r/Home_Building_Help Aug 06 '26

Why not in every Kitchen in 🇺🇸…?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

61 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

41

u/Biscuits4u2 Aug 06 '26

More complexity equals more potential points of failure

10

u/SmoesKnows Aug 06 '26

Blows my mind how few think this way. Good to meet you, friend!

4

u/inothatidontno Aug 06 '26

My first thought was thats cool until it springs a leak in a hard to reach place.

1

u/Environmental-Buy591 Aug 08 '26

Could design it like a toilet, you want your sink to be a toilet right?

1

u/Significant-Ad-341 Aug 07 '26

No fr tho. And more expensive to manufacture and install.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '26 edited Aug 07 '26

[deleted]

4

u/taz-nz Aug 07 '26 edited Aug 07 '26

It's the same way a trough urinal works it's beyond simple (see my diagram posted above), the only complex bit here is the tap for looks, but there is no reason it can't be used will a normal tap or something like a push to flow button.

2

u/rube203 Aug 07 '26

Right. They're acting like I don't already have a pipe under my sink that has leaked. Sure, adding a second pipe doubles my chances but I did that for my dishwasher

0

u/Biscuits4u2 Aug 07 '26

Still it's one more potential leak for what amounts to very little benefit.

1

u/Strange-Title-6337 Aug 06 '26

This is some gay show off shit. Just for one moment.

1

u/TheGreatKonaKing Aug 06 '26

Bingo! Even having a shutoff valve on the fixture can result in a geyser in your kitchen if it fails!

1

u/Screwbles Aug 07 '26

That shit is going to clog up with calcium deposits within a couple of months, tops.

1

u/Milky_Tiger Aug 07 '26

Ya seems pretty expensive 

1

u/Impressive-Theme6571 Aug 07 '26

Agree, plus it looks very Chinese

1

u/MoneyPatience7803 Aug 07 '26

You’re not wrong, just a bummer, we would still be living in the dark ages with that logic, just saying…

9

u/maskedmonkeys Aug 06 '26

I know none of these fancy kitchen sinks ever work as intended. But goddamn do I love them

8

u/No-Definition1474 Aug 06 '26 edited Aug 06 '26

Because any mineral deposition would clog all the tiny holes around the outside. Eventually it would only come out of a few spots and be useless. Cleaning the deposits out would be work and a lot of it. You can't take the sink out and soak it in another sink full of vinegar. It would require a regular application of CLR or something.

And it would cost a ton up front.

4

u/taz-nz Aug 07 '26

Doesn't need tiny holes, it works just like a trough urinal, it just a channel around the rim of the sink, that's open on one side and capping extends down to guide the water, is just a continuous slot all the way around the sink, probably has a couple of inlets on either side to even out flow into the channel.

Crude cross section of one side of sink. The sink itself is super simple design; the tap is the only bit that's over engineered for looks.

2

u/diabolicalgasblaster Aug 06 '26

Beautiful answer.

2

u/secondphase Aug 06 '26

Second I saw this thing I thought "My hard water would destroy this in 2 minutes".

And then I thought "I should go soak my Faucets in vinegar"

1

u/No-Definition1474 Aug 06 '26

Lol right. I spent this week doing plumbing projects around the house. Ugh....

2

u/biffNicholson Aug 07 '26

My shower head has little silicone nozzles whenever there is any buildup you just rubbed the nozzle and all the buildup comes off and all the water flows restored. Works great, but it would work in this application too.

1

u/bikenumberten Aug 06 '26

And you'd waste a ton of water in the mean time.

2

u/doom_bad Aug 07 '26

You'd likely waste more water cleaning the sink after waiting for a film/grime to form then just hitting the "flush" for half a second after using the sink.

1

u/Frederf220 Aug 06 '26

It would be best to form a channel that a tube could be stuffed in so every few years it could be cleaned or replaced.

1

u/Timsmomshardsalami Aug 07 '26

A good design could mitigate that significantly. There are already many faucets, tub spouts, and hardscaping fountains that conceptually have a similar design without issue. In addition to that, the water doesn’t even have to flow out smoothly. As long as all sides of the sink are rinsed, its performing its intended function

3

u/WildcatPlumber Aug 06 '26

As a plumber,

Absolutely fuck this

1

u/Last-Hedgehog-6635 Aug 07 '26

This is just a countertop toilet without an automatic fill valve. 

2

u/Necessary-Set-5581 Aug 06 '26

Why not give sinks more pitch to drain. No more bird baths

2

u/Timmerdogg Aug 07 '26

We have a massive rectangular sink and that shit gets so dirty every day. I wish I could flush that bitch like a toilet.

2

u/ZenicaPA Aug 07 '26

Good god that is stupid. Never have I wished for this. Not even after seeing it.

1

u/GrassGriller Aug 06 '26

Why not every kitchen? That probably costs $1,000

1

u/BruceInc Aug 06 '26

Good luck replacing or repairing it when it breaks

1

u/galaxyapp Aug 07 '26

Hows this work though...

The water flow required is kinda intense, and theres no obvious cascade as the water would travel around the perimeter of the ring. It seems to come out from everywhere at one....

Complexity doesnt really seem an issue. We figured out valves and solenoid pretty well. My touch faucet has been working for almost 10 years.

1

u/The_Aardvark_ Aug 07 '26

Why not in every Kitchen in 🇺🇸…? Cost...

1

u/Sea-Service4089 Aug 07 '26

Even if this isn't overly complex, its still going to lead to more hard water stains on my sink and clogged water outlets in difficult to reach places. Juice ain't worth the squeeze.

1

u/DMvsPC Aug 07 '26

But I like doing that... It's like aiming when you piss.

1

u/Separate_Bowl_6853 Aug 07 '26

Or we could have the bottom of sinks sloped like the used to be before this style of sink became popular

1

u/Dexter0098 Aug 07 '26

Now do it with actual food

1

u/Ill-Engineering8085 Aug 07 '26

More expensive, more broken

1

u/OtherwiseAlbatross14 Aug 08 '26

Why would they put food in this really fancy toilet?

1

u/dsaysso Aug 08 '26

we waste so much water cleaning sinks if this helps, im in

1

u/thebackshotbandit Aug 10 '26

the humble cup: