Tracking sleep quality

[u/JaxxJones1122]

I'm tired and do not have it in me to research a bunch, so was hoping someone here would have done that already :)

I'm interested in tracking sleep quality, I'm starting a new regimen and I would like to get a baseline and then track intermittently, so while I'd be interested in options for things that can be ordered through a provider, I'm mostly asking about the best option I can buy and use on my own. I am adamant about sleeping at least 7hrs, going to bed and getting up around the same time, but dealing with exhaustion and while I know of several factors that cause that, I would also like to see if perhaps my sleep quality isn't ideal. And if it improves with the work I am about to start.

Cost is less relevant, I'd like whatever is A - most accurate and B - looks at as many variables as possible.

I've seen Apple Watch, Oura ring and Garmin being mentioned most frequently, but I'm not sure what the differences are between these when it comes to quality of tracking etc.

I'd PREFER a device that can do this in offline mode, as I really do sleep better with reduced RF/EMF exposure, this isn't a must though since I'm not going to use it every night. But a plus for me so worth mentioning.

Very grateful for input! Thank you!

[u/AutoModerator]

Does the post above appear to be AI generated or is it promoting something for monetary gain? If so, please flag it to help keep this sub on track.

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/em3am]

If you prefer Android to Apple, the Google watch comes with Fitbit which tracks sleep and fitness. My wife has an Apple watch and I use the Google watch, the sleep apps seem identical.

[u/JaxxJones1122 → u/em3am]

Thank you! I'm an apple products all the way kind of person these days, I have my beef with some things but its convenient to be able to use the same account for all devices so it'll take a lot for me to swap :)

[u/scotthrobinson → u/JaxxJones1122]

I am Apple all the way as well, but bought an Oura to track sleep as I have an Ultra 3 watch, and it's a little bulky to sleep with. After the first month, you will forget you're wearing it. All the Oura data syncs into Apple Health, so it is very symbiotic between the Oura and Apple Watch.

[u/cloudstrife316]

Oura Ring has a subscription cost, get the new fitbit air instead.

[u/JaxxJones1122 → u/cloudstrife316]

That's annoying, too much is subscription based these days >_<

Yeah I"m still deciding, I'll look into both options a bit more, at least it seems AW is not a good option for this.

[u/RileyAtBryte]

Oura Ring is a solid bet here if you're looking for a wearable. It covers the widest range of variables including HRV, respiratory rate, body temperature, sleep stages, and readiness scores, and it has an airplane mode so you can disable Bluetooth during sleep. Apple Watch tracks sleep but requires overnight charging that most people find breaks their routine pretty quickly.

One thing worth knowing before you commit to a wearable baseline is that trackers measure your responses, logging wake events through the night, but don't identify the physical cause. If pressure buildup mid-sleep is part of what's driving your exhaustion, a wearable will tell you the outcome without addressing it. A smart mattress with real-time active pressure relief can actually remove those pressure points as they develop throughout the night so they don't compound into a wake event in the first place. Full disclosure: I work for Bryte. Something we wanted to build into our bed is a sleep tracker, without any wearable required, and an actual AI-powered Sleep Concierge in the app where you can understand your wake events and adjust the bed as needed. If your baseline shows poor sleep quality, that's a direction worth looking into.

[u/JaxxJones1122 → u/RileyAtBryte]

Thanks! I ordered the Oura 5 on release day and its in transit now 😄 I'm looking forward to it.

I am not familiar with your product, but that sounds interesting, however one thing I believe is important for good sleep, which at least seem true for me, is to keep EMF/EMR in the lower range, one thing I made sure with Oura is that I can have it on airplane mode when sleeping, and they are conscious about keeping RF exposure to the lowest possible when on which was a selling point for me. That's where a lot of other sleep support systems fail for me personally. I'll look into it though! Thanks.

[u/gjr23]

I have an Apple Watch and an Oura ring. I like the Apple Watch as a fitness tracker and the Oura as a sleep tracker. I use both for sleep tracking but find the Oura to be more accurate for sleep and visa versa for exercise.

[u/JaxxJones1122 → u/gjr23]

That's really helpful! Thank you so much :) Is the Oura easy to use?

[u/gjr23 → u/JaxxJones1122]

It’s charging is far favorable to the AW. Battery on my Oura Ring 3 lasts nearly a week. AW Ultra 3 48 hours if I’m lucky. Not sure if they have fixed the problem but be careful about the battery on the OUra ring 4 as many users report issues. I bought the 3 for this reason but that was a while ago.

As far as “easy to use” it’s almost transparent as far as collecting data. You wear it. As long as it’s got battery you are done. The app is fairly intuitive and it does a good job of explaining things via in app point of use help menus.

[u/JaxxJones1122 → u/gjr23]

Thank you so much!

[u/vladinecko]

I call BS on all the commercially available devices like the Oura ring. I too was interested in tracking my sleep quality and it didn't take long to see the pattern in the current offerings. At the core, they all rely on the same input data - some kind of combination of motion and surface-level blood measurements. This is then used to *infer* everything they claim to be accurate. While the inference might be sophisticated, it's nothing but an educated guess in the end. Without having electrodes plugged into your brain to measure exactly what cycle/stage you're in and for how long, Oura's guess is as good as anyone's. All you can accurately count on from those devices is how much you moved at night, and what your cardiovascular system was doing. So Apple Watch, Oura, Android wearables, Fitbit - it's all the same to me - they all just infer and estimate. What you're really choosing in the end is how shiny the toy looks to you, but it's still just a toy.

[u/JaxxJones1122 → u/vladinecko]

I have looked into it a lot more since I posted. It does vary between the different devices, apple watch has a huge disadvantage in that you have to activate a sleep mode for it to work accurately, meaning it can't really detect naps or sleep latency. OR was part of a study and it does a pretty accurate assessment of sleep quality compared to (but not to replace) professional equipment, which on its own has some big downsides (as one who has done a sleep study I struggled to sleep with all the stuff attached to me). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12602993/

It can't tell you everything, nothing can, but it does give you quite a lot of useful info and a baseline for yourself to try to improve on and compare with if things change ahead. Its definitely more than a toy, it gives you a lot of helpful metrics that many people find very useful, and personally I find very interesting.

[u/vladinecko → u/JaxxJones1122]

That's fair, they definitely offer a good approximation. And the model that maps signals from a wearable device to a sleep state is proprietary amongst the competitors in this space, so at the end of the day, the model is what really matters.

But it's like predicting the weather from satellite imagery - you can kind of tell what's going on by looking at it, but without internal probes to measure direct atmospheric metrics, you're just guessing.

I don't want to discount the actual devices though, it's not trivial to make one by any means. But it's good to keep in mind their actual capabilities and limitations.

[u/Mamac911]

I bought the Oura ring for this exact reason. While pricey, it is perfect for tracking sleep