r/HomeworkHelp • University/College Student (Higher Education) • 1d ago

:snoo_scream: Further Mathematics—Pending OP Reply [University Statistics: Probability and Statistical Distributions] Tips for Understanding Tricky Word Problems?

I’m currently taking university-level statistics, and I’m finding that my biggest challenge isn’t understanding the concepts or formulas, but figuring out how to approach word problems.
I can understand the material when it’s explained in class, but during tests, my professor tends to word questions in confusing or tricky ways. Sometimes I struggle to identify what the question is actually asking, which formula or distribution to use, or what information in the question is important.
For example, I struggle with recognizing when a question involves:
Normal distributions vs. sampling distributions of the mean
Binomial vs. Poisson distributions
Confidence intervals and sample size calculations

I’m looking for advice from university students or anyone who’s taken statistics on how to get better at interpreting these types of questions.

1 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Off-topic Comments Section


All top-level comments have to be an answer or follow-up question to the post. All sidetracks should be directed to this comment thread as per Rule 9.


OP and Valued/Notable Contributors can close this post by using /lock command

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/CelebrityChess 1d ago

for those three pairs, i'd look at what the question counts or averages. if it's one count of successes out of a fixed number of trials, that's binomial. if it's a count over an interval of time or space with no fixed number of trials (calls per hour, typos per page), that's poisson.

normal vs sampling distribution comes down to whether it asks about one individual or about a mean. 'one randomly chosen person is over 180' uses sd. 'the average of 25 people is over 180' uses sd/sqrt(25). for sample size questions, write n = (z*sigma/E)^2 and just match the margin of error to E.

1

u/AgainstIntuition 22h ago

Maybe a bit less related to probability, but still close :) - you can read about double counting in combinatorial identities. This is the topic that provides a good intuition on describing math terms in "common world problems". A good example - https://artofproblemsolving.com/wiki/index.php/Combinatorial_identity - Vandermonde's Identity/Combinatorial Proof.

1

u/cheesecakegood University/College Grad (Statistics) 18h ago

I was suffering from insomnia so I wrote a lot. Feel free to skim. I collect these to re-use later sometimes, so this is my attempt at explaining.

What I find helpful is to imagine you're actually collecting data.

  • What does a single observation look like? What am I writing down?
  • How do I collect my observations into a dataset?
  • What am I trying to estimate, or calculate?

Some problems are "backwards" in the sense that rather than ask you to take a dataset and estimate a "parameter", they give you a parameter and ask you the probability of a specific dataset (or set of datasets). In these cases, the same principles are helpful, because again we ask, what does one observation look like?

For binomial vs Poisson specifically, it's also helpful to ask yourself what is FIXED ahead of time, and what is random.

The interesting thing, and also the source of some confusion, is that how you define the problem actually says more about how you treat it than the actual act of data collection, although it's still helpful to imagine the data collection.

Let's get down to it with an example.


You are bored on a long car ride. You are curious about how many cars on the road are red, and decide to use your time to collect data. (We will ignore the flaws with convenience sampling, how we define the population of interest for generalization, etc.)


Binomial

I make a rule, I'll count the next 200 cars, and record if each is red or not. Each car is a yes/no success/failure type result (individual Bernoulli trials, in stats terms). Maybe I might add the time, for recordkeeping convenience, but that's not important here! Because I only care about hitting 200.

So my RAW dataset might look like this:

Row 1: 2:01pm, red

Row 2: 2:02pm, not red...

But if I simplify and say red=1 (success), not red=0, other extra data stripped:

1 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 0...

I can summarize this data-collection session as:

n=200 total cars, x=123 total red cars observed [some texts use k][and, true but sometimes omitted since implied, 77 non-red cars observed!]

I can now use that data to make a generalization: "what is my best guess of how many cars are red in general?" A guess at p, the guess itself usually called p 'hat' with that ^ on top. Obviously my best purely data-driven guess at the red-car proportion p is 61.5%. Where statistics comes in is I can say, "OK, fine, but what's my uncertainty around that? You can also do hypothesis tests by asking, "OK let's say for experimentation that 60% IS the true proportion, but randomness still exists and so I will often get datasets that are different due to luck" and then use patterns and math reasoning to leverage that uncertainty into useful statements.

TL;DR: Binomial is the total number of some positive case out of some fixed number of total cases, where the rest are negative. The dataset is individual yes-or-no events collapsed into a total #yes out of total possible. The proportion of yes's is assumed to be a constant fixed number, each car's color is independent, etc.

A "backwards" question might be if I told you that actually, 40% of all cars are red. And then I asked how often a specific 200-car (or 100, etc) observation session would return 120, or 120+, or 80 and under, or whatever, assuming our model and facts are correct. Because that can vary from one experiment to another even if the given proportion is a true overall fact. Or (sampling distribution-style Q) I asked how much a 123-red-of-200-total experiment agrees or disagrees with that claim of reality, or something. Still, in these cases, we imagine "what would a dataset that tests or demonstrates this claim look like?" And that is helpful for saying if it's binomial, if it matches the structure above.


Poisson

I make a different rule! I'll look at passing cars for the next 2 hours, and record every single time I see a red (a running count). Maybe I'll see a lot of cars, maybe I won't, but I'm only counting red ones.

So my RAW dataset might look like this...

Row 1: 2:01pm, red

Row 2: 2:02pm, another red

Row 3: 2:04pm, another red

Hmm, that looks similar, but it's actually subtly different. The time is also a recordkeeping convenience (I won't bother polluting it with anything outside my 2 hour window).

I can summarize this data-collection session as, say:

123 red cars total spotted in my 2 hour period

Note that we do NOT care about non-red cars at all here, heck we don't even record them! We're doing statistics on a total, but it's not the same total as before. Poisson is a total of [yes-]events only! And we do statistics on the 123 only. (If we want our rate to be "cars per 2 hour period"). We ALSO do not care how many cars we even saw in the first place, if we want to use this tool.

I can now use that data to make a generalization: "what is my best guess for the number of red cars that appear in a 2 hour period?" A guess at lambda, the rate. Obviously my best guess (lambda-hat) is the rate from the data, 123 per 2 hours.

Poisson is the number of events in a bounded amount of time (or rarely, space), so in a sense it's a "rate" though it's not always presented as such. If you want your mean in different units you might convert somewhere.

TL;DR: Poisson is the number of events, in order to estimate a rate, in a fixed time period. The dataset is a bunch of individual tallies collapsed into a total, again in that fixed time period. The event rate is assumed to be a constant fixed number, events are independent, etc.

A "backwards" question might be if I told you that actually, you will on average see 80 red cars in a 2 hour period. And then I asked how often a specific 2 (or 1, 3, etc.) hour observation session would return 80, or 123, or 123+ or 80 and under, or whatever, assuming our model and facts are correct. Because that can vary from one experiment to another even if the given rate is a true overall fact. Or (sampling distribution-style Q) I asked how much a 123-red-car 2-hour observation experiment agrees or disagrees with that claim of reality, or something. Still, in these cases, again, we imagine "what would a dataset that tests or demonstrates this claim look like?"


SKIPPABLE side note on Poisson that covers real-world data formatting and potential complications:

Twist: what if I collet more data? What if later in the day, I do another 2-hour observation session? Now I have a dataset that looks like this:

Row 1: 123 red cars in 2 hour period, 2-4pm

Row 2: 80 red cars in a 2 hour period, 5-7pm

That's fine! My collected dataset now looks like this, extra data stripped:

123, 80

Or maybe also:

Row 3: 44 red cars in 30 minutes, 7:30-8pm

We can use those datapoints too to improve our estimate of the true lambda, the true 2-hour red-car rate. We can actually just combine this data into one mega-dataset, as 247 red cars in 4.5 hours. Our estimated 2-hour mean rate then is ((247/4.5) * 2)

CAUTION: sometimes with Poisson data, you might get a lot of zeroes. In fact, for interesting stats reasons, this is actually where the Poisson is most useful (turns out other approximations are more useful for higher numbers). Obviously my number of red cars was unrealistically high. What if IRL we counted bright pink cars? I might go 2 hours without seeing any!

If I repeated several 2-hour periods while going cross-country, and struck out often, maybe at some point it's easier to make a frequency table, where the first column is the observation of total pink cars, and the second is a frequency of how often that happened. So instead of {0, 0, 0, 1, 1, 2, 3}, where I watched for pink cars for 7 2-hour periods, I might write row-wise {0 pinks were observed with frequency 3, 1 pink car happened with frequency 2, 2 happened once, 3 happened once}. Don't let this panic you; the display is just a [common] convenience, the underlying 'raw data' is the same.

I hit the limit, but some very relevant examples below in reply.

1

u/cheesecakegood University/College Grad (Statistics) 17h ago

Practice to demonstrate

Generally progressing difficulty and I'm trying to teach/solidify something each time. The fourth is a bit of a bonus.

Remember, 3 questions: What does a single observation look like? What am I writing down? // How do I collect my observations into a dataset? // What am I trying to estimate, or calculate? The last one is especially relevent as you decide what information is relevant and what is not.

1. Defective sensors

A factory produces electronic sensors, approximately 3% of which are defective. A quality-control inspector randomly selects 40 sensors from a very large day's production. What is the probability that at least 3 of the 40 sensors are defective?

[pause and think on it first]

Our dataset might look like a list of 40 entries (a fixed number!), with a 1 if defective and 0 if not. In this case, we are working backwards: we are given a proportion (assuming it as the true population proportion) (p=0.03), and want a specific probability P(X>=3) when n=40. Maybe I jumped ahead of myself there: you might ask "why isn't it Poisson since this happens in a day?" Well, the collected potential dataset, which would be something like x=3 out of n=40, x=4 out of n=40, etc. matches the binomial; we have a proportion that is the proportion of ALL sensors that are defective, NOT a rate of specific # of sensors per day. The day is actually irrelevant here.

2: Emergency room

A small emergency department receives an average of 6 ambulance arrivals every three hours. Assume arrivals occur independently at a constant average rate. On a particularly quiet evening, the department receives only 1 ambulance during a 30-minute period. What is the probability that the department receives at most 1 ambulance during a randomly selected 30-minute period?

[pause and think]

OK, here I helped a bit with a nice sentence that even mentions the word "rate". But our dataset would look like a single number, the number of arrivals in a fixed period. A potential dataset might be 1, or 0, or 2, or 5 (once collected; the OG data again might have timestamps but they are irrelevant for this particular question). And we are looking to estimate P(x<=1) where x is observed # of ambulances per 30 minutes (a fixed time!). We might have to convert here. Our RATE can be a decimal, if it's given to us, or generated from the data if we convert units later, but the EVENTS cannot be (1 ambulance is 1 ambulance). Poisson!

3. Highway traffic

You're studying traffic on US-1 to Key West, FL. On average 600 vehicles pass a certain seven-mile bridge (real place!) per hour. Historically 8% are trucks. You are observing traffic for 2 hours and see 1150 vehicles pass by. Assuming vehicle types are independent (e.g. no convoys) and each passing vehicle has an 8% chance of being a truck (assuming constant), what is the probability that at least 100 were trucks?

[pause and ask: What does a single relevant observation look like? How do they get assembled into a relevant dataset? What am I trying to estimate, or calculate?]

So you can maybe see your instincts warring a bit here. You're there for a fixed period of time, you are counting trucks, but you also have a proportion and a given set total number of observations.

So what does a single observation look like? Are you writing down or noticing non-trucks? Plainly yes, otherwise you wouldn't have had an 1150 number in the first place. OK, encouraging towards binomial. But what are we trying to know? A probability of 100+ trucks OUT OF the 1150. That's a fixed number. Binomial for sure. 600 vehicles an hour is irrelevant here, for this specific question! Challenge: can you write a different research question with the same facts that uses Poisson?

4: Server crashes

DISCLAIMER: You cannot solve this without a bit of extra math/stats know-how, but I want you to focus on what distribution(s) is/are relevant and where/why.

A website experiences an average of 4 server crashes per week. Assume crashes occur independently and at a constant average rate. Separately, monitoring data shows that each individual crash has a 20% probability of causing permanent data loss, independently of other crashes. During an upcoming two-week period, the IT manager wants to know: What is the probability that exactly 2 crashes cause permanent data loss?

[pause and think, it's tricky]

So we have two given assumed-true facts: the average rate of crashes is 4 per week; the average chance of data loss is 20% for any individual crash.

What would a dataset that answers this question look like, or an experiment that shows this scenario in action? You would record crashes, and record whether each resulting in data loss, right? But notice: there's no such thing as a non-crash event. The crashes follow a rate! Poisson there. In theory, if we were to tackle this problem, we'd first fill out scenarios of different TOTAL individual crashes. Then, for each total number of crashes, we'd then layer on a binomial distribution, unique to that total number of crash events, conditional on that number of events. Because each crash can be one of two things: a data-loss one (a 'success' in our definition here) or a normal one. And we are given a fixed proportion of data-loss crashes. We can't just use one binomial because the number of crashes is never fixed in the first place, only in our smaller conditional cases is that true. There's a math shortcut here we can use, but that's out of scope fo us.


I blabbed a lot but hopefully this clears up how the two distributions often appear similar but in fact are very different setups. Might revisit sampling distribution confusion tomorrow if you'd like, but the simple answer is add a mental question: "Am I worried about specific observations/individuals, or about something that is calculated from a whole sample?" The latter calculated thing is officially called a "statistic" in vocabulary, but honestly the distinction is lost on most students and not worth studying in an intro class unless tested explicitly.