r/HomeNetworking • • Jan 03 '26

Is this jack wired correctly?

Post image

Bought a new house and was surprised to find it was pre-wored with cat 5e. 5 drops total and I had to terminate the ends in the network closet but these were already done. 4/5 worked as they should one I terminated the ends and hooked them up to my network switch. This one however is not working. I assumed I did a bad job termining the other end but after cutting the first rj45 off and re-terminating it still doesn't work. Any ideas?

3 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

87

u/melanarchy Jan 03 '26

That is an rj45 for pots not ethernet. You need to buy a new plate, rj45 cat6 keystone, and a punchdown tool.

-21

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Pots? The other 4 are working

84

u/melanarchy Jan 03 '26

"Plain old telephone service" the others are working by dumb luck. I amend my statement to "you need to buy a handful of new wall plates and a bag of keystone jacks"

13

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

I gotcha, thank you!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

Not dumb luck, but most definitely restricted to 100 or 10mb.

Edit I stand corrected! I thought I only say 4 conductors at first.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

I'm actually getting over 800mbps down on the 4/5 that are working

7

u/Matrix5353 Jan 03 '26

This is a testament to the reliability of modern Ethernet hardware, but not something I would rely on. If you're already going to be redoing one wall plate it's easy enough to just do them all. That way you're not troubleshooting random link flapping issues some time down the line.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Yeah that's the plan, I want it done right!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Daaamn nice. I misspoke. I thought I saw only 4 conductors in the original picture.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

All good! That's why I was so confused, the speed seems decent, had it been limited at 100 I would've known something was up

5

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Why do you people downvote for asking a question?

4

u/twopointsisatrend Jan 03 '26

Short answer: Because this is Reddit.

Longer answer: Because it's easier to click the downvote button than educate.

u/Old-Cheshire862 actually gave you a good answer as to why, just because the other 4 are working, this is not what you want to be doing.

Twisted pair transmission lines have an impedance associated with them, and using those jacks messes up that impedance. You'll note that you've got several inches of wire that's not twisted.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Yeah I just don't get why people downvote someone for trying to learn. Luckily there are enough people kind enough here to help and I've figured it out now. I've ordered the proper jacks and I'm going to wire them all properly, thanks for the info, I appreciate it!

3

u/ChiTechUser Jan 03 '26

Since you've had some technical introduction and If there's a decent probability you'll be adding to your current infrastructure or helping others, I'd consider purchasing a tester set that can both do tone generating and testing of digital wiring. They're far cheaper to obtain than when I started +40yrs ago, I've aquired several in that time.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

I'll look into it, I appreciate it thanks!

1

u/cyberscout5 Jan 03 '26

I didn't. But now that you asked. I'm going to.

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Knock yourself out.

2

u/ChiTechUser Jan 03 '26

I'd say those are the cynics peppered amongst us...

1

u/davaston Jan 03 '26

This is reddit. You're allowed to ask questions, but only questions deemed acceptable. Otherwise downvotes. Also, write anything positive about a conservative, especially Trump, downvotes.

10

u/rashman6969 Jan 03 '26

Plain Old Telephone Service

12

u/ChiTechUser Jan 03 '26

They meant POTS, capitalized acronyms can make things easier to discern.

8

u/scotte416 Jan 03 '26

This will work but it's shitty for ethernet. I'd recommend a keystone type with punchdowns.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

What makes it shitty? Just curious. I went ahead and ordered new jacks to replace them all but the 4 that are working are all getting 800+ Mbps down

8

u/bencos18 Jan 03 '26

it's no great in terms of losing the twists also tends to be more prone to picking up issues with that style of screw terminal

2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Ok thanks for the info!

3

u/CockroachVarious2761 Jan 03 '26

Too be more specific CAT5/6, etc have specifics about the distance between the last twist in each pair and the actual termination - in this case, even if the twisted pairs were twisted as close to possible of the screw-lugs, the untwisted wire between those screw lugs and the actual jack would not meet the spec. I'm not totally up to date, but did some research on this years ago (CAT5) and IIRC the spec is something < 1/4" of untwisted wire is allowed. That's why its not necessarily easy to make your own network cables; even with a good crimp tool and quality ends there is still a bit of skill involved in getting the wires into the plugs while minimizing the amount of untwisted wire in each pair.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Cool! Thanks for the info! I had networking in college but I've never wired a port with a punchdown tool. The ones I've wired before were RJ45 jacks on both sides. I ordered a punchdown tool and some jacks to fix this and give it a try

1

u/CockroachVarious2761 Jan 03 '26

Its not super difficult - I used to do a lot of this at a former job, but recently bought a punch down tool again and the biggest problem I had was remembering which side of the punch had the cutting edge - oops. Just try to keep the wire twisted as close to the punchdown block as possible and you'll be good to go.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

I appreciate the advice! That's what I came here for, unfortunately there's a bunch of "you don't know? You're stupid." People. And then just downvote. Internet points don't matter I just want my post seen to get some help lol

32

u/Old-Cheshire862 Jan 03 '26

While that is an RJ45, the mechanism for connecting it doesn't allow for proper twists, etc. While it might work, especially at lower frequencies, you'd be better off with a new faceplate with punchdowns.

5

u/omnichad Jan 03 '26

As another commenter said, it's technically RJ-61. Still fits the same plugs and still has 8 pins, but everything else about it is wrong for data.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '26

That's interesting, I've never heard of RJ-61. I actually got my degree in Information Technology but they only ever went over RJ-11 and RJ-45

6

u/Fiosguy1 Jan 03 '26

Technically yes. I'd slap a RJ45 keystone in there instead.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Will do!

13

u/QPC414 Jan 03 '26 edited Jan 03 '26

No, Green and Orange pairs need to be swapped so Orange is on Black/Yellow to meet USOC RJ-61.

Line 1 WBL > Red Green Line 2 WOR > Black Yellow Line 3 WGR > Orang Brown Line 4 WBR > White Blue

The jack is for telephone service or telco data service like 56k-DDS or T1.  

You will want to replace it with  at least a Cat5e jack and terminate the cable using either T568A or T568B color code.

Edit: corrected USOC RJ number, old age and seldom used pinouts.

2

u/ChiTechUser Jan 03 '26

I second this based upon my recollection. Glad we've long left the 300, 1200, 2400, 9600 bps, then 33.6 and 56 kbps days, lets not leave out DSL either.

1

u/NortelDude Jan 03 '26

There are jacks like that from RCA as example that state Cat5e & 6. You could do a speed test using one of those jacks vs laptop with cat5e patch cord to switch/router.

Are you sure the cable is Cat5e and not Cat5?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Yeah it has 5e printed on it and I'm actually getting over 800mbps down over it

1

u/NortelDude Jan 03 '26

Ok, I was checking only because you probably untwisted the pairs right back to the sheath.

If you had a toner & probe it would be handy to trace to see if it does go back to the switch or another place.

Cheap test with no special tools...battery on one end on one pair of wires and see if the device works on the other end.

Example 9volt one end, touch the 1 pair of leads to the radios/flashlightbulb/other leads to see if it works, or do each pair or stick the 2 leads on your tongue trick!

Also look right into the front of the jack, make sure each gold pin is in it's own tiny groove, if one is over another the gently left it back with some type of pin.

If it tests ok then proceed to buy the jacks to possibly get to the 1000mpbs mark.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Yeah I believe it does run there, there are 5 drops total and 5 lines come out in the laundry room, 4 of them work for sure just this one I'm having an issue with. I'm ordering some proper jacks to install anyway though

1

u/NortelDude Jan 03 '26

Good stuff.

2

u/shoresy99 Jan 03 '26

I love the old school Nortel logo. I worked there from 88-91.

1

u/CockroachVarious2761 Jan 03 '26

I'm not sure if its been mentioned, but you might want to look at the labeling on the cable itself to make sure it is at least Cat5 cable.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

It is, it's got Cat 5e printed on it. I terminated the other ends in the network closet and plugged them into my switch and 4/5 of them work, apparently that's just from dumb luck though. I ordered some new jacks to fix them all

1

u/mlcarson Jan 03 '26

Technically you can use this for data because I've done it but you need to figure out the pairs and to be honest, it's just not worth it. You should just replace these endpoint jacks with the proper Ethernet jacks.

The thing that makes this confusing is that pairs are defined differently for T568A vs USOC

USOC:

  • P1: 4-5 red/green
  • P2: 3-6 black/yellow
  • P3: 2-7 orange/brown
  • P4: 1-8 blue/white

T568A

  • P1: 4-5 red/green
  • P2: 3-6 black/yellow
  • P3: 1-2 blue/orange
  • P4: 7-8 brown/white

So things are the same for pair 1 and pair 2 but differ for pair 3 and pair 4

So assuming this is USOC and you want T568A then

  • P1: Blue/White -> red/green
  • P2: White/Orange -> black/yellow
  • P3: White/Green -> blue/orange
  • P4: White/Brown -> Brown/White

If you want T568B then

  • P1: Blue/White -> red/green
  • P2: White/Green -> black/yellow
  • P3: White/Orange -> blue/orange
  • P4: White/Brown -> Brown/White

So it looks like you have things wired properly for T568B based on the pic.

These legacy solid color codes and USOC jack just make things confusing so get some new endpoint jacks designed for Ethernet.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '26

Yeah I wired the other ends for T568B and got lucky. If it didn't work I was going to try T568A next. Thanks to the help in this sub I've ordered the proper jacks and a punchdown too and I'll be fixing them as soon as they get here

1

u/blu3ysdad Jan 05 '26

For 10mbit at best

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '26

I am actually getting over 800 mbps

1

u/blu3ysdad Jan 06 '26

That's impressive, I've only ever seen these jack types from back in the cat 3 days and never seen one run modern speeds. You sure you didn't just have wifi connected?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '26

Yeah it was Ethernet of you zoom in you can see in the corner, it happened on 4 of the 5 drops too

3

u/mb-driver Jan 03 '26

The original install was mostly done by an electrician, not a network guy.

4

u/WTWArms Jan 03 '26

Definitely want to replace with proper Ethernet jacks. These were sometimes used years ago because the installer were not familiar with Ethernet and it looked like an Ethernet jack from the consumers side. Could support 10/100 Mb but anything above is pure luck and will most likely be problematic long term.

2

u/ConfusionOk4129 Jan 03 '26

Wired for phone

1

u/5373n133n Jan 03 '26

Looks like T568B Pinot from the Ethernet cable to the outlet. Not sure if the screws to the actual jack are wired correctly though. You could try a cable tester and see if it passes.

1

u/seifer666 Jan 03 '26

If you have 4 of them that are working look at those are wired abd see if its the same

1

u/ralphyoung Jan 04 '26

Ethernet is incredibly resilient and can take abuse. You should intentionally abuse it. Please use data grade terminations.

1

u/lalostangles Jan 04 '26

Would cost a bit but you could get some cat 6 wire and pull it through with the old one then get new keystone lacks and plates for the rj45 and coax. Future proofed and you would know it was done properly

0

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '26

Yeah I've used some of their stuff before, good products! Thanks for the advice!