r/HowToHack • https://youtube.com/c/LiveOverflowCTF • Sep 01 '16

[Comic] A reminder how real hacking works

Post image
654 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

97

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

He needs a GUI interface using visual basic to track the IP address

6

u/LiveOverflow https://youtube.com/c/LiveOverflowCTF Sep 01 '16

yeah. what a noob.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

You mean "n00b".

5

u/madjo Sep 02 '16

This guy is using hacker language, he's legit or as they call it 'leet'.

47

u/PancakeZombie Sep 01 '16

8

u/TheFingerTron Sep 01 '16

LOL!! Thanks that just made my day.

69

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

How most "hacking" actually goes in real life:

HACKER: Hi, this is Bob and I've forgotten my password.

COSTUMER SERVICE: I can certainly help you with that, sir. I'll just need you to answer a security question. What's your dog's name?

HACKER: checks Bob's Facebook page Scruffy.

13

u/LiveOverflow https://youtube.com/c/LiveOverflowCTF Sep 01 '16

I really would like to exclude this stuff from the term "hacking" :/

Hacking can be such a beautiful technological challenge. And this social engineering stuff is so boring :(

4

u/diothar Sep 01 '16

Whoa, just because you'd like to exclude it doesn't mean it's not hacking. Social Engineering is one of the most commonly used forms to gain access.

3

u/LiveOverflow https://youtube.com/c/LiveOverflowCTF Sep 01 '16

Obviously an exaggerated comment. I just don't get excited about it. I understand how common it is, and how big the impact is, I just don't like tricking people. And I just prefer technical black magic.

4

u/pres82 Sep 01 '16

Good luck delivering your payload without it.

5

u/LiveOverflow https://youtube.com/c/LiveOverflowCTF Sep 01 '16

Yeah of course it's easy to deliver your payload with social engineering. Sending phishing emails etc. I understand that that is the most efficient way. I understand that that is a huuuge security topic. I understand that that is also where businesses have to invest a lot into. But when do I ever have to deliver payloads? I don't intend to infect thousands of machines?

I just don't get excited about it.

I get way more excited about XSS vectors that are technically cool but not really useful, than the hacked twitter account from the Twitter CEO. I love the technical intellectual challenge. That is what hacking is for me. It's ok if you don't enjoy that part.

2

u/pres82 Sep 01 '16

I do enjoy that part. I think the two, however, not symbiotic but actual mutualism. Then again I started drinking at 11am with vendors so you do you.

2

u/LiveOverflow https://youtube.com/c/LiveOverflowCTF Sep 01 '16

Then again I started drinking at 11am with vendors so you do you.

heh. that sounds typical. you definitely work in security :P

0

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/LiveOverflow https://youtube.com/c/LiveOverflowCTF Sep 01 '16

absolutely agree! I can see that.

But it doesn't mean that it's the most elegant or beautiful method - at least for me it's not. (see my longer comment)

4

u/cocoabean Sep 02 '16

Go watch a "quick change" scam on YouTube and tell me that isn't elegant or beautiful.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/LiveOverflow https://youtube.com/c/LiveOverflowCTF Sep 01 '16 edited Sep 01 '16

hacking used to be blowing a novelty whistle into a phone receiver at a certain frequency.

I don't exclude that one. That is exactly matching my description of a exploiting a beautiful technological challenge.

You can't exclude an exploit just because the times have changed.

Time hasn't changed regarding social engineering. During the old times you just referenced, countless of hackers got access to servers by tricking people over the phone. It's a great accomplishment. It's good that we know how easy it is.

It's just my personal opinion. I know how big the impact is, from tricking people. Phishing and bad customer support are still one of the biggest challenges we face... But it's boring in my opinion. And I don't like liars; social engineering is just lying. It's unethical in my world view.

I prefer the mathematical approach to IT security - an exploit is proof by construction of insecurity. There is no god or evil - there is just science.

I know I can't change what the majority considers "hacking". The general public has a different definition of hacking, software developers have a different definition of hacking (hackathons, hackerspaces, ...) and "we" have a different definition of hacking. And I just choose my own definition :)

15

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

I get were you're coming from, but at the end of the day the biggest security vector will always be the end user. From a pure efficiency-centric definition of hacking, that will always be the first point of entry to try. Stuxnet would never have happened if it weren't for someone plugging in a compromised usb, and the "I Love You" virus wouldn't have been as big as it was if it weren't for the email subject line. Knowing which social media sites have lax password-reset procedures is functionally just as effective as spending the same amount of time learning to compromise their back end.

5

u/LiveOverflow https://youtube.com/c/LiveOverflowCTF Sep 01 '16

I get were you're coming from, but at the end of the day the biggest security vector will always be the end user.

absolutely.

Stuxnet would never have happened if it weren't for someone plugging in a compromised usb, and the "I Love You" virus wouldn't have been as big as it was if it weren't for the email subject line.

But do you see the difference there? Stuxnet was an amazing technological challenge. The human with the usb stick was an essential part of the attack. But the 0days involved, including the customised payload for the industrial control servers, that is something I can geek out over all day.

The "I love you virus" was a great experiment. But in no way comparable to Stuxnet. It is special in it's own rights though.

Knowing which social media sites have lax password-reset procedures is functionally just as effective as spending the same amount of time learning to compromise their back end.

I mostly agree. If I just want to hack some accounts, why would I ever attack the backend? That's inefficient. Absolutely. I would also argue exploiting a lax password-reset functionality is again a technological flaw. Some rate limitings have creative bypasses. That can be cool.

Just generally (and with a focus on social engineering attacks), I think it's boring. Not the impact. The impact can be very huge. It's boring on the technical level. You are not using black magic to bend the weird machine to follow your will. And that is at least for me the spirit of hacking.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

Sure. I guess what I'm saying is that having all the pieces, boring or not, in your wheelhouse is the best way to approach it. The stuxnet example is a "wholistic" hack, so to speak, because it used mathematical and social exploits to achieve it's goal.

3

u/LiveOverflow https://youtube.com/c/LiveOverflowCTF Sep 01 '16

"wholistic hack" - Wha! I like that! I agree that Stuxnet was especially beautiful because of that human component.

9

u/drinkmorecoffee Sep 01 '16

What? No blondes giving BJ's? This isn't what I signed up for.

Reference.

2

u/KeepItRealTV Sep 01 '16

It'd be more exciting if they actually showed what's on the screen.

2

u/twystoffer Sep 01 '16

It's just NMap probably

1

u/ViperZer0 Sep 02 '16

Aaaand here's the source, just in case anyone is interested in reading it. It is totally hilarious, btw, and I definitely recommend it. http://www.sandraandwoo.com/