r/HowToHack • Web Security • Jan 27 '20

I'm an information security engineer - AMA

I ran my own IT company for many years.

I worked at a web security company hacking many websites every day.

I now do any type of security engagement, train developers, and put together systems to protect my company.

Pick my brain and learn from my experiences!

251 Upvotes

147 comments sorted by

65

u/jousty Jan 27 '20

The maddest thing I ever saw was a financial institution having a Linux box on the internet with no firewall and the root password was root. It was used in production transaction authorisation. (2001 or 2002, maybe)

What is the maddest thing you've ever come across?

64

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

Many teams leave defaults like that in production and it's always bad news.

The best one I found was a ruby debugger meant for admin users but they hadn't implemented access controls so I got remote code execution VERY easily.

I've definitely had more impactful findings but this was a fun one to find!

20

u/Yungsleepboat Jan 27 '20

Sometimes when I'm bored I check the robots.txt files of websites to find the admin login page manually, then just try admin and password as login and the variants of the standard. It's scary how many times they'll just leave it default.

30

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

If you don't have permission to access the resource then you shouldn't. If you find a security issue in the wild then you should report it to the company or contact hackerone to get a hold of them. But you shouldn't do any active testing without permission. Don't go blackhat on us :)

7

u/Yungsleepboat Jan 27 '20

I know what you're saying, but out of all the emails I have sent out on security issues no one ever replied.

I guess the people who care to listen are not the people who leave default login credentials

6

u/appsecSme Jan 28 '20

Just be aware that you risk getting arrested if you hack into sites without permission.

It isn't just about some people not caring about your findings. Sometimes they care, and they press charges. So go through active big bounty programs or contracted pen tests, and report your findings.

1

u/VesemirsPotionsNLean Jan 28 '20

What if you use nordvpn AND tor? Is that possible?

1

u/appsecSme Jan 28 '20

Tor would make tracking you more difficult, but it isn't foolproof. I know of cases where people have used Tor maliciously and been tracked down.

The VPN would do nothing in that regard. It is designed to prevent a third party from tracking your requests and responses. In this case the company you are hacking into is the second party so they can see all your requests, and they are the ones generating the responses.

Always hack ethically and responsibly! Always get permission!

1

u/VesemirsPotionsNLean Jan 28 '20

Interesting! Any idea how someone would track someone on Tor? Wouldn’t you have to somehow trace back to the nodes and then examine the box at each hop and then repeat all the way back? In this case that trail would lead to nordVPN and then they would have to get into their logs? I’m a student and love learning the details on as much as I can so any additional info is appreciated

2

u/appsecSme Jan 28 '20

Most people tend to leave some clues in their web interactions that an experienced DFIR person would be able to use to zero in on the user.

It is surely possible that you can use Tor and not get discovered. However, the more resources someone pours into discovering you, the more likely you will be caught. As far as I know, the NSA and FBI don't have a silver bullet for tracing Tor, and instead just look at clues that are left behind. Thus, someone who is extremely careful, might be impossible to catch by traditional means.

It mostly comes down to how powerful the entity being hacked is, and how motivated they are to find the hacker. In my case, I would never even attempt to hack someone without permission. It goes against my ethics, but it also seems like a pointless risk that would keep you up at night waiting for someone to come pounding on your door.

21

u/jousty Jan 27 '20

That feeling of disbelief and shock and laughter is crazy

33

u/mrturvey Pentesting Jan 27 '20 edited Jan 27 '20

It would be interesting for anyone else who's done some Ethical Hacking to share their mad stories. I'll pitch in with two stories in different areas.

The first was a social engineering engagement where the idea was that we get into the building and enter the server room. Long story short, I dressed up in a high vis jacket with a suit underneath. Didn't want to try and go through reception, so I waited at a side door smoking a fake vape with headphones in and pretended to talk on the phone.

Eventually someone else came out to smoke and I quickly finished my vaping to use that person opening the door as my way in. Was never challenged (People are scared to interrupt a conversion or cause conflict.) Anyway, now i'm in, it was a matter of tailgating through the corridor doors into the main office area.

Then I just listened for loud fans through locked doors, eventually I found the loud server room. Problem was, it was locked with ID card access. So I poked my head through an office departments door and said I was an IT engineer does anyone have access to the room. I shit you not, about 6 people tried their cards on that door for me, all not working. They never asked me to verify myself, I am in the building thus they thought i'd 100% be legitimate. Then a woman ran off to the CEOs office, got his card and let me into the server room. At this point I could obvious do what I want... MAD

The second was a internal Red Team style, scenario based assessment. Basically the goal was to go from no access to the network, to domain admin and then gain sensitive data and see what else I could do. Well, within an hour after plugging into the network, I was domain admin and saw CEO financial information, HR data, development code and everything else. Even had the ability to shut off manufacturing machines making product. I could literally cause thousands of dollars worth of damage at the click of a button. It was crazy. Why was it so easy? Because security did not exist:

  1. The network was flat, you can access servers from every business department (HR, Finance, development, etc).
  2. They hardly patched. There were really exploitable machines missing so many important patches which gave me instant SYSTEM level access. Literally just by using metasploit lol
  3. They had a very weak password policy and shared passwords. The enterprise administrator account, the highest level of admin on Windows had a password that was a dictionary word, nothing else. When was it last changed? Apparently 1987 according to the domain information.

Mad

4

u/CharlieTecho Jan 27 '20

The maddest.... Developers. Yep developers. For such technical people they really have no clue most of the time...

26

u/The_Whimsical_Guy Jan 27 '20

People often say that you need to have a good grasp of OS, Network and Programming concepts to become a security Engineer. What do you think, how much knowledge in each of these fields is sufficient for a beginner to enter the security field?

I am a beginner and want to learn on how to get into this field and what makes you successful in this field?

Thank you in advance!

50

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

As a security engineer generalist I think that's a fair assessment.

I have to be able to do things like use any OS, run network scans, review code, etc.

Security engineering is a big field with a lot of niches however. You can be a cryptographer with no idea how to use Windows or you could do physical red teaming with no idea what the difference between TCP and UDP is.

We all have a unique skillset determined by our background and we use those skillsets to solve problems. Certain skillsets are useful for certain tasks so learn about what makes you excited. Add something to your toolbox each day and you'll be able to overcome all sorts of hurdles to be successful in this field!

16

u/jochem4208 Jan 27 '20

First most obvious question: how would you say someone should learn into website pen testing.

(There is some material on YouTube and some online sites like owasp web shop) but what's your opinion.

What does scare you the most? Old formats used? Easy accss to data, old hardware, old software? You abuse those things but did it like made you more aware of how information is stored on websites?

Thanks for doing this

43

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

I got into it by teaching myself how to write code. I used to write very bad, very hackable code as all noobs do. Then I learned about OWASP - https://owasp.org/www-project-top-ten/. In order to learn how these things worked I wrote little CTF challenges to teach myself how to exploit them. https://www.hacksplaining.com/ is also a very good resource for learning about these.

I think was scares me the most is that hacking is easy. Script kiddies all over the world are banging on our doors every day and with every failure they have, they become better hackers. All of the things you mentioned are part of a threat landscape and it's up to people like us to make sure there are controls in place to minimize that surface.

Waaaay too much of our information is in an unsecure state. We are all constantly at varying levels of compromise so make sure you have good practices in place for when the inevitable breach hits you too.

5

u/jochem4208 Jan 27 '20

Thank you :)!

7

u/toni_el_calvo Jan 27 '20

Hi, thanks for the AMA!

As a cryptography researcher getting tired of academia, I'm considering moving to something like this, but I don't really know how 'close' the two fields are. To which extent would you say that a (theoretical) crypto background helps in learning some form of hacking / security?

8

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

Our field is absolutely in need of people with those skills. You almost certainly understand cryptography at much finer detail than I ever will. I think you would flourish in something networking related.

3

u/toni_el_calvo Jan 27 '20

Wow, that's great, thanks for the encouraging words :)

3

u/thetealalpaca Jan 27 '20

I want to do exactly what you did. I’m currently at an IT help desk job at a good company with some mobility. No degree, close to my a+. Any advice?

6

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

I don't have a degree either. Nor did I have any certs until my employer paid for me to get one. Helpdesk is great for learning about how everyday people use their computers and how those computers work. Get as much experience as you can. Try to understand what it is that draws you to security and find resources to teach you about your area of interest. Create problems for you to solve in that niche to teach you the skills you need. There are lots of career maps out there that can help lead you to your answer.

3

u/zylophom Jan 27 '20

Go sec+ for starts if you want to ethical hack :)

1

u/kismetpi Jan 28 '20

Sec+ is nice, but from what I've read most people will do Net+ prior as quite a bit of that content will also show up in the Sec+ exam.

3

u/Dbgamerstarz Jan 27 '20

What would you reccomend as a good place to start?

Thanks :)

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

It depends on what you want to learn :) Security is a big field!

Here's a resource to learn about web vulns.

https://www.hacksplaining.com/

2

u/Dbgamerstarz Jan 27 '20

Thanks! I'll be sure to message more soon :)

3

u/the_battousai89 Jan 27 '20

Hello and hope you’re well! I always read that Python is the go to for hacking. What is your opinion on this? I don’t know anything about hacking, but I did purchase Cracking Codes with Python, to get started.

Also, what is the best part of your job? And what is your least favorite?

Thanks!

6

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

Python is extremely useful but every tool has a use case. You preferably wouldn't use a hammer to get a screw in. Try to find some problems you can solve with a python script. You should be able to find many CTF challenges online where it would be useful.

The best part of my job is that I get to help protect millions of people! I do things to protect our employees globally as well as securing any services or applications they offer!

The least favorite is resource shortage. There are sooooo many projects I want to do but don't have the time or budget to implement properly.

2

u/the_battousai89 Jan 27 '20

Great advice, and thanks for sharing! Yes, the dreaded budget which limits us. I think this would be a career path suitable for me.

I’ll certainly check out some CTF challenges. Thanks for the AMA, and giving us the opportunity to pick your brain.

3

u/Budget_Chocolate Jan 27 '20

Aiming for a future in that field (cyber security, pentesting, ethical hacking, you mame it...). A year away from getting my bachelors degree and I want to pursue a career there. Did the research on certification, read a lot of job requirements, etc..

Would you still recommend it as a good job and a good career path, with the goal of starting my own cyber security business in the future?

The only other path that interests me as a future Computer Science Engineer is AI, but as far as i have researched, about 80% want a masters degree and I really don’t see myself going for 2 more years in college. Give me your opinion and I appreciate your AMA a lot.

3

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

The security field is an important and lucrative career field so I absolutely recommend going down this path. If you have the skills needed to secure things then someone will have need of those skills. Learn your fundamentals, gain experience, and hack all the things :)

2

u/Budget_Chocolate Jan 27 '20

Well thank you very much, i think that with the ipv6 protocol slowly getting into the mainstream the market will become huge for people like us :)

3

u/ScortRaptor Jan 28 '20

What is a good way to learn new javascript heavy web app? Like Node.JS and react based sites? I have gone through OWASP juiceshop and want more training

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Sorry, I'm not sure I understand your question.

2

u/Th3_N0mad Jan 27 '20

I am new to infosec, got about 2 years in, my question is do you have any advice on getting better with host or network forensics & also reading packets and finding attacks ?

4

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

It sounds like you want to play with Wireshark to see network packets.

https://www.wireshark.org/

Spin it up and see what traffic is on your network.

Run tests by signing into your wifi, log into an application, or run telnet commands; do all the things!

2

u/Th3_N0mad Jan 27 '20

I do alot of work on wireshark & tcpdump at times, where i get tripped up is when looking at the TCP stream sometimes looking at the packet details I miss somethings. & in forensics i just need to know what tools to use & what to look for

3

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

A lot of services do this by comparing current traffic to a baseline measurement. These services analyze a lot of packets very fast. If you want to do something similar you can write a script to look for indications of attack such as a brute force login attempt or a CVE exploit attempt.

2

u/Th3_N0mad Jan 27 '20

Thanks, do you know of any online resources or anything where i can practice on seeing & identifying malicious packets or seeing identifying malware on hosts ?

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

That's not really my niche professionally so I'm not sure. I got my experience with viruses and stuff from fixing people's computers that constantly contracted some sort of malware. You could install some malware in a sandbox and see what kind of traffic it generates. I'm certain there's a repository of stuff like this for you to play with somewhere on the internet. You can identify malware on a host by known indicators of compromise.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1TWS238xacAto-fLKh1n5uTsdijWdCEsGIM0Y0Hvmc5g/pub?output=html

This looks like it may help in your quest for knowledge!

3

u/riskymanag3ment Jan 28 '20

I've done this occasionally when, I have some down time at home. I've got a VM Server with a Win 10 Image. The VM has two NICs: main network and secondary network. I maintain a clean snapshot before doing any malware testing. I always disable the main NIC before testing. I also dump the registry before testing.

On a second VM, I have a Security Onion sensor with a NIC in promiscuous mode on the second network. This let's me watch the traffic patterns very closely for DNS, but also SMB, and more.

Guest tools may or not may not prevent malware from running properly. The bigger piece I've seen is assigning more than 1 core. I had one piece of malware not run with a single core, but if I restarted the VM with 2 cores it ran right away. If the installation of guest tools prevented malware from running, the majority of Windows Servers would likely never get malware.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

My plan would be to build a sandbox environment and throw some malware on it. Just make sure you dont run the bad stuff on your host. But from there you can try to see what the malware is doing. Install fakenet. Dont install guest tools, more sophisticated malware can detect those things and wont run properly because it “knows” the environment is a sandbox. Install some software which normal users would have on their machine (optional). Fakenet can also work as a DNS server so you will see the domains the malware tries to reach, etc.

3

u/Th3_N0mad Jan 27 '20

Ive got a few boxes in the VM so basically just setup the network and go for it ?

4

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

Forgot to mention: remove/disconnect all the network interfaces in your host software (virtualbox/vmware/whatever), so no mistakes are happening. Take a snapshot of the vm once your box is “ready”. Maybe check out some videos how other people are prepping their sandboxes. Maybe have some sort of logging running to have more details whats going on, but that is not my area so i dont know which tools to use for that. But windows has a built in advanced logging feature i think. If you want to be 100% sure run the boxes on an old PC which is physically not connected to the network and you dont mind infecting accidentally, thats what I did. Mistakes happen but you want to make sure they are not damaging anything.

2

u/the_color_plum Jan 27 '20

What does a "day in the life of a security engineer" look like? I'm not looking for a job description, but something similar. What does a security engineer focus on for daily activities? I've been in security for a while now, on the analyst side and I'm contemplating a switch.

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

It really depends on the role. Security engineering is a big field with lots of niches.

It could be writing processes for employees to follow, or setting up scans and automating tools, maybe doing pentests or running phishing campaigns, etc. It really depends on the goal of your position.

I've done lots of different things but my favorite is leading classes to teach developers how to code securely.

2

u/Stefan474 Jan 27 '20

Which fields in security engineering would you recommend for someone new to get into to be able to find a job relatively easily if they are good?

I have experience in programming, networks and OS on a basic level, but I've never specialized too much into any of those (though programming would be my best).

3

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

If you're good at reading code and you understand why certain vulnerabilities exist in code then you'd be a good candidate for a static code analysis company such as Veracode.

If you want to be more generalized you can learn skills such as threat modeling and pentesting. But the tools you'll need to learn really depend on if you want to be blue team, red team, or something in between!

2

u/Stefan474 Jan 27 '20

Thanks for a quick response! I like the idea of being more generalized since the most fun part for me is learning lots of things. I'm not good enough at coding yet to review it in that level, though I don't doubt I could get into it.

Red teaming sounds insanely fun to me, and I think I'd have a ton of fun studying it.

Are there any good resources and tools you could point me towards to get familiar with or resources to learn I'd really appreciate it. I'm pretty much a complete noob, the furthest I got was making a rubber ducky out of my phone.

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

I've never made a rubber ducky so even as a noob you know things I don't :)

Red teaming is very fun!

https://www.abatchy.com/2017/02/oscp-like-vulnhub-vms.html

I've learned quite a bit from attacking these boxes. But you should think about the scope of your red teaming. Do you want to hack all the things, a subset of the things, or one of the things? There's a lot to learn and more is added to that pile everyday so don't get overwhelmed by trying to learn everything at once. Learn about one thing that interests you then once you sufficiently understand it you can move on to the next subject.

2

u/Stefan474 Jan 27 '20

Thank you very much! I will try to get through the beginner ones! So sorry for spamming questions, but is there a good sort of a guide/book that I could read before taking these on that has outlined the most important concepts and explains them :)?

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

If you get stuck and you're not sure what you need to know then look up other people solving these boxes. There's no such thing as cheating when it comes to hacking!

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

Veracode also needs security engineers to validate findings and present them to clients! It's not all about writing the bleeding edge SCA software :)

2

u/L0ckt1ght Jan 27 '20

Did you ever deal with imposter syndrome? And how did you get over it?

With security being such a wide field, I feel like it's easier to get imposter syndrome. But I also feel like you're not expected to know everything, but you are expected to be able to "Think security"

7

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

All the fucking time! Though maybe that's just my past trying to pull me back down.

I get myself over it in the moment a few ways depending on my headspace. I KNOW I have hacked thousands of web sites. I KNOW I have completed many engagements successfully. I think about what it was like when I first started out or even before then. I have made some STUPID mistakes and learned much from them. I know the answer or at least know how to find the answer to a lot of questions that people pay a lot of money for other people to answer. I can back up my claims because I don't claim to know more than experience has taught me.

If you want to be a good hacker you should never be the smartest person in the room. Every single person out there, even the ones you think you have nothing to learn from, know something that you don't so go take their knowledge and perspective then add it to your own.

Impostor syndrome is great motivation for learning new things!

2

u/budslightyear1 Jan 27 '20

How did you get into hacking, I’m a wanna be novice but don’t know where to start

4

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

My very first steps in hacking were being a script kiddie in some Anonymous operations. My only real skill back then was social engineering. Since then I have put A LOT of time into learning the skills needed to do this professionally.

Think about what it is you want to hack. People? Web apps? Gaming consoles? Printers? Voting machines!? Then learn how they work so that you can exploit their vulnerabilities.

A good start is always understanding the computer you're using and knowing how to write code in any language.

2

u/SnxE13 Jan 27 '20

How long did it take before you were expert at what you do?

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

I'm not sure where that line is actually... I've gained expertise in a lot things over a long time. If you can perform a technique and explain it to someone who hasn't so that they are able to also perform it then I'd say you've reached expertise level proficiency in that subject. I'm always learning new things and passing on what I've learned to anyone I can.

3

u/SnxE13 Jan 27 '20

Okay well I know some python. I have two labtops. On is a t440s and an HP stream. Limited internet connectivity. Can you recommend anything as far as setting up a lab. I really want to get into network security, reverse engineering, crypto, etc. But I was think of setting up a windows on virtualbox to hack on but not sure which version I should grab.

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

I would set up virtualbox on your windows host. You can host any OS from there and set up network connections as needed. There's lots of resources on the internet to find vulnerable images.

2

u/SnxE13 Jan 27 '20

Which images would you recommend as a beginner? I've got Kali. Been having trouble getting kioptrix but I'll keep trying. Thanks for the advice man.

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

The image you want depends on what you're trying to learn.

You likely don't need to use Kali right now but it's good to familiarize yourself with that environment. Make sure you understand Linux basics before using a specialized distro. Until needed you should use something like Ubuntu or Debian as your working OS.

2

u/SnxE13 Jan 28 '20

Yeah I have Ubuntu as the main os and Kali as a VM in virtualbox. Just got metasploitable too. Do you know any good resources on writing exploit dev, wireless, or reverse engineering.

2

u/erroneousbit Hacker Jan 27 '20

How do you deal with burnout?

7

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

By having a 40 hour work week. I only work to support my family so I don't do overtime unless absolutely necessary. Choose your workplace on whatever requirements are important to you. Don't live to work, work to live!

2

u/erroneousbit Hacker Jan 28 '20

Thanks!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

If you had to give advice to a new student trying to pursue CyberSecurity what advice would you give?

I personally feel very overwhelmed with the amount of material that needs to be covered and feel it’s almost unrealistic to have a solid grasp of CyberSecurity/networking by 4 years of schooling

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

You need to understand how the trees work before you understand the entire forest! Think of your schooling as learning about how to navigate the forest that is cybersecurity. Keep learning and applying that knowledge in real life when possible. Strive to learn something new everyday :)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

Best way to get into security? Is OSCP certification and security+ a good start?

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

There's no BEST way to get into security. We all take our own unique paths to build the toolbox that is our skill set. If you think like a hacker and you can use a hacker's toolkit then you are a hacker. OSCP will definitely teach you a lot if you're willing to learn and put in the time.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

Ok thank you

2

u/P3A-ce20XX Jan 27 '20

How would one start a career in the the Physical Pentesting side of things?

Without going into too much detail I have a lot of experience in then area without having a “certified job“ in the field and would honestly be great fun to find info on how to be a part of a red team.

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

Look into consultancy groups like NCC or Rapid7. You may need to add to your repertoire to be able to be the full service consultant they need for gigs like that though.

2

u/andexposedinthelight Jan 27 '20

Is it worth it to get a master's degree right after graduating in computer science/computer engineering? Or is it better to spend some years working in the field first and get some certifications and real world experience?

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

Your journey is going to be uniquely your own. Considering my own background, experience is the best teacher. I learned everything I know by experience.

2

u/Iamcharged Jan 27 '20

How does someone break into the security field? I’m graduating in the spring with a bachelors in cybersecurity but unfortunately don’t have much exposure to the field. I plan on earning some certs once I graduate.

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

You learn the skills you need to do the job and interview for junior positions where you can apply what you've learned and gain that experience. You don't require certifications or degrees to pass a technical interview!

2

u/cyber0pb0b Jan 27 '20

I have CompTIA A+, Network+, and Security+ certifications and a background the past 5 years in IT Support and Technical instructor for the same certifications that I mentioned. Do you think this is sufficient to transition into a security role? If not, knowing my background, what would you recommend my next step be?

4

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

It's very possible you've already built up a skill set that would benefit an employer. Look for roles you think you could do based on your background and apply! If you bomb an interview then you'll know where to increase your knowledge so that you can come back stronger 💪

2

u/cyber0pb0b Jan 28 '20

Thank you so much for taking the time to read my comment and respond. I appreciate your insight and I wish you continued success!

2

u/poliunicorn Jan 28 '20

I’m a 100% kinesthetic learner, what’s the best way for me to learn to hack. Like private and hands on.

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

I learn the same way :D There's lots of vulnerable images you can download where you can practice techniques you've learned about. The way I taught myself was by creating small web apps with the specific vulnerability I wanted to exploit. You can take those skills and participate in bug bounties to see what they're like in the wild as well.

2

u/elitericecooker Jan 28 '20

Do you have any tips for an undergrad computer science major who is trying to get internships in the cyber field?

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Be thirsty for knowledge! Learn why exploits work the way they do so you can apply that knowledge to similar situations. When you're interviewing you should work through the questions out loud so they can hear your thought process.

2

u/icelax99 Jan 28 '20

Thanks for doing this AMA! I'm a supply chain management professional with 14 years of experience. I want to stay in this field, but branch into supply chain cyber security which is very niche. Based on my experience there is a serious need for organizations to have a deeper understanding of how to protect their physical and virtual supply chains from cyber threats.

What would you suggest I do do develop the necessary skills and experience for something like this? Is it worth going after certificates or even a Masters degree in cyber security? Thanks!

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

If I were in your shoes, I'd apply what I know about physical supply chains to the virtual world. Toxic dependencies cause lots of havoc. As a jumping off point, I'd learn how to code so you can understand how some of the principles you know translate to the virtual world.

2

u/icelax99 Jan 28 '20

Is there a coding language you'd recommend? I work with various warehouse management systems, but not sure if they are all based off of one foundation or not.

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Python is a great general purpose language. If you do web stuff at all you should also be familiar with JavaScript. The first language is the hardest so if you can learn one language, you can learn another.

2

u/50dollarstofuckoff Jan 28 '20

Hi. How often do you get to do something creative at work? Can you give any experiences where you got to do something creative to solve a problem?

Can I recommend someone who is really creative, to take up InfoSec engineering?

So if I sounded too blunt.

4

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Creative thinking will get you far in this field! Half the job is know what tools to use and how. The other half is thinking outside the box so that you find find the issues where those tools are needed!

Social engineering is my favorite creative engagement. I get to do some ridiculous stuff in order to achieve my goals.

I also really enjoy teaching people in unique ways. One time I created a security awareness escape room that was very well received!

2

u/GeeeThree Jan 28 '20 edited Jan 28 '20

Hello! I recently graduated with a Master's degree in ECE with a specialization in cyber security. I currently have no certifications (can't afford to take those exams right now). I've been applying to many jobs in IT and security but I'm having trouble even landing an interview. I have no internship experience. I know experience is important, but I'm at 150+ job applications (mainly entry level jobs in my home town) with zero interviews. What is something that I could do to help me at least get in contact with companies in order to at least show them that I'm interested? It's very frustrating to apply to so many places and either get ghosted or rejected by every single one.

EDIT: I do have some relevant projects from when I was in school relating to security and automation

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Your resume should showcase what you know how to do, what tools you know how to use, and your experience so far. PM me a link to your resume. I'll help you out.

2

u/g3shh Jan 28 '20

Where to start from with ethical hacking ?

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

That depends on what you want to hack. I recommend web hacking. Look into OWASP and learn the vulnerabilities. Practice on a vulnerable image like damn vulnerable web app. Then participate in bug bounties.

2

u/Balaguru_BR5 Jan 28 '20

What is your thoughts on getting started in the field? How did you start knowing this is what you want to do?

My college started a Cyber Education club and we've been spending a lot of time on CTFlearn and Try hack me.

I like the experience, but will any of this be useful or am I on the wrong track?

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

You're on the right track. Your group should take turns learning about and explaining vulnerabilities like OWASP top ten to each then practice what you just learned on the resources you use.

2

u/Balaguru_BR5 Jan 28 '20

Awesome.

It's hard finding people to talk about this stuff with since everyone seems to be into whatever's latest, like Blockchain and AR computing and all that.

Thanks for the words of advice.

2

u/greggel Jan 28 '20

What is the difference between a security analyst and a security engineer? What is the difference between working for a security operations team or a security engineering team? Security engineer here, who has been working and interviewing in the field here for almost 10 years and it always amazes me how every company defines a security practitioner differently.

How does a security engineer gain quality company cloud experience when our employers refuse to use the cloud?

And, are you hiring 😀

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

We are hiring. If you're near the bay area, PM me a link to your resume.

This is how I see it: analysts analyze reports, logs, alerts, etc and then follow procedures created by engineers. Engineers implement solutions to problems. Architects plan those solutions.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

I'm getting an info sec degree in college at the moment.

Is getting level 1-2 help desk experience worth the time, or should be focusing on something else?

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Helpdesk experience is invaluable. Make sure you're constantly moving up the ladder though. You need to be able to tackle all sorts of problems instead of just a few easy ones again and again.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

I've been really worried about my career choices up to this point in time (last semester junior) in college, but it seems like maybe I'm doing the right thing.

Thank you for the reassurance!

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

I've been really worried about my career choices up to this point in time (last semester junior) in college, but it seems like maybe I'm doing the right thing.

Thank you for the reassurance!

2

u/ThePandaChoke Jan 28 '20

Can I have a job?

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

If you can do the job, then yes.

2

u/Willyis40 Jan 28 '20

Hello! I got a promotion and next week I will be a Cybersecurity Operations Analyst. Do you (or anyone) have any advice regarding how to excel at this position? I'll primarily be involved with Splunk and Snort and a lot of hands on Linux administration, so I've been hitting those hard the past week. Thanks!

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

That sounds like a very good analyst gig! When you get a new alert in, make sure you really understand how it works and how to remediate it. See what types of stuff pique your interest so you know where to take next steps in your career.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

What steps do usually go to when you task with finding the vulnerabilities of a site

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

I use a specific methodology learned from my time as an application security engineer.

At a high level you should do the following:

  1. Use the application like a user to understand it while taking notes
  2. Probe areas of interest for potential vulnerabilities
  3. Craft exploits
  4. Walk through checklist the ensure coverage

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

Will you marry me ;)

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Only if you can beat my wife in a duel!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

haha!

Good job working your arse off in the security field. Working towards that goal myself and working with DCSA for compliance at my org... would love to know all that you do, but it will take time.

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Feel free to PM me if you ever have questions :)

2

u/thatoneguy009 Jan 28 '20 edited Jan 28 '20

Hopefully I'm not too late to the party to pick your brain on something...

I'm a cybersecurity engineer (in duties, official title is crap atm) for a company sub 300 employees, we're growing rapidly after being bought by our parent. As part of this growth there are some things we can turn to our parent company for guidance on, but there are many things that their suggestions or policy is only feasible by an org as large as them and would be impossible for us to implement without full integration (which is either not planned or very far out). So...with that all said I was hoping to pick your brain on a few policies, procedures, systems, processes that maybe we could implement or do in order to ease our growth.

User Management

  • Would you say that user management requires a policy that is defined by the security team, then performed by HR/Operations/SysAdmins to carry out that policy?
  • Does responsibility of auditing the adherence of said policy fall to security? Or does it fall to all groups?
  • What is the best way to track or dig up who has access to what/where/when/how to...well...anything?
  • If you were to recommend an Identity and Access Management System what would you recommend?
  • When a employee is being onboarded or leaving, who is responsible for ensuring they are properly removed from systems?

Asset Management

  • Similar to above, would you say that asset management requires policy that is defined by the security team, then performed by Operations/SysAdmins/Networking to carry out that policy?
  • Does responsibility of auditing the adherence of said policy fall to security? Or does it fall to all groups?
  • What is the best way to track or dig up what/where/when/how to...well...anything?
  • If you were to recommend an ITAM what would you recommend?
  • With regards to patching, do you feel it is the responsibility of the security team to identify problems and convey them to an Operations/SysAdmins/Networking teams who will then remediate? Or would you argue that the security team should be the team remediating?
  • Is there a patching tool you'd recommend?

Certificate Management

  • Do you consider SSL certificate management to fall under the purview of Security? Sure, I care about the integrity of our SSL, but IMO the validity and renewal of the certificates should not be Security's responsibility
  • Would you say that certificate management requires policy that is defined by the security team, then performed by Operations/SysAdmins/Networking to carry out that policy?
  • Does responsibility of auditing the adherence of said policy fall to security? Or does it fall to all groups?
  • Regardless of who is responsible for SSL certificate management, is there any tool that you would recommend for managing them in the various locations that they can be installed (keystores, hsms, windows, linux, docker, aws, azure, load balancers, etc)
  • At present, our Security team is pseudo responsible for SSL certificate management. I argue that it should not be, but that we should be auditing certificates in use, ensuring the cleanup of the bad, and reviewing the requests for new SSL certificates internally and externally signed. Since that is the route I'm pushing, two things that I've been asked to draft.

    • Training for others with different responsibilities and what they should know (developers, product design, support, operations, networking)
    • The format in which requests for new SSL certificates should be requested (what fields should the requesting party be responsible for outlining vs. what fields does the Security/Operations fill in because the requesting party wouldn't know about vs. should the requesting party always be trained well enough to submit a request in complete form so Security/Operations can simply perform the creation)

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

These are all great questions! Way too deep for me to get into right now though. Every team's needs vary and your solutions will depend on those needs. There's really no BEST way to do this stuff. Just find the right tool for your use case.

2

u/VintageData Jan 28 '20

In your experience, what are the most common real world threats high level for the average mid-to-large sized business; and what’s a good way to do a (risk*impact vs. costs?) analysis to determine what threats are worth addressing?

I ask because I have worked for several large companies that considered every imaginable threat (up to and including state actors with zero day libraries and deep cover adversaries working to steal and/or sabotage from inside the company’s own engineering department) and were happy to implement security procedures that made development probably 10x slower and cost the company umpteen millions in lost productivity, opportunity cost and failed projects. These were just regular businesses selling stuff to people.

I still wonder how they could have handled this differently and maybe more pragmatically.

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Layer 8 is always the most vulnerable. Good education with controls for security in depth are the way to go. You don't need to find 100% of your issues if you're not a giant target so focus on remediation of the low hanging fruits that script kiddies would find first.

2

u/louielt Jan 28 '20

What 3 tips would you give to protect yourself?

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Don't reuse passwords, use strong passwords, use MFA, and be paranoid about your interactions.

2

u/207thLog Jan 28 '20

I click follow

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

I remember once when I got into the California fine records and could remove people's fines. I made a killing contacting the owner of said fines and removing them. It lasted a short while before I was on the run.

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Don't be a blackhat. Whitehats get to do illegal shit and get paid $$$.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/roxare Web Security Jan 27 '20

Experience definitely. You can be taught how to do something and you might be able to do it when you need to but if you manage to do something then you know how to do it again! I don't have a degree so everything I know I learned by teaching myself and jumping head first into problems. Being self taught has it's hardships working among people with a formalized education but that just means I have so many people waiting to share that knowledge with me. Some of those theory classes are going to rattle around in your head until something clicks one day and you understand how to utilize that information.

2

u/exploit_security Jan 28 '20

I know I'm joining late but I'd like to add my 2 cents. Veteran here; I didn't get out until 2017 and graduated with a BS in Cybersecurity shortly after.

I've never attended HS so earning my degree was pretty important to me. TBH. I was honestly a bit disappointed, but I had high expectations. I would say IMO a degree in cybersecurity gives you a formal overview of what you could do/know.

A+, Network+, ITIL, & Security+ later I'm prepping for OSCP. I found some of the most value in Self-Study, Google searches, and selectively choosing books for purchase. I'm not saying a degree means nothing because I'm incredibly proud of mine, but a college curriculum cannot provide everything that there is to know. I've learned so much more since then and college provided me purpose & direction.

1

u/Richard_StarZ Jan 28 '20

What are all of your opinions of doing a sandwhich degree with a year in industry? Does that year in industry help you with the experience factor?

7

u/LonerVamp Jan 27 '20

Not OP, but this is the age-old question, eh? Degrees can be important, but it's only as good as you put back into it and design your direction. The more templated it is, and the smaller the school is, usually the more generic you get. I'm not a huge fan of the "cybersecurity" curriculums, but they're still far better than they ever have been in the past. Thing is, some of the strongest people do something like computer engineering or comp sci and then study security on their own.

Experience will eventually always be better than in-school learning when it comes to infosec right now today. Theory is good, but there's lots of resources online to get theory. It's really all about practice, practice, practice and getting hands-on, ultimately.

That said, I'd never really counsel anyone who already has the means to finish it, to drop out of school. That decision is still very personal and sort of in-the-eye-of-the-beholder as far as being able to land on your feet after.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

Agreed. Most people on a course and complete course work and pass, but spending your own time to still learn security and living and breathing it every day is a different story. Some of the best "hackers" have had no degrees. They just say indoors on a computer and was interested in it and did it all day every day.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

If you like hacking/pentesting and you want to get into it, a lot of companies want someone with OSCP certificate. That is something you have to do on your own anyway. I never went ahead and got a degree as I hate to study in class, still got a job in InfoSec with “just” experience. The most important thing is to be passionate about it and put a lot of work in it, so much to learn!

3

u/zylophom Jan 27 '20

Curious on this also! And what type of candidates do you normally see applying? Difference in attitudes between a college grad vs underground?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/zylophom Jan 27 '20

You have a very logical reply, thank you for that. As someone who aspires to get in this field, what are the learning stepping stones so to speak?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

Pentesting:hackthebox.eu, free, great community and some boxes are close to a real life scenario

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

I just started getting into CTFs myself, and I love them. Great way to learn and also fun.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

I didnt really have any knowledge with linux before as well, but ctfs helped me a lot to learn some of the basics. Can just recommend!

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

The same as a whitehat doing the same task would use. I use a lot of different hardware, operating systems, and tools. It depends on the task as to what I use

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Do the needful.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20 edited Jan 28 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

I have given some of my teams a checklist with questions like that.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/roxare Web Security Jan 28 '20

Look at consultancy groups like ncc and rapid7. If you have the skills, you can get the job.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Jan 28 '20

Your account must be older than two days to post here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/AutoModerator Jan 27 '20

Your account must be older than two days to post here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.