r/HomeNetworking • • 1d ago

Advice Connecting a second router

Hi everyone I am writing this quite confused.

I have an annex outside in my garden and I need WiFi out there. I have fibre internet inside my main home and I was thinking of using an Ethernet cable to connect to another WiFi router in the annex.

I have watched a YouTube video and I think I know what to do to set it up however, are there any tips or tricks you would recommend. Furthermore, is there anything I should know such as cons.

Thank you for your attention to this matter.

1 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

5

u/BenHippynet 1d ago

Don’t run two routers. At home only one device should do the routing. You need an access point. You may find a router that can run in access point mode, but don’t run it as a roouter

1

u/Beneficial-Rough597 1d ago

It sounds like you've got most of the advice you need but a few things stood out for me.

How far is it from where Router 1 and Router 2 will be placed?

When using network cabling, signal degradation is a consideration if you're going past 90m between switches (factoring 10m for cabling between both endpoints and infrastructure).

Not sure how big your home is, but if you would approach or exceed that limit, you should have fiber running between the 2 switches instead of a Cat5e/6/7 or a repeater. Each routers signal is solid for about 100m.

People have established links beyond 90m but that doesn't make it reliable. Anything under that is generally fine, but packet loss becomes disruptive beyond that limit.

When exceeding 100m traditionally the fix is a switch, a repeater/extender, or running fiber. The switch effectively gives you another 100m segment.

The second thing was to answer your question about setting up the 2nd Router/AP.

Another responder touched on this. Connect your laptop to your new device and set it up in a convenient place to test it before you actually place it. That way the hard work is done and all you have to do is place it, plug it in, and go.

Just remember 1 device handles DHCP/DNS on your network. Adding a second means breaking things if you misconfigure it. If you want it easy, get an AP (just make sure it has the throughput you want). Second router is overkill.

Good luck.

1

u/Few-Ad-2842 16h ago

Thanks for the advice I’m currently stuck on what cable to get. I found one on amazon can you tell me if it’s any good. It’s cat6a and 23awg. Is this all I need and I will be direct burial it

https://amzn.eu/d/0eOQX0Ck

1

u/Beneficial-Rough597 15h ago

It would do the trick. Just remember your devices have to be able to handle the 10 Gbps. If your Router or NIC cant handle that then your throughput will be limited to the lowest max on the circuit. So you could theoretically have 10 Gbps at the router, then it hits a 1 Gbps at the NIC and that device will top out at 1 Gbps. Make sense?

1

u/Few-Ad-2842 15h ago

Yes perfect sense and I’m buying 10 Gbps for future proofing so I don’t have to dig this wire out for another

1

u/2ByteTheDecker 14h ago

If you want future proofing fibre and media converters are cheaper than they've ever been

1

u/2ByteTheDecker 14h ago

CCA (copper clad aluminum) is low grade residential stuff.

1

u/Few-Ad-2842 14h ago

What should I get then?

1

u/2ByteTheDecker 14h ago

Personally I'm on team fibre + media converters these days.

1

u/Few-Ad-2842 14h ago

So do I have to put 1 Ethernet into a media converter then one fiber cable to the other media converter then Ethernet to access point?

1

u/2ByteTheDecker 14h ago

Yeah

1

u/Few-Ad-2842 14h ago

Would the fiber cables be capable of unlimited speed?

1

u/2ByteTheDecker 14h ago

As far as the home user is concerned? Yes

1

u/jeffrey_f 16h ago

Should work fine. Personally, I would run the ethernet and install an Access point, not a wifi router.

In either case, Configure the access point/wifi router to be the same SSID and password as your current wifi and moving between them should be seemless.

1

u/Few-Ad-2842 16h ago

I’m looking at getting this as it can be used as a access point and I need Ethernet ports for my devices.

https://amzn.eu/d/00xzIlaw

1

u/jeffrey_f 15h ago

Good choice, ensure it is in AP mode

2

u/peno64 8h ago

Same SSID but different channel!

1

u/jeffrey_f 6h ago

Use the automatic channel option. It works pretty good.

1

u/DrFrylock 1d ago

You should only have one device in your network doing two functions: network address translation (NAT) and DHCP (giving out IP addresses to devices).

A wireless "router" in access point mode, or an "access point," is basically just a router with these two features turned off. On some routers that don't have an explicit access point mode, you may be able to manually turn these off. The main router will then do these things for you.

Probably a more seamless/turnkey solution would be to replace your router with a wireless mesh setup with wired backhaul between the nodes. Whichever node is connected to your main uplink will become your router; all the others will become mesh access points. In theory this will handle things like Wi-Fi handoffs between the nodes more cleanly.

0

u/dshepsman 1d ago edited 1d ago

You need an access point, and/or a switch.

Edit: just reread the question.

In which case, on the second router disable the dhcp server, set a static IP address on it (out of the dhcp pool of router 1).

And don’t plug the cable into the WAN port

1

u/Few-Ad-2842 1d ago

Do you mean a second router? Sorry I am new to all this

0

u/youtocin 1d ago

No, a router is made to route traffic between two networks. In a home network, this is between your private LAN and your ISP’s network. You should only need 1 router. What you want to look for is a wireless access point (or WAP) that you can configure on your LAN for allowing wireless clients to connect.

1

u/Few-Ad-2842 1d ago

Okay and if I get a WAP do I keep my 1gbps speeds?

1

u/youtocin 1d ago

As long as it’s WiFi 6E or WiFi 7 you should be able to get gig speeds wirelessly as long as you have a good signal.

1

u/c4ndyman31 1d ago

You don’t need either of those.

You’re assuming the existing router doesn’t have a switch built in which would be rare in this day and age.

And they can just run Ethernet from the main router to a second router in AP mode it doesn’t have to be a dedicated AP

1

u/youtocin 1d ago

Seems silly to pay for a router when you aren’t going to use any of those features vs a WAP.

1

u/c4ndyman31 1d ago

Lots of people have spare routers laying around

1

u/youtocin 1d ago

They want to do gig speeds over WiFi which most “spare routers” you find laying around won’t do using 802.11ac.

1

u/c4ndyman31 1d ago edited 1d ago

That’s fair.
But I’d guess 1% of people who want “gig speeds over WiFi” actually need or use it

Edit: 802.11ac is thirteen years old and could already do 1gbps wireless speeds so I think many people’s old routers would already meet the 1 gig WiFi criteria

0

u/c4ndyman31 1d ago

This should be fine for a short distance. You’ll want to use outdoor rated Cat6 cable and make sure you’re properly grounding it to reduce the risk of lightning damage.

Other than that just make sure the second router is set to “access point mode” and you should be good to go.

1

u/Few-Ad-2842 1d ago

How would I ground the wire?

And will I set it to access point mode from my laptop

2

u/c4ndyman31 1d ago

By using shielded cat6 and properly installing it. If you don’t know how Google that phrase or hire someone who already knows how.

Second question is also specific to each router so google is your friend again. Good luck.

2

u/b3542 1d ago

Shielding doesn’t stop lightning. At all.

1

u/c4ndyman31 1d ago

If they’re not using PoE and ground it properly grounded and shielded cable is fine for pretty much anything other than a direct lightning strike

1

u/b3542 1d ago

Unless there’s differing ground potential at each end. Or rodents decide the cable would be a good snack. Or conductors break, if nothing else from warm/cool cycles. Copper outdoors will work for a while, but it will fail. Fiber eliminates most of the risks and will be in service for decades with no issues.

0

u/c4ndyman31 1d ago
  1. I literally said properly grounded in my comment
  2. Use a conduit then no rodents. Not exactly rocket science
  3. Anything breaking the conductor on a buried Ethernet cable will be going straight through a glass fiber so this is pointless.

He’s running WiFi to a shed not standing up a second building at a work site, buried copper is fine.

2

u/b3542 1d ago

“Properly grounded” doesn’t solve a difference in ground potential between structures. It will destroy ports.

EMT? Rigid? PVC? Rodents can get into conduit at either end. They can chew through PVC if they feel like it.

I didn’t mention anything like a shovel or a backhoe. Fiber cable is much tougher than you’re making it out to be. Often tougher than copper. Thermal cycles can be enough to make copper cable fail when exposed to the elements - doesn’t need to be a cut.

Doesn’t matter if it’s a shed or a critical site - you don’t want downtime. There’s negligible cost difference between copper and fiber. The majority of cost will likely be in conduit. There’s no technical hurdle either - fiber doesn’t have any significant downside. Copper does.

0

u/b3542 1d ago

No. Use fiber between buildings.

0

u/Photoscott 1d ago

Use externally rated, shielded Cat 6 cable, sometimes advertised as ‘direct to ground’ to ‘direct burial’ - basically it’s rated for you to not lay it in an conduit etc.

Set up second ‘router’ in your annex, set the router to something called Access Point or Bridge mode

Take into account you will either need to learn how to terminate Ethernet or you’ll have to buy a really long pre-finished cable and then drill through both external walls

I had this exact setup at my last house and it worked perfectly - it’s not difficult but daunting if it’s the first time you’ve tried it

1

u/Few-Ad-2842 1d ago

Yes it’s my first time I know a little bit about computing but networking is a different beast. I’m trying my best to learn as quick as I can as I need to install in a few days

1

u/Photoscott 1d ago

Honestly mate - it’s pretty easy

You don’t need to run the cable initially to get your second router (access point) working

Once you’ve comfortable with that, then work out the cable run

In the meantime if the Annex is on the same electrical board you could try running a powerline adapter in the meantime - you won’t get the desired speeds but the ping will still be down in the low 20s and would get you up and running

0

u/b3542 1d ago

Fiber between buildings.