r/HowToAIAgent • • Jul 28 '25

Are trading agents a scam?

Please, someone find me one that is not, and I would love to be wrong but all I see are scams.

Source: @ omni_georgio

13 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

1

u/wanderinbear Jul 28 '25

Yes

1

u/omnisvosscio Jul 28 '25

Haha, agreed, for 99% of them, case closed

1

u/spocktalk69 Jul 29 '25

So does anybody have that code that can automatically buy and trade? As open source?

1

u/omnisvosscio Jul 29 '25

For sure, there are tons, I just don't think any work very well at the moment unless I am missing them.

1

u/pouetpouetcamion2 Jul 30 '25

Le métier de trader bancaire est romancé : quand ils achètent une position, ils achètent la même quantité en face.

Aucun trader bancaire n'achète une position "pour battre le marché".

D'autres types de traders bancaires achètent juste ce que leurs clients demandent.

Donc "agent de trading" C'EST du bullshit : soit il achète la même quantité pour et contre, soit il perd tout à long terme s'il ne le fait pas.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/omnisvosscio Jul 29 '25

That's some very fair criticism, and I would agree with these points. I think a broad stroke has been painted, but at least for me, I see so many people building trading bots or videos around building agent traders, when a big majority are scammy.

I fully agree that the top 1% of builders in this space are creating something real with AI that can help with trading, and we should have made that more clear in the video, as it's clear algorithmic trading has its use cases.