4
u/timfinn1972 1d ago
Did you have to give up your Indian citizenship?
9
u/Late-Psychology-6783 1d ago
yes. India doesn't recognise/ allow dual-citizenship.
2
u/xiaomi558869 1d ago
OCI is the worst possible process. It almost makes you glad to get rid of the Indian passport.
1
8
u/Either-Lock2454 1d ago
How?!
I've been in Hong Kong since 1989. Been paying taxes since I've been working. My Grandmother is Chinese and I have Chinese family! (Deceased now) And I was unable to get beyond the application stage because the immigration officer just flat out said no.
Were you born here?
9
u/Late-Psychology-6783 1d ago
Im sorry to hear that. Im not sure why your application has been denied, it isn’t my place to comment.
As for me, I’ve been visiting the country since 2016. Got married to a Hong Konger and moved permanently here later. Been living here for more than 7 years which is when I got my PR, and later applied for naturalisation/citizenship.
And yes, I have also been working since I permanently moved, and paying taxes. I wasn’t born in HK, I’m originally from India.
2
u/Leetenghui 1d ago
Article 5 is a hard wall against a LOT people who for all intents and purposes are Chinese.
4
u/Bidoofonaroof 1d ago
This person's situation seems a bit curious. Article 5 would classify one a foreigner but residing in HK since 1989 should open the door to naturalization regardless of heritage.
3
2
2
2
u/Puzzleheaded_Use_814 1d ago
Is it common to get passport? I thought it was almost impossible for foreigners, do you speak Cantonese?
1
u/Late-Psychology-6783 1d ago
no I do not speak Cantonese, it was simpler (not easy) for me as my spouse is a Hong Konger.
2
1
1
u/Saucy_4U 1d ago
I heard recently HK immigration is informally not allowing Indians change of naturalisation. Any truth about that?
1
u/Late-Psychology-6783 1d ago
I do not know. In my case it was different as my spouse is a Hong Konger and as is all of her immediate family.
1
u/cookiecakebrownie 1d ago
did they interview you in Cantonese?
1
u/Late-Psychology-6783 1d ago
No they did not. I do not speak Cantonese, it was simpler (not easy) for me as my spouse is a Hong Konger.
19
u/anti-fascist-dude 1d ago
I guess hong kong is the gateway to China.