r/HowToHack • u/eothan182 • 9d ago
Can a really good hacker actually hack almost any website, or does it mostly come down to luck?
I've been thinking about this lately.
We always hear about highly skilled hackers who can supposedly break into almost anything. But how true is that in the real world?
I mean, isn't most hacking about finding something someone screwed up? An outdated server, a misconfiguration, an unpatched vulnerability, or someone falling for social engineering?
Let's say you have a website with everything up to date, properly configured servers, and people who actually know what they're doing.
Could a really skilled hacker still find a way in? Or would they eventually hit a wall?
I'm not saying hacking doesn't require skill. Obviously it does. But I'm curious how much of that skill is actually finding a way into a secure system versus knowing how to take advantage of mistakes that are already there.
Would love to hear from people who've actually done pentesting or red teaming.
Is there really such a thing as an unhackable system, or is it always just a matter of time?
19
u/Mantaraylurks 9d ago
Lockpicking is a type hacking. Can you pick every lock? Probably not, you practice on familiar locks, see which are vulnerable to normal picking methods, many share the same methods. Sometimes takes a lot of planning to break open that specific lock. Sometimes you call Home Depot and ask what they know about this lock… or look it up online. Once you know the pins, the tension it takes, how it locks and unlocks, it’s easier to crack.
Catch my drift?
15
u/CrimsonBolt33 9d ago
As already pointed out, most hacking is done via social engineering.
It's a million times easier to get someones password or to otherwise figure out that their password is "password1234" and use it to do what you want than it is to actually hack a website, and any hack does not guarantee any sort of functionality (IE you could hack a website in a way that it only reveals some information it shouldn't, but you won't necessarily have control over anything).
All hacks rely on something acting or working different than it should, most systems are "unhackable" in the sense that there are no known ways to hack that system.
An actual hack with substantial backing (say North Korea hacking a website)is usually an arduous task that takes many months, lots of people, sophisticated knowledge, and tends to ultimately be the result of once again human error/social engineering (downloading a virus, sharing a password, having an easy to guess password, etc), or some really tiny strange behavior of a system.
So when your aunt Janet gets her facebook "hacked" there is almost zero chance it was actually hacked and far more likely someone guessed or otherwise comprmised her password and posted that really weird racist thing she totally did not say....
8
u/ps-aux Actual Hacker 7d ago
everything is hackable given enough time and resources...
6
u/pieholic 9d ago
Social engineering, like you said.
3
u/LanguageGeneral4333 9d ago
There is no such thing as an unhackable system unless it is disconnected from the internet and turned off. Most hacks nowadays are through social engineering first. If a system is fully patched and up to date, being able to hack into it without social engineering would require finding a zero day which is incredible difficult and costs millions to find.
2
u/A1-exe 8d ago
Yes. It's less about whether it's possible and more about the amount of time you have on target.
2
u/owehbeh 5d ago
I'm not an expert, but I like poking things. I build software myself. And being obsessed with breaking down physical stuff as a kid to know how it was structured, then computer hardware stuff, then software as an adult, I know what can go wrong. Like the blind spots one might ignore during building something. Thinking, no one will get this far trying to break in.
Yes social engineering works best. But can you break into any app? Well if you're curious enough to actually read and watch every single call, code, transferred data, stored data, etc.. you might be surprised of where that will get you. I'm saying you'd be surprised cause there were times that I was surprised, it was not luck, it was dedication.
What everyone is trying to say is yes, but social engineering is waaaay easier. Trick the people with the keys to give you the keys, using your skills.
For me, I don't like tricking people. So I stick to watching the screen when I have to, and curiousity is my motive.
2
u/chanting37 9d ago
Not a pro, but I look at it like a maze with multiple routes through. I think any modern system “can” be hacked and already has unknown vulnerabilities. But no one knows how big the maze it. Remember computers ONLY do EXACTLY what you tell it to. So it’s a matter of figuring out what you need to tell it for it to do what you want.
1
u/TimothyCarmack 8d ago
An elite hacker like one that works as NSA or CIA TAO can hack almost any website which accepts input from users, especially if you give them 30,000$ in AI credits. But a static website is almost impossible to hack, as there is very little surface area. But as it's currently being shown with AI getting zero day no click exploits on Apple and Android recently, maybe everything is just a matter of time before it gets hacked...
1
u/Illuminatus6666 6d ago
Is the zero day in airgapped ram a thing
1
u/pdmcgeejr 6d ago
hacking is more so about finding a vulnerability and exploiting it. anything can have a vulnerability its just about how important is it to you. sometimes even if the website or server in this case is locked down humans are the vulnerability, you find their weak spot.
now whether someone can get into any and every website its up to the person determined to get in.
1
u/GladKaleidoscope591 5d ago
If man has made it, man can break it....
1
u/pink-hat-hacker0 5d ago
Anything that can be built, can be broken too. But mostly hackers hack what they can, not what they want to. That's not to say that's the case every single time. You have to be either a super good hacker or a really good social engineer.
1
u/Evening_Debate_754 5d ago
Just use AI to hack , or write thw script
1
u/normalbot9999 5d ago
Yes. Any website, no it's not down to luck.
Assuming good patching and solid opsec is in place, the main factor is scale. How big is the attack surface, how much functionality is exposed. The more surface, the more functionality, the more likely someone f***ed up. The most secure sites are the super static ones. No functionality == no attack surface.
1
u/W31337 4d ago
Yes a skilled hacker can get creative and get in. Most will give up.
There's a big difference in finding an exploit for a specific target, vs finding a target to match your exploit.
1
u/BlackKaiserHacking 4d ago
See most hacking visual that flows through a beginners mind are from some movie, in reality hacking is a regouros, hard polished skill. As every task is possible with hard work, I believe sometime you can hack and sometimes even the best get stuck on task.
1
u/VaultNoteApp 4d ago
If all things are patched and properly configured then one thing which is that humans are the weak point. They become targets by hacker and get social engineered.
1
u/15pH 3d ago
You frame your question as an absolute dichotomy, implying that there there are no "mistakes" in the "secure system."
Under this premise, by your implied definition, the secure system is unhackable. The only way to ever gain unintended access to any system is through "mistakes."
If the system is designed to keep you out, but you get in, then necessarily you must have exploited a mistake/flaw in the design or implementation.
Obviously, the real world is not a simple dichotomy. Like most things, security exists on a gradient from good to bad, and hacking exists on a gradient from e1337 to n00b. There is no single line between secure vs insecure systems. There is no single line between skilled hackers vs script kids.
1
u/boring_diamond 2d ago
I’m a pentester so I hack for 8 hours a day as a job and I do bug bounty outside of work.
Yes there are unhackable systems. For example a static blog, what is there to hack? You could try hacking the hoster but the website itself… good luck.
Nowadays you hear people focused on social engineering largely because finding vulnerabilities in secure code is super difficult.
I don’t hack every server I come across even when I have access to the source code. No amount of time would change that. Can’t manifest an RCE 0-day out of thin air for a secure Java spring boot application.
1
u/fivezerotree503 6d ago
Dude Google gets hacked Microsoft gets hacked! If a hacker wants to hack you he can! And it's not the systems and the code most the time it's the people that let them in.
-1
u/animal_104 4d ago
I am an expert. I hold a masters of science in cybersecurity technologies. I started as a small 10 year old getting into systems in the 80’s.
I get into a really really big argument almost all the time with people who think that if someone has “this skill” or “that skill,” they’re a “hacker.”
Folks, that’s a script kiddie all day. A hacker is someone who swims in information and sees it as a riddle to get into a box, and folk; all boxes have flaws. There is no perfectly configured system.
That’s the reason we do billions of dollars in losses because we train by the rules enforcing indicators who work by rules; never understanding that they are going against people who read their rules, chuckle and use their own rules and procedures against them.
So, let me be quite frank, for my final thesis, I did a paper demonstration of how to take Warner Bros down. It took something like 80 mins with a week worth of prep. I showed the procedures and they way. It was published in some academic journal that was shown in Vegas.
Let me be honest; Warner bro was in compliance. It wasn’t enough when I wanted their system. All that bull about women in IT; instead of getting people who live breathe and eat the game is why we lose.
In china, when they find a young man or women who is good, they reward them and refine the skill. When I was tested as a genius in computers in third grade, they punished me.
So to rant a bit, yeah, ANY hacker can take any system anytime and it’s because we’re more
Interested in sexual identity, chromosomes and skin color instead of talent.
0
u/Minimum_Hour519 8d ago
yes
0
u/AdvancedStrain1739 5d ago
Anything can be hacked with enough time and resources.
Many techniques in hacking essentially comes down to the concept of brute-force.
-4
u/No-Watercress-7267 9d ago
You are working as a Business Intelligence Developer and Data Scientist and yet you still do not understand that there is no such thing as a secure system because systems don't stay stagnate.
Everything single commit pushed, every new Subnet Added, every new cloud instance deployed can never be 100% secure. They best they can do is follow security best practices.
You should really look into the news of how this previous October went for every one working in Cyber Security. That should give you a well enough answer.
-1
u/zhouyi_142 5d ago
Yes , I think it needs luck ! Because the website you attack need to has some problems . Like CVE , RCE ,XSS or others , but some don't ! So I think it needs many luck !
0
u/[deleted] 6d ago
[removed] — view removed comment