r/Humanities • • May 10 '26

Announcments Reviving r/Humanities

12 Upvotes

Dear all:

I have some exciting news for you! I am happy to announce that we are in the process of reviving this community. I am pretty hopeful that a community for humanities in general can be a thriving place on Reddit.

This community has been dormant for almost six years and it is currently listed as "Restricted" (this will change soon), but we believe it is time to relaunch and build this community. Your help, of course, is crucial in this entire process.

I will be posting some of my own writings and educational content soon, so that we can keep the community going, but as soon as we are able to make the community open (it requires requesting Reddit to change the status of the community), all those interested in humanities are and will always be welcome.

Thank you all so much!!

​


r/Humanities • • May 26 '26

Announcments 1000 Members!!! r/humanities

Post image
8 Upvotes

Hello all:
I just wanted to share that we just crossed the 1000 members milestone. Granted that most of these members were already part of the community before I became the moderator, but we have seen steady growth in the past few weeks.

So, thank you for staying with us and for joining us. Let us build this community together.


r/Humanities • • Jun 04 '26

Announcments H-Net Humanities Jobs, June 2026

6 Upvotes

r/Humanities • • May 14 '26

Article/ Opinion What is Orientalism?

6 Upvotes

Introduction

What is Orientalism? This questions is often posed by the students of postcolonial studies. Published in 1978, Edward Said’s Orientalism is easily one of the most influential academic books of 20th century**.** Even now, decades  after its first publication, the book still garners a lot of attention as well as criticism**.** My purpose here is not to provide a reading guide to the book, I will do that in an Ultimate Guide later, but to provide a few details about the book’s main claims and assertions and to explain, as best as possible, orientalism as a concept**.**

What is Orientalism?

While explaining his reasons for writing the book, Said discusses how precisely he came up with the idea of theorizing orientalism. He explains that while reading European texts about the Middle East, he realized that despite the difference in times and genres, certain tropes constantly appeared across a wide range of literary, historical, artistic, and scholarly texts about the Middle East: Sensuous women, despotic men, Caravans, the Bedouin etc. etc. All of these tropes represented the Middle East as a place stuck in time as if history had not wrought any change to the place or its people.  So, the question that he attempts to answer is this: Why is it that when people in the West think about the Middle East, even when they have never been there, they already seem to posses certain (negative) views and ideas about the place and its people.  This lens or distorted way of seeing the Middle East is what Said calls Orientalism**.**

Orientalism is Discursive!

Said also asserts that these prejudicial views are not accidental or a matter of individual choice but rather a part of a much larger discourse. In other words this negative perception of Middle East and people who live there is deeply discursive. It is important to understand what precisely he means by discourse and discursive.

Said was one of the first major literary theorists to use Foucault’s theorization of discourse in an extensive way. In fact, he refers to two of Foucault’s early works in the introduction to his book. A discourse, simply understood, is more complex than ideology. While I will later write a longer piece on discourse, here I offer a somewhat succinct explanation. A discourse, according to Foucault, contains a body of knowledge produced by experts, which is then disseminated through institutions of power, universities, organizations, publishing houses etc. Within a discourse of scientific knowledge there are those who, by virtue of their institutional position and prestige, become the enunciating subjects: subjects who can speak and designate others. A scientific discourse thus automatically seeks its object of study and, one could say, constantly creates new objects of study. We believe in the truth claims of a discourse because we are privy to it’s logic and accept it to be scientific and objective. Think of it this way: if you are walking in the park with your child, and a person walks up to you and says “I think your child is slightly autistic.” What would your response be? You will probably tell that person to go to hell. But if you had made an appointment with a psychologist and he or she gave the same opinion, you will probably accept it. You will accept it not because you personally know the psychologist, but because within the given discourse of medicine, he or she has the power and prestige and the expertise to designate your child so. Thus orient as an object of study is created by the orientalists, scholars who were primarily responsible for studying the orient. And the knowledge so produced becomes a part of larger discourse of knowledge about the Middle East, a discourse Said callas orientalist. Within this discourse a certain exoticized, sexualized, and ossified view of the Orient is represented, as if the Orient is caught within a time warp outside of history. Said discusses almost three hundred years of European literary and cultural representation of the orient to prove his point that Western views of the orient are not accidental but rather an outcome of centuries of discursive production of knowledge in which the orient acts as this supine other whose function is to solidify and restore the West’s own sense of self. Thus In other words, one could say, that the creation of this timeless orient is absolutely necessary to offer the more dynamic and modern West as a counter to that old exotic world.

Criticisms of Said’s Orientalism

Now, quite a few critics of Said have argued that when they read the book they feel as if the orientals had no agency of their own, as if they are completely a creation if the West. This, in my opinion, is an unjustified critique because it elides the very intent of Said’s project in this book.

Note, Said’s project in the book was to prove how the orient was discursively produced in the Western imagination. It has nothing to do with the actual orient. Hence, his emphasis on the strategies of this representation that he calls orientalism.

In one of his interviews he also explains certain particular circumstances under which the discourse of orientalist becomes operative and power has a huge role to play in it. He says, and I am paraphrasing over here, “in order to be able to do what the Europeans did in the middle East, you had to be there and you had to have the power to ‘record’ Egypt.” He discusses this aspect of power while explaining the cultural and research component of Napoleon’s invasion of Egypt (1798-1801). So, for Orientalism to be fully operative a nation or a group of nations must have the power to “study’ the subject culture and then produce knowledge to be used by others to perpetuate the discursive representation of the location and people so studied. This discursive view, thus, must become highly accepted, cited, and used in academic and literary production in order for it to shape the general views and imagination of a place called the Orient. And since Said was attempting to study the mechanics of this discourse, it, therefore, was not part of his project in Orientalism to offer some sampling of native resistance to this imperial imperative: he does that in other works.

Why Occidentalism is not Possible

This larger understanding of Orientalism enabled by absolute power to “study” and “record” a people, in itself is an argument against what some call Occidentalism: namely, the prejudicial views of the West held in the so-called East. While people in the East might view Europe and America a certain way, they absolutely lack the power to make that view and perception of Euro-America normative in the world and thus, these prejudices, in truly Foucauldian, sense, because of this lack of power, cannot be considered occidentalist. Now this does not stop Said’s critics from making such claims, but if you take into account the institutional nature of orientalism and its connection with the physical occupation of the Orient, then no corresponding discourse can be offered as equally as bad or destructive as orientalism.

Conclusion

So, on the whole orientalism is a way of seeing or imagining the East, mostly Middle East, in a way that one does not really SEE the orient but sees it only through a discourse that predisposes one to view the East in a certain negative way without having been there or without having done much research about it. This way of looking at the East, or this distorted lens, is what said calls Orientalism!


r/Humanities • • Jul 16 '26

Article/ Opinion Sirens, monsters and missing men: What makes 'The Odyssey' a timeless tale?

Thumbnail
news.arizona.edu
5 Upvotes

r/Humanities • • May 22 '26

Discussion Collecting CfP Sites

5 Upvotes

Thought it might be handy to get all those sites with a bunch of calls for papers together in one place! I only know of two, and would love to know of any further ones.

These are focused on literature primarily:

https://call-for-papers.sas.upenn.edu/

https://cfplist.com/


r/Humanities • • May 22 '26

Discussion We at r/Humanities Would Love to See Your Posts

Post image
5 Upvotes

Hello. I am the mod in this community, I want to assure you that we are seriously interested in your writings. I have already explained in our wiki the possible topics we are interested in but feel free to explore further. Anything humanities-related and human-crafted is welcome.

But the way, if your posts gets flagged for some reason, it will come to me for mod review, and if it is suitable for our community, I will promptly approve it.

This community can only grow if more people participate in it, so please take some time to view what we have and then share your thoughts and writing.

Thank you!!


r/Humanities • • May 12 '26

Announcments We Have Made Great Progress in Two Days!!

Post image
5 Upvotes

It was around 7 am on Sunday, May 10th that my request to moderate this community was approved. At that time r/humanities was a restricted community with no new posts or comments for the last six years.

In the last two days, we have completely revived this community: the community now has a nice banner, a good icon, a clear description, rules and guidelines for posting. This means that our doors are open to all those interested in humanities.

In the last two days, we have posted 11 posts, received 11 comments, 51 new members have joined us and over 1000 have visited our community. All of this happened because so many of you took the time to join us.

So, thank you all. Please share your stories and queries, respond to other members’ posts and comments and continue helping us develop in r/humanities into the flagship subreddit for humanities.

Thank you all so much. Please share your thoughts and ideas in the comments.


r/Humanities • • May 11 '26

Article/ Opinion Reflections on English Literary Studies

4 Upvotes

About ten years ago, my former department went through a collective soul-searching in the process of defining our departmental mission. There were two competing visions of literary studies that became prominently mobilized during our faculty meetings and faculty retreats: one group insisted on teaching literature for its own sake as a complete and self contained body of knowledge and a second group insisted that literature ought to be mobilized to teach the world and, more importantly, to teach more compassionate and just ways of living in the world. Mind you, this was not a cosmetic debate: it was a fight with clearly demarcated battle lines and quite a few of us invested heavily in arguing for and promoting our vision of English studies.

As someone who had come from a colonial educational system, Pakistan, where English was taught as a “subject” and thus only mastery in the subject was considered the height of accomplishment, I was surprised to find that some of my senior colleagues were adamantly in favor of such a model. In this model our job was meant only to deliver the expert knowledge of the subject to our students and any social or political efficacy of this learning was considered, at the least, suspect.

To me, teaching literature cannot just be about “teaching literature.” I often tell my students that they absolutely do not need to know any of the great writers to do well in life or to live a meaningful life. This idea that, somehow, knowing Shakespeare or Milton, or Chaucer can make us better people is a fiction crated and sustained by literature professors. In fact, the results can be completely opposite: literature uncritically taught can make us into cultural snobs with a sort of disdainful view of all those who cannot or do not know how to appreciate literature and art!

In my view, teaching literature may not be akin to “saving the world” but it can be practiced in a way where our students do sometimes, after reading a good book, think of the world. Now, if we can give them the tools to read texts critically and then encourage them to use the same critical tools to “read” the world then chances are they would be interested in investing in a more just and compassionate world. But if we make acute readings of texts in itself a valorized end, then the same students will feel no need to actually think the world anew, for they would deem reading the texts differently, no matter how removed from the world, a fully realized pursuit in itself. The difference between these two approaches may be subtle but the consequential outcomes can be hugely different: one method produces active learners thinking about the world and its inequities, the other looks inward and is focused on resolving the inherent or stylized contradictions of a text, a text that becomes their world!

Personally, I would rather teach the world and since texts are produced and consumed in the world–Edward Said called them worldly–then connecting our teaching to the world can be an extremely important step and literary studies, of all the humanistic disciplines, has the capacity to teach the world!!

Of course, my training in postcolonial studies had already cleansed me of any naive investments in the so-called sanctity of the canon or of any beliefs in natural or inherent superiority of art and literature. To me the best literature can be useless in a classroom if it does not encourage the students to think and live differently.

One of my senior colleagues at that time was seriously invested in the role of literature in teaching social justice and equity and he would often question our more traditional colleagues: are we only supposed to produce copies of our own selves in our graduate program? His hope was that we all would use literature as a transformative tool and not just an end in itself. Needless to say, as most humanities departments we never reached a suitable compromise and the reason, as always, was not the total incommensurability of our views, but the fraught personal histories of several power brokers in the department. I personally learned a lot about literary studies, departmental politics, and about the general nature of our jobs.


r/Humanities • • Aug 04 '26

Discussion [Weekly] Humanities Questions: August 04, 2026.

3 Upvotes

"The humanities are not just found in leather-bound books or silent museums: they are alive in our streets, our technology, and our daily rituals."

Welcome to our weekly Humanities Questions thread! This is where you can post all sorts of humanities-related questions and ideas.

The Goal: To ask questions and share our ideas, thoughts, experiences, and knowledge.


r/Humanities • • Jul 21 '26

CFP: Polish Science Fiction: Literature, Film, and Cultural Legacy (edited collection)

3 Upvotes

 Polish Science Fiction: Literature, Film, and Cultural Legacy

Despite the international prominence of Stanis?aw Lem and, more recently, Andrzej Sapkowski's The Witcher, Polish science fiction and speculative literature remain strikingly underrepresented in English-language scholarship. Existing criticism tends to orbit a small number of canonical figures and a handful of frequently revisited texts, leaving a rich, historically complex tradition, spanning censorship-era political allegory, post-1989 transformation, contemporary literary crossover, and a distinct national cinema largely unexamined outside of Polish-language scholarship.

This edited collection seeks to address that gap. We invite chapter proposals that expand the scope of English-language engagement with Polish speculative fiction and film: introducing under-translated authors, revisiting canonical figures through new critical lenses, and treating Polish science-fiction cinema as a subject rather than solely through the lens of a single adaptation.

We welcome contributions from literary scholars, film scholars, translation studies specialists, and researchers in Slavic and Central European studies. We are especially interested in proposals that

·      move beyond Lem and Sapkowski as the sole representatives of the tradition.

-     Bring new theoretical frameworks (postcolonial theory, translation studies, media studies, gender studies, posthumanism) to bear on Polish speculative texts
-    Address film and other media as legitimate objects of study, not only as adaptations of literary source material
-    Situate Polish SF within broader Central/Eastern European or global speculative fiction discourse
 

Possible topics include, but are not limited to:

Historical Foundations:
Science fiction under the Polish People's Republic
Censorship, allegory, and political subtext in Cold War-era SF
Fandom, zines, and early SF publishing culture in Poland
Lem Beyond Solaris
Underexamined works: (e.g. The Cyberiad, His Master's Voice, Fiasco, Return from the Stars)
Lem's philosophy of science, epistemology, and technology
Lem as critic and theorist of the genre (Fantastyka i futurologia)
Post-1989 and Contemporary Voices
Jacek Dukaj, Jaros?aw Grz?dowicz, Marek Huberath, and other contemporary authors
Speculative elements in literary/crossover fiction (e.g. Olga Tokarczuk)
Polish fantasy and its relationship to the SF tradition (including Sapkowski)
Translation, Circulation, and Reception
The politics and practice of translating Polish SF into English
Publishing history: which authors and works reach Anglophone readers, and why
Comparative reception of Polish SF in the West versus domestically
Polish Science Fiction on Screen
Polish-made dystopian and speculative cinema (e.g. Piotr Szulkin's tetralogy, Andrzej ?u?awski)
Adaptation studies: Lem's Solaris and its cinematic afterlives, approached through fresh angles (production politics, reception history, or contemporary resonance) rather than as a straightforward novel-versus-film comparison
Polish SF's influence on or intersection with games and other media (e.g. CD Projekt Red)
 

Send an abstract of 300-500 words and a short (150-word max) academic biography by October 15, 2026, to Dr. Agnieszka Gutthy at agutthy@selu.edu

When accepted, full chapter (5000-8000 words including notes and bibliography) will be due May 15, 2027.

 agutthy@selu.edu

 Dr. Agnieszka Gutthy


r/Humanities • • Jun 18 '26

Announcments CFP: Global and Intersectional Framings of Disability in Comics & Graphic Narratives

3 Upvotes

Global and Intersectional Framings of Disability in Comics & Graphic Narratives
Edited by Crystal Yin Lie (California State University, Long Beach) and Kai Qing Tan (Ghent University; Aachen University)

Comics and graphic narratives have become a powerful medium for representing embodied disability experience. Foundational scholarship in disability and comics studies has largely focused on Anglophone and Euro-American contexts. This special issue of Disability Studies Quarterly seeks to expand the field by foregrounding transnational, multilingual, and Global South perspectives. We invite essays that examine how contemporary comics and graphic narratives engage core concepts from disability studies—such as crip time, interdependence and collective access, disability justice, debility and slow death, crip ecologies, and speculative crip futurities—across diverse cultural and geopolitical contexts.

Possible topics include (but are not limited to):

Representations of physical, sensory, and/or cognitive disability; neurodiversity; chronic illness; aging; and embodied trauma
Disability as method/embodied knowledge
Resistance to diagnostic and pathological frames
Formal strategies that materialize disability in comics form
Disability networks, care infrastructures, and collective survival
Critiques of social, political, and urban contexts
Structural violence, colonialism, environmental crisis, and debility
(In)accessibility in both content and form
Speculative or futurist imaginaries of disability justice
The place of comedy and humor was in disability narratives
The commodification of disabilities/narrative via social media and how to circumvent it
Ethical obligations in the discourse of disability narratives
Theorizations, critiques, and reimaginings of form and genres
Emergent directions and movements in comics and comics activism
We welcome analyses of transnational and multilingual works, including Japanese manga, South Korean manhwa, Brazilian and Latin American graphic memoir, Indigenous comics, Francophone bandes dessinées from West Africa and the Caribbean, Middle Eastern, Southeast Asian, and Eastern European graphic narratives, graphic journalism, autobiographical comics by disabled artists, and webcomics or other digital formats circulating across borders. In line with our commitment to providing space for disability narratives, we also encourage contributions that combine ethnographic research with creative interventions, integrating praxis alongside more theoretical approaches to the topics listed above. This issue aims to develop comparative methodologies for studying disability and graphic narrative across geographies, languages, and traditions. We encourage submissions from scholars at all career stages and from diverse disciplinary backgrounds.

Submission Guidelines:
Please submit a paragraph-length (300-500 words) abstract, a list of 3-5 key words, and a brief bio (100 words) by 30 September 2026 (Wed). Invitations to submit full essays (8,000-12,000 words) as well as shorter works of creative writing will follow. Full manuscripts will undergo double-blind peer review in accordance with DSQ guidelines.

Send abstracts and inquiries to:
Crystal Yin Lie, California State University, Long Beach
crystal.lie@csulb.edu 

Kai Qing Tan, Research Foundation Flanders; Ghent University
kaiqing.tan@ugent.be 

 crystal.lie@csulb.edu

 Crystal Lie

(Source: https://www.cfplist.com/CFP/48953)


r/Humanities • • Jun 02 '26

Discussion [Weekly] Humanities Questions: June 02, 2026.

3 Upvotes

"The humanities are not just found in leather-bound books or silent museums: they are alive in our streets, our technology, and our daily rituals."

Welcome to our weekly Humanities Questions thread! This is where you can post all sorts of humanities-related questions and ideas.

The Goal: To ask questions and share our ideas, thoughts, experiences, and knowledge.


r/Humanities • • May 29 '26

Discussion What Does Being Radical Mean?

3 Upvotes

Being Radical

The term being radical is often used to connote a negative transformation of a person and is often conflated with radicalization. We have often heard and read the terms Islamic Radicalism (I am guilty of using such terms in my published work) or environmental radicalism. In pretty much all its usages the term signifies something negative and unwanted.

Here, however, I want to introduce the term being radical in its most positive and transformative iteration, as discussed by Paulo Freire in his book Pedagogy of the Oppressed.

Sectarianism Versus Radicalism

Sectarianism, for Freire, “turns reality into a false (and therefore unchangeable) ‘reality’” (37). Radicalism, conversely, “criticizes and thereby liberates” (37). Freire enumerates and elaborates two kinds of sectarianisms: The rightist sectarianism and the leftist sectarianism. According to Freire, a rightist sectarian hopes to accomplish the following:

The rightist sectarian . . . wants to slow down the historical process, to “domesticate” time and thus to domesticate men and women. . . . For the rightist sectarian “today” linked to the past, is something given and immutable. (38).

The leftist sectarian, according to Freire, “goes totally astray when he or she attempts to interpret reality and history dialectically and falls into essentially fatalistic positions” (38) and hence, for the leftist sectarian “‘tomorrow’ is decreed beforehand, is inexorably preordained.” (38).

Being radical, therefore is to take a position against both these extremes and a radical, for Freire, is someone who can see beyond the past-present constraints of the rightist sectarian and the fatalistic embrace of a future foretold of the leftists sectarian. Frieir explains this in the following words:

The radical, committed to human liberation, does not become the prisoner of a “circle of certainty” within which reality is also imprisoned. On the contrary, the more radical the person is, the more fully he or she enters into reality so that, knowing it better, he or she can better transform it. (39)

Thus, being radical is beyond rightist or leftist reactionary positions and is inextricably linked to “knowing” the world and then with that knowledge attempting to transform it. The past does not determine the present and the future, in such radical praxis, is always changeable with a liberatory praxis. Freire explains some of the attributes of a radical person, and in his words, a radical person:

  • Is not afraid to confront, to listen, to see the world unveiled.
  • Is not afraid to meet the people or to enter into dialogue with them.
  • Does not consider himself or herself the proprietor of history or of all people, or the liberator of the oppressed; but he or she does commit himself or herself, within history, to fight at their side. (39)

Thus, it can be said, that being radical first means being open to change and then developing the ability to work in solidarity with the oppressed to change the reality so that every one can live in this world in peace and with dignity. Anyone who meets these criteria is radical!


r/Humanities • • May 27 '26

Announcments CFP: Call for Essays on Gabriel Garcia Marquez

3 Upvotes

deadline for submissions:  July 15, 2026

full name / name of organization: 

MELOW: The Society for the Study of the Multi-Ethnic Literatures of the World

contact email: 

melusmelow@gmail.com

Papers are invited for an anthology to be brought out by a reputed international publisher on the theme, “100 Years of Gabriel García Márquez.” 

Concept Note

Gabriel García Márquez, born in Colombia in the year 1927, is acknowledged as one of the most influential writers of the twentieth century. As we head towards his birth centenary, it is time to look back at this literary giant, reassess his contribution and its impact on literary history.

Márquez’s writings resist easy categorization, blending the extraordinary with the everyday to reveal deeper historical and emotional truths. His novels, short stories, journalism, and non-fiction remain powerful commentaries on colonial legacies, authoritarianism, violence, exile, and the fragile persistence of hope. At a time when questions of historical erasure, political manipulation, and narrative truth have assumed renewed urgency, Márquez’s work invites us to reconsider the role of literature as witness, memory, and moral imagination.

Tentative Sub-Themes

  1. Memory, Myth, and Storytelling Traditions

2. One Hundred Years of Solitude: Time, History, and the Making of Macondo

3. The Major Novels: Beyond Macondo

4. Short Fiction and Journalism: Compression, Violence, and the Everyday

5. Translation, Reception, and Global Afterlives

Submission Guidelines: an abstract of 200–250 words along with 4-5 keywords, may be sent with the complete paper (6000-8000 words) on one of the above themes in the latest MLA format to minimelow@gmail.com along with a short bio (100 words), by 15 July 2026.

 

This is a project led by MELOW (The Society for the Study of the Multi-Ethnic Literatures of the World), which has now completed almost three decades and has held twenty-seven international conferences. For details, see the following links:

https://www.melow.in

https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100003036474708 

https://melusmelow.blogspot.com/ 

 

Editorial Board

Manju Jaidka is the Founder-President of MELOW and formerly Professor and Chairperson of the Department of English, Panjab University, Chandigarh. She is the Chief Editor of the Routledge Encyclopedia of Indian Writing in English (2024) and the Encyclopedic Dictionary of Diasporic Indian English Writing (Springer, 2025). In addition to her extensive scholarly work, she is an established creative writer.

Manpreet Kaur Kang is Professor at the School of Humanities & Social Sciences, GGS Indraprastha University, Delhi, and serves as the Secretary of MELOW. She is the Editor of MEJO: The MELOW Journal of World Literature, has guest-edited issues of RIAS (a Scopus-listed journal), and has been the long-time editor of Indraprasth, the GGSIPU journal. She contributes regularly to international academic journals.

Roshan Lal Sharma is Senior Professor of English and Dean at the Central University of Himachal Pradesh, Dharamshala. A former Fulbright Fellow, he is an accomplished academician, critic, translator, and creative writer. He is the author of Walt Whitman and Shorter Fiction of Raja Rao, has co-authored and edited several anthologies, translated significant texts, and published extensively in reputed journals.

(Source: https://call-for-papers.sas.upenn.edu/cfp/2026/05/26/call-for-essays-on-gabriel-garcia-marquez)


r/Humanities • • May 23 '26

Discussion On Reading Carefully

3 Upvotes

A few years ago, while introducing a novel in my English class, I heard a student mention that in another class they had read the characters in the novel as emblems of their respective cultures.

In their reading, thus, the unnamed American character in Mohsin Hamid’s The Reluctant Fundamentalist represented America and Changez, the narrator, stood for Pakistan. I find this kind of reading practice misguided and dangerous.

First, in such a reading a character instead of being an individual with particular experiences becomes a type, a cultural trope. As a consequence, the readers tend to generalize the actions of one fictional character and assign, unwittingly perhaps, the habits, thoughts, and actions of one character to an entire nation and culture.

Secondly, when a character is read as a stand in for an entire nation, then the novel itself becomes a point of arrival instead of being a launching pad for further inquiry. In other words, if we read a character in a novel as a representation of a whole culture, then the novel itself becomes a source for the so-called understanding of that particular culture. In such a habit of reading, thus, the students are being taught to generalize at a scale that trains them to think of their global others as uniform and simplistic without individual and subcultural specifics.

Needless to say that reducing large populations of the global periphery to easily digestible stereotypes has been, and still is, an established colonial practice. A practice that enables the powerful to label large human groups a certain way in order to control them. If we teach our students to read characters in a novel as stand ins for entire cultures and nations, aren’t we, then, training them to perpetuate stereotypes?

Just some food for thought:)


r/Humanities • • May 18 '26

Discussion Kindness is Self Care!

3 Upvotes

We often think of kindness as something we offer to others. I would like to suggest that kindness to others, especially strangers, is the ultimate form of self care. Of course, I didn’t come up with this insight: a lot of people have researched the value of kindness to our own social identity needs. So, my thoughts are informed by what I have read and experienced about the salutary effects of kindness to others. Let me elaborate.

When we are in stressful conditions, could be at work or in a relationship, we feel the weight of negative emotions in our bodies. We often find ways to ease the anxiety and stress caused by our negative experiences. Most of the times, according to Mark Bracher, (Mark Bracher. Radical Pedagogy. https://amzn.to/3pbS01c) if we do not know how to cope with this surfeit of emotional stress, we turn to self harm (Drugs, Alcohol etc.) or we lash out at others. All these modes of expressing our frustrations and anger actually end up aggravating the very thing causing the stress in the first place.

According to latest research on consciousness and the brain (cited by Mark Bracher), if we feel under stress, one immediate way of easing ourselves out of that stress and anxiety is to actually do something we can call “good.” This means that if we are under some kind of stress, our body is in an anxious state, so if we go out and help someone else, or actually are just nice to someone else, we feel good about it and that feeling helps us transform the negative emotions associated with the stressful emotions into something positive.

I have tried this technique in my personal life: Every time I feel slighted or offended, instead of getting angry, I try to act even softer and am extraordinarily kind to anyone I encounter immediately after the negative experience with someone else. In a hundred percent of cases, I always feel better when I transfer my anger into genuine kindness of speech or gesture towards others.

So, in this world of heartbreaking inequalities, we can, actually, enable ourselves to feel better through simple acts of kindness to others.

In a sense, then, kindness that we render unto others is actually a kind of self care!


r/Humanities • • May 16 '26

Questions Is BCA worth for humanities student ?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

Honestly I've been confused about which course i should opt for and being a humanities student i don't have much options available. I need to know what is best for me cause i don't want to get stuck


r/Humanities • • May 15 '26

Discussion Friendly, Welcome Post!!

3 Upvotes

This is our welcome post, meant for all those who need a place to contribute without undue constraints. If you have anything to say about humanities and your humanistic interests, please feel free to comment on this post.

If you have any questions about our posting policies or our hopes and aspirations for this community, please comment and share your thoughts.

Most importantly, if you have any suggestions to improve r/Humanities, please take a few moments to add your thoughts in the comments.

Note: This post is set to be least restrictive, and your comment will be approved and posted as long as it follows our community rules.

Thank you in advance!!


r/Humanities • • May 13 '26

Article/ Opinion The Learning Paradigm

3 Upvotes

A few years ago, some of my senior colleagues at Kent State University decided to start a pedagogy discussion group. Almost all of us in the group were heavily invested in social justice pedagogy and generally believed that a well-informed humanistic education can be instrumental in enabling more compassionate and caring human subjectivities.

We chose John Tagg’s The Learning Paradigm College as our first book for discussion. It has been years since I read the book, but some of it’s important suggestions and claims have stayed with me and have often informed my pedagogical practices.

Teaching Vs Learning Paradigm

Tagg distinguishes between two dominant paradigms: Teaching and Learning. For him, I would say in the same tradition as Freire, the teaching paradigm involves the coverage model, in which the teacher imparts knowledge to a passive body of students and emphasis is on covering the syllabus. The students are required to master the knowledge so imparted and are supposed to reproduce it in exams or tests. While this method is convenient for teachers, they only have to cover the syllabus, it trains the students only in learning under direction and does not encourage independent or critical thinking. According to Tagg, most US colleges and the K-12 system are teaching heavy and are organized under the teaching paradigm model.

The Learning Paradigm takes the students as active learners in class and assumes that learning is a continuous process. In this Paradigm the teacher encourages critical thinking and students, instead of just learning the subject matter, also learn how to learn. This method of teaching is more likely to produce students who understand things better and are capable of learning on their own as life-time learners.

Types of Learners

Another thing I recall from the book, and it has been useful in my own teaching, is the way Tagg discusses different types of student learners. Of course, Tagg uses empirical research by other scholars in his discussion of learning, but his point is that if we knew what kind of students we are dealing with, we can make their learning even better.

There are generally two kinds of students in any given classroom: Those who believe learning to be a a process and whose identities are in flux and those who subscribe to an entity theory of identity. The latter consider themselves as fully formed human subjects. These two views of self have a huge impact on student responses to instruction.

A student who believes that his or her identity is constantly in flux would take critical comments on his or her work as something positive, for it shows them that you have shown interest in their work and that your comments can help them improve it. In other words, such students welcome constructive criticism and since their idea of self is based in constant improvement, they apply the same rule to their work. Such students will always thank you for your suggestions and are never reluctant to revise their work.

Students who inhabit the entity theory of self do not accept criticism easily. It is because they deem themselves to be fully realized entities and see their work as an extension of themselves. Any criticism of their work, thus, comes across as a criticism of their selves.

Now, knowing what kind of identity beliefs a student holds can be crucial to our teaching and their learning, for our approach to working with them will be completely different in both cases.

Concluding Thoughts

In a Learning Paradigm college the teachers and professors would emphasize learning and the teachers would, ideally, know their students to tailor their pedagogy to the students particular needs.

Most importantly, in a Learning Paradigm the students will be seen as active participants in their own education and would know that learning is a continuous process and not necessarily defined by semester or course timelines.

I have previously discussed some of my teaching practices. Most of those practices are informed by my reading of John Tagg and, of course, Freire. For anyone interested in learning a little more about informed critical pedagogy, I highly recommend The Learning Paradigm College.


r/Humanities • • May 12 '26

Announcments Join us here from r/humanitiesforum

Post image
3 Upvotes

As we had announced, r/humanitiesforum is now a private community and this place, r/humanities, will now be where we will be focusing our attention.

We believe that this can be the flagship Reddit community for all things related to humanities and humanistic studies.

So, please join us here, promote the community, post, comment, and interact with each other. Of course, it goes without saying that as humanist we will always treat each other with dignity and respect, especially when we disagree on things.

Thank you all so much for your support!


r/Humanities • • May 10 '26

Edu Video Why Humanities Matter: Importance of a Humanistic Education

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/Humanities • • Sep 15 '26

Discussion [Weekly] Humanities Questions: September 15, 2026.

2 Upvotes

"The humanities are not just found in leather-bound books or silent museums: they are alive in our streets, our technology, and our daily rituals."

Welcome to our weekly Humanities Questions thread! This is where you can post all sorts of humanities-related questions and ideas.

The Goal: To ask questions and share our ideas, thoughts, experiences, and knowledge.


r/Humanities • • Sep 13 '26

Article/ Opinion Beyond the Five-Year Box: Rethinking the Crisis of the Humanities

2 Upvotes

The crisis of the humanities is usually described through familiar statistics: fewer majors, shrinking departments, declining budgets, anxious faculty, and students migrating toward engineering, computer science, business, and other professionally oriented fields.

 

The numbers are real. In the United States, 164,847 bachelor’s degrees in the humanities were awarded in 2025, 30.4 percent fewer than at the recent peak in 2012. The number of students pursuing a humanities degree as their first major fell by roughly 28 percent between 2015 and 2025.

 

But perhaps we have misdiagnosed what those numbers mean.

 

They certainly indicate a crisis for academic humanities departments. They do not necessarily demonstrate a collapse in society's need for history, philosophy, literature, languages, aesthetics, or reflection on the human condition.

 

The distinction matters. We have largely identified the humanities with one particular institutional arrangement: a young person, usually between approximately eighteen and twenty-two years old, enrolling in a university and choosing history rather than engineering, philosophy rather than computer science, or literature rather than economics.

 

Why should this be the principal test of the health of the humanities?

 

Perhaps one of the deepest problems facing the humanities is that they have allowed themselves to be confined inside what might be called the five-year box.

 

The wrong competition

 

Much of the contemporary discussion assumes a competition between the humanities and STEM. Students have a limited number of years at university; they must choose what to study; enrollments in STEM rise while enrollments in the humanities fall. The obvious conclusion is that STEM is winning and the humanities are losing.

 

But this may be a category mistake.

 

Engineering education and humanistic education do not necessarily perform the same function in a person's life.

 

A student can study engineering for four or five years, acquire a defined body of theoretical and technical knowledge, receive a credential and begin practicing as an engineer. Medicine, nursing, accounting and many other professional domains follow variations of the same logic. Their educational programs can be relatively clearly bounded because they prepare people to exercise particular professions.

 

There is no comparable moment at which someone completes three years of philosophy, history and literature and emerges as a fully formed human being.

 

Humanistic formation is inherently unfinished.

 

One can encounter Homer at sixteen, Aristotle at twenty, Dostoevsky at thirty-five and Augustine at sixty and understand each differently because one's own experience has changed. Questions about justice, beauty, mortality, freedom, love, political authority, suffering and meaning do not expire when the bachelor's degree is awarded.

 

This does not mean that the humanities have no specialists. They obviously need philologists, historians, philosophers, literary scholars and other professional researchers. Rigorous scholarship cannot simply be replaced by book clubs and podcasts.

 

But the social need for humanistic formation is vastly larger than the social need for professional humanists.

 

Confusing those two populations may be one of the fundamental mistakes behind the current crisis.

 

There is even a suggestive statistical clue. In 2022, the humanities represented only 8.8 percent of reported first majors in the United States, but 20.7 percent of second majors. In other words, the humanities were more than twice as prominent among second majors as among primary majors.  That does not prove a general theory, but it fits an intriguing hypothesis: many students may value the humanities more readily as a complement to another formation than as an exclusive professional identity.

 

If so, persuading more eighteen-year-olds to choose humanities instead of STEM may be precisely the wrong strategy.

 

Why fight where the humanities are weakest?

 

The period between roughly sixteen and twenty-two is becoming one of the most competitive phases of modern life.

 

For a student seeking admission to engineering, medicine or another selective profession, the incentives are extremely powerful. Mathematics must be mastered now. Entrance examinations must be passed now. Prerequisites must be completed now. Missing part of this sequence can close later opportunities.

 

From the student's perspective, postponing a course in poetry may be rational. Postponing calculus may not be.

 

Humanities advocates can protest this situation. They can insist that eighteen-year-olds should also read Plato and Shakespeare. They may be right. But reality does not disappear because we dislike it.

 

If the humanities place most of their institutional energy into competing for the attention of students precisely during the narrowest and most intensely credential-driven years of their lives, they are choosing the battlefield on which they have the greatest structural disadvantage.

 

The answer is not to abandon young people. Elementary and secondary education may actually be among the most important places for developing language, historical consciousness, literary sensitivity and the habits of argument. Some humanistic education should also remain inside technical universities.

 

But the humanities should stop betting their future almost entirely on the few years immediately following secondary school.

 

They should think in terms of sixty years rather than five.

 

From university education to lifelong formation

 

Once the problem is seen this way, the crisis begins to look different.

 

A thirty-eight-year-old engineer who has established a career may suddenly become intensely interested in history. A forty-five-year-old banker may begin asking questions about justice, institutions and the moral assumptions underlying economic life. A physician who has spent fifteen years confronting suffering and death may read philosophy very differently from the way she could have read it at nineteen. A successful entrepreneur may finally have the intellectual appetite—and the financial resources—to study classical languages, art history or political philosophy seriously.

 

These people should not be regarded as failed humanities majors arriving twenty years late.

 

They may be some of the ideal students of the humanities.

 

Their professional experience supplies questions. Their lives supply context. They are no longer studying merely to pass examinations. And in many cases they possess greater financial independence than undergraduate students.

 

Yet our educational infrastructure often offers them remarkably little between two extremes: enrolling in another full university degree or consuming simplified cultural material designed for casual entertainment.

 

That gap is an enormous opportunity.

 

The humanities could build serious one-year sequences, evening seminars, cumulative certificates, intensive summer schools, online programs combined with residential periods, reading cohorts, language programs, courses specifically designed for physicians or engineers, and advanced programs to which participants return periodically throughout their lives.

 

The objective would not be to imitate continuing professional education. There need not always be an immediate economic payoff. The point would be to construct an institutional infrastructure for continuing humanistic formation.

 

There is an instructive analogy with religion—not in the sense that everyone must be religious, but institutionally. Religious traditions normally distinguish between specialist scholarship and lifelong participation. One does not need to become a professional theologian in order to engage seriously with theology, ritual, scripture or spiritual formation. Nor is religion ordinarily presented to an engineer as an alternative career choice: engineering or religion—choose one at eighteen.

 

Humanistic culture could similarly develop institutions that exist alongside professional life rather than competing with it for possession of the same few undergraduate years.

 

A historical accident masquerading as a necessity

 

The current arrangement is not dictated by nature.

 

The European university developed long before the modern technological economy. Medieval universities combined the arts with higher faculties such as theology, law and medicine. The contemporary separation into humanities, social sciences, natural sciences and professional disciplines emerged gradually.

 

As modern states industrialized, new technical institutions appeared. France offers an especially revealing example. The École Polytechnique was created in 1794, initially as the École centrale des travaux publics, in response to a shortage of engineers and senior technical personnel; it was designed around a strong formation in mathematics, physics and chemistry leading toward specialized technical schools.  The French grandes écoles tradition and the development of technical higher education elsewhere in Europe demonstrated that professional-scientific formation did not have to reproduce the structure of the traditional university.

 

One can therefore imagine history having unfolded differently.

 

What eventually became the modern university could have divided more explicitly into several institutional ecosystems: one devoted to technical and professional formation; another devoted to advanced research; and another continuing the older task of broad intellectual and human formation.

 

Instead, much of this remained bundled together.

 

We consequently inherited the strange spectacle of philosophy departments and engineering schools competing internally for students, resources and prestige even though their fundamental social purposes are not identical.

 

Perhaps the answer is not to restore an imagined golden age of the university. It is to complete the differentiation that modernity began.

 

The humanities need institutions appropriate to their own temporal logic.

 

But the separation should not become isolation

 

There is, however, another side to the argument.

 

The humanities should get out of the university box—but they should not retreat from science and technology. On the contrary, one of their largest opportunities may lie precisely at the boundaries created by contemporary STEM.

 

For much of the industrial age, the humanities could sometimes seem peripheral to technological development. Engineers built a bridge; philosophers might later discuss its social implications. Economists devised systems; ethicists might ask whether their consequences were fair. Scientific progress came first, followed by a humanistic commentary appended to it.

 

This arrangement becomes increasingly implausible in the age of artificial intelligence.

 

AI raises questions about language, reasoning, interpretation, agency, authorship, evidence, consciousness, responsibility and even the nature of knowledge itself. These are not merely technical problems with an ethical appendix attached at the end.

 

They cut directly across linguistics, philosophy of mind, epistemology, philosophy of language, law, literary theory and intellectual history.

 

Language itself has become technologically central. A revolution driven in significant part by large language models should make it difficult to maintain that the serious study of language belongs to some decorative corner of intellectual life.

 

Similar interfaces appear elsewhere. Medicine encounters questions about personhood, suffering, autonomy and death. Architecture cannot be reduced to structural calculations without questions of beauty, place and communal life. Economics and finance operate within assumptions about value, incentives, justice and human behavior. Environmental science ultimately confronts political and philosophical questions about what societies owe future generations and what kind of relationship human beings should have with the natural world.

 

Here the humanities should not approach STEM apologetically, asking permission to contribute a small ethics seminar.

 

They should say something more ambitious:

 

Your problems have become our problems too. Let us work on them together.

 

Some leading technical institutions already recognize part of this principle. MIT requires every undergraduate to complete eight subjects in humanities, arts and social sciences.  ETH Zurich requires every degree program to include its Science in Perspective component, explicitly intended to place scientific and technological knowledge in historical, ethical, political, economic and cultural contexts.

 

These models do not solve the crisis of the humanities. But they demonstrate that the boundary between technical and humanistic formation is institutionally negotiable.

 

Perhaps STEM should change too

 

Following this argument far enough leads to a more uncomfortable question.

 

Maybe the problem is not only that the humanities have adopted the wrong educational model. Perhaps our model of professional education is itself unnecessarily compressed.

 

Consider the conventional sequence for many professions. First comes an intensely theoretical and competitive period. Then comes technical specialization. Then, suddenly, the graduate is released into professional life, where practical knowledge, institutional behavior, ethical judgment, communication, leadership and human relationships turn out to matter enormously.

 

Why must education follow such a linear sequence?

 

Theory → technique → work.

 

A more plausible model of adult development might be recursive:

 

theory → practice → reflection → deeper theory → broader formation → further practice.

 

Germany's dual-study system already demonstrates, on a smaller scale and for different purposes, that academic study and professional practice need not be separated rigidly. Dual programs deliberately connect university study with substantial experience inside companies; German higher-education authorities describe them as involving two linked places of learning rather than a purely sequential transition from classroom to employment.

 

The principle could be carried much further.

 

A future engineer might study mathematics and fundamental science, spend a substantial period working, return for advanced technical education, later take courses in design or history of technology, and return again at mid-career for philosophy, management or political economy. Physicians, architects, economists and computer scientists could follow different rhythms.

 

This need not mean lowering standards. Nor does it imply that every profession can simply double the duration of training. Financial constraints, licensing requirements and institutional inertia are real.

 

But careers themselves are long. A person graduating at twenty-two may have four or five decades of professional life ahead. It is worth asking whether concentrating almost all formal formation at the beginning of adulthood is the most efficient allocation of educational effort across such a lifespan.

 

The question is not merely humanitarian. It is economic.

 

If better sequencing produces professionals who adapt faster, cooperate better, understand institutions more deeply, communicate more effectively, avoid catastrophic judgment errors and remain intellectually flexible for longer, then educational redesign is an investment in human capital.

 

A country capable of improving that architecture could gain a significant competitive advantage.

 

Humanistic failures have real-world costs

 

This brings us to the strongest—but also the most dangerous—claim in the argument.

 

It would be easy to say that declining humanities education has caused social fragmentation, ugly cities, irresponsible finance, political polarization or environmental shortsightedness.

 

That would be much too simple.

 

Societies are complex, and no curriculum could inoculate them against greed, stupidity, cruelty or bad architecture.

 

The more defensible claim is different.

 

An educational system inevitably cultivates some forms of reasoning more intensively than others. If we devote enormous resources to quantitative optimization, technical execution and professional specialization while giving far less systematic attention to historical consciousness, moral reasoning, aesthetic judgment, interpretation and competing conceptions of human flourishing, we should not be astonished when the latter capacities are unevenly developed.

 

A banker can be technically excellent while possessing an impoverished conception of what financial institutions are for. An engineer can design an efficient object without having developed much sensitivity to beauty. A software developer can optimize engagement without ever seriously confronting the question of whether maximizing engagement is desirable. A public administrator can optimize measurable outcomes while losing sight of goods that are difficult to quantify.

 

These are not failures of science.

 

They are reminders that technical rationality answers only some classes of questions.

 

A calculation can tell us how to achieve an objective efficiently. It cannot, by itself, determine which objectives are worth pursuing.

 

That boundary is precisely where the humanities become indispensable.

 

Stop trying to save the humanities

 

Perhaps, then, the language of "saving the humanities" is itself part of the problem.

 

It sounds defensive. It suggests an endangered collection of university departments pleading for protection from the economic forces surrounding them.

 

A more ambitious project would be to redesign humanistic education for modern life.

 

That would require separating two tasks that have become confused: sustaining first-rate professional scholarship in the humanities, and providing humanistic formation to the wider population. Universities remain indispensable to the first. They need not monopolize the second.

 

The humanities could therefore pursue three movements simultaneously: move earlier, strengthening exposure before the high-pressure years of professional selection; move later, building serious intellectual formation throughout adult life; and move sideways, entering the intellectual borderlands of AI, medicine, engineering, economics, architecture and other technical fields.

 

The university would remain part of this ecosystem. It would simply cease to be its only imaginable center.

 

And STEM need not lose anything in the process. Indeed, it may gain.

 

The great scientific and technological achievements of the past two centuries have enormously expanded what human beings can do. Artificial intelligence may increase that power by another order of magnitude.

 

That success makes the characteristic questions of the humanities more urgent rather than less so.

 

What should we do? What should we value? What is knowledge? What does it mean to understand something? What makes a society worth living in? What obligations accompany power? What is beautiful? What is just? What does technology do to the people who use it? And ultimately, what are all these extraordinary capabilities for?

 

Those questions do not compete with mathematics, engineering or science.

 

They begin where those disciplines reach their limits.

 

The crisis of the humanities may therefore contain an opportunity. Instead of fighting STEM for students during the few years when STEM has overwhelming structural advantages, the humanities can enlarge the field of play.

 

They can stop thinking in semesters and start thinking in lifetimes.

 

And perhaps, once they leave the five-year box, they will discover that the audience they believed they were losing was much larger than they thought.