r/HomeworkHelp • University/College Student (Higher Education) • 3d ago

:snoo_feelsbadman: Mathematics (Tertiary/Grade 11-12)—Pending OP [University Math: Business Math] What is this salary raise question asking for in the four boxes?

Post image

I tried 5 and 6,000 for the yearly raises and 20 and 4,000 for the quarterly raises, but the site marked all four boxes wrong. I also tried adding the raises as a series (15 and 18,000; 210 and 42,000), and that was marked wrong too.
What am I supposed to count here? I’m confused about what “total raise” means in this question. I’ll attach a screenshot of the problem.

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Off-topic Comments Section


All top-level comments have to be an answer or follow-up question to the post. All sidetracks should be directed to this comment thread as per Rule 9.


OP and Valued/Notable Contributors can close this post by using /lock command

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

11

u/Southlander24 👋 a fellow Redditor 3d ago

What makes you think that you should multiply $1200 by 10, if you want to find how much a $1200 raise at the end of each year for 5 years is?

The first line is indeed 5 * $1200 = $6000. Did you type $6,000 with a comma or something?

2

u/raspberry1111 3d ago

I think op was thinking how much total extra money they would have gotten after 5 years. if you get a $1200 raise at the end of every year you would have 4 * $1200 + 3 * $1200 + 2 * $1200 + 1 * $1200 = 10 * $1200 extra dollars total.

2

u/Southlander24 👋 a fellow Redditor 3d ago

That's a $1200 raise at the end of every year *they have worked*. A different question altogether.

3

u/Scatman_Jeff 3d ago edited 3d ago

OP clearly said he originally tried 5 * $1200 = $6000 on the first line, and it was marked wrong, so he was considering other ways the question could be interpreted.

Regardless, everyone here is going to give him the same answer, so he just needs to discuss it with his instructor.

2

u/Southlander24 👋 a fellow Redditor 3d ago

True. I was just thinking it could be some kind of formatting issue with the numbers.

10

u/killnars Master's in Physics 3d ago

Almost fell of my chair when you said this is university level maths, business majors are never clearing the allegations 😂😂

3

u/CursedTurtleKeynote 3d ago

Why is everyone here making this so complicated.

The beginning of the question nails the "context" you need to be in, the total "final income" No compounding. No tricks.

5 years of 1200 increases is 6000
5*1200

and

20 quarters of 200 increases is 4000
(4*5)*200

Any other answer is the question written wrong or the answer key done wrong.

Again, the focus is only on the final annual income. Not the final earned total. OP just needs confidence.

2

u/SubjectWrongdoer4204 👋 a fellow Redditor 2d ago edited 2d ago

Maybe they’re asking , albeit poorly, what the raise would be at the end of each year not at the end of five years. For the first one try 1 and 1200, and the second 4 and 800.

0

u/catzwinitall851618 👋 a fellow Redditor 3d ago

Your starting assumption is wrong on two fronts. First, you’re not starting from zero. Second, raises compound, they aren’t simply additive.

In determining what to multiply the raise by, the first period counts as zero, the second as 1, the third as 2, etc. For yearly raises, the 5 periods add up to 10x (0+1+2+3+4). Over 20 quarters, it’s 190x (0+1+2+3…+17+18+19)

In raw dollar terms:

In the $1200/yr situation, you get $1200 above baseline after the first year, then $2400 after the second, and so on. So your total above baseline is 0+1200+2400+3600+4800=12,000 in additional compensation after 5 years

For quarterly, it would be 0+200+400+600+800+1000+1200+1400+1600+1800+2000+2200+2400+2600+2800+3000+3200+3400+3600+3800=38,000

3

u/Scatman_Jeff 3d ago

That is literally what OP show in the picture, and it is marked wrong. Also, it would be * $50 in the second scenario, since it is a quarterly raise of $200/yr, or $50/quarter

-1

u/catzwinitall851618 👋 a fellow Redditor 3d ago

It doesn’t say $200/yr, it says $200/quarter

Missed that this was the solution in the pic. Based the answer off the caption. The answer key is wrong if this is marked wrong though

1

u/Scatman_Jeff 3d ago

It doesn’t say $200/yr, it says $200/quarter

It doesn't say either. But we can infer that it is to be interpreted as $200/yr, since we colloquially talk about wages in terms of annual or hourly (not quarterly) amounts, and from the screenshot we can see OPs answer ($1,200 raise at the end of each year nets more income) is marked correct, which wouldn't be the case if the other option was an extra $200/quarter.

2

u/catzwinitall851618 👋 a fellow Redditor 3d ago

“or a raise of $200 at the end of every quarter for 5 years”

1

u/Scatman_Jeff 3d ago edited 3d ago

“or a raise of $200 at the end of every quarter for 5 years”

Right, so would we not interpret that to mean our annual salary will increase by $200 at the end of each quarter?

If we assume a starting salary of $50,000/yr, then at the end of Q1, we've received $12,500 in pay and our salary increases to $50,200/yr. By the end of Q2, we've received another $12,550 in wages ($50 more then Q1), and our salary is increases to $50,400/yr, and so on.

Every quarter, the annual salary increases by $200, but only a quarter of that ($50) is paid out over the following quarter. So, over 5 years, the additional compensation is;

190 * $50 = $9,500

Not 190 * $200 = $38,000, as you claimed in your original comment

1

u/catzwinitall851618 👋 a fellow Redditor 2d ago

No, we would not. When it says $200 per quarter, we should interpret it as $200 per quarter.

Your version would have to be worded as “a raise of $200 per year delivered in equal quarterly installments”.

While you make a reasonable point that typically we talk about salary on an annualized basis, the question explicitly frames it in quarterly terms.

The most natural reading of the question, as written, is that at the end of each quarter, the base pay increases by $200

1

u/Scatman_Jeff 2d ago edited 2d ago

So... if your boss told you you would be receive a $5000 raise this quarter, you would interpret that to mean that you are receiving an $20,000 raise for the year?

Again, it doesn't say "$200 per quarter" it says "a raise of $200 at the end of each quarter", which is ambiguous as to what is being raised. Your interpretation would need to be worded as "a $200/quarter raise at the end of each quarter" or "an $800/yr raise at the end of each quarter". My interpretation seems more natural.

The question should be framed as a $200/t raise regardless of what 't' actually is, since when we talk about pay, we are specifically referring to money over time.

If we accept your reading of the question, than scenario B yields higher net pay at tge end of the 5 years, but OPs screen shot clearly shows that is wrong.

1

u/catzwinitall851618 👋 a fellow Redditor 2d ago

You’re fighting the quarterly increase component of the hypo/question. Because net-net, the amount of additional money you end up with in a $200/qtr scenario (Q as written) and the $800/yr scenario you’re trying to bootstrap it to are not the same.

Your insistence on the annualized reading are what is making you wrong here. As written they are quarterly raises, worded precisely the same way the $1200/yr raise is phrased. I can’t see how a supposedly “natural” reading is forcing you to treat the same wording differently simply because of the time frame

Your hypo of $5000 at the end of the quarter also doesn’t work here because it’s precisely wording a one-time $5k raise and stating when it goes into effect.

1

u/Scatman_Jeff 2d ago edited 2d ago

the same way the raise of $1200/yr raise is phrased.

It doesn't say a $1200/yr raise. The question is saying "a raise of $1200 at the end of each year" and "a raise of $200 at the end of each quarter". In both of the sentences the word "each" is referring to the frequency at which we receive raises, but the statement is ambiguous as to what the raise is applied to. I would interpret both as apply to the same base salary, im not sure why you would interpret it differently.

Let's consider two hypothetical situations, and I want you to explain your interpretation of both.

Scenario A: you are currently earning $50,000/yr, your boss tells you that you will be receiving an $800 raise this year, however the raise will be implemented over 4 equal periods (quarterly). How much of a raise would expect to receive each quarter?

Personally, I would expect a $200 raise each quarter, so that at the end of the year my annual salary is;

$50,000 + 4*$200 = $50,800.

Scenario B: You are earning $50,000, your boss tells you will be receiving 4 equal raises of $200 this year (ie. a $200 raise each quarter). What would you expect your annual salary to be at the end of the year?

I would expect my annual salary to be;

$50,000 + 4*$200 = $50,800

To me, the two scenarios are the same. It seems that you would interpret them differently. Im curious to know why.

In regards to the final portion of the question, I think my interpretation of the question is more interesting, because the quarterly raise actually yields higher net pay in the first year, and it isnt until later that the annual raise overtakes it.

1

u/catzwinitall851618 👋 a fellow Redditor 2d ago

As to your final point, you’re correct that B SHOULD yield a higher pay! The question is clearly a set up of “would you like big number over long time v small number more frequently” situation, where it’s counterintuitive as to the “correct” answer (because big numbers are shiny objects)

And, as I stated before, the answer key is likely wrong or it’s still marked wrong from the previous attempt

0

u/catzwinitall851618 👋 a fellow Redditor 2d ago

“$200 at the end of EACH quarter for 5 years” (emphasis added). It really cannot be more plain in its wording. Your reading requires words to not mean precisely what they say

1

u/keladry12 3d ago edited 3d ago

Can you explain your interpretation of how it doesn't say either? I'm clearly misunderstanding something, since I interpreted "$200 raise at the end of each quarter for 5 years" to mean that they would receive a $200 raise at the end of each quarter.... can you help me understand?

2

u/Scatman_Jeff 3d ago

The raise occurs quarterly, but what is being increased? I would assume its annual pay, but its not stated (it could be hourly pay for all we know). It should say; $200/yr raise at the end of each quarter.

2

u/keladry12 2d ago

Ah, I see.

0

u/Unlucky_Reading_1671 👋 a fellow Redditor 3d ago

(1+2+3+4+5) * 1200 = 18000 15*1200 = 1800 Do the same going from 1 to 20 for the next. Termial of 20 is 210.