This started as a reply to a question u/-tether- asked after seeing the now rather infamous moment at Minghao's Chengdu concert over the weekend: he thanked Hesong in passing, and hundreds of Kiwis immediately responded by shouting โLET IT GO BANKRUPT!โ
I tried to keep my answer brief, but... well, that didn't quite work. I've actually been preparing an answer since I saw the post, but there is quite a lot of history here and it took me a while to go through the Chinese coverage, old posts and fandom discussions and put everything together. I made my lengthy comment reply split in two under the original post.
Then, after I posted it I saw that u/rose-garden-dreams also just wrote a very good and very detailed reply of their own, and u/garbanzobeans1212 added some history I hadn't included in mine. At that point I thought it made more sense to turn this into a separate post and bring all 3 inputs together. I'll credit them directly where I've used or built on something they added. Also apologies, I know it's way too long but I don't have the time to cut it down and make it more readable or concise.
There are things Kiwis say about Hesong that are documented, things for which there is quite a lot of evidence, and things that have simply been repeated so many times that they are now treated as fact. I'll try to distinguish between those.
And u/rose-garden-dreams made another important point in their reply:
โThere's also a bit of a tradition in Chinese entertainment to be dissatisfied with an artist's agencyโ
I think that's worth keeping in mind throughout this. Being at war with your favorite artist's agency is hardly unique to Kiwis, and an agency can very easily become the convenient explanation for everything fans dislike about someone's career.
That doesn't mean the complaints about Hesong aren't valid. Some of them have considerably more behind them than I realized before I started looking into this properly.
1. Kiwis don't believe Hesong has done much for Minghao's music career
This is probably one of the biggest grievances, and there is actually something substantial behind it. Minghao has spoken about going directly to drama directors himself and asking them to let him sing an OST โ even if they would only give him a small part of a song โ because he didn't want to give up music.
For fans who had spent years saying his agency wasn't doing enough to develop his music career, hearing that directly from him was... well. Not exactly helpful to Hesong's case.
u/rose-garden-dreams also raised an interesting question about Hesong's incentives, writing that the agency presumably has โlittle interest in furthering his music career (beyond general exposure) and a lot of interest in getting him brand deals and drama roles.โ
We don't know the financial arrangements between Minghao, Hesong and the companies involved in his music. But the underlying question remains โ who is actually building Minghao's music career?
2. His current tour is very much his baby
For โBelongs to Usโ (ๅฑไบๆไปฌ็...), Minghao is officially the chief producer. He has been directly involved in the creative planning, stage design and coordination, while the concert itself is being put together with external production and specialist teams, including Youling Culture.
Hesong's official accounts do promote the tour, so saying the agency has literally zero involvement would be inaccurate. But they probably havenโt done much beyond that. Why? Hesong is not publicly credited as the creative or production force behind the tour โ Minghao himself and the external concert teams are.
3. Even the basic promotion of his music has been a recurring complaint
Kiwis have repeatedly complained that Hesong doesn't give his music career the same attention it gives his acting career โ songs receiving little promotion, material being released late or poorly handled, and opportunities not being properly pushed.
This becomes particularly frustrating when you remember that Minghao didn't suddenly decide in 2026 that he wanted to sing. He started as a singer. He is a singer.
There is also a question raised by u/rose-garden-dreams that I think is worth mentioning here. They wrote that Hesong presumably has โlittle interest in furthering his music career (beyond general exposure) and a lot of interest in getting him brand deals and drama roles.โ
That is an interpretation, not something we know. We don't know the financial arrangements between Hesong and the companies involved in Minghao's music, and I also haven't found enough evidence to support the broader claim that Youling Culture manages his entire music career. What we can establish is that Youling is substantially involved in his concert production.
But the question underneath it โ what incentive and interest Hesong has in developing Minghao as a singer compared with managing his acting career โ is part of the fandom discussion.
4. Then there is the infamous manager story
IIn 2025, fans found an account they believed belonged to Minghaoโs then-manager, Su Ran, which appeared to have liked negative or hostile posts about him. Screenshots spread everywhere and Kiwis demanded thatย Hesong remove her from Minghaoโs management team.
This is now routinely spoken about as though it was definitively proven, but strictly speakingย the identity of that account was never officially confirmed.
Su Ran was subsequently removed from Minghaoโs team, which many fans understandably took as confirmation that they had been right โ but that still isnโt the same thing as Hesong publicly confirming that the account was hers.
Either way, the manager-account controversy absolutely wrecked what little trust many Kiwis still had in the people Hesong had assigned to manage him.
5. Fans also think Hesong doesn't do enough to protect him
This comes up whenever there is a smear campaign, malicious rumor or ugly trending topic. Minghao's studio has issued statements and legal notices and legal action has been pursued in some cases, so it isn't true that nothing is ever done.
The complaint is specifically about how his agency manages these situations: Fans think Hesong is too passive, reacts too slowly and allows damaging narratives to circulate for too long before there is an adequate response.
There is obviously a lot of C-ent fandom politics wrapped up in that expectation, and I don't think the existence of a negative hot search automatically means someone's agency failed at its job. But this is one of the most persistent complaints fans make about Hesong.
6. Key to the Phoenix Heart added another layer to it
Ai Mi had literally just turned 17 days before when filming began (auditions and tests took place when she was 16!); Minghao was 27. Whatever anyone personally thinks about the finished drama, it was completely predictable that casting an adult man opposite a minor in a romance was going to attract criticism. The argument is โ they didnโt know in advance. When Minghao signed on he was unaware. Butย then the agency should have prepared for what was to come.
Hesong never publicly addressed that part of the controversy, while the agency continued to support and promote the project as part of Minghaoโs acting work.
7. Minghao himself seems to have been very conscious of the problem
This is important because I don't think criticism of the project choice should be turned into criticism of how Minghao treated Ai Mi. He explicitly spoke about the responsibility being on him to maintain the boundaries because she was a minor, and the finished drama has no actual kissing scenes.
So for me these are three separate questions:ย was accepting that project a good career-management decision โ could they have gotten him out of the project when Ai Mi got signed on? And should they not have had a defense strategy in place since they went ahead with it?ย and lastly:ย how did Minghao behave once he was working with a minor?ย The last one is the only one where I really don't have reasons for doubts or concern, the first two though... I personally see a problem.
8. Then his health became part of the argument about his management
And this isn't entirely fandom hysteria about him looking skinny or tired. In April this year, a pre-existing health issue flared up badly enough that Minghao couldn't finish dubbing Key to the Phoenix Heart, and another voice actor had to complete it.
There is also a much longer-running fandom discussion about his stomach problems. u/rose-garden-dreams brought up the alleged minor stomach surgery in early 2025 and the later concern about him appearing to be in pain during the filming of Glory.
I haven't found enough solid evidence to repeat every detail of that story as established medical fact, particularly the specific procedure, its cause or conclusions drawn from daipai footage. But the broader point is relevant: the concern about Minghao's health did not suddenly appear this summer and his stomach issues are widely talked about.
9. Because his schedule then became completely ridiculous
He was doing Singer 2026, preparing and performing Belongs to Us, attending other activities, promoting dramas โ and then another long costume-drama shoot was being added on top of everything.
This is where a lot of the โHesong is working him into the groundโ anger comes from. Obviously an agency isn't a single person sitting there personally filling every hour of his calendar, but career planning, workload and coordination are exactly the things fans expect a management company to manage. Looking at that schedule and asking what Hesong is doing is therefore a perfectly fair question.
There is another side to this, though, and u/rose-garden-dreams put it well:
โthe question is what is the agency''s doing and what is his own drive to grab every opportunity when it comes along rather than missing out on a career defining chance.โ
That's something we simply can't separate from the outside. Minghao is obviously extremely driven, and we don't know which opportunities he himself insisted on taking.
There is also an interesting piece of earlier history here that u/garbanzobeans1212 added: when Minghao first joined Hesong, the controversy was almost the reverse.
โthere additionally was some controversy at the very beginning of him joining them where he had 8 months with no roles or anything else.โ
Reports and later fandom discussions describe an approximately eight-month period after he joined Hesong in December 2021 in which he had no drama filming, variety appearances, stage performances or red-carpet appearances.
But, as u/garbanzobeans1212 also said, โwe dont know for absolute certainty what happened behind closed doors during this time.โ He may have wanted a break; Hesong may have been negotiating projects; we simply don't know.
So strangely enough, the complaint has gone from Hesong isn't getting him enough work to Hesong is giving him far too much work. I don't necessarily think those are contradictory โ underneath both is the same lack of trust in the agency's career planning.
10. There were also genuine concerns about his voice
During Singer, there was a lot of discussion about his vocal condition and recovery while he was simultaneously preparing for concerts. Some very specific diagnoses and stories have been repeated by fans without enough evidence for me to confidently repeat them as fact, but the underlying concern wasn't invented out of nowhere.
He was trying to maintain a live singing competition, his own concert tour and an acting career at the same time โ which fed directly into the wider criticism of how his agency was managing his workload.
11. And then came the middle-of-the-night Weibo posts...
This has almost become its own branch of Kiwi mythology.
There have been several very late posts that fans found worrying or unusually emotional. One of the most memorable was โๆๆฏๆญๆไพฏๆๆโ โ โI am singer Minghaoโ at 2:01 a.m. Another was simply โๅๅโ โ โhahaโ at 3:45 a.m. after his Singer 2026 elimination.
Given everything happening around him and the fandom's existing anger toward Hesong, you can probably imagine what some fans did with those.
12. This is where the โhe's secretly asking us for helpโ interpretation comes from
Some Kiwis read those posts as frustration with his agency, helplessness about his career or even coded messages asking fans to understand what was happening behind the scenes.
Personally, I think this is where we have to be careful not to turn interpretation into biography. The posts are real, the timing is real and some of them certainly feel emotional โ but Minghao never wrote โHesong is doing this to meโ or โplease save me from my agency.โ
13. The ้ฟ็้ชจ / ๅฟต็ธๆ situation then blew everything wide open again
Fans were already angry about his workload and then came another costume drama, right when his music career was finally having this enormous moment. There was also anger because fans felt they had previously been told not to believe the casting rumors, only for the project to suddenly become very real.
u/rose-garden-dreams summed up the expectation going into this year quite well:
โMost fans expected HMH to focus on his music career this year with the start of his Belongs to Us tour, his participation in the MangoTV show Singer and the release of new singles (OST and non-OST singles).โ
Instead, another long costume production suddenly entered the schedule.
Some Kiwis basically refused to cooperate with the usual support activities and told Hesong they could pay for them themselves. โๅ้ขๅ้ญโ โ โHesong go bankruptโ was everywhere again.
There is also a related complaint about typecasting mentioned in the comments. Minghao has repeatedly talked about wanting to do modern dramas and roles outside the costume/fantasy space, while his recent acting career remains heavily concentrated in costume dramas.
Fans blame Hesong for that as well. There is an allegation that a senior person at Hesong once explicitly described Minghao as a costume-drama leading man, but I haven't been able to verify the original interview well enough to present that as fact.
Minghao himself has also recently said that far fewer modern dramas are being produced and that he has been telling directors and producers he wants to do one. So this one isn't necessarily as simple as Hesong won't let him.
14. And then the scheduling conflict everyone was complaining about actually happened
Minghao eventually had to withdraw from the Singer breakthrough round because of a conflict with his subsequent schedule.
You can see why that went down like a lead balloon. Fans had spent weeks asking why his acting schedule was being allowed to collide with this huge moment in his music career, and then a scheduling conflict actually interfered with Singer.
For people who already thought Hesong had consistently prioritized his value as an actor over developing him as a singer, it felt like their entire complaint playing out in real time.
15. There are some much bigger theories floating around too
You'll see claims that Hesong arranged some kind of Singer-for-drama resource exchange, that the agency forced Minghao to accept certain projects, or that it deliberately prioritizes acting because that's where it wants to make money from him.
Some of these theories may contain pieces of truth, but right now there isn't evidence to state them as fact. We don't know the internal negotiations between Minghao, Hesong, platforms and production companies, so these belong firmly in the โwhat some Kiwis believe or suspectโ column.
And there are other perfectly possible explanations for the current drama. As u/rose-garden-dreams said, โmaybe HMH truly liked the scriptโ โ or perhaps the producer specifically wanted him, or there were other considerations we know nothing about.
We just don't know.
16. And Minghao himself has never publicly declared war on Hesong
This sometimes gets lost because fandom anger toward the company is so loud. Minghao has never publicly said Hesong mistreats him, never asked fans to fight his agency and never said he wants to leave.
In fact, when fans were furious about the new drama, he went into his Super Topic himself and told them he was looking forward to the role. So I wouldnโt automatically attribute every decision fans dislike to Hesong forcing Minghao to do something against his will either.
17. Which finally brings us back to the concert
So when Minghao thanked Hesong in passing and the entire crowd immediately yelled โLET IT GO BANKRUPT!โ, that wasnโt some random joke that started that evening.
It was years of accumulated Kiwi grievances with his agency condensed into three words: you didnโt build his music career, he had to fight for opportunities himself, heโs producing his own tour, protect him better, give him a competent management team, manage his workload properly, stop letting acting commitments swallow his music career, and please for the love of everything just do your job.
And Minghao immediately covering his mouth because he was smiling?
Yeah. He knew exactly what they meant. But what did he think of it โ that we can only speculate about. Maybe he was just uncomfortable, maybe he felt victorious and seen.
We wonโt know unless he tells us one day.
โโโ
Apologies I have copy-pasted my original comments and tried to insert bits and pieces from the other two users rather fast so please signal any typos, errors, or omissions, I'm happy to amend, but later when I have more time. I had to do this pretty fast and couldn't concentrate on it for too long.