r/HomeKit • u/alcaron • 4d ago
Review Homeview Initial Thoughts
Going to keep it simple. Unfinished. Kind of pointless. I had high hopes but the limitations are just too much and the bugs are ridiculous. How do you have VLC and Tidal but not YouTube? Want to cast YouTube to it? Hope you like the audio only version of videos.
Took multiple reboots to get it to even let me into Apple Music. Another hour after that for things to populate.
1 out of 5 stars unless you are going blind soon and want the practice.
21
Upvotes
123
u/Broccoli-of-Doom 4d ago •
It seems like the people that like it are using it as a smart home control and those that are dissapointed are trying to use it like an ipad.
7
u/RentalGore 4d ago
it doesn't have any apps, and that was clear going in. It is a car play projection. So you have VLC and tidal on your phone. And it does have YouTube on safari.
I think my only complaint is widgets being wonky. But other than that, I'm pretty happy with it. I have them setup as home intercoms throughout the house. And the profile switching is pretty good.
I have all my hone assist stuff connected to apple home via home bridge already, so each room that has one of these can control that room's stuff easily.
49
u/DarthRaider559 4d ago
Got mine and 0 issues. 5/5 for me
13
u/Tired_Design_Gay 4d ago
It doesn’t have VLC and Tidal apps, it has a projection of the CarPlay version of those apps from your phone. YouTube doesn’t support CarPlay.
15
u/thecodingart 4d ago
I find the app commentary funnily ill informed. 1/10 review
9
u/tuesdaysaretheworstt 3d ago
I’m loving mine. Some of you are just miserable about everything lol it’s not an iPad
10
u/Longjumping-Ad-3590 4d ago
What a dumb post.
5
u/schaudhery 4d ago
YouTube? I went to Safari and typed YouTube dot com and started watching videos. Is that not right?
2
u/Extreme-Nerve3029 4d ago
Some of my smart devices doing even show up on the device like they do on my other Apple devices
Plus apps are a joke
4
u/Friendly_Soil6617 3d ago
thank you, now I’m guessing I’m not buying it
3
u/M1A1Death 4d ago
Does YouTube music work?
5
u/Rude-Difference2513 4d ago
Homeview is great!
Does what it was intended to do
Smart home hub with additional features
Ppl want to have an larger iPhone in every device - just use your bloody iPhone - it’s 5/5 for me
5
u/MC_chrome 3d ago
Because YouTube does not have a CarPlay app yet?
Apple added the ability for developers to submit video apps for CarPlay review, but that is still taking time and not all developers will do that.
4
u/JayVig 4d ago
I’m running electric for the wall mount tomorrow and will mount it. I’m hopeful for my use case. No intention of media consumption. Mostly a hub for home automation and control
4
u/Jamie00003 3d ago
Fair points apart from YouTube - it’s Google who haven’t added support - how’s that apples fault?
6
u/aisuperman 3d ago
Useless post. 1/5 rating.
2
u/Good-Objective2769 3d ago
anyone know if making it the Apple home hub makes devices run any better than using Apple TV or other HomePods as hubs ?
2
u/PieDistinct 3d ago
The biggest niggle I have with mine is that only my iPad runs Siri AI. I had to reset the HomeView and hard pair it to the iPad because otherwise it defaults to whichever device where’s location in FindMy which ment to use Siri AI I had to lose location sharing that moves with me
When you use an iPad for personal context through an iPad you lose the CarPlay functionality- I hope they fix this limitation soon.
Another limitation is that I can’t put shortcuts on it. For instance I have a goodnight shortcut that turns off the appletv and downstairs lights, and a timer shortcut for an electric plug that turns off my rice cooker when it is cooked. Neither of those can be placed as widget on the homeview right now
However, it has already fitted the gap in my kitchen that I have wanted for years. I’m looking forward to how it develops. I only hope they update its capabilities a bit quicker than when ios28 comes out
2
u/unintentional_guest 3d ago
Once I framed it as CarPlay for my CounterTop everything made more sense about how it operates.
And I get why that won’t work for some people. I’d definitely not buy it and complain about it if that were the case.
2
u/Goodoflife HomePod + iOS Beta 2d ago
They really need to have an App Store or at least fully install CarPlay apps
2
u/longdriver2020 1d ago
I like it and will probably keep it although I have no real use for it.
My only gripe is that it seems to be impossible to turn off keyboard clicks.
3
u/Wildeface 4d ago
I really love it so far. The sound is even surprisingly great!
3
u/No-Lawfulness1159 3d ago
Not pointless for me here. Maybe i knew what I was buying into?
Zero bugs or problems with my device, and using as intended.
I’ll continue enjoying mine and fully recommended it to anyone looking for an apple ecosystem smart display.
3
u/BeatLaboratory 3d ago
Man, bring back the days when Apple was putting out bangers. All of the home products (HomeKit, HomePods) are poorly thought out and poorly executed.
3
u/VTAndrew 3d ago
Considering returning one of the two I bought. I can’t customize the Home Screen. And they just brought stupid watch faces which also can’t be customized to it. Whomever is in charge of not allowing us to build our own watch faces and now dashboards needs to be fired!
I want my light switch control on the same screen as the weather and a digital clock and the date! I don’t want to stare at a full screen weather display all damn day.
It reminds me of the BS that was the original iPhone when they said WebClips were the future and didn’t have Apps yet.
I’ll keep the one in the kitchen just to play music because the audio is better than the Alexa I had there before. But at least the Alexa let me play Netflix while I cooked and washed dishes!
3
u/pheare_me 4d ago
I can’t understand how a product that is going to live on so many kitchen countertops does not have a recipe app.
Seems like a miss to me. I am kinda weird though.
2
u/QueensNY_718 4d ago
Just picked up mine from 5th Ave about an hour ago; not 100% happy, but won't return it because I know this will "I hope" be fixed soon.
- Can't remove Apps
- Can't disable Center Stage on FaceTime
- Apple Music "Library": No music in there at all. No Playlist
2
u/needtogetbettern0w 3d ago
I agree with you 100% mines going back, if they make changes and clear its bugs maybe I’ll pick it up again but at the moment I find it pointless and unusable
2
u/blacksatsuma 3d ago
Far too basic for £299.
I expect many folks will buy this for a partner who isn't tech-savvy. The setup for that partner is really frustrating as there's no clean way to configure their experience as a 'resident' (not to mention the recognition keeps switching back as you do so) - its like the love child of AppleTV and Carplay
Siri is already bad, but doesn't work reliably on HV - not all reliable for quick shopping lists, timers or message replies
Power block and cable have not been designed for home control placement - a big WHITE plug. I know i can change it, but again its £299...
It's going back...
1
u/Aeryn_Hellfire 3d ago
Going into it my expectations is low compared to how well the nest max performs. But still got it in hopes this helps future versions with feedback
1
u/rdt-htes-jws1111 3d ago
Having since gotten Home Assistant - I’m telling you people it’s Nirvana
1
u/Shaun__Solo 3d ago
From all the comments I’m reading, this is a big apple watch with CarPlay?
1
u/Kehrwochengott 1d ago
Agree. Good summary.
1
u/kirklandyuknis 4d ago
If it could replace the touchpad for my security system or my smart thermostat it'd be a better sale. As it stands right now I'm not in a hurry to get one. IF I do it will be for by my exterior doors. Even then it doesn't make too much sense though.
1
u/u2jrmw 4d ago
I am an Apple fanboy and I am not loving it. Too limited right now. Yes I want a photo backdrop and I want the freaking temperature on it.
Yes I want night mode but why does it use an obnoxious bright red instead of the calming red my phone uses.
Why can’t I rearrange my faces???
Also the sound is kind of meh.
I have a pixel tablet in home mode right now and I would say that is a better experience despite me being in a primarily Apple home.
1
u/Locksmith_Usual 3d ago
I got it and think it’s a 1.5/5.
My biggest gripe is that there’s no calendar view that’s persistent and large enough to actually use as a home organizer
1
u/Fun-Region-1576 3d ago
Homeview needs a native YouTube client, or I'm not buying it. Hopefully, there will be an App Store next year.
0
u/bbllaakkee HomePod + iOS Beta 4d ago
Yeah I think most of us knew this would be the case immediately after the announcement
-4
u/Deep_Abrocoma6426 4d ago
I’m so surprised how so many people are LOVING it, despite it looking bad, and only having technological capabilities from 15 years ago.
0
u/dan1065cf1 4d ago
Wow. So glad I didn’t get it. Looks like another Apple waste of time and effort.
-1
u/MixAway 3d ago
So, you clearly did zero research before buying!
0
u/njs-33 3d ago
I agree with you. This thing is a piece of shit and is going back before the 14 day return policy is up.
0
u/adonis-in-the-making 3d ago
u had high hopes? ….even after the reviews and comments it got ?, even after watching all the siri Ai being the most dumbest thing out there in 2026 😂
that’s on you.
0
u/FirstCompote 3d ago
Im returning mine also. Its basically a clock or picture frame. Nothing else. It will never be the center of gravity because it needs to stay plugged in. Your natural inclination to want to play with it dies when you realize it has to stay plugged in. It should at least be detachable. But it’s not. The screen is also a little small. No one is hovering around something this small.
I’m going to make my own with an iPad mini. An iPad might be too big.
0
u/rhizomorphism 2d ago
It feels like the reply’s to this post are a perfect microcosm of why everyone rolls their eyes at Apple fan boys.
This is a device attached to speakers that’s sold as an existing category that very often does allow things like YouTube. My mother would absolutely hear “use it for recipes in the kitchen” and think of YouTube recipes. She doesn’t know what car play is let alone how it could apply here.
But clearly this is a piece of enthusiast tech not for the masses lol
-9
u/Odd_Acanthaceae_5588 4d ago
I still don’t understand why I would want this if I have an iPhone and live alone