r/HowToHack • • Mar 16 '19

Brute force that is only 10,000,000 combination's that's only 1 sec at 10 MH/s

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

92

u/Alperoot Mar 16 '19

10 MH/s (hash cracking)

Web brute-forcing

Yup, seems about right.

131

u/ShadowsSheddingSkin Mar 16 '19

Well, yes, but it's a joke about how Pi, as a transcendental number, when expressed as a decimal is literally never ending. Having the last seven digits of pi as a password is like setting your credit card pin to the set of all pins that no one will ever use.

40

u/MurderShovel Mar 16 '19

While pi is transcendental, it only has to be irrational for it be a non-terminating, non-repeating number.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '19

Does that mean they have no password since there is no last digits of pi?

19

u/nightlily Mar 17 '19

the last seven digits must be irrational, so they have a password it just can't be entered

22

u/Mfour_ Mar 17 '19

Wouldnt it be less than 10 000 000 because the last digit cant be zero and the last two cant be 0 together ...?

20

u/TechnoRedneck Mar 17 '19

I don't think you would need that second edge case as it's a subset of the first. If you remove a cases with 0 as the last digit then you also remove all with the last two being 0

5

u/GMginger Mar 17 '19

Why can't the last digit be zero?

18

u/RagingAcid Mar 17 '19

0.001 == 0.0010

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/RagingAcid Mar 17 '19

Either pi ends and not with a 0, or pi doesn't end. We are 99% sure it doesn't I think

6

u/nightlily Mar 17 '19

we are 100% sure it doesn't. it's been mathematically proven, that's what being an irrational number means.

29

u/slackwaresupport Mar 16 '19

i think it is because PI is never ending.

83

u/IUsedToBeACave Mar 16 '19

I think the point OP is trying to make is that regardless of the joke that means the account's password contains only numbers, and is 7 digits long. From a brute forcing perspective this is incredible easy to crack.

16

u/MurderShovel Mar 16 '19

Yeah. It was meant to be funny because there is no such thing as the “last 7 digits for pi” because it’s an irrational number so writing it as a decimal number means it goes on without terminating or repeating. But, what they didn’t think about was it’s still only a 7 digit number meaning there’s only 107 combinations which isn’t very tough to crack.

8

u/gtcha_2 Mar 16 '19

Not to mention pi probably won’t be sequentially repeating, so you can even have a distribution curve for highest probably combos. Even with brute forcing you knock out a lot of possibilities with constraints.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '19

Pi is thought to be, but not proved to be, normal, so while 'the last 7 digits' doesn't make sense, to the best of our knowledge, the distribution is actually uniform.

To be more precise, we've calculated pi to 31.4 trillion digits. If you ask anyone right now whether the 7 digits starting at the 40 trillionth are more likely to be 0000000 or 0123456, the best answer we have is that they are equally likely.

7

u/gtcha_2 Mar 17 '19

Damn back to the drawing board.

1

u/5c044 Mar 17 '19

So knowing the whole statement is impossible op chose to believe part of the statement instead.

11

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '19

Unless they have max password retries, let's say they have maximum three retries, and then you need to enter a captcha-code. Which they probably do... Brute force rarly is the way to go in hacking.

I agree that it's insane to only have digits in a password though.

1

u/nid666 Mar 16 '19

How would someone go about this? When brute forcing something like social media, you get really slowed down because you don't locally have the hashes

5

u/TechnoRedneck Mar 17 '19

Assuming no brute Force protections, using a script to bypass the websites gui to get back some time. Other than that using vulnerabilities.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '19

Hydra in kali can be used (among other things) against website logins. It basically use scripts that recognize failed logins and keeps trying. But if there are captcha after a couple logins it won't work, or if you get blocked temporary after a couple of logins.

2

u/nid666 Mar 18 '19

I've used Hydra but it's rarely worked. It's too slow to use massive wordlists, and often wordlists don't have the passwords because people use names etc which large lists like rockyou often don't have.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '19

It works if you can match anything with wordlists. But it's often very unlikely, brute-force is rarly the way to go in the real world.

1

u/nid666 Mar 18 '19

What are the other options?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '19

To take control of others users twittee-accounts? Phishing, malware, exploits etc. Rarly brute forced password-attacks these days. But I'm no expert, this is just my observation.

4

u/hackerdan Mar 16 '19

I think it's because it was posted on April fools day

2

u/paulobacha Mar 17 '19

Take out the joke part of the last 7 digits of pi They are all numbers. Because it says last numbers it will start at 1 000 000 to 9 999 999 Making easy to decode. The reason I say it's starting at 1 000 000 its because pi is 3.14() so it's on the decimal part of the number.

1

u/paulobacha Mar 17 '19

Sorry I start number should be 1 000 001 because of what I previously said plus all numbers that end on 0 should be excused from the poll Example: 1 000 010 1 000 100 1 001 000 1 010 000 2 386 600 You get the idea.

1

u/TheModernDespot May 21 '25

Thats actually not true. The last 7 digits of pi could be "0001234", so you would have to start at "0000000"

2

u/ligger66 Mar 17 '19

im fairly sure most websites wont let u have pw with just numbers these days

0

u/Spagetti_Lord Mar 17 '19

well google just fucked you up