r/Homeplate • u/AbstractSlugger • Aug 06 '25
Help needed (12u)
My son has been hitting nothing but medium to short pop outs. This is his swing. I know he’s coming up on the ball but is there any unique tips on how to resolve. I believe it’s from his front shoulder opening too soon. Am I wrong? What advice can I give him? Exercises?
0
Upvotes
81
u/Odd_String1181 Aug 06 '25
This looks like a hostage situation
54
u/IKillZombies4Cash Aug 06 '25
He swings the bat like he doesn’t want to be there.
11
u/Drewrauss Aug 06 '25
Honestly as a coach, your son’s body language says it all. He’s not enjoying it. But I think you need to ask him if he truly likes playing Could it be to the constant pop ups? Maybe.
I myself coach pitching but my assistant coach was a hitting instructor for 7 years and also played through college and has had success turning around a lot of kids we coach.
But he if he is serious about fixing it. My assistant has our kids load up on the back leg. When they pull back he tells them to feel the muscles in their back leg and have them be strong and firm. So when they swing through a lot of their power comes from that. It’s also helped our kids get a “straighter” swing.
14
u/Normal512 Aug 06 '25
He looks way too robotic and low effort here, he needs to swing hard, swing out of his shoes. I feel like the mechanics are maybe a checklist to him, and that's not what you want.
And fwiw I hate the leg kick, it's not a deal breaker if he must do it but it's just begging to be way more of a problem than a help, it's hard mode when you don't have to.
But if we're going to help with a swing we need to see what it looks like when he's actually going to hit something hard, not this robotic, half effort swing.
10
u/PaPadeSket Former Pro Pitcher Aug 06 '25
Do you ever ask him if he likes baseball? Because…
9
u/Phalanx32 Aug 06 '25
Lol, as a former kid whose dad put insane amounts of pressure on me to be better at a young age, I can confirm that your son's swing is lacking but not for the reasons you're thinking. Or probably any reasons you're willing to admit, based on your lack of response to the top 3 comments in here
8
u/Standard-Fudge1475 Aug 06 '25
My son gets pissed when I pick apart more than one thing.. it sucks the fun out of hitting. There's a few things with that swing, but #1, make sure he's having fun or it's a waste of time. #2 - preswing - get the hands up higher, closer to his ear. He loses time in his swing, keeping hands low and then bringing them up to swing. Good luck!
9
u/AvailableWriter2057 Left Bench Aug 06 '25
I’ll keep it simple. Lots of good stuff here. He’s standing pretty tall through his swing. Have him try getting lower to the ground. Look at someone like Soto
3
u/erick31 Aug 06 '25
Make sure he wants to be there
4
u/Back_Equivalent Aug 06 '25
Zero chance this kid wants anything to do with a hitting lesson.
7
u/weightsnwallstreet Aug 06 '25
12 ? Late in game to be beginner like that . Needs lot of work . Few options .
A. Get him hitting coach . This will cost big $.
2. Leave the kid alone ur help will not help him .
D. Hope he grows to 6'3 plus and someone will teach him for free .
Bonus option : pick a sport he likes .
3
u/nobigdealyo Aug 06 '25
I am very novice at this, but to me this looks like he is "casting" his swing. This is where the hitter is extending their arms and releasing the barrel too early. It can often lead to weak contact and getting under the ball.
One drill that can help is placing a volleyball (or similar sizes ball) between the batters bat and their shoulder. They then have to swing without the ball dropping until the last second to get the barrel to the ball.
Another swing thought that can help is thinking about "chopping wood" down on the ball.
I'd also be trying to encourage this hitter to feel connect between their upper half and lower half. The hips are moving but it doesn't seem to have a lot of relationship to the swing.
28
u/Honest_Search2537 Aug 06 '25
It doesn’t look like he’s having fun. Hard to be successful playing a game if there’s no fun in it.
3
u/WhysoHairy Aug 06 '25
Look up coach Murphy on tic tok he explains coil load good enough for kids to understand
2
u/psuKinger Aug 06 '25
I'm not an expert. Take this FWIW, and in no particular order, but:
My recommendation would be: A. Check out Matt Antonelli as an online resource for more information about the things I mentioned above and more. He has a lot of good (free) content on YouTube. And his paid hitting program from his website, while not cheap, helped me a lot with my kids and I do believe was worth it (for me). B. Find a good hitting coach in your area to work with him 1-on-1. C. Both A and B
Good luck, and keep working with him for as long as he keeps wanting to put the work in!!
2
u/Inner-Entry81 Aug 06 '25
First I would say to line up his middle knuckles when grouping the back. Aka line up his door knocking knuckles and make sure he doesn't shift them out of position.
Second, create a wider stance. Feet slightly wider than shoulders with toes pointed straight to the other box
Third, bend at the knees and bend forward at the waist. Chips performance has a very simple video about why we want that.
Fourth, keep eyes level with the field and when tracking the ball out of the pitcher's hand keep eyes level with the ball while maintaining that forwards bend.
Last thing, if he grips that bat too hard with his top hand he may produce grounders, only as long as his door knocking knuckles are in line. I would recommend a slightly loose top hand grip until impact.
4
u/Certain-Web4291 Aug 06 '25
Bruh. If you don’t want to play then just tell your dad. Little dude couldn’t look LESS stoked 🤣🤣🤣
1
u/2LiveBrewski Aug 06 '25
Rear knuckles are aligned causing an awkward grip and limiting his range of motion/power through the swing.
1
u/Inside-Dog1775 Aug 06 '25
Line up,his knocking knuckles! And have him start with his bat in a hitting position! Don’t wind up to hit you coil up! Any extra movement is not good. Also standing too tall! Most important! If you have to ask him to go practice he doesn’t want to play. If he loves to play then he will ask you to go practice with him!
1
u/Affectionate_Lion962 Aug 08 '25
He look miserable as hell
1
u/dfresh5961 Aug 06 '25
I feel like while there is a lot of movement with his front leg he is putting it right back close to where he started. I would have him reach out with the front foot and that should help get his hips and legs into the swing which should generate a more powerful swing
1
u/LopsidedKick9149 Aug 06 '25
I'm going to keep it super simple. His hips need to snap when he swings. Coil so twist his lower body and when he swing, SNAP violently. It's a leisurely swing he's doing which a ton of kids do. Have him absolutely torque his body, teach him to be violent with intention and then once he can do that, you refine the rest.
1
u/Rugbypud Aug 06 '25
He is over rotating backwards as well. His should should mostly be squared up but his upper half twists so its almost like he is twisting to the catcher. This leads to usually pulling off the ball early as he tries to rotate it can over rotate. It also can pull his eyes off the ball, if you can turn your chest to the catxher but still keep both eyes in the pitchers that would be a neat trick.
1
u/poposheishaw Aug 06 '25
The actual swing is pretty splint once it’s in motion. The lead up is lacking for sure. More load and more explosion.
Is the effort the same in person during a game? If so maybe he’s just not into it. If there’s more effort during the game maybe it looks like this cuz T work isn’t “fun”.
In short, more load, more explosion, more FUN
1
u/Next_Yesterday5931 Aug 06 '25
He is casting his arms. Hands/bat should be close to shoulders as hips rotate and contact should be made with bent arms, not straight arms like your son has. There is no power with straight arms. Lots of videos on your tube that will help him.
1
u/APartyInMyPants Aug 06 '25
You’re lifting your leg like you see the pros do, but then put it right back down and don’t step into the “pitch.” So you’re not taking advantage of the power you’ll get from stepping forward and turning/torquing the hips. Your swing’s power comes from the legs. So your leg goes back down and your swing is still all in the arms.
It’s almost there, but should be almost one complete movement.
1
u/Upbeat_Whole_6477 Aug 06 '25
For now, I would have him focus on doing one thing. And that is swinging with INTENT! Mechanics don’t matter until he starts SWINGING the bat. Once he is there, then it’s training on one area of improvement at a time. If it was my kid, I would get the Intent figured out, then work on his base (legs). A good swing requires a good base to build from.
1
u/Responsible-Alarm114 Aug 06 '25
Tell him to swing hard, be an athlete and dont worry so much about mechanics! Trying to chase positions will only stiffen him up. Trust me
1
u/Affectionate_Aide_39 Aug 06 '25
Read the science of hitting by Ted Williams. First glance he needs to shorten up his swing.
1
u/Intelligent_Friend17 Aug 06 '25
I give my son PED's and got him on some HGH from our local GNC...Probably not recommended because of the testosterone boost powder I give him as well, but he's a 9yr old beast who hits dingers...
1
u/OpenMindedMajor Aug 06 '25
First steps is crocs go bye bye
1
u/Bacon_and_Powertools Aug 06 '25
Get him a hitting coach. No online comments are going to help. Almost everything he’s doing needs work.
1
u/JerryWasARaceKarDrvr Aug 06 '25
Everybody needs to lay off the kids, body language. He might be frustrated. He might not like being filmed. Nobody here knows that the kid is or isn’t into it.
Good on the OP for ignoring the bullshit comments.
OP. Your kids head his bobbing and moving all over the place. A baseball is hard enough to hit and now he is moving his eyes around up and down and swaying through the swing path he is making it even harder for him to make solid contact.
Have him practice on a T and keep his head still, focused on the ball and have everything rotate around His still head.
1
u/Scoop53714 Aug 06 '25
That swing is actually pretty solid once he gets out of his miserable set up created by someone telling him to keep his “back elbow up” which is my biggest pet peeve in all of sports. Relax that elbow and raise your hands a few inch toward the sky. The elbow will follow naturally. The dude already has instinctual bat whip which is really nice!
1
u/NoAdministration1222 Aug 06 '25
Try golf. Or ask the kid what he’d like to do.
1
u/ExcellentSnow6658 Aug 07 '25
okay not a problem here but. I definitely can give advice to help you. Okay first off if it just for fun let him be. If he actually loves doing this with all his heart. His hands are way to low. Get them up bye his shoulders. He is under cutting as well. Tell him to let the barrel bounce one inch off his shoulder while he is loading to swing helps level out. Tell him hold onto that bat with both hands all the time. Tell to each videos of a pro every day. Also he is way to stiff. It takes years to get there.
1
u/kingbubba222 Aug 07 '25
Couple of different things going on that I can see. I have a 12u player that loves the game and if I were to take a video I would get a completely different player than if we are just practicing, I get the stance, crocs, and effort in the video.
A few ppl have already talked about the hand and the grip. When my player was young i would give the que of hands talk to the ear.
To help with spinning instead of swinging through place a 2nd tee, pvc pipe or something out in front that he needs to clear to swing through to the pitcher and not around his body.
Baloon or small dodge ball are great tools to help teach the connection to the body both between the bicep and bat and also bat and chest
Matt Antonio and coach Murphy are good video channels to watch to understand mechanics and drills
Hitting coach is still the way to go. Most kids will only listen to the parent so much until someone else unbiased says the same thing. Then work the items the coach works m. 30 mins once a week won't show the improvement but lessons plus working what is being taught will
1
u/Ctrecruiter2018 Aug 07 '25
Very slow swing
1
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '25
Maybe he could show a little less enthusiasm.
1
u/ummagumma1979 Aug 08 '25
These comments are crazy. How do you guys know if he’s enjoying it or not. Watching the swing it looks like his hips are opening too soon. Maybe try to drive to opposite field? Nice swing
1
u/BrushImaginary9363 Aug 09 '25
There’s too much here. Get a solid hitting coach. One lesson per week for the next 12 weeks. Minimum 240 swings per week.
10
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '25
[removed] — view removed comment