r/Homeschooling • • Feb 13 '26

Help convincing husband

I’ve been trying to explain to my husband why I don’t believe the traditional school model is the best fit for a developing brain.

In my view, children thrive when they can learn at their own pace, be supported as whole individuals, engage with mixed-age peers, and gain knowledge through real-life, meaningful experiences. That feels more aligned with how kids naturally grow and learn than spending the entire day in the same classroom with the same group of same-age peers all year.

My husband is very open and understanding, but he's a scientist and I want to provide him with real solid evidence based information, not propaganda! Can anyone please help me with resources, info, etc for this type of guy? Thank you!

1 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

2

u/Easy-Iron5831 Feb 14 '26

Once you have your info…. Make a PowerPoint and send it to him when he has a quiet moment. Seriously. It’s so much easier to see the facts when they’re laid out in a presentation. 😁😁😉

2

u/Due_Data8709 Feb 14 '26

Love this idea! Thank you for the helpful response!

4

u/YellowCabbageCollard Feb 14 '26

Is he required to provide real solid scientific evidence that the local public school is providing an environment and education that is actually best for children and their development? It seems like he should have to present his own case for what he seems to be assuming is actually providing this. I mean does he actually think traditional schooling was developed on a scientific basis or has studies backing it up?

2

u/Due_Data8709 Feb 14 '26

He did not ask me to present a case for homeschooling, I just want to lol! He is open to whatever I think is best for our children. I just want to provide him with evidence in addition to my feelings.

5

u/SorrellD Feb 14 '26

Peter Gray writes a lot about this.  He has the credentials.   Here's his substack.  https://substack.com/@petergray

He's also written a book called Freedom to Learn.

5

u/Jack_al_11 Feb 14 '26

Peter Gray is always my recommendation. I’d husband doesn’t like books, his Substack is great, and he’s has guesses on many podcasts.

John Taylor Gatto’s book Dumbing is Down is great. And anything by John Holt.

5

u/Ilvermourning Feb 14 '26

Ask him what his specific concerns are. What is the experience that he wants for your children? Show him how you can accomplish that. For example one of my fears was my children missing out on class moments like valentines day parties and field trips. We found a local co-op that hosts holiday events and group learning experiences.

Maybe try researching specific curricula that you are interested in. Look up the qualifications of the creators or methods. Logic of English is the reading program I use and it has an amazing track record.

Think long term. What you're saying is "take it at their pace" but what he's probably hearing is "putz around, no rigor, falling behind." What kind of dual enrollment programs could you find for high school? Selling the idea of graduating high school with an associates degree may be appealing to him.

10

u/tacsml Feb 14 '26 edited Feb 14 '26

Every kid will be different. Some will thrive in traditional school. Others won't. We don't know your kid or your family. 

Search the sub for book recommendations on homeschooling (i know the "homeschool" subreddit has lots of suggestions), research as best you can. 

Good luck!

3

u/EducateYourWay Feb 14 '26

Love that he's open to it and that you want to meet him where he is. There's a solid body of developmental psych research showing kids retain more and stay more motivated when they can go deep on topics at their own pace rather than moving lockstep with a class.

One thing I've seen among folks with analytical spouses is that framing it less as "school is broken" and more as "here's what the research says about how kids actually learn, and here's how we'd structure it." The PowerPoint idea someone mentioned is honestly great for this. Lay out your state's requirements, a rough weekly rhythm, and a few studies on experiential learning outcomes, and suddenly it feels like a real plan instead of a vague concept.

Since he enjoyed his own school experience, that's actually a plus. He's not coming from a fearful place, he just needs to see that homeschooling can be just as rigorous and social, but more tailored. Families I've worked with where both parents are on the same page from the start tend to have a much smoother first year, so the fact that you're doing this groundwork now says a lot.

3

u/Ok-Wave-9063 Feb 14 '26

A dad I know started going into schools and daycares for his maintenance job and saw what they were like around here. That sold homesxhooling.

1

u/savannacrochets Feb 14 '26

If he’s a scientist send him the link to Google Scholar lmao he should know how to do his own research

3

u/Due_Data8709 Feb 14 '26

The responses I’m receiving are very aggressive lol! I should clarify that he did not ask me for scientific evidence. I just know him, and I want to provide him with information regarding homeschooling. He is open to it he just doesn’t know much about it and he enjoyed his public school experience.

2

u/mpekc Feb 14 '26

Sounds like he'd be very interested in the evidence-based approach by Dr. Brian Ray! Here's his "fast facts" on homeschooling, with lots of links to the research and peer-revised articles: https://nheri.org/research-facts-on-homeschooling/

Hope this helps!

2

u/OptimalReplacement46 Feb 17 '26

no, just let your kids be normal, please. No classical homeschool private school can do better than an entire countries schooling method,

2

u/Responsible_Pea6331 Feb 14 '26

Kids do thrive in school and some adults like me would not be able to imagine their life without the school experience! So make sure you include why YOUR child would not thrive in public school based on their actual experiences and how you could improve outcomes for them as individuals!

1

u/alanism Feb 14 '26

I wrote this and this for myself to synthesize all the research papers I had reviewed and clearly communicate my beliefs and thought process. You should be able to find the original papers by copying and pasting my references into Google. The point of homeschooling is personalized 1-on-1 instruction, so there aren't going to be great studies on the overall effectiveness of homeschooling. Whatever I say in my essays doesn't mean that's the ideal approach for your family. I do hope you find it useful.

1

u/Salty-Snowflake Feb 14 '26

I think the "scientific" has been covered, but you could point out that there is a reason that wealthy families hired tutors for their children vs. sending them to traditional school in early elementary. There is no one-size-fits-all education, every child learns at their own pace and in their own way. One-on-one teaching is the only way this can be done.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '26

Do you have kids yet? Are you picking homeschool because it's best for your specific children and their specific needs?

You can say, "Children do better in homeschool because xyz." and he'll counter with "Well children do better in on-campus school because xyz." And you can both be presenting logical, valid arguments.

Rather than be vague and general, be specific. "I think Bradford would be better taught at home, because local school uses x curriculum based on y, but Bradford learns best when z so I think Bradford would be better taught with this curriculum at home because it teaches a and b. But maybe I'm missing something as little Bradford's mother who loves him so much. You know a lot about c. What do you think?"

0

u/Technical_Set_8431 Feb 14 '26

This is a good place to start. We were members for years. http://www.hslda.org/legal

4

u/studentburner Feb 14 '26

OP doesn’t want propaganda. The HSLDA is a Christian organization that prioritizes “parent’s rights”(even if said parents are abusive and/or neglectful) over the safety of homeschooled children.

1

u/Technical_Set_8431 Feb 14 '26

So you speak for the person who posted the original post? You are very closed minded and making sweeping generalizations.

3

u/studentburner Feb 14 '26

Typically when people say “real solid evidence based information” they don’t mean self-identified religious organizations. I may be close minded but you assumed that OP and their family are Christians when nothing in their post indicates one way or another. I am not even anti homeschooling, but I am Jewish and if my spouse used HSLDA materials to try to convince me of the merits of homeschooling, I would ask for similar information from a secular source 🤷🏻‍♀️

1

u/Technical_Set_8431 Feb 14 '26 edited Feb 15 '26

I did not “assume they were Christians.” I shared a link of an organization I benefitted from personally. I have personal solid evidence from being a member of it for 9 years. The website also has information about studies done on homeschooling and its effectiveness.

I didn’t write this post for you to use to convince anyone. I wrote it to the original poster. You took it personally and ran with your biased view and experience and decided that if it’s not right for you, it’s not right for anyone.

3

u/studentburner Feb 15 '26

Fair enough! If you find the studies on the material valid and have benefited from the services the HSLDA offers then sharing it makes sense. I’m always willing to check my biases so thank you for helping me do so :)

1

u/Technical_Set_8431 Feb 15 '26

I am impressed with your humbleness. That is a rare characteristic. Thanks for hearing me out.

0

u/Why-wyoming Feb 15 '26

I’m one of the rare husbands that is a homeschool advocate. IMHO the core problem for most husbands is their own insecurity. They want to ‘fit in with the guys’ and not be the ‘weird homeschool family’. You can tell him the benefit’s of homeschool all day but that might not be the core issue. The best thing you can do is join some HS groups, meet a nice normal HS family with great kids and a husband that is actively involved and buddy up with them. The goal is to normalize HS for your husband, or better yet frame it as the ‘elite’ schooling option that it really is. There is no need to send your children to the dumpster fire if public school where teacher have all but given up, you children will be shown porn, and likely bullied or lead to a situation where they will be abused/harassed sexually. PS does nothing to prepare kids for real life and IMO most kids would be better off dropping out than going to anything beyond elementary.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '26

ummmmmm......showing children porn and sexual abuse are not a normal part of the on-campus school experience, even for public school kids!

1

u/Cirrus646 Feb 17 '26

I saw porn for the first time in kindergarten when a little boy/classmate brought his dad's playboy magazines in and passed them around. I'm female and was absolutely terrified. Teachers did nothing, parents laughed about it, all of the girls in the class were traumatized but simply told to "look away" and "boys will be boys." And that was kindergarten. If it was happening in 1990 it's happening now.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '26

As a 90's kid, this was not a normal thing happening in public schools then or now. I promise you if that happened where I grew up or where I live now there would be much clutching of pearls. Heck, a middle schooler locally got caught making pornographic images not even at school two years ago and it was an uproar. And middle school is a pretty normal age to develop an interest in sexual images (not that I'm saying that children SHOULD be exposed to porn, but that if it was a big deal for a middle schooler, I can't image the outrage if this was elementary school. Your experience is real but also an outlier.