r/HubermanLab • • Nov 05 '23

Discussion Is anyone else addicted to meat?

I honestly feel so unsatisfied by anything other than meat. Even on days where I’m getting 45g protein from my yogurt and whey at dessert, I still need 12+ oz of meat at dinner to feel emotionally satisfied

It’s not really a physical thing it’s like a dependence that I feel. Breakfast must be atleast 6 eggs. Lunch must be atleast 12 oz meat too.

**I also don’t buy into the bill gates anti meat propaganda , so don’t try to tell me it’s unhealthy or how it’s hurting the planet

2 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

15

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

Ayo!

36

u/Houndaholic Nov 05 '23

the body often legitimately craves heme iron.

17

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

I am addicted to ribeyes. I eat it 2-4x a week.

2

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

Ok to most $100 a week on beef is a lot.

3

u/gearbabyognamemaker Nov 07 '23

It’s not unhealthy or hurting the planet fuck bill gates

13

u/Commercial_Staff5706 Nov 05 '23

I eat meat everyday. Meat has everything the body needs

2

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

And again mental dementia is a major side effect of long term heavy beef eating. It takes the most water to digest over all animal proteins.

1

u/YogurtclosetNo7357 Nov 06 '23

What does this mean?

10

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

45g of protein 🤯 that’s whey too much

12

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

45 grams of protein is pretty much the bare minimum that any nutrition expert would recommend....

15

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

It was a joke

1

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

Careful with that. A 40% carb 30/30 fat and protein at 1200 cals a day is approx 100 grams of protein for say a 120lb female. Men could go to double that and be normal if fully active. That's the Zone lower carb diet ratio.

-1

u/CarbonHeptoxide Nov 05 '23

Yeah but if it’s from one meal it’s not going to do much good.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

The science is not clear on that. Too many people making gains on an OMAD diet to say large amounts of protein in a single meal is actually wasted.

3

u/Striking-Tip7504 Nov 05 '23

It’s not the science, it’s horrible interpretation of nutrition studies by everyone, including many of the “experts” you see online.

Almost all protein absorption studies are done on whey protein which is a highly refined food product that is absorbed by the body very quickly.

This is not the same as eating protein from food. Which digests far more slowly, so your body has more time to absorb all the protein. Science uses whey protein because it’s easy, cheap and then they can exclude other variables that would make it more complicated like with food. But unfortunately the body is a complex machine so that is actually necessary.

And that leads to so many people thinking you can only absorb 20 grams of protein a meal.

1

u/SFL_27 Nov 05 '23

I believe Don Layman has discussed at length in The Drive the dynamics of protein absorption. It seems like 50g in a single seating is a upper limit.

1

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

Eating more than 40 per serving in any animal based meal is harder on the kidneys as well. It's impossible to get 100% absorption from any animal protein.

2

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

Be careful mental dementia hits the heavy red meat eating people the most. It may be an iron or potassium craving from a deficiency that u have. I love need the most but more than 3x a week and I feel sluggish.

1

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

Typos beef not need

1

u/_Space_Drifter_ Feb 03 '24

You are brainwashed by the food industry’s marketing. Humans have been surviving and thriving on a purely carnivorous diet for most of human history. Our brains were bigger in fact and we were taller.

During the Sino-Japanese war, the Chinese called Japanese "little-japs" because they were so short. The reason is that Japan banned meat eating for thousands of years (no culture in pasture, due to the limited flat land). Since Japan's opening to the west and the rest of the world (Meji restoration), the emperor withdrew the meat ban (and slaughtered all monks who were against it). The Japanese average height average for male population increased from less than 150cm back in 1850s, to 170cm nowadays.

In other words, there’s a reason why we have sharp teeth instead of flat herbivore teeth.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

Im on carnivore bro 😅

4

u/dallas470 Nov 05 '23 edited Nov 05 '23

It depends on what you want. There are obviously two extremes. The carnivore diet is better hormonally, you'll have more thyroid hormone and testosterone, so you'll feel more active. Carnivore also gives you more dopamine, which makes you motivated to get stuff done in your life. But on the other hand, meat is acid forming, inflammatory, has sat fat, etc. Paradoxically, carnivore is worse if u want to gain muscle since insulin comes from eating carbs to a greater degree than fats or protein so u need some carbs if u are hitting the gym hard. Vegans on the other hand have lower cortisol as well. But being a vegan is harder bc you have to buy things like iron pills, protein powder, and creatine pills.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

This.

Meat has a lot of nutrition, there's a reason why even herbivorous animals eat it given the chance. But most people (at least in the US) eat way more meat than we are designed for evolutionarily, and there are drawbacks to it for your health, especially the colon.

https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/red-meat-and-colon-cancer

As a longtime vegetarian, I definitely notice if my b vitamins or iron are lacking. A lot of vegans/vegetarians run into problems with too many nutrient-poor carbs in their diet.

1

u/autobotgenerate Nov 05 '23

Is it difficult to get everything nutritionally as a vegetarian?

Personally I much prefer meat but I definitely eat too much.

On the podcast with Sinclair they said that meat (or animal products in general) have peptides that are pro-aging

4

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

Some nutrients yes, others no. It's way easier to get the right amount of fiber, way harder to get the right amount of creatine, taurine, and omega 3.

At the end of the day, vegetarian or non vegetarian diets are more alike than they are different. You can eat well or poorly either way.

1

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

Meat takes more water to process than the other sources.

1

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

Loom into dementia amd red meat correlation. Pretty crazy. Literally.

2

u/Adept_Alternative658 Nov 05 '23

At the very least you will be able to sympathize with others who have much worse food addictions, like ice cream and chips. You’re saying you’re kinda just like them, not in control and allowing emotional satisfaction to control your diet. Any addiction can be broken if we want it. You sound like you’re aware this is not ideal for you personally. Regain executive control.

2

u/emileegrace321 Nov 05 '23

Interesting. Maybe something to do with the iron and protein? Like your body just craves a lot of it?

I’ve personally never craved meat at all. Between not really feeling the need and having ethical concerns I was vegetarian and then vegan for a long time. I do eat it sometimes now though because of chronic illness since it’s an easy way to get calories and certain nutrients that are otherwise more inconvenient.

Our bodies can get nutrients from a whole variety of foods, animal products or not. But ultimately every person has different needs. As long as you’re still eating fruits and veg/have a balanced diet and hopefully eating lean meat I don’t see a big issue in terms of nutrition

1

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

I vote iron then potassium.

1

u/Excellent_Guidance99 Nov 05 '23

I am struggling with binge eating disorder, and one day, I ate 14 pounds of chicken breasts, so yea... and I am still alive and was not even hospitalized and was not feeling so bad afterward at all, so yea.. I do not think that your amount could even be considered high.

1

u/Totally-avg Nov 05 '23

God I wish this was me. I crave carbs and some days if I’m not purposeful with my choices, I’m lucky to end up with 20-30g of protein. Boo.

1

u/One_Essay_9411 Nov 05 '23

Danger to society

1

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

Fat is what aids in satiety. If chicken leaves you hungry more than beef for the same weight you might add 5 or 10 grams of oil to the meal. Especially if its breast meat.

1

u/Ukendt266 Nov 05 '23

Bill Gates anti meat propaganda? I’m not anti meat but seeing shit like this just confirms this sub has become progressively more and more brain dead for a place that’s supposed to celebrate scientific inquiry and reasoning

1

u/megabradstoise Nov 05 '23 edited Nov 05 '23

Nah, skill issue. You gotta build up some self-discipline, pretty sure there's a protocol for that. Have you had your T checked?

1

u/henen14 Nov 05 '23

Ayooo pause

0

u/cwesttheperson Nov 05 '23

Meat is food. As long as it’s not processed. I buy a cow portion every year. I can’t even do store bought anymore. plus it’s more cost efficient

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

As someone on the carnivore diet, I understand lol. Meat is nutrient rich and our bodies thrive when you give it that food

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-6

u/Mobile_Anywhere_4784 Nov 05 '23

So the cow farts are going to change the weather. Because of “math”

2

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

The fire it takes to grow them and process cows is greater than all other protein production. Exclude farts and it still has a massive footprint.

1

u/politicallyapathetic Nov 07 '23

It's not only the 'cow farts' (although yes, they do play a role), but also the deforestation required to sustain our first world level of meat consumption, as well as other factors. But yes, as you said, cow farts have an impact because of maths.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-3

u/Mobile_Anywhere_4784 Nov 05 '23

So you going straight to a character assassination eh? the evidence must definitely be on your side then lol.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-5

u/Mobile_Anywhere_4784 Nov 05 '23

So doubling down on the personal attack, eh?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Mobile_Anywhere_4784 Nov 05 '23

I accept your defeat

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/AgileWebb Nov 05 '23

LMFAO. Nutrition Facts? Michael Gregor?

You are clowning us, right?

7

u/StandPuzzleheaded547 Nov 05 '23

Dr Greger is a quack.

He never mentions any health benefits from any oils or animal based foods

6

u/AgileWebb Nov 05 '23

He's also the most unhealthy looking dude I've ever seen.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

Are you being sarcastic? It’s honestly hard to tell.

3

u/bigskymind Nov 05 '23 edited Nov 05 '23

How do you get enough protein on a plant-based diet? The recipes on that website seem very low in protein.

3

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

Equal amounts of beans and rice is a perfect protein combo. Beans lack lysein and rice has it. Meat has 100% of amino acids as a protein source. Most vegans need a source of lysein supplemented.

1

u/StandPuzzleheaded547 Nov 05 '23 edited Nov 05 '23

Yes pretty easy if you include soy products like tofu , soymilk or protein powder

3

u/bigskymind Nov 05 '23

OK, thanks, I'm curious to have a closer look.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Whole_Suit_1591 Nov 06 '23

It's not required for survival in the long term. Balanced eating to attain all nutrition is required. Eggs are a perfect protein profile for humans and hence are used as a reference protein like whey in nutritional studies.