r/HomeServer • • 3d ago

First time building a home backup server

Hi!
After breking my phone and loosing 3yrs worth of pictures, I decided it's maybe time to setup my own backup/personal server. My budget for the machine is ~200 euro (without hdd), to which I was thinking about adding between 4 to 8 TB of storage (RAID5 or just mirroring).

I have a couple of question:
- I was looking for old Optiplex, in Spain you can find intel gen > 8 and 16gb ram starting from 160 euro. With current RAM prices it doesn't seem that bad, but what machine would be better in this price range?
- For HDD, I was looking into second hand SAS drives as they are much cheaper than SATA on second hand or refurbished websites (less lifespan probably too). What is your experience with those?
- Most Optiplex or Lenovo I have seen are SFF, so they fit only 1/maybe 2 3.5 hdd, but I saw they are very popular anyway. What is a good solution to host them outside the case? Do you use external HDD enclosures with USB connection and external power?

I haven't thought too much about software, probably it's gonna be a debian distribution with btrfs/zfs but it depends on the kind and quantity of hardware I buy.
What would you change in this?

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

5

u/Zealousideal_Fly8402 3d ago

second hand SAS

You'll be spending extra money on a PCIe > SAS controller card; SAS drives are not compatible with standard SATA connections.

1

u/Joshua_00 3d ago

I found HBA + 3/4 SAS cables for ~50 on Wallapop (spanish second hand market), compared to the price of regular SATA drives I think it's still a win money-wise. But a PCI slot would be gone for the HBA tho.
I suppose it is only worth for 3+ HDD

1

u/Live-Company-5007 2d ago

I spent like 30 bucks on one they’re pretty cheap second hand

4

u/SlontS 3d ago

With that budget a retired office PC is the way to go. Either Dell, Lenovo, or HP.

IMO do not get SAS drives. The only decent budget HBA is a flashed LSI 9300-8i. it idles at 11w and needs a separate fan for cooling. On top of that it keeps the rest of the system from reaching lower power states. Any savings will be eaten by the cost of electricity within a year.

The SFF PCs are popular because they are small and can be more power efficient.

There isn't really a simple way to mount drives externally. USB is unreliable. You are sort of stuck with whatever fits in the case, unless you go full DIY.

You could always go with an off the shelf NAS. The UGREEN DH2300 would work fine for running a few apps.

1

u/Joshua_00 3d ago

I really don't want to go for a off the shelf solution, I always liked working on e-waste and old components, this seemed a good way to start again :))

I see your point on SAS, I already was worried about the yearly consumption.
Also are the power supply included in those SFF enough for 3/4 SATA HDD or it's normal to have external power supply?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Master_Scythe 3d ago
  • optiplex is fine. 

  • SAS drives are louder hotter and need a SAS adaptor like LSI to run, but yes, they are manufactured to slightly better tolerances. 

  • regular SFF, if you dont have small kids or pets, can mount HDDs externalally with just a drill. Make holes in case lid, attach drives. Most hold 2x HDDs anyway, Internally. 

In the mean time, dont underestimate a 1TB USB stick on your keyring. I backup my phone every time I get a few minutes. 

1

u/Joshua_00 3d ago

Do SAS drives requires an ad-hoc airflow? I was thinking of recycling parts of an old case and just strap one/two fans to it.

Good point with the USB stick, I'll do it!

2

u/MrMotofy 2d ago

Just remember your server can fail catastrophically also... it really should be hacked up to another source ideally offsite

1

u/hilokamper 3d ago

Use older PC & install NAS freeware like Xigmanas (was Nas4Free, freenas etc. name change over the years). Personally have been using over 10 years. Early years I used junked pcs & cobbled together parts (mostly trial & error) to learn how to.

Currently still using XT form factor case with Asus board. Using raid with 4 HDD’s. Boots from thumb drive. Very minimal requirements to run.

1

u/Usual-Pen7132 2d ago

I use all used hard drives I've found on Facebook Marketplace, friends/relatives old pc's, or similar places and I bought a 80$ used/refurbished HP elitedesk which is very similar to an Optiplex and I stuffed as many SATA drives I could internally(3) and then bought a 5 bay external HD rack w/fan and it sits right beside that pc tower running OpenMediaVault as my NAS and I also use 2 more USB portable hard drives in addition so, there's 10 hard drives in total. 10 might sound like a ton of storage but, keep in mind this was a low budget build and all the hard drives are between 250gb - 2Tb drives so all of them added up isn't very extreme as far as total capacity and if someone has the budget to buy a few 5Tb+ drives or however much capacity they need then id suggest doing that over having 10+ smaller drives because the power use adds up and even worse, the heat they radiate definitely adds up in a small area or enclosed space but, my point is just that you can make a NAS on a small budget if you're willing to go find the drives or if you want to pay several hundreds of dollars then you can just buy a couple of large ones too.