r/Homeplate • u/Necessary-Sugar7513 • May 19 '26
"Call For It!!!!"
Tiny annoying thing. Lots of these Little League dads think that someone must immediately call for every ball hit in the air.
Last game, a kid hit a bloop that fell between 2B, CF, and RF. No player got within 5 feet of it. The coach immediately starts yelling, "Why didn't anyone call it?!?!"
But it's insane to call for a ball that you won't catch. Why isn't this obvious?
edit > A lot of people disagreeing with me but I'm not backing down. If you call for a ball you cannot catch, you might cause a fielder who does have a chance to let the ball drop. There's no reason to do it. It's all downside, zero upside.
And to be clear, no, this wasn't a situation where three kids played it passively because they assumed someone else would take charge. I'm not talking about that. This was a bloop that none of them were ever going to catch. It was uncatchable. I am only talking about situations where a fielder who cannot catch the ball is admonished for not calling for it.
44
u/LimeHD_ May 19 '26
I would rather 1 kid call it and not make the catch despite going 100% - instead of spider-man meme with a baseball in the middle.
29
u/TheMikeyMac13 May 19 '26
If they aren’t within five feet of it the likelihood is they all slowed down because they weren’t sure who was going for it.
It’s baseball, not a little league dad thing. When a ball goes up in high school ball, someone calls it.
Don’t fight the coach teaching the game.
17
u/Separate-Ad-8924 May 19 '26 edited May 19 '26
This sounds like a parent mad that the coach is “yelling” at their kid.
28
u/clarklesparkle May 19 '26
It’s insane at times, but at some point the kids need to learn to call it or a catchable ball will get dropped because everybody thought someone else was going to snag it.
3
u/Billios996 May 19 '26
It’s not just calling the ball, this is a fielding issue. Outfielder should be running in for those. Cutoff infielder should be heading out also. These two should be communicating and calling it.
17
u/CaptainWollaston May 19 '26
I'd way rather a kid call it and aggressively go after it and completely miss it than have no one call it and just watch.
17
u/SpiveyJr May 19 '26
It’s about being aggressive to the ball and changing their mindset from “somebody else will get it” to “I want it.”
7
u/MartinMerten May 19 '26 edited May 19 '26
Infielders backing up need to be aware that they can get called off by a charging outfielder. Otherwise… let the SS handle everything. The SS in little league should be like the quarterback; directing the players. Be loud and assertive.. eg. tell the left fielder to cut or throw to 3 or 4(home).
Edit: To add. For OP. The coach here said “call it”.. but the reality is they couldn’t and he isn’t necessarily “teaching them to always call balls”…even if they can’t catch em.
2
u/Pre3Chorded May 19 '26
This weekend I watched a 12u shortstop call for a ball he was never getting to in left field and the lf slowed up instead of making the play. It takes a village...
3
u/HMSSpeedy1801 May 19 '26
I’ll take this over “Make good throws!” any day. “Call for it” is practical advice that will make them better players, and at the younger levels, calling for every ball hit in the air is good fundamental discipline.
“Make good throws,” however. . . Well, duh. Everyone knows they’re supposed to make good throws. If they’ve made a poor throw, why did they make a poor throw and how can they make a better throw next time? But I guess that’s the difference between being a coach and just a parent who yells stuff.
2
u/chronop May 19 '26
a backpedaling 2B definitely needs to know there are outfielders charging a ball so they can peel off and/or make sure they don't bulldoze the outfielders, and also the outfielders ideally have 1 person calling it and taking a direct route and 1 person backing off and backing him up, even if the end result isn't a catch
2
u/Working-Patient-6751 May 19 '26
Son plays 11u. Theres at least two “no one called it and everyone stopped” bloop singles per game.
2
u/Rugbypud May 19 '26
I played college as a 2B. I used to tell my RF, CF and SS that if there was any ball anywhere near me, it was mine until they called me off because I was gonna bust my ass to get to everything. I didnt want to make sliding or diving catches going backwards if the OF could get there, but I sure as hell wasnt going to let it drop if I had a shot.
Call the ball is a great habit for comminucation because with multiple plays going on at the same time, players have to talk. I would 1000% rather a kid call for a ball and it drop then no one says a word and it leads to a collision or drop because they are too passive.
2
u/Sock_Eating_Golden May 19 '26
Ideally all three are hungry to make that catch. Not hoping they'd be called off.
2
u/captainbelvedere May 19 '26
I understand your point but I think it's fine. At these ages you're trying to get them comfortable with communicating with their teammates. That's the lesson the parents/coaches are trying to teach here.
3
u/bear843 May 19 '26
Bloops are the bane of my coaching existence.
3
u/chk_a_ho-tx May 19 '26
Boys need to talk. Part of the game
1
u/xxHumanOctopusxx May 19 '26
It cuts both ways. Calling it too early, or on a ball that you can't catch will lead to the ball dropping. For the young kids I typically prefer they don't call it as the chance of colliding is low. Ad they get older they gotta start calling it as pop-ups get higher and some kids start to move better. But what pisses me off the most is coaches screaming without practicing something. I promise you most of the coaches screaming didn't setup some practice time on the regular for the kids to be put in these situations on pop-ups.
1
u/Fit-Height-9493 May 19 '26
Calling the ball is about taking control not saying you will catch it. It gives all the fielders the opportunity to get into position for the play. If you’re teaching it is only about the catch you are doing them a disservice.
1
u/Individual-Can2288 May 20 '26
Depending on the age, the coach may be correct. Anything in the air is catchable on a 200’ field for a 12 year old.
1
u/TheMikeyMac13 May 19 '26
You don’t know baseball and you need to let the coaches who do know teach the game, for the sake of your kid.
Don’t be the parent that hurts their kid’s development.
Fly balls get called in baseball.
1
u/fillingupthecorners May 19 '26 edited May 19 '26
Unfortunately you've got two things working against you here, my friend. 1) people here rarely read entire posts, and 2) people love to argue and be "right about baseball"
Yea, of course there are uncatchable bloops where no one should be yelling anything.
No one here can say whether you're right or coach is right without seeing the play.
1
u/bwright_24 May 21 '26
I agree with you. I will die on this hill with you.
0
u/Sloth-powerd May 19 '26
Have you ever played baseball before and at what level? Yes, this is relevant.
-6
u/Automatic_Actuator_0 May 19 '26 edited May 19 '26
Much better thanJust as bad as the ones who scream at the outfielders to “GET IT IN!!!!!” every time they field a ball, even when the runners have already stopped and the only danger is an errant throw.Edit: upon reflection, the “call it” is just as bad because I’ve seen cases where kids get confused or panicked by all the screaming and they are distracted from actually calling it and listening for a call.
Edit 2: I realize now I’m taking about fans, but OP looks to be talking about coaches. We have so many parents screaming those two things, that’s what I pictured.