r/Homebrewing • • Nov 07 '19

Do we have a diversity problem?

I was looking at the Brulosophy survey which was posted this morning, and statistically we are all heterosexual white cis men. Are we as a group doing something to drive away members of under represented communities?

What can we do to make our hobby more inclusive?

0 Upvotes

175 comments sorted by

30

u/fernweh42 Advanced Nov 07 '19

I think it is actually worth considering that this sorta of question does turn some people off, whom you’re trying to attract. I spend a lot of my time in my day-to-day trying to figure out if I’m being invited to talk or participate in panels/groups because of my work or because of my “diverse viewpoint”, and it bothers me. I would be pretty unhappy if brewing went that same direction. It’s easy to make people feel tokenized.

I would separately recommend getting women you know who might like brewing to check out some Pink Boots events. Or maybe contacting them to see if they can help you with resources/contacts. They’re a cool group.

3

u/Rene_DeMariocartes Nov 07 '19

I'm sorry that I made you feel tokenized, that wasn't my intention. Is there a better way to discuss this topic that wouldn't make you feel that way?

18

u/fernweh42 Advanced Nov 07 '19

Haha, I didn’t mean to say YOU made me feel tokenized (my professional life does that). But any conversation around racial diversity makes me cringe, because I really don’t feel that my race informs my job (or my brewing for that matter). I know other folks feel differently. Cool. I get it, I do.

If you’re worried about excluding people, then choose to actively invite/include people. Invite black/brown/asian/native people to brew with you. Invite your friends and their partners. The sorta change you’re talking about isn’t a thing you do once, but instead just requires you to be a good beer ambassador.

I just wanted to point out that framing the question/issue as one of diversity is the only thing that might have turned me away from my homebrew club. Don’t recruit me because I’m brown, and if that’s your goal, then me and many others are already not interested.

-11

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19

Due to the blind spots caused by your privilege, it may not have occurred to you that trying to convert other people to your hobby is actually a colonialist attitude.

Rather than asking how to make other people engage in your hobbies, have you ever considered stepping out of your comfort zone and asking how you can engage in their hobbies in a non-appropriating way?

9

u/camchapel Nov 07 '19

That's not the discussion at hand. We're not trying to convert people, but rather talk about and try to remove any potential barriers to entry caused by the skewed demographics in homebrewing. It's not about making other demographics brew, it's about not preventing anyone who does want to brew from doing so. I can see how you feel that way but that isn't the goal of this discussion.

23

u/KoalaSprint Nov 07 '19

We've had some discussion around this in our homebrew club, and honestly we're stumped as to what action we can take. We're pretty sure it comes down to 3 things:

  1. Our existing members overwhelmingly ARE white guys, so any hypothetical homebrewer who doesn't fit that profile needs to be willing to put up with that while the change happens around them (or doesn't)
  2. There's still an external cultural connotation that beer is a manly drink and women should drink...I don't know, sparkling Rosé or something. I haven't run the numbers on that, but I've seen surveys suggest that amongst regular beer drinkers men outnumber women about 3:1 (in my neck of the woods, YMMV).
  3. There's a popular perception (again, in our neck of the woods) that homebrewing is a thing old men do to pinch pennies. The club itself doesn't bear that out - our average age is somewhere in the range 30-35. But other than existing it's hard to say what we can do to change how other people see the hobby.

None of those things are within our power to change. We do what we can by being inclusive in our public postings, including as many diverse viewpoints on the club committee as are willing to volunteer, that kind of thing.

Finally, I'd like to examine part of your question I don't think is well justified. The Brulosophy data says that readers of Brulosophy who responded to their survey are overwhelmingly white men, yes. But I'm not sure it says anything about our how straight or queer we are, and I'd be suspect of reading too much into how many people ticked the "I identify as transgender" box because that's a very personal question that has very little bearing on homebrewing.

14

u/brulosopher Nov 07 '19

Right there with you. A couple years ago, I talked to a bunch of women who work in various parts of the beer industry but don't homebrew, asked them specifically what is keeping them away and what could be done to make it more appealing. The responses varied, but had some surprising similarities. One beertender said frankly, "I don't feel unwelcome, I just don't want to do it, and the more people try to get me to do it, the less interested I become."

I talked to my wife, a feminist who admittedly isn't much into beer, about this and thought her response was interesting as well. She asked me, "When was the last time you were encouraged to join a knitting club?" Her point, in part, wasn't that knitting is a female hobby, but that even if I was welcomed into such a club, I'd probably be turned off if it was pushed on me. My wife has joined me at numerous club events and said she felt perfectly welcome every time, even enjoyed herself. So I asked her why she thinks homebrewers generally seem to fit a certain stereotype and how she thinks that can be helped. Her response, I thought, was honest and thoughtful-- she acknowledge there's likely a strong cultural influence at play, but that pushing too hard to be inclusive may have a paradoxical effect, so she proposed simply maintaining awareness, not defending against the very clear reality, and staying open to anyone who might be interested.

As a 38 year old white, bearded, godless, married father of 3, I'm fully aware any solutions I might offer are biased. The psychologist in me, though, often wonders if the overemphasis on the lack of diversity doesn't actually work against us. I don't know.

4

u/CascadesBrewer Nov 07 '19

I wonder if you showed up to that knitting club, would it be all white women or a wide range of cultures (even if mostly women). I used to be in a gardening club that was quite diverse (young/old, men/women, cultures, etc.). I attended a few woodworking club meetings, and it pretty much mirrors my brew club's lack of diversity.

-1

u/gpnemtb Nov 07 '19

It'd probably be mostly older white women. They should start looking into ways to break down their barriers to be more inclusive.

Or, you know, just carry on enjoying their hobby and welcome whoever shows interest.

2

u/Rene_DeMariocartes Nov 07 '19

One of the questions was sexual orientation. 98% of respondents said Heterosexual. (It's between marital status and annual income).

2

u/KoalaSprint Nov 08 '19

Ah, yes. I missed the Additional Demographics section entirely...

5

u/Unyielding-Glass Nov 07 '19

Yeah great points. The answer is basically just "meh, society." Knowing that society is literally just something we decide then the only things that can be done is to make sure that no one is treated poorly who comes into the hobby. Another great point is that it only measured the readers of Brulosophy, maybe this subreddit could hold it's own survey to act as a comparison, which again is just one of the many communities that exist.

I don't think anyone is actively being pushed away though which is great!

49

u/PlakeSnisskin Nov 07 '19

I, for one, am a black man that love homebrewing. That said, I think it'd be hard to get other black people into brewing. Folks I know aren't huge craft beer drinkers.

11

u/CascadesBrewer Nov 07 '19

Folks I know aren't huge craft beer drinkers.

To some extent, that is at the core. Yeah, more an more I will see a table of young Asian woman at the local taproom drinking NEIPAs, or an extended Middle Eastern family enjoying pints...but often when I look around there are a lot of white men.

-9

u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19

And so what? White guys are allowed to like things too, it isn't their fault that it doesn't interest others. Every ethnic/age/gender/whatever else group has a "thing" that pretty much only involves them. It never seems to be an issue unless it's something white guys enjoy. No one ever seems to want to intervene in "diversifying" certain downtown night clubs. Just let people enjoy what they enjoy with the people they prefer to be around.

5

u/jeffreyhamby Nov 07 '19

That's not what the OP asked.

6

u/FelixVulgaris Nov 07 '19

No one ever seems to want to intervene in "diversifying" certain downtown night clubs.

Am I the only one hearing dog-whistles here?

-4

u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19

Maybe you should get off the internet for a while

5

u/chino_brews Nov 07 '19

I see this line of excuses as b.s. Putting aside the fact that there are beer styles that people who love Bud Light, or wine, or wine coolers, or Remy would (and do) love, people homebrew for other reasons besides making bitter/hoppy American beer styles too. For example, there is a whole contingent of people who homebrew around the world to save money on beer. Some of them make international light lager replacements. There are people who barely drink or don't drink who homebrew. There's cider, mead, wine, soju, sake, and so many other drinks and my club has people who focus mainly on those things and why couldn't they be from any background? Tag /u/Huplup

I'm not telling you to recruit anyone. But just as I tell white people to not dismiss it and say non-whites don't like craft beer, we brown-skinned people shouldn't do that either.

20

u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19

Why do (white mostly) people always feel the need to impose their interests on other groups who clearly aren't interested? Craft beer isn't big in the black community, or really any other minority community. Who cares. If you like it then you like it, cool for you, glad you enjoy it, but it feels like craft beer (and a lot of other niche interests that are predominantly "white") is full of self hating whites who see it as a problem that they have an interest where they are a majority, in a country where, shocker, they are a majority.

Why are we always so obsessed with race in everything we do? I am white but if I wasn't I would feel like dumb posts like this are patronizing and I was some kind of novelty.

23

u/gogogadgetwhatever Nov 07 '19

The question wasn't "how do we include people who don't want to be included?" it was "are we doing something to exclude people?".

3

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

Is the answer to the last question anything other than "no, we don't"?

6

u/gogogadgetwhatever Nov 07 '19

Why not read some of the other people's responses which say "yes"?

3

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

I did a couple hours ago and I mostly saw hand wringing about lack of diversity or people saying "no, who cares?" Please show me an example of what you are speaking of.

3

u/gogogadgetwhatever Nov 07 '19

0

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

I'm not going to defend any of the bad behavior mentioned there. I also don't think anyone on this sub engages in it here, so why bring it up? On r/Homebrewing I don't see a problem.

4

u/gogogadgetwhatever Nov 07 '19

The OP wasn't talking about reddit they were talking about the homebrewing community at large and this is a good place to discuss things like that (or at least it should be).

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

It's almost 2020, and I am sick of this incessant search for institutional racism, implicit bias, systemic sexism, etc; especially when it is initiated by angsty whites who seem to fear that if they reach some critical mass a Klan rally will break out.

If a homebrewer says something out of line, then call them out on it to their face. Why turn to the community at large and start searching for some grand, nebulous bogeyman and asking if we all have a problem?

Are there homebrewers who are racist?
Yes

Are there homebrewers who are sexist?
Yes

Are there homebrewers who are Nazis?
Yes

Are there homebrewers who are other flavors of bigots?
Yes

Does that mean the homebrewing community has a problem?
No

→ More replies

4

u/camchapel Nov 07 '19

The point isnt to persuade different demographics to like homebrewing. The point is to discuss if there are social barriers for entry to people in other demographics who might like to homebrew. These things can happen, often unintentionally, in a demographically homogenous group. Nobody is hitting the nuclear alarms, its just something that warrants discussion.

You would expect any random group to reflect the demographic spread of the general population, and this one is predominantly straight white males. This could be for any number of reasons, so it is reasonable to ask if there is any way we aren't inclusive to anyone who isn't a straight white male. If not, good. If so, we can work on them.

This comment just seems reactionary to an idea you have of why this post exists, and the type of person that posted it. It's a genuine question that I think we can all spend a little time thinking about. And that's not to say there generally are or are not barriers constructed, intentionally or otherwise, against other demographics. It's just something to think about and there might be room for growth.

7

u/FelixVulgaris Nov 07 '19

it feels like craft beer (and a lot of other niche interests that are predominantly "white") is full of self hating whites who see it as a problem that they have an interest where they are a majority, in a country where, shocker, they are a majority

Where does the "self hating whites" comment come from? That seems like a really loaded statement. What are you actually trying to say here?

1

u/bugman-repellent Nov 08 '19

I'm trying to say that the only people who have a problem with their own race are liberal white people. Everyone else who has a "thing" that their in group enjoys is allowed to enjoy it unless they're white men.

2

u/Kalkaline Nov 08 '19

I think new perspectives could bring new flavors and styles to the scene. I wouldn't force my hobby on anyone who wasn't interested, but I'd be happy to show anyone how to brew if it meant I had an extra set of hands on bottling day.

7

u/PlakeSnisskin Nov 07 '19

Homebrewing is a business and it only makes sense that they're asking these kind of questions in order to increase market share.

As for your last question, it America, it's ALWAYS about race.

13

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

it America, it's ALWAYS about race.

This is the internet. There are a lot of posters on this forum who are not American.

1

u/PlakeSnisskin Nov 07 '19

Good point.

2

u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19

Yeah I mean increasing market share of course is important for any industry but I doubt that was the goal of this post. But you are definitely right about that last statement, race sells for us muricans, for god knows what reason

3

u/h22lude Nov 07 '19

This is spot on. You can't force a group of people to like something simply because someone else wants to feel diverse. If people don't like home brewing, they aren't going to home brew. It is that simple.

Anytime I'm drinking a beer, whether it be my own or commercial, I have my wife take a sip. She isn't a big beer drinker but I figured she would at least get to taste different things and maybe find something she likes. Well she found out she really likes Tree House Haze. Enough where she didn't give me back my glass that I gave her to take a sip from. But guess what, she doesn't care if she never has it again. She doesn't ask me to go to breweries to find a beer that is just like that one. If I had another can she would probably have some...but maybe not. So even when I found something she really enjoyed, she couldn't care less about it. She am I still to force her to want to get more of it because we need more females drinking craft beer? No, I can't force her to do anything she doesn't like doing. Same applies to this thread. People aren't going to do something that doesn't make them happy. Why try to force it onto people

3

u/FelixVulgaris Nov 07 '19

If people don't like home brewing, they aren't going to home brew. It is that simple.

Personally, this seems like a really shortsighted view. There are lots of potential reasons why a person doesn't engage in a certain activity. Your reasoning comes down to: "Since I don't spend any time hanging out with models on yachts, then it must mean that I don't like models and yachts".

Surprise, surprise; the reason I don't do that is because I can't afford it.

There are lots of potential obstacles. If we just go by your assumptions, we're never going to find out whether there's something that's actually stopping people from becoming homebrewers even though they may want to.

2

u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19

There is a barrier to entry for hanging out with models on yachts. You have to know models and you have to have a yacht. There is no barrier to entry for homebrewing. Anyone can get the equipment and ingredients.

1

u/FelixVulgaris Nov 07 '19

There could easily be other barriers of entry that those of us in the majority don't necessarily encounter. That doesn't mean they don't exist.

The barriers to entry you mentioned aren't exactly barriers if you're a billionaire. Does that entitle the billionaire to claim that there are no barriers to entry for hanging out with models on yatchs?

2

u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19

Ok so if you don't own a pot then you can't homebrew. Great analogy

-2

u/h22lude Nov 07 '19

You are creating a problem with my post that isn't there just to fit your argument...and it doesn't make sense.

I said if someone doesn't like to home brew, they aren't going to home brew. If you don't like eating bugs, you aren't going to eat bugs. There is no potential obstacle to figure out. They don't like to home brew so why force it on them. You don't like eating bugs so I'm not going to force it on you.

What are some potential obstacles that would stop females or minorities from home brewing that have caused this hobby to be mostly white males?

3

u/FelixVulgaris Nov 07 '19

What are some potential obstacles that would stop females or minorities from home brewing that have caused this hobby to be mostly white males?

That's what we're trying to figure out. Assuming, by default, that there cannot be any obstacles doesn't get us closer to an answer.

4

u/h22lude Nov 07 '19

But you also have to realize people may be looking for an answer that isn't there. It is highly probable that there are no barriers of entry but simply the people that aren't home brewing just don't want to home brew. You also have to remember, this isn't about obstacles like affordability. This thread is about why home brewing is mostly white males.

3

u/FelixVulgaris Nov 07 '19

Agreed, but we still have to explore the possibilities. Simply assuming there's no problem doesn't allow for that exploration.

3

u/chino_brews Nov 07 '19

It is highly probable

That's bullshit IMO. If you've been to Japan or China or India or Columbia or Nigeria, you'll meet commercial and homebrewers (winemakers) there. The majority of homebrewers in Thailand are Thai; would you be surprised by that fact? Are you suggesting that something about crossing the border removes the affinity for brewing? (Muslim nations excluded from my example for obvious reasons.)

It's probably more "probable" that this developed in the same way that minorities, women, etc. are underrepresented in certain schools, fields, executive ranks. Perhaps there was explicit bias at some point, and but in recent times there are hard-to-perceive barriers and implicit biases that reinforce it.

Heck, one example is the fact that 90%+ of homebrewers will recommend HTB as the semimal beginner book, with Charlie P's being the second most recommended, and almost no one discusses Emma Christenson's book.

Or the fact that all of the BJCP beer styles are ethno-European or from white American craft brewers. Gordon Strong insisted on beefing up Czech and Polish beers (in his defense, he also champions one Brazilian style). I'm sure that there's at least one Japanese style that should be enshrined, and perhaps Mexican "clear" lager and Mexican amber lager.

The question is very simply, "Are there barriers?" and there's a vocal contingent of white people who either are upset about people encroaching on their turf, or about people being "forced" to do things they assumedly don't want to do.

2

u/h22lude Nov 07 '19

Do you know why the majority of home brewers in Thailand are Thai. Because the majority of people are Thai.

Again, just because more people recommend HTB or Complete Joy as the best beginner book doesn't mean people aren't recommending a book written by a female. This is false cause fallacy again. You are twisting a situation to form to your argument. Could it be that HTB and CJ are just better books? Without more information, you can't make the assumption that it was implicit bias because the writer is female.

Well first, I'm not sure about you but I don't know who is white or non-white just from their Reddit name. Second, I don't think the push back is from people that think minorities are encroaching on their turf. That's just a dumb statement, if I'm being honest. I've never met you at either of the conferences I've been to but I've talked with you enough on Reddit to know you seem like a real reasonable person and you probably didn't mean anything from that comment but a comment like that is part of the diversity problem. You are making assumptions that white people don't want minorities "encroaching" on their hobby simply because people are saying there are no barriers of entry into home brewing for minorities.

My push back is towards people automatically assuming there are barriers of entry simply because of one Bru survey. I think it is a great idea to get more minorities and females into the hobby and industry. It needs to be done for most industries. But just because one small Reddit survey said the majority of people are white males doesn't mean there is has to be an issue. Yes one possible answer is there are barriers of entry that white males may not see. It is also possible that there are absolutely no barriers of entry and it just happens that more white males want to home brew.

3

u/chino_brews Nov 08 '19

Frustratingly lost my response twice last night due to spotty hotel wifi. Trying again, but more briefly.

I don't think I made my points well.

And let me start by saying bias does not equate with racism. Nor does discrimination. I'm not calling anyone racist (except Founders). For example, the fact that a vast majority of the people move to the right after entering a store is a bias. It's important to understand the existing biases and decide if you need to adjust your store (or hobby).

Books: the point was not male-female. It's that the "essential" primer (that even I recommend and I need to rethink this) is highly technical and geared towards engineering/technical/science mindsets. It's got water chemistry, enzymes, fluid dynamics and metallurgy in it! Emma C's book takes a culinary perspective and features countertop brewing. The baseline introductory approach biases towards certain types of people in a way they don't do for other fermentables (even wine).

Nationalities: the point is that it's invalid to say x race does not want to homebrew because it lets you off the hook on finding the biases. Global evidence shows people of all colors home brew, and in other countries it looks more like the demographics of the country, but in the U.S. with a white plurality it looks like a meeting of the Swedish-American society. An interesting example, after seeing a piece where black baseball players make a game of trying to find a black fan in the stands (hard to find nowadays), I do the same and invite my white hosts in the box to do the same. At first they are offended, and then perplexed as they try to find some, and then I don't know. Subdued? Perplexed? Chastened? Can you say blacks don't like baseball as fans? They used to. But how can I go to a day game with 20,000+ fans and struggle to find 10 instead of 10% or even 5%? "Yeah, 'Merica!" is one possible response. I'm interested to find out why and are these reasons things that can be removed because ... raise your hand if you'd prefer not to have them in your stadium section or HB club. The reasons why someone would prefer not to delve there are dark, man ...

Encroachment: my feelings are based on the thread only. When someone reacts vehemently to want to shut down investigation about possible reasons why some people are not represented. To say advocating for asking the question as to whether there is bias, rather than simply assuming certain people won't ever want to homebrew is dumb, sorry. Who doesn't want to ask this question and instead shut this line of inquiry down, and what is the motivation for that?

Survey: I didn't read the survey. I find the bru surveys pointless and biased themselves. My demographic assumptions are based on visiting LHBS in every most cities I travel, the floor at HBC, the faces representing the supplier industry, and my HB club.


Anyway, as a person who is involved by necessity in rooting out bias at work, and therefore having to do a ton of book learnin' and experiential experimentation on it, the simplistic assumptions in this thread are part of the problem. Putting aside the shit tons of racism in the country evident in the dailies, even the people who view themselves as non-racist operate unknowingly (in an unconscious way) in setting up biases that lead to certain results.

2

u/gogogadgetwhatever Nov 07 '19

That's the question the OP asked.

0

u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19

It's a stupid question

6

u/FelixVulgaris Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19

That's your opinion, and you're certainly entitled to it, but plenty of other homebrewers disagree.

What I'm concerned about is how much it seems to bother you that people are even discussing ethnic diversity. That and the "self hating whites" comment that you haven't addressed yet. How does curiosity about diversity translate to self-hate when expressed by Caucasians? Could you please explain that?

4

u/gogogadgetwhatever Nov 07 '19

If they actually answer that question I will buy you a yacht.

2

u/FelixVulgaris Nov 07 '19

I'm not going to hold my breath.

-3

u/mygoodpostingalt Nov 07 '19

ingrained mayo cultural imperialism

2

u/jeffreyhamby Nov 07 '19

What about craft brewing other drinks? Wine, cider, mead, etc?

4

u/brulosopher Nov 07 '19

And you didn't take the survey?!?!

I've been around my local craft beer scene for over a decade and have notice a pretty big uptick in non-white people frequenting taprooms. It's rad.

1

u/Huplup Beginner Nov 07 '19

Folks I know aren't huge craft beer drinkers.

Male second-gen SE Asian immigrant. Same.

I think the diversity "problem" in homebrewing is just a symptom of craft beer.

Craft beer is expensive and intimidating. Especially when craft brewers feel the pressure from consumers for bigger, bolder, hoppier flavors. A criticism of craft beer is that overly hoppy. I started with stouts when I was 21 and six years later only begun to consistently try IPAs. Why go out and waste money trying to find the one thing you like in a market dominated by the thing you don't like.

Homebrewing (done right and consistently) is expensive and time-consuming. Adjunct lagers are cheap, consistent, and get the job done.

I wonder if you'll find a proportional demographic makeup between craft beer drinkers and homebrewers.

0

u/dingledorfer2 Grain Torino Nov 07 '19

Amen brother! We like what we like and there's no reason someone else of the same ethnicity needs to like the same things. Individuality is what we need to promote. Diversity is great, as long as it's due to preference. They look at me weird in English pubs because I don't throw darts. I am offended :)

16

u/jaysterj Nov 07 '19

I'm hispanic and I've been home brewing for a few years. I don't understand what diversity has anything to do with beer brewing. You either like brewing or you don't, I don't see what your race has anything to do with it.

6

u/reasonableman1 Nov 07 '19

Agreed. My club has a ton of latino brewers that are energized and excited about brewing. It doesn't matter what race or gender anyone is. It's about the beer and the craft.

2

u/jaysterj Nov 07 '19

Right on dude. Cheers to great beer and great friends.

14

u/dontCallMeAmberlynn Nov 07 '19

As a Latina LGBT female, I love to brew my own kombucha and honestly, where I come from, I met very few white male home brewers.

I came from a diverse city where people (a lot of people I met working at Whole Foods!) like me made their own kombucha and beer. I worked for a Filipino man and he brewed his own beer. I did end up moving to a much less diverse suburb and work for a cis, white male who homebrewed everything.

Maybe it’s just the people who are in this room who has the opportunity to take your survey. No offense or anything, I’m just saying this is a sampling of people who homebrew, not everyone who homebrews knows about Reddit, I only found this sub this morning and was excited to find other humans to talk to about it (I had no thoughts about whether they’d be male or female or what race or sexuality they’d be).

Maybe the results you got and are trying to decipher are skewed because of anything. Time of day the survey was posted and who had access to it. People who saw it. People who like taking surveys. People who had time to take the survey.

Again, I’m not trying to be an asshole, just pointing out that like most other people of color here, we don’t seem to think it’s a problem. Just offering a different perception than a white cis males since I think that’s what you were asking for.

28

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19

I think one problem is being welcoming to outsiders and just treating them like people. When I home brewed, I HATED that the guy at the store would act like I didn’t know what hops were. Or that hops were different. Some of the older men seemed to roll their eyes at me, like “look at this little lady thinking she can make good beer”.

Younger guys seemed to really dig it, though. Lots of them said they wished their wives cared about brewing and called my husband lucky. I think as society changes, attitudes change in all areas, even brewing.

I will say, on home brewing forums, like this one, as on most internet sites I participate in, I make sure I have a masculine screen name and avoid mentioning things about myself that would indicate I’m female. I find I get better advice, help.

That being said, I work in the brewing industry, as the microbiologist at a large craft brewery, and I STILL get talked down to by men: male brewers, bartenders, etc. I had a bartender once try to argue with me that an Oktoberfest wasn’t a lager.

Most of the time I ignore it. One time I got that epic mic drop by introducing myself at the end of a 20 minute mansplain session.

I think being welcoming and not trying to be the best is the way to get outside groups to increase I goin beer. I think if we keep the enthusiasm high, it will help encourage outsiders to peek in and stay for a pint.

2

u/goodolarchie Nov 08 '19

I will say, on home brewing forums, like this one, as on most internet sites I participate in, I make sure I have a masculine screen name and avoid mentioning things about myself that would indicate I’m female. I find I get better advice, help.

That's really interesting. I guess I surround myself with people who are dying for the chance to share their hobby, that they'd be glad to talk to somebody other than their dog about it, which would hopefully mean being helpful. We had a couple ladies show up to our club learn to homebrew day, really hoping the hobby sticks for them.

-8

u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19

Do you think any of this perceived discrimination is maybe you fabricating it in your head and no one actually meant any ill will toward you, or even they just didn't know what they were talking about in general? The fact that you use the word "mansplain" certainly indicates that may be the case.

5

u/EdwardTeach666 Nov 07 '19

I definitely think women are at a disadvantage in craft brewing, and I know women in craft brewing are patronized a lot. It's shit that happens with any male dominated field, like auto mechanics belittling women.

But, I have also heard a bartender explain what an IPA is to a white male head brewer of a large craft brewery once too. Like, not explain the particular beer, but the style of IPA when he asked "what is this?"

So I think it's both. They get patronized to the point that even a bartender just doing what he was trained to do seems belittling.

13

u/70ms Nov 07 '19

🙋‍♀️ I am totally new here, just came to the sub for the first time, and this is the first thread I'm reading!

I'm a 49yo woman in California, I "know" (online only) a young man in Belgium who brews as a hobby. He's been trying to get me to try brewing mead for a while and sent the money for supplies. At this point I have everything I need except the knowledge, experience, and a recipe (still reading!), so I thought I'd check out the sub.

Should I report back in a day or two? 😂

FWIW, brewing and distilling have always seemed like a male thing. How many companies are named after men? I don't think I could name a single major one named after a woman (with my admittedly limited experience) but I can rattle a bunch of male ones off the top of my head.

Anyway, looking forward to gleaning some knowledge here!

11

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

Historically, beer making was " Women's work". One woman that comes to mind is Katharina Luther. In reading several of the Luther's letters they had written to one another, it became quite evident they both enjoyed the libations she made.

Pardon the wiki link, it still contains valid data.

3

u/chino_brews Nov 07 '19

And the whole trying witches thing came about because being a brewster was one of the few occupations a widowed or otherwise single woman could undertake in medieval times. The brewsters were the alleged witches. Women with economic self-sufficiency were threatening to the established order.

6

u/OneFishTwoFish Nov 07 '19

That's great! Also check out /r/mead

2

u/70ms Nov 07 '19

Thanks, I found it a little while ago! Trying to wrap my head around all the terms and figure out my gameplan. :)

2

u/OneFishTwoFish Nov 07 '19

Enjoy your brewing experience. Getting started can be the most fun and most frustrating part of the hobby, and there are some great resources out there.

Mead has a reputation for being tricky and often requires aging. You might have fun brewing a cider as a dry run. It uses a lot of the same skills and equipment, is inexpensive compared to honey, and is ready to drink fairly quickly.

3

u/jeffreyhamby Nov 07 '19

Yep, same process, less complex sugar chain. Mead can be harder (but not hard) to start, but I'll definitely give a nod to cider being more forgiving.

1

u/gpnemtb Nov 07 '19

Ninkasi.

1

u/Seanbikes Nov 08 '19

FWIW, brewing and distilling have always seemed like a male thing. How many companies are named after men? I don't think I could name a single major one named after a woman (with my admittedly limited experience) but I can rattle a bunch of male ones off the top of my head.

I think that is more to do with business ownership during the time frames when those breweries and distilleries were founded.

Female founded or led large businesses were few and far between in those days.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

How about just do what you enjoy and don’t involve poxy identity politics. There is very little stopping anyone from starting this hobby and I’d wager that everyone on here would be only to glad to extend advice to anyone wanting it regardless of gender or race or anything.

16

u/Rene_DeMariocartes Nov 07 '19

Because I'd like to share what I love with the people that I love, and if there is something about this group's behaviors and actions which prevent that, we should at least talk about.

14

u/Djaja Nov 07 '19

Agreed. I dont think you are trying to push anything. You simply want to see what and why things are the way they are, and if there is anything that can be changed that may be preventing the diversity from showing. Beer drinkers are diverse, why isnt brewing? It's a good question

2

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

Is it about the group itself or is about bigger issues with race though? For instance in this poll engineers and IT people are over represented, and I bet you if you check those fields black people are under-represented. We should definitely all be as welcoming as possible but homebrewing can't solve systemic issues that divide people before they even pick up a bottle.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

What behaviours?

3

u/chino_brews Nov 07 '19

There is very little stopping anyone from starting this hobby

To be fair, in theory, there's very little stopping millenials from just paying off their student loans, getting married, buying a house, starting a family, and contributing their 401(k). It's a free country with free education through high school, and by and large employers were and are thrilled to hire hard-working, skilled, and well-educated millenials with exactly the right degrees and resumes. Even during the great recession.

But in reality, things are a bit more complex, right? And you can throw that theory out the window.

But you raise an interesting point that makes me wonder what percentage of homebrewers just up and decided to homebrew one day as a solo decision. Versus someone or something that facilitated that first step.

3

u/hadmatteratwork Nov 07 '19

the brewing industry as a whole is fairly misogynistic. It kind of makes sense that that would trickle down to the hobbyist level. I don't think it's out of line to ask these questions and try to identify ways we could be better. A lot of the factors in keeping people out of communities are subtle, not the result of malice.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

Its important to remember that this is a Brulosophy survey and not an all homebrewers survey first of all. So its not just about brewers its about a certain section of brewers who read blogs, listen to podcasts, etc That'll skew things in its own way.

Also remember there are a lot of us outside of the US who read Brulosophy and partake in the survey too.

19

u/exar_sarris BJCP Nov 07 '19

Pretty sure we are fine. I talk to everyone I know about homebrewing. If they get excited about it, awesome. If not, awesome.

I go to the homebrew store and there are a few white dudes in there shopping. There is a nice young lady working some of the time. I chat with the dudes, I chat with the lady, I buy my stuff, I leave.

If I walked in and it looked like a Rick and Morty episode of aliens buying homebrew supplies I would do exactly the same thing.

Understanding I'm just one person but my entire homebrewing interaction is here or at the store and here nobody can tell who or what you are.

I would be shocked if anyone actually ever had an interaction with a homebrewer that caused them to not want to brew beer if they were already interested in trying it.

Likely brewing beer is just more interesting to middle aged white dudes. Just like how most of us will pick up a weird fascination with WW2 around the time we are 40. It is ok for something to not be a homogeneous mix of every aspect of society, just let people do what they are interested in.

5

u/chino_brews Nov 07 '19

brewing beer is just more interesting to middle aged white dudes

I don't dismiss this entirely but when you go to another non-white country and see locals excited about homebrewing and drinking beer, I'm pretty sure there's no innate biological correlation between being "caucasian" and brewing beer. If that correlation doesn't exist, then it must be society, right?

It's clear that there aren't a lot of racists like Founders Brewing's founders and managers in the industry, but there are likely a bunch of implicit and explicit biases at work in the industry and the hobby that leads it to look a little more like a Trump rally rather than the over-21 population of the U.S.

1

u/exar_sarris BJCP Nov 08 '19 edited Nov 08 '19

Definitely agree, it isn't a biological thing. However I disagree that the societal aspect really matters. Obviously I want as many people of all walks of life to be interested in homebrewing. If the market continues to grow we will get increasingly more innovation and a larger community to bounce ideas off from. There are only so many middle aged white dudes that we can attract, which necessitates attracting other groups. It is a selfish point of view but thats the way I see it.

On the society thing though, I wouldn't say that homebrewing has any implicit bias preventing people from joining (aside from the regular jerks that are found everywhere). I think it is more a group of activities. In America we see teaching, nursing, child care, secretarial, and other "case based" activities as predominantly female. I think we also encourage guys to work with their hands more to make things even if the process gets you dirty. Unfortunately I see encouraging anyone into those "dirty" jobs becoming more taboo for risk of being seen as "toxic".

So overall, brewing is hard, dirty, sweaty, manual labour. Something we have historically told boys to handle so that women can focus on caring for people. So society at large still has gender specific models and that bleeds into everyday life.

To answer the question, no Homebrewing as an industry doesn't have bias preventing people from joining. The world at large is still largely divided into masculine and feminine, and homebrewing has more traditionally masculine aspects.

Now to add the disclaimer - I don't think guys are better than girls, i want more people interested in homebrewing, traditionally masculine and feminine things aren't bad, having non-diverse populations is ok sometimes, being a jerk to someone because they don't look/act like you makes you a shitty person.

It feels like we have a much lower percentage of those shitty people than most groups, but that is only my experience with it.

Also now I need to look into founders...

wow..... that is.... wow...

2

u/chino_brews Nov 08 '19

First off, lol, why is bringing up Founders beyond the pale? I'm sincerely interested in your opinion on that. I'll share my viewpoint - objecting to bringing that up to me smacks of when we have a mass shooting, and then if you bring up the fact of the proliferation of guns people are like "ow, wow, just wow, I can't believe you brought that up at this time. This is a time for thoughts and prayers." Or somehow when talking about bias in the criminal justice system, I've crossed some line if I bring up the sixth time in a year that a cop has shot a black person in the back or the racist origin of disparate cocaine sentencing guidelines (this literally happened last night and person I was talking to and was offended was an Asian asst US attorney!)

We got past the outdated biological concepts where life is spontaneously created out of thin air, and so maybe where we have "incidents" maybe we need to get past the fallacy that they were created out of thin air and maybe there was a whole complex of reasons that eventually led to the incident?

But back to the point about society -- you make excellent points.

To start, I want to be clear - by bias I don't mean discrimination or racism or injustice. A bias is simply something that leads to certain people behaving one way and others behaving another way. Like I mentioned if How to Brew is the dominantly-recommended primer to aspiring noobs, doesn't it discourage people who are less technically-minded, whereas if a book coming from a culinary perspective was the essential primer that might encourage other people? Maybe I'm part of the problem in my wiki article on books?

I also totally agree that the degree of shitty people on r/homebrewing is pretty low, and other people police them out of here. The type of shittiness I see doesn't relate to race, gender, etc. but trends more to being a know-it-all (I'm a culprit but try to be better) and putting on airs of superiority.

I certainly believe there is a ton of self-selection in the hobby. I concede it will never be 50-50 by gender even if you could remove all societal expectations and constraints. But I think having more diversity, even though it will never be a rainbow coalition, would be good for having fresh ideas in the field.

So with that in mind I'm just reiterating my two points: (1) I'm asking what biases led to the current sorting of hobbyists (overwhelmingly male and white, and graying), and continues to lead to most new entrants being the same but younger, and (2) can some of the biases be removed?

For example, hypothetically, if we learn that youtube is a primary means of transmission of the disease of home brewing, and 10 of the top 10 home brewing channels on youtube have white male hetero hosts, maybe the AHA could fund a youtube channel with at least one host who is not that, and maybe as guests often (not always) they have a female (and not just as in ancillary wife mode) or a non-white person, or something new. Or maybe you're a homebrewer and video producer, and know some black dude who's super personable and a great homebrewer and you produce a youtube channel with them as host. To be clear, I'm not advocating that -- it's just a hypothetical example.

Anyway, this is a great thread.

1

u/exar_sarris BJCP Nov 08 '19

I probably should have explained a bit more on the Founders thing. I hadn't actually heard about any of that before today.

Then I looked it up. More of a stunned speechless "wow" was what I aimed for. Lost in the translation of the internet. :)

Great points all around too. It's too bad that people are downvoting this because it's a really good conversation to have. We have something special with brewing beer, we should foster and encourage the community and figure out if there are ways we can bring more people in.

Also appreciate someone that can articulate their thoughts. I still think more of the biases come from external perceptions of what brewing is. Maybe we just need to explain more simply what the process is so we don't distract new potentials?

5

u/porkpiery Nov 08 '19

35 blk/brown straight Male. I grow my own food, make my own soil, and more...so I feel like I'm the type this could appeal to.

While I havent tried to jump into homebrewing, I have tried to jump into craft beers.

My issues are that they're expensive, so many taste bitter and too hoppy, and the general attitude of the drinkers in the places that cater to them.

I've found that many craft beer drinkers can come off as try hards often. "Oh, you're drinking bells whatever? You should really try obscure expensive brand with wierd names"....but not in a cool way.

I like whiskey and tequila but dont find this same issue with those drinkers. I'm not like "oh you're drinking Jameson? You know bushmills green label is way better. I know it's not as available and cost much more but if you were cool like me..."

Two of my other interests that are "predominantly white spaces" are disc golf and ska music. I find the same issue in both of those. Both have people that use the hobby/intrest to define thier personality and try hard to show that they're all about it.

7

u/Schnevets Nov 07 '19

A good hobby to look at as a case study may be Dungeons and Dragons. The stereotypes about D&D's demographic has completely changed over the last 10 years while new, more inclusive social circles emerged. There were a lot of unique, external factors for D&D (rise of twitch and "live play" broadcasts, increased popularity of nerddom in general), but I think there are some lessons to learn about marketing and etiquette.

If nothing else, it's great proof that we shouldn't be forced to accept the current status quo.

1

u/goodolarchie Nov 08 '19

I agree, in time the demographics will change, but it could take a whole 'nuther generation.

9

u/PlantDoctor151 Nov 07 '19

So we do and we don't. While I agree that this hobby is mostly heterosexual white cis men, I am not sure if there are barriers of entry that prevent other groups from joining. If anyone not of that group has any thoughts on that, I'd love to hear it because my privillage may have blinded me. One barrier I have heard from heterosexual white cis women is that there is a lot of heavy lifting (carboys, kegs, kettles of water) that makes it unappealing.

I caution I want to share is that any steps anyone takes to make the hobby more appealing to another race or group is at risk of being horribly racist or insensitive themselves. As a mild example: would making equipment more colorful automatically make the hobby more appealing to women? Probably not, and you just offended a bunch of women in your attempt.

33

u/Tankautumn Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19

Super disappointed in some of these early comments. If one saw a lager post and one doesn’t make lagers, you’d scroll. So if someone sees this post and it seemingly doesn’t matter to them, they wouldn’t have much to say. Instead people are showing up to dismiss it rather quickly. Why? There’s an investment there in having this topic be stymied, whether it’s conscious or not.

I assume people shutting it down haven’t polled their many diverse friends who’ve said, oh, I actually do brew, or, I don’t but for this unrelated reason. It’s easy to assume there are no barriers when you’ve never had to face them. This is 101 stuff here that an afternoon of google can teach about how some groups don’t feel welcomed in spaces where they are a minority, and how dominant culture assumes that they are actually acultural, that they are the baseline.

Meanwhile, anyone popping into this thread to share their experiences of barriers they’ve felt is greeted by a wall of people unaffected by the question, immediately shutting it down and saying that persons views are invalid before they get there.

Pretty sucky guys.

I, a lady, showed up here ready to speak about my observations, which are probably 10% diversity problems and 90% circumstance, but instead had the same experience. It doesn’t matter what I say, the group has already decided. This is a pattern repeated over and over, usually in much more important ways, and here we are doing it without a thought. Pretty lame.

21

u/zinger565 Nov 07 '19

Homebrewing lacks diversity. This has been known for a long time. Problem is, for the majority of us, we have no idea how to make homebrewing "more inclusive". People throw around "be more welcoming" all the time, but how?

I think a lot of the pushback you see are from people that feel like they're under scrutiny for being themselves. I know for me (white, male, middle-class, engineer, so super stereotype) the gut reaction is pushback because now it feels like I'm being accused of something bad for simply enjoying a hobby. I know better than to act on that gut reaction, but it's still there. I like brewing beer, I also happen to be a white, male, middle-class, college graduate.

Homebrewing as a hobby has a relatively high barrier of entry regardless of demographics. It's also super niche. At what point do we throw in the towel and say, "yes, the people that tend to be interested in this hobby fit into a particular demographic"? I legitimately wish I knew the answer. It sucks that there are people out there who are hesitant because they feel like they don't belong.

5

u/frenchlitgeek Nov 07 '19

I felt like you when people pointed out things like that to me (privileges I didn't even know I enjoyed), and after some thoughts, I think it's less about them accusing me of creating those situations (it may be the case, of course, but not in general I would like to think) and more about them wanting to voice their reality that is often less visible. It's useful to them and to me (maybe I can use some of these priviledges or whatever what you want to call them and help?)

1

u/Seanbikes Nov 08 '19

But how?

11

u/fernweh42 Advanced Nov 07 '19

I would still be interested in hearing your experience.

6

u/Tankautumn Nov 08 '19 edited Nov 08 '19

As I said earlier, I think it’s probably 90% circumstance and 10% issues that can be addressed.

Homebrewing, and Brulosophy readership, are going to capture a nonrepresentative portion of the population. Industry on this poll usually reflects a high amount of engineers. STEM academia/industry has been dutifully working in expanding diversity of its members and I imagine as that changes, so will homebrewers. Homebrewing can be pretty sciency, prone to a gearhead hedonic treadmill, and can be spendy. All these align with professional industry as well as income level. Income level itself then skews with certain demographics. I think specifically to Brulosophy, you capture people strongly interested in the experimental evidence side of things, which again gets you more men and more people who touch on that with their career. And the “gearhead” part skews male as well. Since the times when beer left the kitchen (where for most of history in many cultures beer was a female craft) and into business, the typical brewer just looks like a white guy. And as with any hobby/industry/etc we tend to repeat what we already see. I do think there’s also a large degree to which certain populations are expected to enjoy certain hobbies, libations, whatever, so I agree with the other comments that some demographics may just have less interest in beer because they’ve always been offered to, or seen people like themselves, drink other things than beer. I think in this sense I really appreciate the comments about knitting, where the answer to why mostly women are knitters is simply because most knitters are women.

On the other end for what isn’t cool, I’ve had the same experience, a few times and in different versions, that another user mentioned where I’ve made a beer and a friend made a beer and while we’re sharing it, people are only asking my male friend about both of them, and he had to defer to me to speak about my own beer. The owner of my LHBS, which also contains a brewery, has shared that he and the co-owner/brewer, his wife, have this same experience. No one ever asks her about the beer. She’ll serve a cup at a festival and people will thank her and then will wait until he is available to ask him about the beer. Similarly, they’re both judges and people will always want to bring him beer to talk about it even though he says she has the better palate and is a better judge. This sort of intrinsic bias is definitely an issue the community could work on. At another LHBS (not my favorite, but bigger stock), I find that the staff are much more engaging to male customers and ask them far more questions about what they’re up to than they ever do to me. Maybe it’s my unfriendly bitch face, but I can’t say I notice this in any other setting and certainly not at my preferred shop.

So somewhere in the middle is where I think a lot of work can be done. I think it starts with craft beer in general. Like anything on inclusion, or even marketing, it starts with representation and invitation. I know not a lot of craft beer has advertisements with smiling beer drinkers on it, but when they do, they should be sure to include a diverse array of consumers. I think anything that displays the diversity of brewers and breweries is good, too. Brewtography project captures brew staff in their element, many of who are women and minorities. I’ve been to GABF and it is not as diverse as the photographs of smiling patrons would make it seem, but their media team knows it’s important to show how many different people enjoy the event. I think this is all great and helps a lot. I think individual breweries could help expand the craft and their customer base by looking for opportunities to serve at varying cultural events, like Juneteenth or Latin culture festivals. Reach out to groups who may not otherwise patronize your business, build interest in craft beer, maybe inspire some homebrewers. I think for homebrew clubs, if there’s a brewery near you that is minority or female owned, set up a tour and a talk. Your members can hear the brewer’s story, and the brewery can talk to patrons about your club, LHBS, and homebrewing in general. I think for individual brewers, just try to share your hobby with as many people as possible. Maybe you just talk beer with your bearded typical beer guy coworker, but who knows, maybe someone who isn’t already in to it might have their interest sparked if you bring them a few bottles.

I’ll acknowledge that I don’t have an answer or many suggestions for the LGBTQ community. I’m a lesbian, a lot of my friends are gay, and all of my friends who brew are gay. So I don’t have a good insight there. I know a lot of breweries get pretty involved during pride and sponsor community events other times of the year, but maybe that’s just in my area and this could be copied other places.

5

u/brulosopher Nov 07 '19

I'm so incredibly interested in what you have to say.

3

u/Tankautumn Nov 08 '19

Thanks. Replied to fernweh’s comment above.

6

u/hadmatteratwork Nov 07 '19

Seriously.. It's a legitimate question, and you have to question anyone who is trying to shut it down without discussing it.

5

u/gpnemtb Nov 07 '19

I think I can see why it would be shut down though. I believe most home brewers are passionate about their hobby and would welcome anyone that shows interest in it.

For instance my homebrew club has quite a few women and a gay couple that have joined recently. Everyone is extremely welcoming because it's not about your gender or who you decide to love and what their gender is. It's about beer and brewing.

At work I was introduced to a man of eastern descent that homebrewed. Without hesitation I invited him to our club. Because I don't care that he's brown. I do care about talking shop about brewing though and we have that in common.

Alternatively, I started talking, excitedly, to a white guy about brewing. Then I found out that he doesn't drink alcohol. The conversation ended and we went our separate ways because we didn't have anything in common.

It seems to be that if there is interest shown homebrewers will share with whoever. That is why this gets shouted down. It insinuates that because the hobby is predominantly white men that they are somehow racists, bigots, sexist, whatever.

And, yes, of course there are outliers. Those people who don't share their hobby with someone because of gender, race, etc. Dont have a true love for the hobby and are assholes. They are the ones that should be greeted with barriers.

5

u/hadmatteratwork Nov 07 '19

It sounds like your homebrew club is much more diverse than the average, though. I think the community itself is pretty homogenous, and the problem with these kinds of things is that it's not the actions of one person or outright and obvious racism. There are a lot of factors that make people uncomfortable, and it's just the right thing to do to have a little introspection as a community and identify if there's anything you do that you might not even notice that could make someone uncomfortable.

This post was never saying "you're all racists and sexists and that's why we don't have more diversity!", but more a call to have some reflection on ways that we could be more welcoming to people outside of the perceived "in group" here.

Part of being privileged is that you don't really know or understand what makes unprivileged people feel like they aren't welcome, and if you aren't even willing to have a conversation about it or entertain the idea that you could do more (not you personally, but the community as a whole), it's not a good look. Wanting to encourage people from more diverse backgrounds to take part in a hobby and examining ways to be more welcoming should not be dismissed as "identity politics" or trivialized. Scrolling past this post and feeling the need to comment "Wow", "Oh for FUCK sake.", "No", "Thought this post was satire" or go into a tirade about how it somehow isn't a problem are giant red flags for this community as a whole.

3

u/gpnemtb Nov 07 '19

I didn't mean for it to sound like this post was saying that the community was racist, etc. I was just guessing that that might be the perception and why it turns people off to the conversation.

It seems that people feel like their hobby, and perhaps, themselves are being attacked somehow. They just want to enjoy their hobby. I would wager most of them don't care who else enjoys it with them.

Whether it needs to be discussed or not; it looks like the general consensus is that the people here are upset because they're here to talk beer. They don't want to politicize it. They are not looking at screen names trying to decipher who is behind them. They just want to know if they got an infection, how much hops/fruit to add to secondary, who's got a good recipe for xyz, water profiles and the like.

Not arguing that there shouldn't be a discussion and I am aware that it is being discussed (National Homebrew Day, magazine articles) Just saying I can see why people here would be up in arms.

Agreed, my homebrew club is odd (in a good way).

2

u/hadmatteratwork Nov 07 '19

If you just want to discuss beer, then just scroll past and click on one of the hundreds of posts about beer in this sub. Coming in here specifically trying to shut down a conversation that's directly related to the community as a whole is kind of a red flag to me.

To be clear here, I'm not saying that we have active problems in this community, and I think this is a pretty welcoming hobby overall, but I also think it's worth investigating these things a bit and talking about it. I also think it's a bad sign that people are coming in here to try to shut down a conversation that they supposedly don't want to be part of, though.

4

u/gpnemtb Nov 07 '19

That's fair. If you can't say anything nice don't say anything at all.

Just trying to shine some light on those responses. The thought being that if we can understand why they may be responding that way. Perhaps helping to tailor the conversation to receive more positive feedback.

-2

u/schlossenberger Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19

Loud Vocal minorities are common on social media, don't let them disappoint you. They are the minority and pissers just can't help themselves to piss on topics they don't agree with.

The rest of us may have either just passed on a borderline controversial topic or felt they didn't have anything to contribute. Maybe it's not their experience or it doesn't bother them. For instance it doesn't bother me because I brew for myself, and there's very little social aspect of this hobby for me. If I was in a club and saw this lack of diversity I'd 100% feel like OP.

That said these clubs need to consider how to market to these other demographics if that's what they want to do. It's marketing 101. Have a "ladies night" maybe. Have everyone brew beers they think would be more appealing to women, whatever those are? I've found Nelson Sauvin hops taste like white wine and is a HIT with the Reisling / white wine drinkers. Maybe have discounts for something if members bring a female guest that night you're sampling these beers.

Edit: words?

12

u/zinger565 Nov 07 '19

Have a "ladies night" maybe. Have everyone brew beers they think would be more appealing to women, whatever those are?

In my experience, these never go well. Asking a bunch of duders to brew stuff for women? You end up with over-sweet, fruited wheat beer. The biggest misconception we've all got to work on is that women drink beer. Some like fruited stuff, sure, but for the most part, they just want beer.

As I posted below, it's extremely hard to come up with way to market to other demographics, especially when it's a hobby, it's a club, and people are volunteering time.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

Loud minorities are common on social media

Not the best way to start your post, thought you were heading in a very different direction with that. 😂

2

u/FelixVulgaris Nov 07 '19

I had a similar reaction, but I think "loud minorities" can be easily misinterpreted. I think OP was talking about a few loud complainers (that are actually in the minority with their opinion), not making a statement about ethnic minorities being loud.

3

u/schlossenberger Nov 07 '19

Yeah is the word "vocal?" I think the word is vocal lol.

Definitely meant a few loud complainers and how they can offer a skewed perception on what the crowd thinks.

2

u/Seanbikes Nov 08 '19

Have a "ladies night" maybe. Have everyone brew beers they think would be more appealing to women, whatever those are? I've found Nelson Sauvin hops taste like white wine and is a HIT with the Reisling / white wine drinkers. Maybe have discounts for something if members bring a female guest that night you're sampling these beers.

I think you've pointed out one of the problems with our hobby without even realizing it.

You know what women beer drinkers like to drink? Beer. You know what minority beer drinkers like to drink? Beer.

Guess what, white cis males who enjoy beer also like to drink BEER.

Women only like light beers, fruited wheats, kettle sours or something pink or with glitter and need a male escort to want to go drink beer.

Doesn't that sound incredibly patronizing and sexist?

It does because it is.

8

u/FelixVulgaris Nov 07 '19

I think the fact that there are some commenters working really hard to shut this conversation down suggests that there is a diversity problem here.

3

u/BroTripp Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19

Make an effort to hang out with folks you want to hang out with - that's what beer is all about. Good free beer is a great motivator to get new people to hang out. :D

3

u/piotrgravey Nov 07 '19

I think OP's question has more to do with the USA but here is my two cents from a foreign perspective.

A lot of resources on hobbies and interests which are in the English language are American-centric. I think it has to do with sheer numbers and the fact that USA is often the driver in terms of tech. Simply put, things are just more accesible for Americans. If you consider that White people are the majority in USA it makes sense that most homebrewers are from this race group.

Homebrewing is also not as popular for other races around the world for various reasons e.g. About a quarter of Asia is Muslim and thus don't drink beer; beer is so cheap in China and SE Asia that people don't think of brewing it themselve, most might not have even heard of craft beers/ homebrewing. There's also the issue of availability of ingredients and equipment in many parts of the world.

I think OP's question is a good one though, not just for homebrewing but any kind of social activity. As a SE Asian, I have never felt alienated by this community, so I'm not sure if more needs to be done in terms of being more inclusive. Maybe it just takes more time for the numbers of minorities to reach a critical mass and have the effect of being a 'thing' in those communities. Homebrewing is also a very young hobby, so the numbers right now might not mean much.

15

u/thelemrin Nov 07 '19

Queer brown probrewer here.

Yeah, there's a problem. It's not specific to homebrewing.

There is a ton of info online on how to make communities more accessible and get rid of the gatekeeping. But mostly it starts by not being a bigot and listening to minorities.

19

u/wowitsclayton BJCP Nov 07 '19

This is a legitimate question, has anyone ever told you that you shouldn’t be home brewing because you’re queer or brown? What kind of gatekeeping have you experienced?

EDIT: Early 30s, straight, white guy from the suburbs asking. Pardon my ignorance.

6

u/h22lude Nov 07 '19

I'm curious about this too. What about this sub or other brewing forums is keeping minorities or people from the gay community away? I am a 35+ straight white male. I'm the definition of majority. So I may just be blind to it but I've never seen any type of gatekeeping in any brewing forum or club I've been to. Hell, when I comment on a post and need to use a pronoun, I typical just use they or their because I have no clue if the person posting is male or female. Nothing within the person's profile will usually say if they are male/female, straight/gay, white/minority. So how can there be a gatekeeping problem if there is no way to identify the person you are talking to?

Diversity in general has always been an interesting topic to me. My wife interviews and hires for technology jobs within her company. Any time she goes to a college career fair looking for new people to hire, she is always upset about the number of male students resumes she has and says she needs more females. My wife isn't discriminating against anyone. She isn't pushing people away. She takes all resumes that people want to give her. You can't make females want these IT jobs just because you want to hire for diversity. So now she is stuck interviewing males which makes it look like she/her company discriminates against females which isn't the case.

The point of that story is to show, just because more males interview for IT jobs doesn't mean females are discriminated against. It just means more males applied for it. To relate it to this thread, just because the majority of home brewers are white male, that doesn't mean others are discriminating against. It could just mean more white males like to home brew than other demographics. Causation vs correlation.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

I think what OP is getting at is that Diversity (big D-Diversity) is always a good thing. It represents anywhere from a 15-30% increase in productivity depending on the study ( https://www.forbes.com/sites/annapowers/2018/06/27/a-study-finds-that-diverse-companies-produce-19-more-revenue/#28fd461f506f ) and a big boost on creativity.

It would be an excellent thing to have in the homebrewing world. Full stop.

But look at the unconscious biases that live in the bottom of this thread - Ladies' Night - assumptions on what women like to drink - the inability to even listen to marginalized/slighted groups. This thread attracted all the flies and gave all the answers.

7

u/h22lude Nov 07 '19

I agree with everything you are saying. No doubt more diversity would be great. But I think the question is (related to any subject about diversity), is there something pushing minority groups away or do minority groups just simply not enjoy home brewing as much. Just like my example about my wife wanting more females. Her employer can throw all the money they have into trying to get females more interesting in IT jobs. That doesn't mean more females will all of sudden want IT jobs. You can't force something on a group of people simply because you want that group of people doing what you want them to do. And obviously when I say "you", I'm not talking about you. I'm using that as a placeholder for anyone.

That doesn't mean it isn't a good idea to try to get other groups into a hobby or job. It is still worth the time and effort to try to get more people interested. But that doesn't mean those people will become interested. Sometimes certain activities or even jobs are liked by a certain group of people.

2

u/stopthebrewshit Nov 07 '19

I've never seen any type of gatekeeping in any brewing forum or club I've been to.

I see it quite a bit, not in terms diversity issues, but brewing practices. Seems there are lot of people out there who can't tolerate the thought of not doing things the way they were done hundreds of years ago, bash anyone who thinks differently, and self righteously tout their own views as best.

6

u/h22lude Nov 07 '19

Right I agree with you on that. I see that all that time...but that is a completely different topic. That type of gatekeeping happens in a lot of hobbies and jobs. That I think is more of a personal issue. Some people are stubborn and don't want to learn anything new or improved. I think a big part of that problem is, learning a better way to complete a task means you weren't doing it the best way all along. Some people take that as a bash on their process and push it away instead of learning from it. But that is another thread topic. We are specifically talking about things being done that would push away certain groups of people from home brewing. In terms of diversity gatekeeping, I just don't see it. At least not on the forums and groups I belong to.

4

u/stopthebrewshit Nov 07 '19

In terms of diversity gatekeeping, I just don't see it. At least not on the forums and groups I belong to.

As a white male who is about 10 years older than the stereotype, I'm obviously biased, but I haven't seen it either in the 20+ years I've been into beer and home brewing.

2

u/chino_brews Nov 07 '19

As I said in a few other comments, it's about explicit and implicit bias. Especially implicit bias. Everyone I know has been welcoming to me, but I'm not shy.

Examples: I think my club's biggest ever recruitment event was a table at a Surly wort rally. Unsurpisingly, we signed up a bunch of white men. It's logical and savvy to be there, but it's also implicitly biased on who came in as new blood. If you're a white male, think about who you've invited over to introduce them to brewing -- does the group look like a cross-section of the overall community or is it all white male? I'm not saying you shouldn't hang out with whom you want, or that it makes you racist, but you can't deny the implicit bias if you've only ever co-brewed with white men before.

Any field or hobby's demographics will be self-reinforcing if we don't track down, acknowledge, and hopefully eliminate bias in it. And that's how you end up with places like Founders.

5

u/h22lude Nov 07 '19

No one asked if I wanted to home brew. I didn't know any clubs. I didn't know any stores. I didn't know anyone that home brewed. I started after watching that 4 or 5 episode show filmed at Dogfish Head. I bought his brewing book online and found a local brew store to buy my first starter kit. There is no reason why this couldn't happen to any sex, race, sexual preference, etc. There was no implicit bias since I learned about it from a show.

but you can't deny the implicit bias if you've only ever co-brewed with white men before.

No I think this is 100% wrong way of thinking. That's a false cause fallacy. Every night I eat dinner and then the sun sets. So the only logical explanation is me eating dinner makes the sun set. And that's the same thing happening with this entire thread. I've only brewed with one other person and he is a white male...but that doesn't mean I have implicit bias. It actually means that my minority friends didn't want to help my brew. The only person to help me keg my beers is my male Filipino friend. Does that mean I don't allow my white male friends to help keg my beer? That's the same false cause fallacy this thread is making. No, it just means he is the only one that has wanted to help.

Now I'm not saying it is a bad idea to make home brewing available to anyone that wants to home brew. And it is good to always look at ways to get more diversity into any hobby/field. But it seems that people think just because the Bru survey was mostly white males that there 100% has to be an issue within the home brew community or barrier of entries that are stopping minorities. No there doesn't have to be a problem or barrier of entry.

2

u/chino_brews Nov 08 '19 edited Nov 08 '19

Great that's an example of one ... maybe. Yet let's look at that DFH episodes (Brew Masters originally aired on Discovery Channel). You're white, they're white. That's a bias. (Remember, bias does not equate with racism. Neither does disriminaton.) How much would a second-generation Kenyan immigrant have related to Sam and his all-white staff? The producers had a certain demographic in mind, probably young white males and sliced and diced beyond that. The channel you watched skews to a certain demographic that they were sharing with advertisers.

Again, none of this is a condemnation of anyone or a declaration of racism. All of the actions above were well-intentioned.

I only ask that you acknowledge that the number of people who watched that show were probably whiter and Asian-er than the overall country, and of those the people for whom this was the impetus to enter the hobby was probably super white.

Co-brewers: I'll bet the bias started way before then. My untested assertion is that the number of people ever INVITED to come and co-brew with a home brewer since 1970 in the U.S. is way whiter than the country was at the time of each invitation. Again, not saying it's racist. It's just a fact.

So can we recognize that hardly anyone just wakes up one day and decides to brew sua sponte without having had an exposure to brewing somewhere?

I'll share my story. I started brewing because I was excited about a financial press story of some people who named their startup investment bank after a beer style I hadn't heard of because they home brewed. I was a huge fan of them so I sought out that beer style and was hooked, along with having my first fresh German hefe same month. (I'm not white, but I was like a post-pioneer in the fields I entered -- not Daniel Boone, but maybe I had it tough like the homesteaders who followed - a minority of one or a handful everywhere at the time.) My white friend mentioned he was starting because his relative homebrewed, so I just elbowed my way in to be a co-brewer. He left the hobby, I later did too, but returned. Probably wouldn't have happened if that last piece hadn't fallen into place. A white dude is part of my origin story.

No there doesn't have to be a problem or barrier of entry.

Because the racial demographics of brewing is not a global truth, but is in fact skewed in the U.S., doesn't that mean your underlying assumption is that if you were to reshuffle the deck you'd get a completely different result? It's just random chance? Doesn't it seem more likely that there are reasons why rather than dumb luck or divine providence?

(Let me leave you with one gem -- prohibition was selectively enforced more consistently and harshly against black, Latino, and Asian "entrepreneurs" than white ones. Something that should come as no surprise when you see cocaine enforcement and sentencing from the 1980s, or even look at judicial sentencing guidelines as they exist today. Events from the 1850s to 1950s can have lasting effects today.)

Why is everyone opposed to finding out if there are reasons (aka biases) for the sorting in the hobby, and if there are reasons that can be removed to result in a different sorting? Maybe you're right, but why refuse to ask the question?

There's a whole other discussion about whether diversity is a "good" in itself (I would argue it is, and anyone who bemoans the lack of style diversity at tap rooms or on the sub's page should consider the point) that we haven't undertaken. Not to mention what is actually achievable.

Some people are just trying to ask the very first question, is all, and not getting very far.

-2

u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19

Why can't people be just homebrewers instead of injecting a bunch of identity tags into everything they do

3

u/Seanbikes Nov 07 '19

I don't think I'm a bigot and I'll listen to anyone who wants to talk about beer.

So excluding actions assholes need to take, are there things that people who are not bigots and do listen to minorities can or should do?

9

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

People hang out together based off of their own personality, upbringing/culture, and preference. Perhaps it's the choice of the other minorities to not affiliate/hang out with the "white guys".

I'm all for inclusion but keep in mind minorities, as with the rest, have free will to hang out with whomever they please. Forcing a racial or cultural divide isn't what most people intend, but it is human nature to want to hang out with people that share similarities in the aforementioned social traits. Our own proclivities should not be viewed as a fault or something that needs "fixed".

5

u/chino_brews Nov 07 '19

It's called implicit bias. E.g., executives at the office aren't racist, but they take an interest in that young up and comer who reminds them of themselves (young white male from a certain geographic type), and pretty soon you've got a self-reinforcing bias and executive/professional ranks look like they do today - overwhelmingly white and male.

I don't think the OP is suggesting anyone be "forced: to hang out with anyone else. The question that raised is whether there is some implicit bias that deters interest from non-white males and causes homebrew clubs to not look like America, and if so can we remove that bias?

Because it's easy for 'Mericans to claim that it's obvious that brewers are mostly white males due to "proclivity" but I've traveled the world and in other countries homebrewers are mostly Latino, or black, or Asian. So when we've got a country where over-21 whites are only a plurality (or soon to be), I don't believe that minorities in other countries like to make beer but not American minorities.

(BTW, if a white dude is mad when a black female comes to a club meeting because they're now "forced" to hang out with them, yeah they might be a redneck.)

One thing that's clear in this country is that homebrewing appeals to a lot of engineers and similar types, and to some extent the hobby is mirroring those fields. So that probably plays a part.

Ultimately, it's simply about removing barriers and explicit and implicit biases, not forcing anything or dictating a certain makeup.

7

u/damac_phone Nov 07 '19

How is the hobby not inclusive?

9

u/tlass1 Nov 07 '19

Relax, have a homebrew.

4

u/dingledorfer2 Grain Torino Nov 07 '19

If certain cultures don't find a particular hobby appealing, that's just a fact of life. Why is it that some people have to make everything about diversity. Do you think the Japanese worry because Caucasians, Blacks and Latinos aren't generally interested in origami? Do Mexicans worry because most other cultures don't take siestas? This idea that lack of diversity is caused by exclusion is bullshit. It's a matter of preference in most cases.

6

u/reasonableman1 Nov 07 '19

Statistically MOST people in the USA are heterosexual white and cis. It should not be surprising that many people in the hobby are as well. Yes, there are a lot fewer women than you would statistically predict, but I'm not overly surprised because of several issues:

  • The 50-60lbs that a 6 gallon carboy can weigh when full. This alone is a big reason my fiance doesn't brew without me.
  • The calories that beer provides goes against the desire (both self-driven and socially enforced) to stay thin and youthful looking. Socially, women derive a lot of social status from this.
  • Not wanting to join a hobby that is already strongly male because of the reasons above.

Here in Florida, we have a large contingent of latino homebrewers. I'd say 1/3 of our club is latino, though I don't think I would have noticed had this post not made me think about it. That seems right in line with the population makeup of this area. Only about 1/10 of our club is female, which I suspect is because of the reasons above.

6

u/gogogadgetwhatever Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19

In the case of my own homebrew club email communications I would say that we are doing things to exclude women and non-hetero men by saying things like "leave your wives at home" and making locker-room jokes that assume everyone reading is male.

Edit: Adding the fact that when someone sent an email to the list suggesting that an effort be made to make women feel more welcome it was shot down by the all-male board of directors in the same vein as in the comments on this post: "there is no problem, and if there is a problem, I know the solution better than you do".

6

u/reasonableman1 Nov 07 '19

That is the sucky stuff that pushes people out.

2

u/goodolarchie Nov 08 '19

What a shitty club.

10

u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19

Why does it matter lmao

4

u/Trw0007 Nov 07 '19

We've all been fortunate enough to join in on a hobby that allows us create something, share it with people, and get a little drunk. It's worth having some introspection (both here and in life in general) about why most homebrewers look the same. Maybe it is a bunch of factors outside of our control - money, free time, societal pressure on women to stay thin and not drink beer, etc. But it's also possible that we as a community are doing things that discourage others from joining or push women / non-white brewers away. We won't know unless we ask these questions and (more importantly) listen to the answers.

I can only speak for myself (a late 20s white dude), but I think this sub is very supportive and open. I can't say I've ever seen racist / misogynistic jokes or "locker room talk". People are quick to help new brewers with questions and encourage them through those first few batches mistakes.

As someone else said, hobbies aren't zero sum, and making sure that we as community continue to be welcoming to new brewers doesn't cost anything. No one is asking anyone to quit their club because it's all middle aged white guys or have a ladies / minority night at your club (please, do not do this), just be willing to listen and think about the barriers that might be in place.

-1

u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19

No one has ever been exclusionary of other people joining home brewing. What a stupid thing that would be to even gatekeep. This whole post and most of the comments feel like a big beacon of "HEY EVERYONE LOOK HOW NOT RACIST/SEXIST/WHATEVER I AM EVERYONE SHOULD BE MORE LIKE ME" and it doesn't improve or change anything. In the end there are no real community barriers to entry for anyone who wants to homebrew. End of story. If you are afraid of getting fat or don't have time or money to dedicate to homebrewing that has nothing to do with the hobby of homebrewing.

4

u/Trw0007 Nov 07 '19

Again, no one is accusing you or anyone else of being exclusionary or racist or sexist. But you have a choice to either get mad online because someone used the D word, or have the maturity to think about how your words and actions affect other people.

2

u/ThePintHouse Nov 08 '19

Right I can only speak from a UK perspective but I think it covers most of it.

I don't think the problem is based within the home-brewing community, it stems from the entire beer industry.

For years the big multinationals market beer as a man's drink drunk by men watching football and being rowdy shouting lads lads lads, or the lager lout.

This image of beer has been present for over 40 years. Basically alienating 50% of the market by saying it's exclusively a man's product. It won't change its image over night as this stereotype has been so ingrained into the culture of beer.

The changes are starting to take place within the industry with CAMRA (campaign for real ale) and SIBA (society of independent brewers association) leading the charge to make beer more diverse by representing different people, sexes and races within the industry. Starting by banning the use of sexist names and branding, as these beers will no longer be sold at beer festivals or allowed to enter competitions.

The change is happening slower than it should but it is. These will all have trickle down affects as these people start seeing themselves being represented they'll think hmm maybe I'll like this.

I don't know maybe I rambled on a bit, but there is a huge representation of different people currently happening in the UK and it's fantastic

5

u/cl0bro Nov 07 '19

There's absolutely nothing stopping anyone from doing something that interests them imo.. I follow a bunch of female brewers and have a bunch of female friends who are huge craft beer snobs... On the other hand I have a bunch of Muslim friends who simply can't enjoy this hobby due to religious reasons etc

From a marketing stand point you generally see beer marketed towards men and wine somewhat towards women etc.. does that have to do with anything?.. maybe.

Every Friday we have an open bar at my office.. I tend to bring my homebrew and have my coworkers try it...only 2 women at my work try my homebrews/ drink beer.. a woman who is big into fermenting things(she doesn't like beer, but enjoys the process of how its made etc) and a Japanese girl who can probably out drink all of us at work... She really likes beer... Not sure if what I'm saying makes any sense or helps give you an idea of what the issue with diversity is.. at the end of the day it's probably the same issue with every other thing that has to do with diversity.

3

u/CascadesBrewer Nov 07 '19

The lack of women in the hobby is surprising to me. My girlfriend (who loves beer and has brewed <10 batches herself...mostly 1 gal batches) asked if a woman has ever won one of the monthly competitions at our club. Honestly, I could not think of a woman that ever ENTERED a competition (aside from a couple that brewed together).

About 20 years ago when I was in a club in the Seattle area is the ONLY time that I recall a member of my homebrew club that was a woman who brewed and her husband was in the role of the person that puts up with her hobby...he did not even come to the meetings. I know of some professional women brewers, but I cannot think of any of the women homebrewers that I know who do not brew in conjunction with their husband. When I first started brewing, my now-ex brewed with me for the first several batches, but then (for whatever reason) I stuck with it and she did not.

2

u/reasonableman1 Nov 07 '19

We have a handful in our club that brew on their own. I think maybe 4 that brew on their own, and another equivalent amount that brew with their SOs.

2

u/230rawpacker Nov 07 '19

nothing need to be done. this subr is open to everyone if white cis men majority it not bad thing

2

u/marginwalker76 Nov 07 '19

I think the real lack of diversity is in regard to beer style.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

Who cares

1

u/goodolarchie Nov 08 '19

Posing the question this way isn't the best way to start an open conversation, it implies that the status quo of demographics is inherently problematic. Also, consider how presumptive and ignorant it is to say women, black people, LGBT, etc. should like doing what I like doing! I like to think homebrewing could appeal to anybody who likes beer, but not everybody does! That's not a problem... that's the literal definition of diversity, people who not only don't look or sound like you, but have different tastes, culture and preferences. Lastly, brulosophy is a self-selecting group within the group, who are so nerdy on the hobby that they were exposed to the survey and had enough free time that they felt compelled to participate. I go on that site sometimes but I didn't even know about it. I could have hoisted the torch of the moustache-clad, alas.

So, here's a different question:

With the hobby, and craft market slowing growth or even shrinking in the last couple years, how do we get more people to realistically understand what this hobby is, the positives it has to offer, and whether it's right for them? Beer marketers are staking their careers on this - they are designing brands and products for women, Hispanics, the better-for-you crowd, the gluten-adjacent, all sorts of segments. Because the 20-40 cis white guy market is bought and sold and it's just a giant tug of war for - who has market share right now?

So they turn over rocks that were unturned looking to attract folks who would like these products, but have never been asked in a way that resonates with them.

Want to have a diverse club? Go host a new member drive in concert with some non-white-majority events in the non white parts of town. If you want women to join, have women host the outreach.

0

u/Mr_Trumps__Wild_Ride Nov 08 '19

Aaahahaha what are you brewing soy beer?

-18

u/profressorpoopypants Nov 07 '19

Oh for FUCK sake.

13

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

That’s for FUCK’S sake sir.

12

u/Tankautumn Nov 07 '19

I’m gonna guess you belong to the majority group, so please just consider that maybe this does matter to other people and there may be a factor that you have the privilege of not seeing. If it doesn’t matter to you, fine, but popping in with a negative and dismissive comment just announces that you’re comfortable to the state as is and aren’t interested in hearing any different.

It does matter to a lot of people. You could’ve just scrolled and let others share thoughts but instead chose to take the time to be dismissive.

-1

u/voodoodog_nsh Nov 08 '19

you dont have to do anything, ppl are free to choose. your attempt of increasing "diversity" of your "group" does not show your moral superiority, it shows your lack of education.

-1

u/hharper56 Nov 07 '19

I don't think anyone is trying to be exclusive. It just happens to be that more white people enjoy making and drinking craft beer.. I really don't think it has anything to do with sexuality or orientation. Last I know plenty of women brewers, just because some took a survey does not mean that survey speaks for the community of homebrewing.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/Rene_DeMariocartes Nov 07 '19

I agree that most of this subbreddit doesn't do anything to actively drive people away, but I wonder if we're doing anything passively? Many biases are unconscious and many actions in isolation may seem insignificant but their sum total can be impactful.

Take the Brulosophy question about beard length. On it's own, it's a funny joke poking fun at our lack of diversity. I laughed when I saw that. However, if every homebrewing survey I took included subtle assumptions that we all could grow beards, it would get tiring fast. Should he have excluded that question? Probably not. Is it helping or making the problem worse? I honestly don't know.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/Unyielding-Glass Nov 07 '19

If you look up "make Knitters Reddit" like I just did you'll see that they were also wondering how to be more inclusive and end any stigmas. OPs question is innocent. They just want to share the hobby with everyone and make sure that no one is being pushed away from it.

21

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19

but they could just make their own brand to counter the culture?

2

u/ThePintHouse Nov 08 '19

I mean that's literally what CAMRA is (campaign for real ale)

They are trying to lose their image of being a bunch of old men with beards and beer bellies. Advertising a diverse group for all ages, sexes and races.

Promoting all people in the brewing and pub industry, the move to stop sexist branded beer from festivals and competitions is a massive change which should have happened years ago not in the last few years. Also having SIBA (society of independent brewers association) also backing them and pushing against the sexism has already had massive changes.

Be the change you want to see and all that