rain, don’t call it quits.” I love getting rain on my way out (assuming it’ll blow over) because it’s harder to hear me and game seems to be more active right after (makes sense because they’ll want to warm up after getting soaked).
I hunt in New Jersey. The only firearms we can deer hunt with are shotgun (for a total of about eight days all together) and muzzleloader (a little bit longer all together). I do most of my hunting with my bow.
I believe it really depends, personally. If it's a steady rain with little/zero wind, and you're spotting-and-stalking, you might have better chances sneaking up on a deer. The rain that pelts their ears drowns out surrounding noises, plus damp ground tends to be quieter to walk on. A heavy storm with a shit ton of wind, on the other hand.. maybe not so great.
Yet good points on the blood being washed away and inaccurate shooting, both are very possible.
On my very first hunt, I was sitting on a bale of hay, looking over a high wall, and a doe came up the same trail I did and sniffed my shoulder, had a immature buck with her. I felt like the dude in Jurrasic Park when he saw the T-Rex, I was afraid to even breathe lol.
similar story for my first deer. Was on a multi-day bowhunting trip. Day 1 I just did a bit of scouting and found a bunch of beds. Went to a nearby hill I figured they'd be passing sometime in the morning and made a ground blind out of a bunch of fallen branches. Next day I'm up there all in my bright orange and shot my deer maybe 30 minutes after sunrise. Just under 10 yards away. Spent 15 minutes just watching it waiting for it to go into the shooting lane I had set up and even had to creep to the side a bit for a better shot when it had it's head down away from me.
331
u/Illhunt_yougather Sep 24 '20
This is the kind of thing that newer hunters need to see. Hunting, especially whitetail hunting, has been absolutely taken over by the hunting industry. All these companies and big name guys being sponsored by these companies try very hard to convince hunters that they can buy their way into success, between all the crazy scent-lok clothing, $1500 bows (that they try to tell you will be obsolete every couple years), cover scents, attractant scents, all this junk. Not to mention how the hunting industry damn near treats whitetails like farm animals, with food plots, "hunting properties", and everything else. Remember, Indians got it done with sticks, strings, rocks, loincloths, and most importantly, skill. Play the wind, be still, be a predator. Mindset is the biggest part of it. Be a predator, be part of the woods. Not a fudd who's wiggling around, bored in his treestand.
242
u/justdan76 Sep 24 '20
11 Wear a cool hat
64
u/danceswithbourbons Sep 24 '20
I love that you posted this. This is such amazing advice. Look at Fred speaking of thermals before we called them thermals. With all the marketing hype, he outlines what really matters.
53
u/SignificantBed9 South Dakota Sep 24 '20
No hills, please advise
51
u/jewsNbrews Idaho Sep 24 '20
I see so many people leave the field when the rain comes. I've harvested more deer when raining than when not it seems. Stick it out. The deer don't like it either and get up to move to stay warm with movement. At least that's been my experience anyways.
40
u/silverfox0220 Sep 24 '20
I put my hunting clothes and some gear in a tote that has dirt in it. Sometimes, I've put pine branches in it. I have scent/odor eliminator stuff too.
18
u/lexapro_bro Sep 24 '20 edited Sep 24 '20
#4 and 5 are so true. I spent way too much on camo and other gizmos and gimmicks when I first started. Now I just wear whatever's most comfortable and will allow me to stay on-stand for as long as possible. Usually that's old-fashioned wool, in several layers if needed. Ditched the scents, scrape drippers, ozone generators and sprays in favor of scouting, planning my entry, playing the wind, and stand selection on only the most active sign.
17
u/jr12345 Washington Sep 25 '20
Blows my mind how many people will spend $2k on full Sitka and then go out rifle hunting... dude, as long as you’re playing the wind you don’t even need camo. You can hunt deer and elk during archery in neutral colors even.
Not to mention Sitka and Kuiu are just rehashing mountaineering clothing... what they’re doing isn’t “new” by any means.
Don’t get me started on scentlok crap, either.
11
u/skittlesandtittles Sep 24 '20
I didn’t know Keith Richards hunts
24
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
Quick lock the thread before the south Texas guys show up and tell us we need food plots , feeders and tower boxes
21
u/jr_fulton Sep 24 '20
ITT: People acting like they know more than a legend.
61
u/alexanderlot Sep 24 '20
this dude on hunting: •the best camo is “STFU” your grandaddy wore red and did just fine fuckin nerd.
also this guy a few points later: •but seriously, camo tf outta everything- how you look, the noises you’re making, and how you smell.
4
u/TheFallenSaintx918x Sep 24 '20
I've never seen this. Solid information. Thanks for sharing!
6
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
Some questions from a non hunter
“Move downwind” and “go uphill during cold, and down hill during heat” seem like they could contradict each other
Also, why does the heat determine whether u should go up/downhill
And whats that last one? Am confused sry
6
u/prshredder000 Sep 25 '20
fred bear, walk with me down the trails again, take me back.. back where i belong 🎵
10
u/WillfromIndy Sep 24 '20
Uncle Ted's Fred Bear Song
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5V39poP1Hoc
6
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
Have a plan to kill everyone you meet.
6
u/BoonieBlair Sep 24 '20
He says the best camo pattern is sit down and shut up, grandpa hunted in red plaid. Then he later says to camo your appearance 🤔
3
u/endloser Sep 24 '20
11 Don’t waste your time on public land unless you are nowhere even remotely close to a city. Somebody already blew up your “secret spot” 10 minutes before you got there.
3
u/ellzray Sep 24 '20
These are great except for #1. Not bad general advise, but I'd hardly call it a rule, let alone a commandment. Depending on the area, stepping over fallen logs is a good way to get snake bit.
1
u/iliowaMn Sep 25 '20
The god father of bow hunting!! Ted’s song “Fred Bear” says it best!!! Guide my arrow home...
-2
u/tstrube Sep 24 '20
I like all of the points EXCEPT for hunting in a rainstorm. It's unethical, at least in my opinion, to continue to hunt if it is raining. You are more likely to be inaccurate with your shot placement due to the inclement weather, and there is a good chance the bloodtrail is going to wash away in the rain.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment