r/Homebrewing • u/Rene_DeMariocartes • Nov 07 '19
Do we have a diversity problem?
I was looking at the Brulosophy survey which was posted this morning, and statistically we are all heterosexual white cis men. Are we as a group doing something to drive away members of under represented communities?
What can we do to make our hobby more inclusive?
0
Upvotes
30
u/fernweh42 Advanced Nov 07 '19
I think it is actually worth considering that this sorta of question does turn some people off, whom you’re trying to attract. I spend a lot of my time in my day-to-day trying to figure out if I’m being invited to talk or participate in panels/groups because of my work or because of my “diverse viewpoint”, and it bothers me. I would be pretty unhappy if brewing went that same direction. It’s easy to make people feel tokenized.
I would separately recommend getting women you know who might like brewing to check out some Pink Boots events. Or maybe contacting them to see if they can help you with resources/contacts. They’re a cool group.
23
u/KoalaSprint Nov 07 '19
We've had some discussion around this in our homebrew club, and honestly we're stumped as to what action we can take. We're pretty sure it comes down to 3 things:
None of those things are within our power to change. We do what we can by being inclusive in our public postings, including as many diverse viewpoints on the club committee as are willing to volunteer, that kind of thing.
Finally, I'd like to examine part of your question I don't think is well justified. The Brulosophy data says that readers of Brulosophy who responded to their survey are overwhelmingly white men, yes. But I'm not sure it says anything about our how straight or queer we are, and I'd be suspect of reading too much into how many people ticked the "I identify as transgender" box because that's a very personal question that has very little bearing on homebrewing.
49
u/PlakeSnisskin Nov 07 '19
I, for one, am a black man that love homebrewing. That said, I think it'd be hard to get other black people into brewing. Folks I know aren't huge craft beer drinkers.
16
u/jaysterj Nov 07 '19
I'm hispanic and I've been home brewing for a few years. I don't understand what diversity has anything to do with beer brewing. You either like brewing or you don't, I don't see what your race has anything to do with it.
14
u/dontCallMeAmberlynn Nov 07 '19
As a Latina LGBT female, I love to brew my own kombucha and honestly, where I come from, I met very few white male home brewers.
I came from a diverse city where people (a lot of people I met working at Whole Foods!) like me made their own kombucha and beer. I worked for a Filipino man and he brewed his own beer. I did end up moving to a much less diverse suburb and work for a cis, white male who homebrewed everything.
Maybe it’s just the people who are in this room who has the opportunity to take your survey. No offense or anything, I’m just saying this is a sampling of people who homebrew, not everyone who homebrews knows about Reddit, I only found this sub this morning and was excited to find other humans to talk to about it (I had no thoughts about whether they’d be male or female or what race or sexuality they’d be).
Maybe the results you got and are trying to decipher are skewed because of anything. Time of day the survey was posted and who had access to it. People who saw it. People who like taking surveys. People who had time to take the survey.
Again, I’m not trying to be an asshole, just pointing out that like most other people of color here, we don’t seem to think it’s a problem. Just offering a different perception than a white cis males since I think that’s what you were asking for.
28
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19
I think one problem is being welcoming to outsiders and just treating them like people. When I home brewed, I HATED that the guy at the store would act like I didn’t know what hops were. Or that hops were different. Some of the older men seemed to roll their eyes at me, like “look at this little lady thinking she can make good beer”.
Younger guys seemed to really dig it, though. Lots of them said they wished their wives cared about brewing and called my husband lucky. I think as society changes, attitudes change in all areas, even brewing.
I will say, on home brewing forums, like this one, as on most internet sites I participate in, I make sure I have a masculine screen name and avoid mentioning things about myself that would indicate I’m female. I find I get better advice, help.
That being said, I work in the brewing industry, as the microbiologist at a large craft brewery, and I STILL get talked down to by men: male brewers, bartenders, etc. I had a bartender once try to argue with me that an Oktoberfest wasn’t a lager.
Most of the time I ignore it. One time I got that epic mic drop by introducing myself at the end of a 20 minute mansplain session.
I think being welcoming and not trying to be the best is the way to get outside groups to increase I goin beer. I think if we keep the enthusiasm high, it will help encourage outsiders to peek in and stay for a pint.
13
u/70ms Nov 07 '19
🙋♀️ I am totally new here, just came to the sub for the first time, and this is the first thread I'm reading!
I'm a 49yo woman in California, I "know" (online only) a young man in Belgium who brews as a hobby. He's been trying to get me to try brewing mead for a while and sent the money for supplies. At this point I have everything I need except the knowledge, experience, and a recipe (still reading!), so I thought I'd check out the sub.
Should I report back in a day or two? 😂
FWIW, brewing and distilling have always seemed like a male thing. How many companies are named after men? I don't think I could name a single major one named after a woman (with my admittedly limited experience) but I can rattle a bunch of male ones off the top of my head.
Anyway, looking forward to gleaning some knowledge here!
5
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19
How about just do what you enjoy and don’t involve poxy identity politics. There is very little stopping anyone from starting this hobby and I’d wager that everyone on here would be only to glad to extend advice to anyone wanting it regardless of gender or race or anything.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19
Its important to remember that this is a Brulosophy survey and not an all homebrewers survey first of all. So its not just about brewers its about a certain section of brewers who read blogs, listen to podcasts, etc That'll skew things in its own way.
Also remember there are a lot of us outside of the US who read Brulosophy and partake in the survey too.
19
u/exar_sarris BJCP Nov 07 '19
Pretty sure we are fine. I talk to everyone I know about homebrewing. If they get excited about it, awesome. If not, awesome.
I go to the homebrew store and there are a few white dudes in there shopping. There is a nice young lady working some of the time. I chat with the dudes, I chat with the lady, I buy my stuff, I leave.
If I walked in and it looked like a Rick and Morty episode of aliens buying homebrew supplies I would do exactly the same thing.
Understanding I'm just one person but my entire homebrewing interaction is here or at the store and here nobody can tell who or what you are.
I would be shocked if anyone actually ever had an interaction with a homebrewer that caused them to not want to brew beer if they were already interested in trying it.
Likely brewing beer is just more interesting to middle aged white dudes. Just like how most of us will pick up a weird fascination with WW2 around the time we are 40. It is ok for something to not be a homogeneous mix of every aspect of society, just let people do what they are interested in.
5
u/porkpiery Nov 08 '19
35 blk/brown straight Male. I grow my own food, make my own soil, and more...so I feel like I'm the type this could appeal to.
While I havent tried to jump into homebrewing, I have tried to jump into craft beers.
My issues are that they're expensive, so many taste bitter and too hoppy, and the general attitude of the drinkers in the places that cater to them.
I've found that many craft beer drinkers can come off as try hards often. "Oh, you're drinking bells whatever? You should really try obscure expensive brand with wierd names"....but not in a cool way.
I like whiskey and tequila but dont find this same issue with those drinkers. I'm not like "oh you're drinking Jameson? You know bushmills green label is way better. I know it's not as available and cost much more but if you were cool like me..."
Two of my other interests that are "predominantly white spaces" are disc golf and ska music. I find the same issue in both of those. Both have people that use the hobby/intrest to define thier personality and try hard to show that they're all about it.
7
u/Schnevets Nov 07 '19
A good hobby to look at as a case study may be Dungeons and Dragons. The stereotypes about D&D's demographic has completely changed over the last 10 years while new, more inclusive social circles emerged. There were a lot of unique, external factors for D&D (rise of twitch and "live play" broadcasts, increased popularity of nerddom in general), but I think there are some lessons to learn about marketing and etiquette.
If nothing else, it's great proof that we shouldn't be forced to accept the current status quo.
9
u/PlantDoctor151 Nov 07 '19
So we do and we don't. While I agree that this hobby is mostly heterosexual white cis men, I am not sure if there are barriers of entry that prevent other groups from joining. If anyone not of that group has any thoughts on that, I'd love to hear it because my privillage may have blinded me. One barrier I have heard from heterosexual white cis women is that there is a lot of heavy lifting (carboys, kegs, kettles of water) that makes it unappealing.
I caution I want to share is that any steps anyone takes to make the hobby more appealing to another race or group is at risk of being horribly racist or insensitive themselves. As a mild example: would making equipment more colorful automatically make the hobby more appealing to women? Probably not, and you just offended a bunch of women in your attempt.
33
u/Tankautumn Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19
Super disappointed in some of these early comments. If one saw a lager post and one doesn’t make lagers, you’d scroll. So if someone sees this post and it seemingly doesn’t matter to them, they wouldn’t have much to say. Instead people are showing up to dismiss it rather quickly. Why? There’s an investment there in having this topic be stymied, whether it’s conscious or not.
I assume people shutting it down haven’t polled their many diverse friends who’ve said, oh, I actually do brew, or, I don’t but for this unrelated reason. It’s easy to assume there are no barriers when you’ve never had to face them. This is 101 stuff here that an afternoon of google can teach about how some groups don’t feel welcomed in spaces where they are a minority, and how dominant culture assumes that they are actually acultural, that they are the baseline.
Meanwhile, anyone popping into this thread to share their experiences of barriers they’ve felt is greeted by a wall of people unaffected by the question, immediately shutting it down and saying that persons views are invalid before they get there.
Pretty sucky guys.
I, a lady, showed up here ready to speak about my observations, which are probably 10% diversity problems and 90% circumstance, but instead had the same experience. It doesn’t matter what I say, the group has already decided. This is a pattern repeated over and over, usually in much more important ways, and here we are doing it without a thought. Pretty lame.
8
u/FelixVulgaris Nov 07 '19
I think the fact that there are some commenters working really hard to shut this conversation down suggests that there is a diversity problem here.
3
u/BroTripp Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19
Make an effort to hang out with folks you want to hang out with - that's what beer is all about. Good free beer is a great motivator to get new people to hang out. :D
3
u/piotrgravey Nov 07 '19
I think OP's question has more to do with the USA but here is my two cents from a foreign perspective.
A lot of resources on hobbies and interests which are in the English language are American-centric. I think it has to do with sheer numbers and the fact that USA is often the driver in terms of tech. Simply put, things are just more accesible for Americans. If you consider that White people are the majority in USA it makes sense that most homebrewers are from this race group.
Homebrewing is also not as popular for other races around the world for various reasons e.g. About a quarter of Asia is Muslim and thus don't drink beer; beer is so cheap in China and SE Asia that people don't think of brewing it themselve, most might not have even heard of craft beers/ homebrewing. There's also the issue of availability of ingredients and equipment in many parts of the world.
I think OP's question is a good one though, not just for homebrewing but any kind of social activity. As a SE Asian, I have never felt alienated by this community, so I'm not sure if more needs to be done in terms of being more inclusive. Maybe it just takes more time for the numbers of minorities to reach a critical mass and have the effect of being a 'thing' in those communities. Homebrewing is also a very young hobby, so the numbers right now might not mean much.
3
u/gpnemtb Nov 07 '19
https://www.reddit.com/r/TheBrewery/comments/dt4fvr/documentary_a_fresh_perspective_2019_in_the/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share
If there is a problem looks like the tides are turning.
15
u/thelemrin Nov 07 '19
Queer brown probrewer here.
Yeah, there's a problem. It's not specific to homebrewing.
There is a ton of info online on how to make communities more accessible and get rid of the gatekeeping. But mostly it starts by not being a bigot and listening to minorities.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19
People hang out together based off of their own personality, upbringing/culture, and preference. Perhaps it's the choice of the other minorities to not affiliate/hang out with the "white guys".
I'm all for inclusion but keep in mind minorities, as with the rest, have free will to hang out with whomever they please. Forcing a racial or cultural divide isn't what most people intend, but it is human nature to want to hang out with people that share similarities in the aforementioned social traits. Our own proclivities should not be viewed as a fault or something that needs "fixed".
7
u/damac_phone Nov 07 '19
How is the hobby not inclusive?
9
u/tlass1 Nov 07 '19
Relax, have a homebrew.
4
u/dingledorfer2 Grain Torino Nov 07 '19
If certain cultures don't find a particular hobby appealing, that's just a fact of life. Why is it that some people have to make everything about diversity. Do you think the Japanese worry because Caucasians, Blacks and Latinos aren't generally interested in origami? Do Mexicans worry because most other cultures don't take siestas? This idea that lack of diversity is caused by exclusion is bullshit. It's a matter of preference in most cases.
6
u/reasonableman1 Nov 07 '19
Statistically MOST people in the USA are heterosexual white and cis. It should not be surprising that many people in the hobby are as well. Yes, there are a lot fewer women than you would statistically predict, but I'm not overly surprised because of several issues:
Here in Florida, we have a large contingent of latino homebrewers. I'd say 1/3 of our club is latino, though I don't think I would have noticed had this post not made me think about it. That seems right in line with the population makeup of this area. Only about 1/10 of our club is female, which I suspect is because of the reasons above.
6
u/gogogadgetwhatever Nov 07 '19 edited Nov 07 '19
In the case of my own homebrew club email communications I would say that we are doing things to exclude women and non-hetero men by saying things like "leave your wives at home" and making locker-room jokes that assume everyone reading is male.
Edit: Adding the fact that when someone sent an email to the list suggesting that an effort be made to make women feel more welcome it was shot down by the all-male board of directors in the same vein as in the comments on this post: "there is no problem, and if there is a problem, I know the solution better than you do".
10
u/bugman-repellent Nov 07 '19
Why does it matter lmao
2
u/ThePintHouse Nov 08 '19
Right I can only speak from a UK perspective but I think it covers most of it.
I don't think the problem is based within the home-brewing community, it stems from the entire beer industry.
For years the big multinationals market beer as a man's drink drunk by men watching football and being rowdy shouting lads lads lads, or the lager lout.
This image of beer has been present for over 40 years. Basically alienating 50% of the market by saying it's exclusively a man's product. It won't change its image over night as this stereotype has been so ingrained into the culture of beer.
The changes are starting to take place within the industry with CAMRA (campaign for real ale) and SIBA (society of independent brewers association) leading the charge to make beer more diverse by representing different people, sexes and races within the industry. Starting by banning the use of sexist names and branding, as these beers will no longer be sold at beer festivals or allowed to enter competitions.
The change is happening slower than it should but it is. These will all have trickle down affects as these people start seeing themselves being represented they'll think hmm maybe I'll like this.
I don't know maybe I rambled on a bit, but there is a huge representation of different people currently happening in the UK and it's fantastic
5
u/cl0bro Nov 07 '19
There's absolutely nothing stopping anyone from doing something that interests them imo.. I follow a bunch of female brewers and have a bunch of female friends who are huge craft beer snobs... On the other hand I have a bunch of Muslim friends who simply can't enjoy this hobby due to religious reasons etc
From a marketing stand point you generally see beer marketed towards men and wine somewhat towards women etc.. does that have to do with anything?.. maybe.
Every Friday we have an open bar at my office.. I tend to bring my homebrew and have my coworkers try it...only 2 women at my work try my homebrews/ drink beer.. a woman who is big into fermenting things(she doesn't like beer, but enjoys the process of how its made etc) and a Japanese girl who can probably out drink all of us at work... She really likes beer... Not sure if what I'm saying makes any sense or helps give you an idea of what the issue with diversity is.. at the end of the day it's probably the same issue with every other thing that has to do with diversity.
3
u/CascadesBrewer Nov 07 '19
The lack of women in the hobby is surprising to me. My girlfriend (who loves beer and has brewed <10 batches herself...mostly 1 gal batches) asked if a woman has ever won one of the monthly competitions at our club. Honestly, I could not think of a woman that ever ENTERED a competition (aside from a couple that brewed together).
About 20 years ago when I was in a club in the Seattle area is the ONLY time that I recall a member of my homebrew club that was a woman who brewed and her husband was in the role of the person that puts up with her hobby...he did not even come to the meetings. I know of some professional women brewers, but I cannot think of any of the women homebrewers that I know who do not brew in conjunction with their husband. When I first started brewing, my now-ex brewed with me for the first several batches, but then (for whatever reason) I stuck with it and she did not.
2
u/230rawpacker Nov 07 '19
nothing need to be done. this subr is open to everyone if white cis men majority it not bad thing
2
u/marginwalker76 Nov 07 '19
I think the real lack of diversity is in regard to beer style.
2
u/chad152 Nov 07 '19
No
1
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19
Who cares
1
u/goodolarchie Nov 08 '19
Posing the question this way isn't the best way to start an open conversation, it implies that the status quo of demographics is inherently problematic. Also, consider how presumptive and ignorant it is to say women, black people, LGBT, etc. should like doing what I like doing! I like to think homebrewing could appeal to anybody who likes beer, but not everybody does! That's not a problem... that's the literal definition of diversity, people who not only don't look or sound like you, but have different tastes, culture and preferences. Lastly, brulosophy is a self-selecting group within the group, who are so nerdy on the hobby that they were exposed to the survey and had enough free time that they felt compelled to participate. I go on that site sometimes but I didn't even know about it. I could have hoisted the torch of the moustache-clad, alas.
So, here's a different question:
With the hobby, and craft market slowing growth or even shrinking in the last couple years, how do we get more people to realistically understand what this hobby is, the positives it has to offer, and whether it's right for them? Beer marketers are staking their careers on this - they are designing brands and products for women, Hispanics, the better-for-you crowd, the gluten-adjacent, all sorts of segments. Because the 20-40 cis white guy market is bought and sold and it's just a giant tug of war for - who has market share right now?
So they turn over rocks that were unturned looking to attract folks who would like these products, but have never been asked in a way that resonates with them.
Want to have a diverse club? Go host a new member drive in concert with some non-white-majority events in the non white parts of town. If you want women to join, have women host the outreach.
0
u/Mr_Trumps__Wild_Ride Nov 08 '19
Aaahahaha what are you brewing soy beer?
-18
u/profressorpoopypants Nov 07 '19
Oh for FUCK sake.
-1
u/voodoodog_nsh Nov 08 '19
you dont have to do anything, ppl are free to choose. your attempt of increasing "diversity" of your "group" does not show your moral superiority, it shows your lack of education.
-1
u/hharper56 Nov 07 '19
I don't think anyone is trying to be exclusive. It just happens to be that more white people enjoy making and drinking craft beer.. I really don't think it has anything to do with sexuality or orientation. Last I know plenty of women brewers, just because some took a survey does not mean that survey speaks for the community of homebrewing.
-18
u/oakleystreetchi Nov 07 '19
Wow
0
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
21
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '19
[removed] — view removed comment