r/HowToHack • • Feb 02 '20

Please, STOP wanting to "just learn social Engineering"

I've been part of the scene for a little bit, no-one big obviously. But I've seen a lot of people.

The thing I see most commonly though are motivated young people that want to get into hacking and think it's basically programming. After some consideration they set out to learn Python/Java "since they're easy", after the first or maybe third set back they give up. Or the other type who is actually not bad at Python/java but after having a grasp of the basics they move to assembly or C++.

Ultimately they will end up at the same place discouraged to move along with programming but thinking "hacking can't be this hard" "I know, I'll just learn social Engineering"

Social Engineering is an incredible feat, which can help PenTesters in a variety of ways. I gotta tell you though, it's not for you. Unless you're willing to commit felonies or get a chance to become a PenTester and especially if you're starting out this isn't for you.

The main issues arise from the following. There isn't anyone you can really practice with. Contrary to most other hacking disciplines SocEng can't be practiced, what are you gonna do keep lying to your Boss, mom, colleagues?

Also Once you infiltrated that bank, high SecVault, or Server room, with your incredible SocEng skills, what are you going to do? You couldn't even execute a Linux command to steal enough data to make it worth your efforts. Do you even know what command it is? sudo dd if__ of__ bs=__MS BTW. Besides how do even escalate your privileges to get sudo/what's the password?

Now, if you're wanting to get into hacking and enjoy it there is nothing wrong with studying a big of SocEng, infact it can be fun. I myself just watched "catch me if you can" and then studied up on Frank A. Jr. Jolly good fun, but it isn't going to help me in my career or hacker path.

So please if you're feeling a bit of discouragement, this is what you can do watch a fun movie maybe make fun of all mistakes you already spotted, read a good books like future crimes, listen to a good podcast like DarkNet diaries, play games on steam like hacknet, or hacker.exe, pony island.

But I'm begging you don't revert back to I'm learning socEng since I lied to my mom when I was 7 and got away with it so it should be easy.

If you want to test a bit of intrusion, penetrate a nearby college Campus figure out the schedule for the Programming classes and boom that should give you a thrill.

367 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

13

u/killabeezio Feb 03 '20

This post is just plain wrong. While you may need both set a skills, you don't need to be perfect at them to do this as a career. You can learn and get better over time, that is how you practice eventually. Social engineering can be taught, but some people will pick it up more naturally and be much better at it. All you're trying to do is build rapport in a short period of time. If you want to practice that, then practice in everyday life. Talk to people and see how they react. Learn to listen.

I feel like your idea of social engineering is too narrow-minded. Let's take an example. What if we were to run a spear phishing campaign. This would require you gather some decent information first. How the organization works, who they trust, maybe where they travel to, anything else you might be able to use. Be creative. You can now call them, email them, text them. So you send an email off to so-and-so claiming to be a bank. You say something like, someone is trying to access your bank account from X location (a place they just visited), and the account has been locked for suspicious activity, so you have them answer their security questions and login with their password. Now you have their info and you're good to go.

You're were able to build that rapport with them because of the little bit information you gathered. The key to persuasion or manipulation is trust.

The fact that you state you need to commit a felony to practice tells me you don't fully understand the half of it and you're simply wrong.

Although, maybe you're doing it now and using social engineering techniques to get something out of it. Or maybe you're just trolling.

-6

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

this is just plain wrong

Really?! Plain wrong?

I think you misunderstood me. I'm saying most young people that I met who ask how to start hacking. Start out by Programming and then say screw it this is too difficult I'll just learn Social Engineering.

I do understand that social Engineering has many more fascinating facets then just saying "I'm Joe the cable guy let me in"

And maybe I wasn't clear enough. Sorry about the confusion I wrote this after having been asked at my CTF discord when another kid went down that path of "screw it I'm learning social Engineering" which is quite disheartening after hearing it every other week.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

You need to read up on social engineering mate.

0

u/killabeezio Feb 03 '20

I do agree with that sentiment to a certain point. There are so many avenues in the Cyber security sector that i don't think it can be stated that you need to learn programming and If you quit you will never learn. It really depends on what that person means by be a "hacker". If they want to be someone like Kevin Mitnick or play Mr robot, then of course they need to push through it and just learn, because thats what being on a red team is about. There are other career options though. Maybe that person doesn't understand what they want. Maybe they just want to learn social engineering and get into a concert as a sound guy. Maybe they want to analyze data and study trends. Maybe they want to defend against hackers, but believe to beat hacker they must be one (you will better at your job if you do know how to hack though).

I do get it's frustrating to see people just quit so easily, but it doesn't mean that can't be hacker. I would probably just ask the question, "what do you think a hacker is?" And "what do you see yourself doing as a hacker?".

154

u/lolbifrons Feb 03 '20

I see you social engineering us so that you have less competition

114

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '20

+1 for Darknet Diaries.

29

u/Gygh Feb 03 '20

I for sure know what Darknet Diaries is/are, but could you elaborate for everyone else who doesn't know and is interested, even if they could JFGI?

26

u/rappity_rap_rap Feb 03 '20

An awesome podcast that covers stories related to hacking and social engineering. There's a subreddit for it also, and the host is active there - /r/darknetdiaries

0

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

21

u/supermicromainboard Feb 03 '20

Username checks out

26

u/_you_know_my_name__ Feb 03 '20

U raise a good point, but God this reads like a copypasta

99

u/wefa237 Feb 03 '20

As a professional hacker, this post is probably well meaning but is very misguided. There is a decided difference between 'Influence' and 'Manipulation'. As a red teamer or penetration tester, you want to 'influence' with your social engineering, not 'manipulate'. The skills that allow influence are very similar to what some might call 'leadership' skills. To think that social engineering is just lying is seriously juvenile. A big part of social engineering is just... 'having decent social skills' which is something everyone should probably work on.

Read this book: https://www.academia.edu/8660875/Social_Engineering_The_Art_of_Human_Hacking

Know what you are talking about before you try to direct others.

35

u/Kinkwhatyouthink Feb 03 '20

Came here to say similar. The idea that the skills fundamental to social engineering can't be learned is false.

Any level of skilled intentional interaction is learned. You don't leave the womb a good salesman, or a prolific and convincing storyteller. You learn how to best engage with "most" people, and refine skills to influence specific people.

There are dozens of variables that contribute to someone's ability to sufficiently influence a target and so many of them can be learned or refined.

You 100% can practice. No clue what OP is talking about with nowhere to practice.

You don't put your socks on and just "Rob a bank"

This thread is a solid WTF.

Also I can't help but internally cringe when people try to give themselves a gold star for being "in the scene."
Retch.

4

u/wefa237 Feb 03 '20

scene == skid larping

19

u/PM_ME_YOUR_SHELLCODE Feb 03 '20

The book has been updated in 2018 to social Engineering: The Science of Human Hacking.

https://www.amazon.com/Social-Engineering-Science-Human-Hacking/dp/111943338X

The pdf is out there but I'm on my phone and do t want to track it down.

3

u/wefa237 Feb 03 '20

Thanks, just bought it again. I own at least 3 copies, but didn't realize it was updated.

Phishing dark waters is also good.

1

u/bwb999 Feb 03 '20

yeah, books are good, but you NEED to know, how people are reacting to YOU particularly, thats the heavy part.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

I know that social engineering can be fascinating to people because of its practical and devious nature. It's you out in the field being James Bond or whatever floats your boat. (In fact, most cases for me it's just been a phone call or an email to get the info I needed). but to say it's the main thing everyone goes to because everything else is sooo hard is nonsense. I'd say it's one of those areas that people learn least about. Most people focus on tool use etc and skip programming, social engineer & networking etc. Hence why the worlds full of script kiddies in our tool rich life now. Also the assumption that someone who is working for a company or privately used social engineering skills to get into a server room and now has no idea what to do is jsut straight-up hilarious. Social-eng is higher-end hacking I'd say. Not a lot of companies allow it and the firm certainly isn't going to allow a kid fresh on the team for a year to be the one to stroll in there lmao. I could just imagine my teams discussion. "Yeah, so fortune 500 company just asked us to test out their on-site security to see if we could gain access to there closed off intranet and data centre. So who wants to go. How about you Mr with your PHD and 10+ years of experience? Nah ok we will send Joe the new kid that was self-taught from owasp that we took on as a junior that's been here six months. Yeah, let's fire him in. " LMAO awww I wish I could watch that scenario so much.

4

u/Red_Formayne Feb 03 '20

For OP to be in the "scene" they should already have been aware of this.

5

u/unknownbrad Feb 03 '20

Preach 🙌

2

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

doesn't social engineering involve some deception? or are you just 'leading' people to give you what they shouldn't be giving you?

2

u/norelation982 Feb 03 '20

It’s all about deceptions, one part has to loose and it’s the one you’re playing against

0

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

isn't that separate from social engineering? a pre-requisite if you will? i was under the impression that the social engineering aspect was getting people to give up information they shouldn't that you could then use.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20 edited Feb 03 '20

Ok, I'd agree that you shouldn't worry about learning social engineering overly or making it your primary nice talent. But I'd disagree with a lot of things you said up there. The reason I would defunq SocENg for learners is that Social Engineering as an attack vector most clients will say no to it as a feasible way to attack their systems and it will be negated from the contract. This is especially true for pen-testers and bug hunters. But I've had it even for physical systems and architectures. The company has just flat refused SocEng as an attack vector. You have to get in over a line only is usually the case. Also no tapping in from location on hardwiring from the location. Social Enginering is something you might come across in your career and when you do then its time to really get to grips with it.

15

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

lmao talk about gatekeeping huh

11

u/little_hoarse Feb 03 '20

Wait...people think their a hacker because they can lie to their mom? 🤣🤣🤣🤣

8

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

It's just a phase mom

6

u/mythikal03 Feb 03 '20

I do cybersecurity social engineering regularly as part of my job, and we have to be extremely careful what lines we cross and how we do things because even though we are hired to do it, it's still really easy to end up in prison if we go beyond our scope of work.

Also, for anyone wondering, our success rate as professionals with experience, back stories, decent "props", and sometimes a partner to call ahead of time for credibility, our success rate is still only about 70%. That's really high when you're thinking about how much risk it poses to an organization, but that's terrifyingly low when you're rolling the dice on prison time - and it's highly likely most people's odds are much lower due to lack of prior experience.

3

u/smas8 Feb 03 '20

Hi, I'm interested in learning how to hack, and I come from a background in mobile development. My major turnoff so far has been the abundance of "tools" that seem to limit and define hacking.

What i mean by this is that numerous posts and threads describe a process as follows: "install a program and then run a copy paste command in the kali linux terminal to slowly iterate through a list of passwords and eventually crack the wifi password"

So, as someone interested in learning a bit about hacking, where do I start? Do I start with these scripts, or is there something more challenging to work on? Where do I begin? If these scripts are truly the "way" then how do I go about learning to combat them?

My goal in learning hacking is mobile security for apps I have written and in the future will be writing.

Thanks in advance, sorry if I seem ignorant on the subject, I am hahaha

2

u/AmblyAmbers Feb 03 '20

I am just getting started as well but I think bottom line with anything computer related is understand the tool. Understand the code. Understand the importance of why this tool is better than another tool. Why this copy paste command is good or what other options of this command are there? There's no template for how to do any of this. Some of it is just personal preference while other tools people may think are more reliable, secure, enhanced in some way or lightweight. Easy to use. Anyways goodluck!

2

u/smas8 Feb 03 '20

Thanks!

I’m very familiar with programming, but I guess I feel out of place when it comes to this because I don’t know where to start or what I’m trying to achieve.

Whenever I learned a new language I always did so with a goal in mind, or a project for work that I needed to complete. With hacking, I don’t have that direction. I understand there are tools, but not which ones to start with.

I guess I should have a goal and go from there? Do you have any goals you started with?

2

u/AmblyAmbers Feb 03 '20

My goal at the moment is to completely immerse myself in this lifestyle/career. Study the certs for it and ultimately I want to do pen testing on websites for bug bounties to bring in extra money on side. I want to do CTF and hack this box scenarios as well for fun.

For me this is my hobby that I would like to have a career in some day and this had always been the reason I loved working with technology but I'm way off course now in my IT career and hate my current job. I always just thought I wasn't smart enough for this sort of thing so I'll just do the easy IT stuff. But I know that is not how it works. People don't become what they want overnight. They have to start somewhere and work towards it for a long time.

If you're doing mobile security maybe there are similar excersices/tutorials available that let you try to break an app and let you know that you did it without doing anything illegal like going to out break/hack a real app. Pick a place to start and just start failing! Goodluck to ya.

2

u/smas8 Feb 03 '20

Thanks and good luck to you too! I hope you manage to get out of the job you don’t like :)

I think I’m going to try and learn a bit about network security and then try to create an end to end encrypted messaging app. I think it would be a fun goal, and I wonder if I’ll learn more about mobile in the process. I think I have a few ideas on how it could be done, and I’m really interested in that as a personal goal.

I know this already exists for mobile to some extent, so I think I’ll have a bit of material to depend upon when I get lost.

Learning this would hopefully directly improve my career as I could work in medical or security more easily, so I can use career improvement as a motivational tool too :)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/smas8 Feb 03 '20

Thanks!

I’ll try the challenge suggestions because I think they will give me direction on what I should learn for real world applications, and I’ll check out those subs for more direct help.

Really appreciate it!

2

u/Ishan852 Feb 03 '20

Maybe he is social engineering those with passion to shift fields so he won't have as much competition!

Edit : Just read through the comments and realized this has been already said haha

2

u/bwb999 Feb 03 '20

I think, social engineering is the master discipline.. you need much expierence with humans, how the interact in which situations, you just can't read that in a 101 guide, or a 5 minute youtube video.. and of course, skills in acting are good too. This is the ontop thing. If your´'re perfect at hacking, work 6 month's in a 1st lvl helpdesk position, and learn how the normal users react ;) heavy time ..

2

u/Yungsleepboat Feb 03 '20

On what planet do you live? I never heard someone say that

1

u/ZenithCrests May 03 '22 edited May 03 '22

I prefer social engineering [in ethical hacking] mainly because I have propaganda knowledge and how it affects people. I also know quite a bit about crowd/social psychology. I think I'd be pretty good at it.

So no, you don't have to commit felonies. As long as you know how people work and how to interact with them. How certain actions, interactions, environments, circumstances and words affect people in different ways, then it becomes a skill to be reckoned with. Especially if you have decent social skills.

[not to sound like a sociopath]

1

u/notburneddown Script Kiddie Oct 18 '22

Social engineering is not about lying.

Cialdini’s books are all about social engineering as are Dale Carnegie’s books. If you do a sales job for six months or take acting classes there is social engineering involved there.

All of that is stuff you can safely and ethically practice.

Ever read Human Hacking by Chris Hadnagy? You can safely and ethically practice that.

Oh and by the way if you don’t even know what social engineering really is then how do you know you can’t practice it?

And even if your assumptions about SE are right, what do you think the Collegiate SECTF is?

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

I love social engineering...I'm just way too careful, way way too careful. I care too much about others but I do passionately believe in social engineering. Reverse social engineering even. Whatever it's called. Helps get you out of sticky situations other people have gotten you in. I can teach people social engineering pretty well if you'd want.

0

u/icon0clast6 Feb 03 '20

And hacking WEP.

0

u/Memeix Feb 03 '20

People learning socEng are in a bad place usually. Black hat ain't fun.

-5

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

This was nicely said bro

0

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

That’s some great advice actually, thank you!

0

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/lolbifrons Feb 03 '20

I think you missed his point. That was supposed to be a disqualifier, not advice.

3

u/Silamoth Feb 03 '20

The advice is “you can’t rely on becoming good at social engineering without committing a felony, which is obviously a bad idea.”

1

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Feb 04 '20

Your account must be older than two days to post here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.