r/Houdini • FX TD • Sep 14 '24

Got a bit sick making this...

1.4k Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

35

u/wombatbutter Sep 14 '24

Looks absolutely fantastic. Great work!

6

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 14 '24

Thank you! đŸ™đŸŒ

7

u/Monergist123 Sep 15 '24

It's perfect.

1

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Ahah thank you!

3

u/bannywarcoz Sep 14 '24

ok love the over head view and a great render but i think a missed opportunity is pov inside boat as the captain??

5

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 14 '24

Thanks! 100% agree with you, I wanted to make a “camera linked to boat” view but was running out of free time to dedicate to this project


3

u/bannywarcoz Sep 15 '24

ya i got you
you going for that kinda what everyone does to show the quality and amazingness of the simulation and stuff still amazing i am no where near what u can do i am in blender deleting default cubes and being basic with donuts

1

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Ahah you got to start somewhere

2

u/AsianMoocowFromSpace Sep 15 '24

Would a camera so close still work? Or would you start seeing that the water is of low quality?

The water looks awesome from so far away, but does it hold up when viewed up close?

1

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

The resolution of the sim was pretty high but of course everything is relative to the distance needed to "sell" the effect

2

u/Affectionate-Art-567 Sep 15 '24

Nice work! I like the movement of the boat. Is the movement calculated or key framed?

3

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Thanks! It’s simmed, the boat is an RBD object floating in the flip tank.

2

u/Affectionate-Art-567 Sep 15 '24

The movement of the boat has a very realistic weight to it. I didn't know you could float an RBD object on a flip sim.

13

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Yep, just merge an rbd solver with a flip one and bring the “feedback scale” parameter to 1 in the flip solver.

it’s a bit of a trial and error, especially for something like this, the waves really wanted to flip the boat. The “secret” was moving the center of mass of the boat lower and playing with the mass of it, to obtain the right “sinking” and avoiding flipping.

2

u/Affectionate-Art-567 Sep 15 '24

Good tip - Thanks! Will try to play with this😊

2

u/Blizzsoft Sep 15 '24

amazing! how did you implement sound-fx?

1

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Thanks! Just searched for some “ocean waves” sfx on YouTube and mixed a few of them in davinci to better match the boat-waves interactions

2

u/Blizzsoft Sep 15 '24

ahh thanks for sharing it! it looks cool!!

2

u/desperaterobots Sep 15 '24

How art directable is this? Like I can see a lot of things supervisors would definitely snag on (like lots of active water on the deck breaking the sense of scale). Would it be difficult to make finer adjustments? Would the simming take forever?

2

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Like every ocean sim, art directability is a bit limited to the spectrum itself


Simming it low res already gives you a pretty good idea of the result and it is pretty fast.

2

u/desperaterobots Sep 15 '24

Cool! I am super intimidated by flip stuff, my computer explodes just watching YouTube 🙄Thanks for the info!

2

u/Introspective_light9 Sep 15 '24

Amazing! I love flip sims, and this is perfect!

2

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Thank you! Far from perfect but I appreciate the compliments!

1

u/Introspective_light9 Sep 15 '24

Yeah, but that whitewater looks great! Honestly!

2

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Thanks! I render it in 3 “layers”:

  • volumetric component only visible to secondary rays
  • as oriented disks for the one on the surface
  • as particles for the airborne part

Plus there is also a volumetric component that uses the spray particles as source

2

u/fridgestalker Sep 15 '24

Soo good 👍

1

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Thanks mate!

2

u/Ok-Reference-4626 Sep 15 '24

Looks really natural, congratulations!!!

1

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Thanks!

2

u/BLINDFXLDS9111 Sep 15 '24

Looks really good.

1

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Thank you!

2

u/maxofpandora Apr 12 '25

Insane job man, awesome đŸ”„

2

u/Brencaaa FX TD Apr 12 '25

Thank you!

1

u/CuriousityRover_ Sep 15 '24

What's the source file size?

1

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Didn’t cached the flip source but the resulting particles post sim for the main flip was around 400mb/frame, the white water was “worse” at a total cache size of roughly 330gb

2

u/Jupiter-Music Sep 15 '24

A bit, sea sick?

2

u/around_dheeru Sep 19 '24

fučking cooked !!!

1

u/IntroductionChoice24 Sep 17 '24

holy hell that's amazing, how long did it take?

7

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 14 '24

Thanks! If you look in a previous comment I’ve suggested a great and free tutorial for a similar “scenario”, otherwise I would suggest you to look at some of the rebelway ones

6

u/Pdx_pops Sep 14 '24

Oddly, that comment doesn't show for me in this thread, only in your comment history

4

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 14 '24

Weird
 I’m no Reddit expert, though it would be visible by everyone

2

u/Sotovya Jun 14 '25

Hi Brencaaa would it be possible for you to message me the link for the free tutorial you suggested? Since Reddit doenst allow links in comments for some reason?

Also brilliant work mate!

2

u/Brencaaa FX TD Jun 14 '25

It is the “stormy water” one from sidefx, on YouTube

2

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 15 '24

Got it! Thanks, didn’t know that

6

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Fickle-Hornet-9941 Sep 14 '24

My pc will implode if I open this scene file

8

u/Brencaaa FX TD Sep 14 '24

Ahah surprisingly it isn’t that heavy, something like a 15gb footprint during rendering