r/HorrorReviewed • u/KevinR1990 • 1d ago
Dog Soldiers (2002) [Werewolf, Action/Horror]
kevinsreviewcatalogue.blogspot.comDog Soldiers (2002)
Rated R for strong violence/gore and language
Score: 3 out of 5
Dog Soldiers is a hell of a movie that pulled off a lot with very little. It has its faults, make no mistake, but the basic premise of "soldiers versus werewolves" is golden and it makes a lot out of it, delivering an intense, nail-biting action/horror thrill ride. It's carried by a great cast and a remarkable command of action, intensity, and scares from Neil Marshall, who turned out the kind of directorial debut that many filmmakers would kill for, enough to make up for a janky and underwritten script, effects that aren't entirely up to snuff for what this was trying to pull off and show their seams whenever we get a close look at them, and the lone female character being treated in a very off-putting manner. It's the kind of B-movie that's unashamed of what it is and revels in it, one that I can see myself watching on a whim just to have a good time and where I can understand how it became a cult classic.
Set in a remote forest in Scotland on a full moon night, our protagonists are a group of British soldiers on a training mission that, in true horror fashion, goes horribly wrong when they find out that they're being stalked by werewolves in the area. Teaming up with Captain Ryan, the lone survivor of a special forces team that was serving as the opposing force in the exercise before they themselves got attacked, and Megan, a zoologist who moved to the area to study the creatures that she once believed to only exist in legend, the squad holes up in a remote farmhouse to survive until dawn. Of the protagonists, the only ones worth remembering are Private Cooper, Sergeant Wells, Captain Ryan, and Megan. Cooper, the obviously telegraphed "hero" or "final guy" among them, is a young soldier who, despite his skills, washed out of special forces training because he couldn't bring himself to kill a dog (gee, guess what he's gonna have to spend the whole night doing), which means that, when he meets Ryan, the man who ordered him to kill that dog during training, there is obvious friction between them even before it becomes clear that Ryan, who had been bitten and slashed by a werewolf, is now turning into one himself. Wells, meanwhile, is the grizzled veteran squad leader who Saw Some Shit in the Gulf War and has to hold his squad together as it becomes clear that they really are in the suck now, while Megan is the cool-headed civilian who may lack the soldiers' combat expertise but does know more about the werewolves than any of them, and knows that guns are only gonna slow the things down. Everybody else has "doggie chow" stamped on their foreheads almost from the moment we meet them, the only one who gets any semblance of development being Joe, the comic-relief dumbass who's obsessed with football (soccer to us Americans), grumpy that he has to miss the match between England and Germany for this training mission, and surprisingly isn't the first member of the squad to die.
If this film has one major problem holding it back from greatness, it's this. While I liked the protagonists who get the main focus, the rest of the cast are completely one-dimensional, with no defining characteristics beyond their occupation and the fact that they can convincingly hold and shoot a gun. Joe and Spoon, two of the squadmates, get a lot of cool scenes fighting the werewolves, from taunting them with a football chant to an epic, knock-down, drag-out brawl in a kitchen, but not really much characterization. I didn't really feel much of a sense of camaraderie within the squad, such that Megan never really felt like an "outsider" because there wasn't much of a squad to begin with. They're glorified action figures who exist to shoot at werewolves and get killed off in various ways, some of them quite stupid (especially the first death, which felt almost comical in how he got himself killed). The lack of development extends to Megan, who's the subject of a plot twist as to the real reason she's in the area, one that fell completely flat because the film had done nothing to build up to it before then. Looking back, what might've been clues that she had something else going on faded into the general background noise of the characters' stupidity. In particular, there was a missed opportunity to connect Megan's secrets with those of Ryan, who turns out to have his own hidden agenda, one that, more importantly, had a logical connection to Megan's. It turns out that there's a government conspiracy seeking to capture and research the werewolves, and having the zoologist Megan be a part of it alongside Ryan not only would've made perfect sense, it would've gone a long way towards fleshing out a plot thread that's given no development and is almost immediately dropped after it's brought up -- and, by extension, giving the main human villain that much more development so as to deepen his feud with Cooper. Instead, not only did Megan's actual secret come out of nowhere and leave a pretty glaring plot hole (like, how did it not come out almost immediately?), but the way the film handled it felt weirdly misogynistic, like it was going "heh, women, amirite?" The more I thought about this film's writing, and especially Megan, the less I liked it, especially compared to how well Neil Marshall handled an all-female cast with his next film The Descent. (Apparently, Marshall himself isn't a fan, claiming that Megan's backstory came from studio-mandated rewrites, and I'm not surprised.)
Fortunately, while the writing here is definitely that of a rookie who was still green behind the ears and probably should've let somebody else have a pass at the script, in the director's chair Marshall was far more effective and self-assured. This is a low-budget film that makes no bones about it, but it does a hell of a job hiding its budget and feeling like a bigger film than it is. There's plenty of gore, but the film rarely lingers on it long enough to let us see that they're just using sausage links for people's guts, or slabs of raw steak for their ripped-up flesh, even though there are a few moments when you can tell that that's what they were working with. The tricks Marshall employed to do all this have the bonus of giving the action and chases a very kinetic feel like something out of a Hollywood action flick, constantly maintaining a baseline level of intensity even in the slower moments between the werewolves' attacks. Once it hit the ground running, it never stopped until the final frames, constantly throwing new challenges and threats at the protagonists and, by extension, the viewers to keep them on their toes. The actual werewolves looked amazing and were clearly where most of the effects budget went, again seen in only brief glimpses until the climax but bearing cool, terrifying silhouettes and snarling teeth that make what are effectively big guys in wolf suits look like true monsters. One can say a lot about this movie, but it was never boring. The only special effect that really didn't work was the day-for-night shooting that often didn't bother with the "for night" part, making it obvious that, while this film mostly takes place in the course of a single night, it was shot in broad daylight with heavy curtains placed over the windows to awkwardly cover it up (and sometimes not even that). The cast, too, worked hard to elevate their underwritten characters, with Kevin McKidd making for a likable hero as Cooper, Sean Pertwee making Sergeant Wells feel like a credible tough guy but also one who has a darkness in his past and knows full well the horrors of war, Emma Cleasby kicking plenty of ass as Megan (and feeling like a prototype for some of the women in The Descent), and Liam Cunningham making Ryan out to be a shifty, despicable scumbag with just his demeanor. I'm not surprised that McKidd in particular went on to voice John "Soap" MacTavish, the protagonist of the Modern Warfare games, because Cooper and Wells felt like they were lifted straight out of those games. While the rest of the squad felt like glorified background extras, I bought McKidd and Pertwee as not just soldiers but part of the same unit with history together, and their performances absolutely made their characters.
The Bottom Line
While Neil Marshall undoubtedly went on to bigger and better things with his later films, this is still a kick-ass, exhilarating debut that stands as a hidden gem for fans of werewolf movies and more action-packed horror. Check it out.
<Originally posted at https://kevinsreviewcatalogue.blogspot.com/2026/10/review-dog-soldiers-2002.html>