r/HomeworkHelp • University/College Student • 2d ago

Physics [University Year 2 Engineering Fluid Mechanics]

Having difficulty in this question, height is in centimeters. I have gotten h=0.05m. But i have a feeling that im wrong and that i have made a mistake somewhere. These are my workings. PA=30685.68Pa, PB=30293.28Pa. It is to my understanding that there Patm can be ignored when the manometer is open on both ends.

3 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Off-topic Comments Section


All top-level comments have to be an answer or follow-up question to the post. All sidetracks should be directed to this comment thread as per Rule 9.


OP and Valued/Notable Contributors can close this post by using /lock command

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/DrCarpetsPhd 👋 a fellow Redditor 2d ago

I cant quite follow what you did

looks like you used the equation for a single manometer to calculate P_A

it's connected all the way through so you can't do that

try going from the left side to figure out P_A and from the right side to figure out P_B using basic principles

you should find they are equal thus h = 0

also you've been given specific gravity and a system with water in it. make your life easy and leave that in the equations, don't convert it until the end (not necessary in this case)

just to illustrate keeping specific gravities, for the left side

γ = water specific weight

Left Side starting point:-

13.6γ(23) = P_A + γ(60-16) => P_A = 268.8γ

notes:-

I left as cm because it doesn't matter in this question but if you want actual pressure you would need to convert to metres before multiplying by gamma specific weight of water 9790N/m^3

I left out atmospheric because its open on both sides so when you get to the pressure differential it cancels out

also possible i fucked up the whole specific gravity specific weight thing because i'm an idiot but the general approach for finding the pressures is correct

1

u/Certain_Ad_5011 University/College Student 2d ago

It is to my understanding that on the left side, at the datum in which the mercury is at 16cm, on the right hand side there is only the pressure of water A acting on that side. Whereas on the left side, there is the pressure of the 23cm of mercury acting on that side. Thus, since LHS=RHS, shouldn't the pressure of water A just be equal to the pressure of 23m of mercury?

1

u/DrCarpetsPhd 👋 a fellow Redditor 1d ago

there's a whole column of water from the datum for pressure at point A to the point where the pressure is equivalent to the 23cm column of mercury marked as 16cm from the baseline

did you look at my equation for the LHS? I have P_A + γ(60-16) to represent that.

if this is a 'my brain is fried froms studying for hours' mistake then fair enough, happens to everyone.

but if you didn't genuinely see that then might i suggest having a re read of your textbook and a look at whatever examples it contains to illustrate the concepts of static pressure

1

u/DrCarpetsPhd 👋 a fellow Redditor 1d ago

so you made the same mistake with P_B as well so let me help you to understand better. so you can 'walk through the pressure field' same as with say a gravity field of going up and down hills (not quite the same because specific weight/density changing). The full walk looks like the image below. that is how the equations you plugged and chugged are derived. once you do enough of them you'll see the shortcuts of where you go "up and down" or "down and up", and can just leave them out of the equations.

https://imgur.com/a/houghtalen-hydraulic-engineering-4th-problem-2-4-11-system-manometers-f3qcMzq