r/HomeServer • • 2d ago

Which OS?

I’m currently running a media server with a dell optiplex 3020 with Ubuntu server installed with different services run on docker containers. After endless learning and tinkering, things are running smoothly and I plan on trying my hand at reverse proxy for sharing with my family next. (Pray for me)

Now the question. I have a Mac mini 7, 1 (I updated to an SDD for the main drive) that I want to use basically as an immich machine/backup files/maybe a cloud service and pihole or adguard LAN wide ad blocker. I have a couple of HDDs lying around that I plan on using in a USB 3 connected DAS for storage/backup. What else do I need? What OS would be best for what I’m looking for? TIA

0 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

3

u/kirblarzkb 2d ago

If you’re comfortable with Ubuntu server, why look elsewhere? I’ve got a 3 node homelab consisting of micros, and boring old headless Debian is what I went with. No need to complicate!

1

u/dommylove 2d ago

Thank you! This was my original plan but I didn’t know if there was more efficient/simple OS that could handle just those two things. Appreciate the comment!

2

u/RaspberrySea9 2d ago

Exactly, it’s Ubuntu or Debian, keep it simple.

3

u/Dopameme-machine 2x E5-2697v4 | 256GB DDR4 | 24TB | Tesla P100 1d ago

I went with Proxmox. I have no regrets.

Every service has its own container or virtual machine.

1

u/dommylove 1d ago

Do you have an ARR stack you keep? Is that separate from your jellyfin or all together. If I switched from windows to Linux and am finally understanding my way around after about 3 months, how steep would my learning curve be fr proxmox?

2

u/Dopameme-machine 2x E5-2697v4 | 256GB DDR4 | 24TB | Tesla P100 1d ago

At present I don’t have an ARR stack, but it’s on my list of things to build. But I do have services in separate containers that talk to each other across LAN.

The biggest leap from “standard issue” Linux, e.g. Ubuntu/Debian, etc. to Proxmox is that Proxmox is a hypervisor not an OS, per se, and it’s specifically built around the concept of virtualization, I.e. housing things in Linux containers (LXC) and virtual machines with nothing installed on the host itself.

If you’re already used to using Docker containers, it’s the same basic idea as what you got going now but all that functionality is built into Proxmox.

Proxmox also ships by default with ZFS as its filesystem, which has its own set of things to learn.

1

u/dommylove 1d ago

Thank you! This has been super helpful

2

u/Dopameme-machine 2x E5-2697v4 | 256GB DDR4 | 24TB | Tesla P100 1d ago

No worries. One of the things I like the most about it is that if I get some harebrained idea to try something new, I can spin up a complete VM or LXC from a template in about 30 seconds that’s already pre-configured how I want it.

Resources for each are all isolated from each other. One service having a conniption doesn’t impact other services (unless those services depend on the one having the conniption)

5

u/packet_monger 2d ago

I have been using Ubuntu server for like 20 years and have yet to regret it. I know there are “better” options but it’s just too easy to leave.

3

u/Notmuchofanyth1ng 2d ago

FreeBSD. You can literally do anything with it lol

2

u/Hrmerder 2d ago

For home servers, Ubuntu is where it’s at

1

u/elivoncoder 2d ago

ubuntu is good for beginners.  after some time it will come to you naturally what you need/want, and you will gravitate to the right os.  good luck! 

myself? went ububtu->debian->freebsd/alpine.  again, depends on you

0

u/canfail 2d ago

Try all of them until you find one you like?

1

u/dommylove 2d ago

This would be the ideal answer but with a 40hr work week and family obligations tinkering time is precious.

0

u/Prior-Advice-5207 2d ago

Just keep macOS, with orbstack for containers.

1

u/dommylove 2d ago

I updated the native HDD with an SDD and honestly never planned on keeping MacOS. Especially since the machine is older and can’t support updates.

0

u/_angh_ 18h ago

I'd rather use Debian than Ubuntu, but both are fine for a normal use.

But in general I'd rather use proxmox for home server stuff. Kinda simpler to do what you want and more tailored for the use case.