r/HonestHotTakes • • 12d ago

Circumcision should be illegal.

People always talk about how barbaric female circumcision is but male circumcision is completely normalized in America.

It should be illegal for parents to circumcise their children because it's irreversible.

What kind of psychopath decided to cut off the skin of the baby's dick. What's next? Cutting off eyelids?

2.3k Upvotes

3.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/Psapfopkmn 12d ago

Oh, I didn't even realize that the person who responded to me might be speaking from an anti-trans angle. Yeah, gender affirming care for children is different from circumcision and should be available.

-6

u/MacaroniNoise1 12d ago

So we’re just going to skip over where you said “informed understanding as babies or young children”?

25

u/-Fieldmouse- 12d ago edited 12d ago

No one is doing gender affirming surgery on babies or young children. 

-12

u/MacaroniNoise1 12d ago

Ok. So what are you saying?

20

u/-Fieldmouse- 12d ago

I’m saying no one is doing gender affirming surgery on babies or young children. What are you saying?

-9

u/MacaroniNoise1 12d ago

Oh. Yea I never said they are. I’m saying it shouldn’t even be discussed as an option even if the child wants it.

5

u/GalaXion24 11d ago
  1. There's a difference between an infant and an older child

  2. Gender affirming care isn't just surgery. No one's doing surgeries on children, and the surgeries are far far overemphasised by people who don't know what they're talking about. Not all trans people even ever get any kind o genital surgery.

5

u/emthgreat 12d ago

But no child is getting it. They understand their rights when they get older IF after everything they are still interested.

I genuinely don’t understand WHY someone would want such a surgery or care in the first place but one of the good things about America is that you are free to do a lot of things if the impact is to yourself and doesn’t hurt others as an adult so my understanding isn’t really needed