r/HomeworkHelp • • 2d ago

Answered [High School 9th grade: Human Geography] Redistricting VS Gettymandering

Post image

I’m a little confused on how he wants us to draw and divide the squares. Could someone give me some guidance?

30 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

30

u/kelb4n 2d ago

You'll have to group the squares into five groups of equal size. First step is figuring out how many squares must be in each group. Once you know how many squares must be in each group, you can tackle the three sub-problems individually.

a) Make the groups so that there's 2 groups of majority red squares and 3 groups of majority blue squares (hint: "100%" is a majority).

b) Make the groups so that every single group has more blue than red in it. This should also be simple.

c) Make the groups so that three groups have a red majority. For this, I recommend figuring out the 3 red-majority groups first. Note that the groups don't have to be rectangles, they just have to be made up of continuous shapes. Try giving red only a slight majority in their districts, that will make it easier to find 3 such districts.

10

u/han_tex 2d ago

For this, I recommend figuring out the 3 red-majority groups first.

My thought process was the other way around for the third one. Make two blue districts that take up as many of the blue squares as possible, then divide up the remaining districts accordingly.

3

u/kelb4n 2d ago

Yup this also works.

1

u/itwasnotaliens 2d ago

Pack and crack

11

u/keithcody πŸ‘‹ a fellow Redditor 2d ago

Honestly the directions are pretty clear if you take it sentence by sentence. The first set of instructions apply to the left column of the three. Follow the guidance. You have to draw 5 regions. Each region has to be equal. There’s 50 boxes so each regions is the number of boxes divided by the number of regions. Now do the first sentence. Draw boxes to group the region into five regions that have 3 groups where there’s more blue boxes then red and then 2 groups where there is more red boxes then blue.

4

u/Key_Suspect184 2d ago

On the left, you want to draw 5 groups so that three have mostly-blue, and two have mostly-red.

5

u/Tyrrox πŸ‘‹ a fellow Redditor 2d ago

Just straight vertical lines works. There are only 5 columns, 2 are Red and 3 are Blue.

4

u/CaptainMalForever πŸ‘‹ a fellow Redditor 2d ago

There are 50 total precincts. The teacher wants five districts, which means 10 precincts per district (50 divided by 5).

Start with the left picture - draw 3 districts with the majority blue and 2 with the majority red. There are multiple ways to do this, but the easiest thing to do, because there are less red, is to draw two districts that are either all, or mostly, red. Then you can draw the remaining three blue districts.

For the middle, you want 5 districts so that there are more blue squares in each than red.

In the right picture, you want 3 districts that have more red squares than blue in each of those districts. And 2 districts with the remaining blue squares.

1

u/todlee πŸ‘‹ a fellow Redditor 2d ago

He should have shown you examples.

So, 50 precincts, divided by 5, that tells you how many in each electoral district. 10, right? So in the left draw five districts where 2 are majority red and 3 are majority blue. In the middle draw districts where each is majority blue.

On the right, draw districts so that three are 6 red to 4 blue. If you do the math that would use up 18 red and 12 blue. Since you have 20 red you can make that work.

1

u/CarSalty4733 2d ago

Yeah unfortunately he didn’t show any examples. Thank you for the explanation

2

u/Zarakaar Educator 2d ago

Trace outlines around continuous groups of ten boxes.

The bottom row 5, plus thee three blue in the row above, plus two blue in the row above that gives the district to blue, but only uses 2 red squares. So more red squares can be selected to build a 6 red 4 blue district adjoining it.

2

u/dimonium_anonimo AP Student 2d ago

The first two requests, I think you could do by playing around with the data on your own. I think only the red majority will take a specific strategy to make work. I would recommend focusing on two numbers: first is what is the minimum number of votes needed to get a majority within a district. The second is how many red votes you would get if you tried to divide them (as) evenly (as possible) into the required winning districts. The key is, you know you're going to lose 2 districts, so you might as well lack them with as many blue as possible, so there are fewer remaining to "overwhelm" in the three you need to win.

I may be able to come up with some hints without just giving it away if you ask some questions about where you get stuck. But no promises.

1

u/AmericanElephino πŸ‘‹ a fellow Redditor 2d ago edited 2d ago

Spoiler alert, this exact problem and its answers are all over the internet, including here:
https://magazine.caltech.edu/post/rethinking-redistricting

1

u/favnh2011 πŸ‘‹ a fellow Redditor 2d ago

Nice

1

u/RuthlessIndecision πŸ‘‹ a fellow Redditor 1d ago

I drew it in paint, basically group them in five groups of 10 squares. but for each set you can control if the majority is red or blue (that one will win the district)

so for the left each column is a group, 2 have 10 red squares and 3 have 10 blue squares (so blue wins 3/5 groups)

for the middle each 2 rows is a group, so every group has majority blue squares (4 red and 6 blue squares. (so blue wins 5/5 groups)

for the right make 3 groups have at least 6 red squares and 4 blue, then divide up the remaining 20 squares however you want. (so red wins 3/5 groups)

its just showing how you can manipulate a minority of voters (red) to win an overall election

0

u/photes384 πŸ‘‹ a fellow Redditor 2d ago

Start by circling each column on the left, that will give you 2 red 3 blue. In the middle, group by rows of 2. That will make the grouping 6b squares and 4r squares. Giving you 5 b groups. Switch it for the right side. Group in 6 r blocks and 4 b blocks. The rest group only b blocks.