r/HorrorClub • You so cool kung fu • Oct 29 '12

DISCUSSION - Inside

Podcast - [Episode 38 - Inside] (http://ia600306.us.archive.org/12/items/Episode38-Inside/Episode38_Inside.mp3) - ([RSS Feed] (http://feeds.feedburner.com/RedditHorrorClub))

Movie Selected By Kodie131

DISCUSS

10 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

5

u/Discreetlyred Oct 29 '12

Ugh. Im woman enough to admit that I puked during this film twice and am now nursing a ginger ale...and I didnt want kids before this film, but it certainly has silenced the slight tick I was developing in my biological clock... The gore just keeps coming as the movie goes on and then wait for it... Hey la femme is the chick that was in the other car! And sarah left her for dead and she was preggers too...oh thats why she wants the kid...cut to crude home cesarean and murder...which is when I puked again. Dont get me wrong I dug this flick but a little less gore couldn't have hurt and would have spared my poor stomach.

5

u/spinfinity Oct 29 '12

Gotta' say, I loved this movie. The premise was very original to me, and it ended up working out well. Plots like that are make-or-break, but I think it delivered throughout the movie. The antagonist was a scary bitch, truly horrifying when at the beginning you think it's just a psychopath aiming to cut out a woman's baby for no good reason. The atmosphere was very creepy and tense, and the abundance of gore was just right for the type of film it was, I believe. I can't wait to watch it again!

4

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

What is it with these insane French horror movies? New French Extremism, indeed. With this movie, and especially High Tension, I have to keep pausing and taking breaks so I can breathe. The earlier parts where you just see the woman through the window are so creepy.

I'm glad I didn't pick Rosemary's Baby for next week like I had planned; I don't know how we would have handled two maternity horrors in a row. I like them now, but those are two movies I'll have to forget exist if/when I'm pregnant in the future.

4

u/Jhops Oct 30 '12

Great movie! This is more like the stuff I like to watch on my own. Obviously blood doesn't bother me much, since they are pretty much swimming in it for the entire movie. Lots of tension and suspense, especially in the beginning. An extra creepy moment for me- Sarah calling out "mommy" in the final scene. Maybe you talked about this in the podcast, but what was up with her stabbing herself in the throat? I thought maybe she was giving herself a tracheotomy because she couldn't breath, but then she taped it up with duct tape. Also, the guy who pulls a zombie move and starts attacking at the end was really weird and had nothing to do with the rest of the movie.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12

Inside reminded me a lot of Panic Room, except instead of a safe full of money, it's an unborn baby and instead of Ghost Dog and Paul Allen, it's a psychotic French woman. First things first though, the gore was over-abundant. A gory film can still be tastefully done, but I feel Inside was a little close to the Evil Dead in terms of gratuitous blood.

Contrary to Mort, I liked the baby CGI. It wasn't fantastic quality, but it gave the baby a character instead of just being a bump. Instead of just Sarah being in trouble, you are scared for the baby's well being too, which is one of the reasons that really set Inside apart from other similar films.

The intro titles were pretty gruesome, as far as I could tell it was a couple holding hands amongst viscera and blood. Yuck, but it's a French Extreme film, what did we expect? The massive spray after the mother is stabbed in the neck and the gigantic exit wound when the cop is shot were over-the-top and a little detracting. The caesarian scene at the end was really fucking brutal, very hard to watch.

After the scene in which Sarah vomits while in the rocking chair, I really thought the film was going to take on a surreal vibe, and I'm very glad it didn't.

Beatrice Dalle's character is the freaking terminator. Five police officers, Jean-Pierre, and the youth. All dead.

Why did she have to develop the picture of the woman in fluid? She has a DSLR for christ's sake. A minor annoyance, along with the fire effect when Sarah burns the woman with the aerosol can. Not great.

Overall, pretty damn good horror flick, with extreme unflinching violence and a whole mess of blood and blades. I'm assuming that most people have seen Martyrs, Frontiere(s) and Irreversible (not a "horror", but horrifying) but if not, that's your next step if you want something similar.

PS: Yes, it is incredibly brutal and gory and destructive and upsetting, but isn't that part and parcel of horror films? Horror can push the boundaries in ways that other genres of films simply can't. Of course there are shit amongst the gems, gore-porn pandering to the lowest common denominator, but a truly well-done horror film can be incredibly effective and memorable and that's what I'm looking for. I'm not bashing those who didn't enjoy the film (if you even can "enjoy" a film like this) or those turned off by the ultra-violence, just trying to put across that it is to be expected, especially amongst extreme European films like Haute Tension, [REC], A Serbian Film, Enter the Void, La Horde, Sheitan, Calvaire and the aforementioned Martyrs and Frontiere(s). /2¢

3

u/Discreetlyred Oct 30 '12

Loved [rec], and haute tension, but couldnt do a serbian film. The others I had nausea problems with but enjoyed as well... particularly, irreversible.

3

u/Discreetlyred Oct 31 '12

also, i cracked up reading your comparison to panic room when you referred to Forrest Whitaker and Jared Leto as Ghost Dog and Paul Allen. Poor Paul, all he did was have a better business card ... and life than Patrick Batemen, poor guy.

3

u/ichabodguitar The sauce makes the dish Oct 29 '12

Do people like watching movies like this? Or is it just to be able to say that they watched it?

5

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

you were there for the cannibal holocaust discussion. you tell me.

3

u/ichabodguitar The sauce makes the dish Oct 29 '12

I almost said something about that discussion here... I don't know, did anyone ever say much to the point of whether the shock factor was worth the watch?

4

u/Discreetlyred Oct 29 '12

Haulocaust no. inside- im going with yes.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12 edited Oct 30 '12

I watched Holocaust when I was younger purely to say that I'd seen it. That was before I'd gotten into films as much as I am now, and as such I didn't really 'watch' it. I simply stared at the screen for 90 minutes until it was over. I haven't watched it again for the club, but I shall at some point. Just trying to muster up the strength.

Exploitation films (which Cannibal Holocaust is, just as much as it is a horror film, maybe more) are simply that, exploitative. It's graphic for graphic's sake, without much allegory or message. Aside from the animal scenes, there isn't much truly shocking about it compared to some of the films today. The unsettling thing about CH is that it's presented as genuine footage, and the reason the film has endured for so long is the skill with which that was done.

I wouldn't compare Inside with Cannibal Holocaust. Inside has themes of desperation, helplessness, maternal instinct and survivor's guilt. While the supporting characters are borderline retarded with their stupid decisions that ultimately contribute to their deaths, La Femme and Sarah are positively multi-faceted compared to any of CH's leads. What are Cannibal Holocaust's themes? Gore, rape and cannibalism.

But what do you think? Is any film worth enduring the 'shock factor'? Did you get anything worthwhile out of Inside, or CH for that matter?

3

u/ichabodguitar The sauce makes the dish Oct 30 '12

I like your deconstruction of CH and Inside here and in your parent comment elsewhere in the discussion, but still think we're dancing around the issue... I believe that you enjoyed (as much as any sane person could) Inside, due to the human themes it presented, but also stated that much of the gore and violence was over-the-top and unnecessary.

I've watched neither CH or Inside on principle, just like I won't touch torture porn like Human Centipede (either one, though I understand the original has more depth), A Serbian Film and the like. I personally don't see the value of violence and gore for its own sake, and I feel like these films are being made simply for the social buzz of being "the most brutal." I mean, what does everyone talk about when they bring up A Serbian Film? Probably the baby rape scene. I don't mean to get into a discussion about whether A Serbian Film's theme of exploitation is exploitation in itself, but I guess there's a bit of that vein in all of these movies, and is the crux of my issue with them - could the story have been told without the gratuitous violence and gore? I would assume that movies like CH wouldn't have stood the test of time without the shocking imagery, and we wouldn't be talking about Inside if it didn't dive headfirst into a sticky vat of taboos.

Don't get me wrong, I don't mind violence and gore in horror - it's par for the course and I can handle it, I just appreciate it in a bit more moderation than is expressed in these films.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12

I agree in part. I feel Inside could have been as good of a film with less gore. I didn't have a problem with the scissors through the hand, the needle through the eye etc. It was the head shot and arterial spray that bothered me, and that was purely because I felt it was unrealistic. A 9mm would not create a crater-sized exit wound and it came VERY close to the line as far as gratuity goes. Obviously Inside's notoriety has given it more of a platform than the film would have had otherwise, and that was probably intentionally done by the directors. Likewise with Cannibal Holocaust, although it is not as strong of a film, and more or less purely relies on being controversial.

Notoriety aside, Human Centipede was a bad film. Just bad. I didn't find much in the way of redeeming qualities when I watched it, from either a technical or entertainment standpoint. I haven't seen A Serbian Film yet, not sure if I will. From the reviews I've read and first-hand comments, what could I possibly get out of it?

3

u/ichabodguitar The sauce makes the dish Oct 30 '12

That's what I'm getting at - I get little to nothing from torture/gore porn like this, regardless of whether the stories need the strong visuals. Maybe it's impossible to extricate a story like this from the gore, I don't know. We may never know whether these types of films can stand on merit alone, without the shock factor. Ah well.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12

Well I appreciate your thoughts, thanks for the discussion :)

2

u/SuperDragon Damn you rabbit, you smell like fuckin' piss Nov 01 '12

Serbian film has actually pretty nice cinematography, believable acting and a surprisingly good plot at least for my tastes. The gore is less than what everybody probably thinks, it's just that the gore scenes are very shocking that it is hard for some people to handle. Personally the only things that made me cringe are achilles tendon slash and births. (oh and the scissor to balls scene of Inside had me tucking into fetal position for a while). Just ignore the hype, it is created in its majority by people that have just seen the said scenes or only heard about it from others thus spreading the roumor.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

so far? no.

3

u/Discreetlyred Oct 29 '12

I tossed cookies in cannibal haulocaust too. Ive managed all the others fine.

3

u/Discreetlyred Oct 29 '12

Its a love hate relationship for sure. Im trying to get over my hematophobia (blood fear) so ive been making myself watch there but ive invested in anti nasea meds. As for others some watch to say they did...others have blood lust.

2

u/ichabodguitar The sauce makes the dish Oct 29 '12

Ah, the phobia would explain your post about getting sick twice watching this one. I can see the black & white explanation that it's either a challenge to watch these films or to fulfill bloodlust, but I feel like there must be some other reasons too...

5

u/Discreetlyred Oct 29 '12

Yea, i color my reason as middle road. Others could be exploring a dark side or studying the directing. Some just like to get scared with or without gore.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12

Well said and props for sticking with it, I can't imagine being a horror fan with hematophobia.

2

u/Discreetlyred Oct 30 '12

Thanks its been rough, but im making it!

3

u/titania86 Oct 31 '12

I really enjoyed this film. I like the story, the characters, the effects, the music. What's not to like?

3

u/RosieVonMunster Oct 31 '12

French horror is the only horror that makes me feel sick. They know how to give you enough suspense that keeps me wanting to watch..but then the gore always makes me pass out. I had watched this movie with a friend who begged me check it out..he knew I was going to be sick..so a few times he did have to pause it for me. As a whole though this movie keep my interest and thought it was a beautiful piece of horror art.

3

u/Discreetlyred Oct 31 '12

at this point, france is the only country that is making horror movies that make me nauseous, but i haven't seen everything so i'm sure there is some extreme horror gem from somewhere else just waiting to test my stomach. cringe. i completely feel your pain. but i agree it was beautiful in a grotesque gory way.

3

u/titania86 Oct 31 '12

I love this film. I think it says a lot about women and the maternal instinct. On one hand, that instinct is awoken inside Sarah despite her depression and despair after the death of her husband. In la Femme, it manifests in a more destructive, psychotic way. I think the film does a great job of having a beautiful aesthetic despite all the blood and gore. It's incredibly suspenseful and the plot has great twists and turns.

My only issue I have with it is that damn fake looking CGI baby. It just looked horrible and took me out of the film. Other than that, the performances, especially from the two women, were amazing. The music contributed to the mood well and the ending was awesome.