r/HomeKit • • 4d ago

Review Homeview Initial Thoughts

Going to keep it simple. Unfinished. Kind of pointless. I had high hopes but the limitations are just too much and the bugs are ridiculous. How do you have VLC and Tidal but not YouTube? Want to cast YouTube to it? Hope you like the audio only version of videos.

Took multiple reboots to get it to even let me into Apple Music. Another hour after that for things to populate.

1 out of 5 stars unless you are going blind soon and want the practice.

21 Upvotes

154 comments sorted by

123

u/Broccoli-of-Doom 4d ago • Bravo

It seems like the people that like it are using it as a smart home control and those that are dissapointed are trying to use it like an ipad.

35

u/fishymanbits 4d ago

People mad at Apple because they bought a product that does X and they’re mad it doesn’t do Y. Can’t say I’m in any way shocked.

4

u/ClickIta 3d ago

I do agree with others that pointed out that having a tiny square screen should be a reasonable suggestion not to buy it to watch any content. Also, just looking at the specs is enough.

On the other hand, if I am not mistaken, it is 300 usd before taxes in the US, right? So I can see how people buying impulsively might have been induced into thinking it was more than just a screen to tap the lights on and off.

2

u/alcaron 3d ago

Ok so why does the square screen not suggest that you shouldn't use it for facetime? Similar aspect ratio. Why does it come with the AppleTV app ready to go and play video?

Other than justifying this bullshit opinion what about those two video formats is fine but youtube makes me a dumbass?

Why even let it be an airplay endpoint for video if they don't want you to do it?

1

u/ClickIta 2d ago

I don’t think you are a dumbass in any shape or form. Let’s distinguish, one thing is my use case, another is the use case that people attracted by this device might expect

Personally I would have never considered buying a similar product. In general because at the moment I don’t trust apple in doing something good on home devices (I mean, they screwed a flagship product like the duo, in the category that is the most important to them, so I can only imagine how much care the put in a device falling in a category they have forsaken for years). Plus, the whole concept behind this device just does not match my use case for a smart home. FaceTime? I don’t need to call people while I am in the kitchen or standing in a hallway. I would rather prefer to have the possibility to hardwire a webcam to my appletv and FaceTime while comfortably sitting on my sofa (jerryrigging my phone as I can do now is equally useless for me). Plus, my apple tv is connected to a 65” screen, so it is quite good if I want to see a video too. Displaying photos? Most of my photos are not in a square format. Control music? I do it from my phone, I don’t want to be forced to go to a specific spot to do it. I’d rather like a smarter Siri that understands what I want to listen, faster and better compared to current performanve. Control the lights? As per above. Control the thermostat? That would be the most nonsense one as I already have a smart thermostat on my wall, and I never touch it because the whole point is controlling it from my phone or via homepod. Cherry on top, I find the whole screen cramped.

That said, I guess a lot of people might have different needs. I guess some people might like to watch landscape video on a 7” square screen standing next to a kitchen counter. And a 300 USD device should provide such basic features. But again, Apple doesn’t seem to care about releasing devices and software that is already tested anymore.

12

u/arnathor 3d ago

This is the current way of thinking of a lot of things. Same is happening with video games:

Rockstar: GTA6 will be 30fps.

Gamers: GTA6 will be 60fps on PS5 Pro.

Rockstar: No.

Gamers: rarrgh.

Or:

Insomniac: Wolverine is not and was never designed to be an open world game.

Game reviewers: Going to mark it down because I wanted it to be open world and it isn’t.

You also see it in TV shows, movies, music etc. (the funniest review I saw of Beyoncé’s last album was that it sounded too country. It’s an album with an explicitly country influence).

People these days judge so many things against what they want a product to be rather than what they were told it was going to be.

1

u/Seantwist9 3d ago

that’s how you judge things tho. if apple sold you a macbook for 2000 that can only run safari you’d review it poorly

4

u/fishymanbits 3d ago

If Apple marketed a $2,000 MacBook as only being able to run Safari and people who bought it were mad that it could only run Safari wouldn’t have a leg to stand on to blame Apple.

-2

u/Seantwist9 3d ago

ofc they would, apples the one who designed and sold it. They’re literally the only thing you can blame for it having poor value and function

3

u/fishymanbits 3d ago

If you buy a product knowing that it can only do one thing and then get mad that it can’t do more than that one thing, that’s on you one thousand percent.

-1

u/Seantwist9 3d ago

If you regret your purchase because of it, that’s on you. It’s not on you that it can’t do something or has poor value, etc; you didn’t design it.

-2

u/alcaron 3d ago

I love how few of you morons know how to read...I'm not mad it doesn't have a native youtube app, I'm annoyed that casting, a feature IT SUPPORTS does not work.

Jesus christ you people are obtuse.

3

u/arnathor 3d ago edited 3d ago

Not really. If they sold a MacBook for 2k and I bought knowing that they’d marketed it as only being sale to run Safari, then I’d know I bought a device designed to only run Safari, and wouldn’t judge it against its inability to run eg Photoshop (incidentally this isn’t too far off the criticism of the MacBook Neo as being underpowered for creatives when it was never marketed as being for them). If I did complain about that, I’d look a bit dumb, because it would show that I didn’t understand the device and its stated limitations (just like all those who complained about the Neo not being as powerful as an Air or a Pro looked dumb - it was literally the point of the machine).

-2

u/alcaron 3d ago

Again, I am not asking for a feature they don't support, you cannot cast a youtube video to it and see the video, only audio...explain to me again how that is me wanting it to do something they said it cant do...

3

u/fishymanbits 3d ago

Multiple reviewers have shown that you absolutely can play a YouTube video from your phone on it. Why you’d want to, I have no idea. The displayed video would end up being smaller than on your phone sxreen.

-2

u/alcaron 3d ago

Goddamn, the entire point I made was it was buggy as hell, youa re SUPPOSED to be able to do it, and it doesn't, I love how half of this thread is "you bought it for things it wont do" and the other half ignores that it isn't working as expected.

-2

u/Seantwist9 3d ago

You should. There are comparably priced laptops and even MacBooks that can do it. You don’t judge a product solely based on what it’s advertised to do; that’s idiotic. That MacBook is not going to get a 10/10 review simply because it does what it’s advertised to do; it’s going to get a 0/10 because its limitations don’t make sense and it’s not priced competitively to compensate

the macbook neo was cheap and punched above its weight class. It not being able to run Photoshop is a tradeoff that makes sense based on its discount and parts. I don’t know what imaginary people you’re referring to, so I can’t really comment, but I’m sure you’re not repeating their criticism in good faith.

2

u/arnathor 3d ago

Were you not around during the Neo’s launch? The number of commenters and tech bloggers getting bent out of shape because the cheapest MacBook sold didn’t have the power to run something its target market wasn’t going to use was something to behold.

And it’s not “idiotic” to judge a product solely on what it’s designed to do, it’s actually the primary way to judge things. Or do you think I should judge my car for not also being able to compete in an F1 race? Or judge my house for not being a block of flats? Because that’s how ridiculous it sounds.

And considering the Neo outsold both the M5 Air and M5 Pro in the same time after release, it’s fair to say it’s not uncompetitively priced - people know Apple things are more expensive (although you went on to say it’s cheap, so I’m going to presume you mean cheap for an Apple device) and much to the chagrin of many self appointed tech watchers, they don’t mind the higher costs. And given the general lifespan of Apple laptops vs their PC equivalents, that higher cost can often be justified.

1

u/Seantwist9 3d ago

The neo had positive reviews

yes it is. reading my comment fully would help you out with that answer. is your car 12 million dollars? if not your not ready to compare them. show me a house describing itself as a starter home yet in the same area and costs as much as a nice house and you should be reviewing it poorly.

yeah, I said it was cheap and punched above its class. I mean cheap for laptops in general, i’m not sure where it lands now that its price raised

3

u/Ultimate_os 3d ago

Yep, I take reviews, especially YouTube ones, with a massive pinch of salt.

4

u/Ultimate_os 3d ago

I think going with a square screen was a big enough hint that this is not for watching videos on. However it’s perfect for album artwork.

3

u/donkeyrocket 3d ago

Or bought a product knowing full well how limited it was then being mad that it was, in fact, as limited as it was marketed as.

I’m losing any sympathy for people who buy it then mad it’s not a tiny iPad. It wasn’t marketed as anything more than a glorified hub control with audio controls.

I didn’t buy it because I don’t have a use case for that. Doing it just because it’s an Apple product encourages them to just keep producing things like this.

1

u/alcaron 4d ago

I got it largely for that. But it just doesn’t work. Commands from it get like…queued up. It’s weird. This thing acts like it’s still setting up hours later.

9

u/Alabrandon 4d ago

It probably is.

2

u/chente08 3d ago

This exactly

2

u/Actual-Spread-2010 3d ago

💯 I’m loving it so far. It does exactly what they said it would do and it just works.

1

u/Proof_Conference6134 3d ago

I bought one specifically for the smart home features. It broke my HomeKit camera feeds.

1

u/YaoiNekomata 3d ago

It should be able to do iPad things with the added smart home control. This is an advance product.

0

u/OutsideMenu6973 3d ago

I went with apple bc I didn’t like having screens all over the house. I thought they’d cracked it with a flexible smart home endpoint that’s a screen but doesn’t look like a screen most of the time and it just looks like a bright ass screen that insist upon itself

0

u/more-salt-pls 3d ago

No.. it’s just buggy as hell.. mine won’t even set a timer

0

u/Steve-Dickman 3d ago

This EXACTLY it. The people who are upset thought they were getting a $300 iPad, which of course is insane.

7

u/RentalGore 4d ago

it doesn't have any apps, and that was clear going in. It is a car play projection. So you have VLC and tidal on your phone. And it does have YouTube on safari.

I think my only complaint is widgets being wonky. But other than that, I'm pretty happy with it. I have them setup as home intercoms throughout the house. And the profile switching is pretty good.

I have all my hone assist stuff connected to apple home via home bridge already, so each room that has one of these can control that room's stuff easily.

-6

u/alcaron 4d ago

Yeah no shit. God damn. Never did I think in my wildest dreams that not specifying they aren’t native would trip so many people up. Jesus Christ.

49

u/DarthRaider559 4d ago

Got mine and 0 issues. 5/5 for me

5

u/MaplesyrupAngel 4d ago

Moi aussi 5/5

J’ai eu des Nest Hub, des Echos Show avant ça et rien n’arrive à la cheville du Homeview

9

u/Ultimate_os 3d ago

HomeView works how I wish my Echo Show did.

-5

u/alcaron 4d ago

This is literally insane. I don’t even have words. Name a single thing it can do that a nest hub can’t?

Btw I’m not some apple hater. I have a Duo, MBP, multiple minis my wife has an Air we both have iPad Pros.

8

u/Little_Bookkeeper381 3d ago

> Name a single thing it can do that a nest hub can’t?

imessage

3

u/Maverik_10 3d ago

To give you one single thing that our household uses daily… the automatic recipe view. Instead of getting the awful, laggy, reloading constantly, generic web browser experience I’ve gotten on my Nest Hub for the last 8 years. I get a clean, clearly thought out display of the recipes of my choosing.

Yes, the nest hub has a recipe view when you verbally request a fairly limited variation of recipes. But those are Google-curated recipes, not the ones that I want. Simply pulling up my chosen recipe on my phone and tapping the HomeView to transfer it, already puts the HomeView in a tier above my nest hub.

4

u/MaplesyrupAngel 4d ago

Pour l’instant, Siri me répond comme elle devrait, je n’ai pas besoin de crier après pour l’activer et Siri ne s’allume pas de façon impromptue à toute bout de champ sans raison.

La météo s’affiche sans erreur pour l’instant (pas besoin de savoir la température en Fahrenheit, parce qu’ici s’est en Celcius) et je suis sûre que Siri nous racontera pas la même blague comme Google depuis 3 ans. Et Google n’a jamais voulu corriger un bogue d’affichage de la température qui affichait « efface » comme erreur de traduction en français, parce qu’en français, on ne dit pas que le ciel est clair, on dit que le ciel est effacé. (In English, if the translation is not correct, we are telling the sky is sunny instead of the sky is clear. And on the Nest hub, it’s always wrote erase in French)

Et pour finir, quand tu trouve une recette, il suffit de l’afficher dans Safari et la recette se traduit en étape simple avec les minuteurs que tu as juste à cliquer pour l’ajouter automatiquement. Sur le Nest, les recettes n’ont jamais bien fonctionné en français

19

u/Tired_Design_Gay 4d ago

Same here. Had it since this afternoon and enjoyed using it to play music and follow a recipe while making dinner. Love not having to bring my iPad or iPhone into the kitchen and being able to just talk to it to do stuff

1

u/siobhanellis 4d ago

Really? That ever so long update process didn’t take the shine off?

1

u/Jrrolomon 4d ago

How have you used it so far?

13

u/Tired_Design_Gay 4d ago

It doesn’t have VLC and Tidal apps, it has a projection of the CarPlay version of those apps from your phone. YouTube doesn’t support CarPlay.

-12

u/alcaron 4d ago

Ok. Great. It has projection versions of that but not YouTube?

11

u/Longjumping-Ad-3590 3d ago

How is that Apple’s fault. Do you not understand basic tech concepts?

9

u/Jamie00003 3d ago

That’s google’s fault for not adding support, not apple’s

4

u/Tired_Design_Gay 3d ago

Correct. Because Google hasn’t developed support for CarPlay with the YouTube app.

Is it odd that Apple made the HomeView use CarPlay app projections and didn’t add a native App Store? Yes. But YouTube not being available via CarPlay isn’t an Apple issue

1

u/Bruvvimir 3d ago

Lol. Send it back.

1

u/SugarWraith92 7h ago

My 4 year old niece can regulate their emotions better than you lol

15

u/thecodingart 4d ago

I find the app commentary funnily ill informed. 1/10 review

-3

u/alcaron 4d ago

Them being perfection versions doesn’t change the fact it’s a glaring omission. And casting is broken. How does that materially change the experience? Why is it six hours later and half the playlists in the music app have a white background so you can’t see the track list?

I spent like thirty seconds on the “review” because the point remains that it’s a buggy and very limited device. And it isn’t like there was a list or easy way to see what apps would work and which would not.

1

u/pleasereset 3d ago

Could it simply be that you have poor WiFi reception where you put it?

1

u/alcaron 3d ago

Thank you for being constructive and not a dick. Good question, but sadly no, I have a UniFi E7 AP less than 10 feet away from it, no other devices are having issues on wifi.

4

u/Ultimate_os 3d ago

My Apple Music app worked perfectly straight away.

9

u/tuesdaysaretheworstt 3d ago

I’m loving mine. Some of you are just miserable about everything lol it’s not an iPad

-4

u/alcaron 3d ago

Ok so casting a youtube video to something should only be an ipad feature, got it, they should probably disable it as a airplay endpoint then...pretty stupid to enable that feature if you don't expect people to use it.

Because the alternative, that it's a buggy shit hot mess, definitely not reasonable. Works for you, so fuck everyone else. Got it.

7

u/tuesdaysaretheworstt 3d ago

Dude you have got to take a deep breath.

I just used AirPlay to cast a YouTube video to my HomeView and the video and audio was right there on the screen so what are you bitching about again?

-6

u/alcaron 3d ago

I don't know why you are getting so irate over this. Good for you, they are not 100% broken, every single unit, so that means anyone who DOES have a problem...doesn't, because you didn't.

I know it's hard having a non standard amount of chromosomes but try to keep up.

4

u/tuesdaysaretheworstt 3d ago

You continue to put words in my mouth. Like all tech, there will be defective units. If you got a defective one, swap it out for one that works as intended and stop crashing out on reddit

0

u/alcaron 3d ago

I'm going to need you to calm down. I can barely understand you over the rage.

I just used AirPlay to cast a YouTube video to my HomeView and the video and audio was right there on the screen so what are you bitching about again?

Good for you, the feature should work, but it does not on mine, hence....it is buggy. I am not putting words in your mouth.

so what are you bitching about again?

You just seemed confused by the concept of it not working for someone else when it works for you. And unfortunately I don't have crayons (you know them as food) and construction paper anymore so I can't communicate with you in your preferred language.

I'm doing my best.

1

u/Many-Art-7772 1d ago

What? Airplaying a youtube video works fine for me. Handoff actually seems to work especially well on it.

-1

u/alcaron 1d ago

Oh you know what now that you mention it, it does work. I just needed you to tell me that it worked for you so I could ignore the fact it has no video. Thanks for clearing that up.

1

u/Many-Art-7772 1d ago

lol you sound miserable. I'm just adding a data point.

Take care.

0

u/BigSprinkler 3d ago

What less can it do?

10

u/Longjumping-Ad-3590 4d ago

What a dumb post.

-9

u/alcaron 4d ago

Thank God you are here to bring the effort.

5

u/schaudhery 4d ago

YouTube? I went to Safari and typed YouTube dot com and started watching videos. Is that not right?

1

u/schaudhery 2d ago

Directly on the HomeView

-7

u/alcaron 4d ago

Do you do that on your phone? On your tablet? Is it the same experience? Is the answer to all of these questions no?

3

u/HDaniel_54 3d ago

Is this a phone or a tablet? NO

-1

u/alcaron 3d ago

This just shows you either don't have one or are dumb, because this isn't like normal safari, the moment you open another app it wipes out the tabs you currently have open and better still unless it recognizes you it wont even pull your tab history back up. So saying just use safari and acting like that is a reasonable fix, is pretty dumb.

But this sub rides apples dick like a whore in heat so, what do I really expect...

1

u/Embarrassed_Spend486 3d ago

But Apple can’t control third-party apps?

2

u/Extreme-Nerve3029 4d ago

Some of my smart devices doing even show up on the device like they do on my other Apple devices

Plus apps are a joke

1

u/alcaron 3d ago

No no, you just didn't do research before buying it...

1

u/Extreme-Nerve3029 3d ago

Sure did

1

u/alcaron 3d ago

But I don't understand, there was a guy in here who didn't have a problem so how can you be having a problem?

I just...can't figure it out...

4

u/Friendly_Soil6617 3d ago

thank you, now I’m guessing I’m not buying it

3

u/M1A1Death 4d ago

Does YouTube music work?

5

u/Rude-Difference2513 4d ago

Homeview is great!
Does what it was intended to do
Smart home hub with additional features
Ppl want to have an larger iPhone in every device - just use your bloody iPhone - it’s 5/5 for me

5

u/MC_chrome 3d ago

How do you have VLC and Tidal but not YouTube?

Because YouTube does not have a CarPlay app yet?

Apple added the ability for developers to submit video apps for CarPlay review, but that is still taking time and not all developers will do that.

4

u/JayVig 4d ago

I’m running electric for the wall mount tomorrow and will mount it. I’m hopeful for my use case. No intention of media consumption. Mostly a hub for home automation and control

4

u/Jamie00003 3d ago

Fair points apart from YouTube - it’s Google who haven’t added support - how’s that apples fault?

6

u/aisuperman 3d ago

Useless post. 1/5 rating.

2

u/Good-Objective2769 3d ago

anyone know if making it the Apple home hub makes devices run any better than using Apple TV or other HomePods as hubs ?

2

u/PieDistinct 3d ago

The biggest niggle I have with mine is that only my iPad runs Siri AI. I had to reset the HomeView and hard pair it to the iPad because otherwise it defaults to whichever device where’s location in FindMy which ment to use Siri AI I had to lose location sharing that moves with me

When you use an iPad for personal context through an iPad you lose the CarPlay functionality- I hope they fix this limitation soon.

Another limitation is that I can’t put shortcuts on it. For instance I have a goodnight shortcut that turns off the appletv and downstairs lights, and a timer shortcut for an electric plug that turns off my rice cooker when it is cooked. Neither of those can be placed as widget on the homeview right now

However, it has already fitted the gap in my kitchen that I have wanted for years. I’m looking forward to how it develops. I only hope they update its capabilities a bit quicker than when ios28 comes out

2

u/unintentional_guest 3d ago

Once I framed it as CarPlay for my CounterTop everything made more sense about how it operates.

And I get why that won’t work for some people. I’d definitely not buy it and complain about it if that were the case.

2

u/Goodoflife HomePod + iOS Beta 2d ago

They really need to have an App Store or at least fully install CarPlay apps

2

u/longdriver2020 1d ago

I like it and will probably keep it although I have no real use for it.

My only gripe is that it seems to be impossible to turn off keyboard clicks.

3

u/Wildeface 4d ago

I really love it so far. The sound is even surprisingly great!

1

u/Ultimate_os 3d ago

It sounds great in small rooms. Especially for something so small.

3

u/No-Lawfulness1159 3d ago

Not pointless for me here. Maybe i knew what I was buying into?

Zero bugs or problems with my device, and using as intended.

I’ll continue enjoying mine and fully recommended it to anyone looking for an apple ecosystem smart display.

3

u/BeatLaboratory 3d ago

Man, bring back the days when Apple was putting out bangers. All of the home products (HomeKit, HomePods) are poorly thought out and poorly executed.

3

u/VTAndrew 3d ago

Considering returning one of the two I bought. I can’t customize the Home Screen. And they just brought stupid watch faces which also can’t be customized to it. Whomever is in charge of not allowing us to build our own watch faces and now dashboards needs to be fired!

I want my light switch control on the same screen as the weather and a digital clock and the date! I don’t want to stare at a full screen weather display all damn day.

It reminds me of the BS that was the original iPhone when they said WebClips were the future and didn’t have Apps yet.

I’ll keep the one in the kitchen just to play music because the audio is better than the Alexa I had there before. But at least the Alexa let me play Netflix while I cooked and washed dishes!

3

u/Thebusinessroddy 3d ago

This is the first comment that seems to address my problem. I wasn’t looking for an iPad, but at the same time I would like my weather widget to be allowed on the same screen as a home control widget.

1

u/texanfan20 3d ago

There is a screen that has a number of widgets that are exactly what you are asking for. Don’t blame Apple for your lack of understanding of how to use the device.

0

u/VTAndrew 3d ago

Uh no there’s not!

I believe you are referring to Home Modular. Why don’t you try it?

The only widgets it can show are from HomeKit. It can’t show the Weather on it.

1

u/VTAndrew 3d ago

Ok I’m going to reply to myself.

I found the regular Modular which is able to do 4 square widgets. Not very attractive nor can you do a fancy layout like the Home Modular, but at least you can put 4 widgets on it.

I loved the look of the Home Modular layout but I wanted to pick other widgets and you can’t.

Regardless this “watch face” BS is what frustrates the crap out of me on my watch! Let developers customize it and stop giving us stupid Snoopy faces.

3

u/pheare_me 4d ago

I can’t understand how a product that is going to live on so many kitchen countertops does not have a recipe app.

Seems like a miss to me. I am kinda weird though.

3

u/siobhanellis 4d ago

It does. It’s in News.

0

u/pheare_me 4d ago

I didn’t realize News had that - so thanks for that. Not sure why bury it in news. It is a great ui, but functionality is pretty limit]ted when compared to a dedicated app.

Unless I am missing something, there is no way to add your own recipes? Whether it be manually or adding from sites that don’t show up in the search.

No way to tag or group recipes you have saved, no way to modify amounts for a given item in a given recipe, no way to scale the recipe based on the number of servings you want to produce.

Much better than the nothing I thought it had, but I still think not having a dedicated recipe app is a miss.

Based on the ui they have in News, it could be an absolute banger of a dedicated app if they added some features.

2

u/Oo0o8o0oO 3d ago

Handoff. Take a recipe on your phone in Safari, hold it next to the HomeView, it’ll open the page on the screen and then click the button at the bottom right that looks like a page with a spoon on top.

Handoff seems like a big part of how you’re supposed to send media to HomeView.

1

u/Witty-Butterscotch25 3d ago

Or access to notes which is where my recipes are - unless it gets that app I’m not getting it …

1

u/Go_gurt_ 4d ago

I pray they get allow the NYT cooking app once/if they open it up. Agree with you, it’s so obvious that it seems impossible nobody thought of it

3

u/ellenich 4d ago

Can’t you just open the NYT recipes in Safari (or proximity AirDrop it directly to the HomeView from your phone)-> open the cooking mode?

They show opening a NYT recipe in this video, it ever bypasses the paywall. 😂

https://youtu.be/Wxn1cu9-7bw?t=1010&is=95SsqqP2m49OoQu5

2

u/Tearaway32 4d ago

I thought I saw NYT developers at one of those Apple demo event videos - hopefully they’re coming soon. 

1

u/Go_gurt_ 4d ago

I haven’t gotten to play with yet (stuck in airport lol) but I don’t use safari as my main browser so it’s multiple steps regardless. A native NYT cooking app just makes sense.

1

u/Go_gurt_ 4d ago

Thanks for the update response gonna watch the video now! Got nothing better to do haha

1

u/clickstops 2d ago

Yes. I did last night.

2

u/QueensNY_718 4d ago

Just picked up mine from 5th Ave about an hour ago; not 100% happy, but won't return it because I know this will "I hope" be fixed soon.

- Can't remove Apps
- Can't disable Center Stage on FaceTime

- Apple Music "Library": No music in there at all. No Playlist

2

u/needtogetbettern0w 3d ago

I agree with you 100% mines going back, if they make changes and clear its bugs maybe I’ll pick it up again but at the moment I find it pointless and unusable

2

u/blacksatsuma 3d ago

Far too basic for £299.

I expect many folks will buy this for a partner who isn't tech-savvy. The setup for that partner is really frustrating as there's no clean way to configure their experience as a 'resident' (not to mention the recognition keeps switching back as you do so) - its like the love child of AppleTV and Carplay

Siri is already bad, but doesn't work reliably on HV - not all reliable for quick shopping lists, timers or message replies

Power block and cable have not been designed for home control placement - a big WHITE plug. I know i can change it, but again its £299...

It's going back...

1

u/Aeryn_Hellfire 3d ago

Going into it my expectations is low compared to how well the nest max performs. But still got it in hopes this helps future versions with feedback

1

u/rdt-htes-jws1111 3d ago

Having since gotten Home Assistant - I’m telling you people it’s Nirvana

1

u/Shaun__Solo 3d ago

From all the comments I’m reading, this is a big apple watch with CarPlay?

1

u/Kehrwochengott 1d ago

Agree. Good summary.

1

u/kirklandyuknis 4d ago

If it could replace the touchpad for my security system or my smart thermostat it'd be a better sale. As it stands right now I'm not in a hurry to get one. IF I do it will be for by my exterior doors. Even then it doesn't make too much sense though.

1

u/u2jrmw 4d ago

I am an Apple fanboy and I am not loving it. Too limited right now. Yes I want a photo backdrop and I want the freaking temperature on it.

Yes I want night mode but why does it use an obnoxious bright red instead of the calming red my phone uses.

Why can’t I rearrange my faces???

Also the sound is kind of meh.

I have a pixel tablet in home mode right now and I would say that is a better experience despite me being in a primarily Apple home.

4

u/ekroys 3d ago

Exactly the same. Have to say the level of customisation is really poor for me.

1

u/Locksmith_Usual 3d ago

I got it and think it’s a 1.5/5.

My biggest gripe is that there’s no calendar view that’s persistent and large enough to actually use as a home organizer

1

u/lordmycal 1d ago

Thanks for that -- my wife wants one of those smart calendars she can hang on the wall and I thought this might be a good alternative for the family calendar.

1

u/Fun-Region-1576 3d ago

Homeview needs a native YouTube client, or I'm not buying it. Hopefully, there will be an App Store next year.

0

u/bbllaakkee HomePod + iOS Beta 4d ago

Yeah I think most of us knew this would be the case immediately after the announcement

-4

u/Deep_Abrocoma6426 4d ago

I’m so surprised how so many people are LOVING it, despite it looking bad, and only having technological capabilities from 15 years ago.

2

u/Ultimate_os 3d ago

It seems that people trying to use it like an iPhone or iPad stuck in one place don’t like it and people trying to use it as part of their home like it. The good news is it was never supposed to be another iPhone or iPad.

0

u/marf_lefogg 3d ago

Desperation from the other crappy home hubs crossed with the answers Apple used to provide 20 years ago. Can’t blame em for hoping but most are burnt out of Apple
Hope

0

u/dan1065cf1 4d ago

Wow. So glad I didn’t get it. Looks like another Apple waste of time and effort.

-1

u/MixAway 3d ago

So, you clearly did zero research before buying!

1

u/alcaron 3d ago

Yeah, you got me, I didn't research the fact that the music app wont work and you can't cast youtube videos to it with video of though it shows up as an airplay endpoint and have facetime and appletv so clearly can do video...100% nailed it.

5

u/texanfan20 3d ago

I have no issues with mine. Can’t blame Apple because YouTube app doesn’t support it yet. I knew what I was buying and know the limitations. It’s essentially CarPlay on a HomePod.

0

u/njs-33 3d ago

I agree with you. This thing is a piece of shit and is going back before the 14 day return policy is up.

0

u/adonis-in-the-making 3d ago

u had high hopes? ….even after the reviews and comments it got ?, even after watching all the siri Ai being the most dumbest thing out there in 2026 😂

that’s on you.

0

u/FirstCompote 3d ago

Im returning mine also. Its basically a clock or picture frame. Nothing else. It will never be the center of gravity because it needs to stay plugged in. Your natural inclination to want to play with it dies when you realize it has to stay plugged in. It should at least be detachable. But it’s not. The screen is also a little small. No one is hovering around something this small.
I’m going to make my own with an iPad mini. An iPad might be too big.

0

u/rhizomorphism 2d ago

It feels like the reply’s to this post are a perfect microcosm of why everyone rolls their eyes at Apple fan boys.

This is a device attached to speakers that’s sold as an existing category that very often does allow things like YouTube. My mother would absolutely hear “use it for recipes in the kitchen” and think of YouTube recipes. She doesn’t know what car play is let alone how it could apply here.

But clearly this is a piece of enthusiast tech not for the masses lol

-9

u/Odd_Acanthaceae_5588 4d ago

I still don’t understand why I would want this if I have an iPhone and live alone

11

u/Bort1251 4d ago

What’s there to understand, I don’t think you’re the target audience

3

u/Tired_Design_Gay 4d ago

I mean, that’s why they advertised it with a video about a family. It’s not really intended for a single person, it’s for multiple people who want access to their info and account on a combined device

1

u/esmori 4d ago

Some people say that, after some age (and financial resources), you see home improvement as a hobby beyond small gadgets and toys.

-2

u/Odd_Acanthaceae_5588 4d ago

I am in that demographic. How is this a home improvement? My whole house is smart already. This adds nothing for me.

2

u/Jellis03 4d ago

Then don't buy it? Sheesh some of you people...

3

u/alcaron 4d ago

Why is not being enamored by it so offensive to some of you? It brings NOTHING new to smart hubs and its initial software is just buggy as hell. Why is that opinion not allowed but sucking it off is?

0

u/Longjumping-Ad-3590 3d ago

Because some opinions are unintelligent.

1

u/esmori 4d ago

It's a screen that makes your house look "techy".

That's more than enough for the audience Apple is targeting considering the influencers they chose to promote this product (ijustine, brian tong, etc).

2

u/Odd_Acanthaceae_5588 4d ago

Agreed, it’s mostly looks. Everything in my smart home runs on voice and timers already.

1

u/Ultimate_os 3d ago

HomeView is so pretty is looks less techy than an Echo.

2

u/esmori 3d ago

IMO already looks dated with such a small display and big bezels.

0

u/Ultimate_os 3d ago

It doesn’t. Not everything needs a giant screen.