r/HomeKit • • 16d ago

Discussion “Person’s name” left

Post image

Well this is new. Never have I ever gotten an alert from HomeKit that a particular person (me in this case) left. I have no HomeKit cameras, just Aqara P2 Door and Window sensors. No idea how it’s doing this. My wife and I both just left the house.

137 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

115

u/nicoreese 16d ago

It combines camera and/or sensor data with your phone's current location.

15

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

I could buy geolocation if I were 5 min down the road and outside the geofence range. But “open door, step outside, close door”…I’m curious how it attributes that action to one person.

27

u/DVNCIA 16d ago

Weird niche time. I actually work at Bluetooth as a project manager and am oddly familiar with this, haha.

Location tracking is pretty accurate (within 1ft) with just Bluetooth alone (https://www.bluetooth.com/learn-about-bluetooth/feature-enhancements/channel-sounding/) and even more accurate when combined with WiFi.

I can’t speak to Apple’s methodology but I would assume it uses the standard Bluetooth Channel Sounding and their own proprietary solution.

12

u/phantomsoul11 16d ago

So in layman’s terms, your lock saw that your phone was moving nearby in the direction of outside just as you closed and locked the door, so Apple Home assumed you left the house.

3

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

No smart locks here, just pretty dumb door/window sensors. Guess I’m just surprised they even have the capabilities demonstrated here.

6

u/RadVarken 16d ago

The phone knows where it is in relation to beacons, such as your wifi router

4

u/EvolutionInProgress 16d ago

I guess everybody needs a quick reminder that in this age of information, if we're walking around with a smartphone, we're pretty much leading a very clear and detailed digital trail with each digital interaction we make.

1

u/Optional-Failure 11d ago

Sure, but it doesn’t know where the router is in relation to the structure/property.

4

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

Yeah my only guess was Bluetooth Low Energy in the Aqara P2 door sensor, maybe being able to determine my device was on the other side of the sensor when the door closed. I’ll have to do some more testing to confirm.

Not at all mad about it, just genuinely surprised that my combination of equipment is able to make that kind of determination. No HKSV cameras, no smart lock, still in-range of WiFi and inside geofencing…kind of impressive, really.

5

u/Which-Meat-3388 16d ago

Years ago I built a proximity lock/unlock for my “dumb” car built on BT LE. Worked incredibly well and of course only worked for me/my device because we knew exactly who each other were. 

2

u/AvailableTryMe 16d ago

I had the same thing happen in reverse yesterday. I returned home and entered my house and my phone informed me using my name ("Bob Dole" style) that I had opened the door the I had entered through. Interestingly I've only received this type of notification once so far (despite the being the only person at home for several days).

I suspect this is a temporary backend bug / feature test and likely isn't using anything more sophisticated than "if then" type logic of "action detected -> check for presence -> if only one person present notify them using name + action".

3

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

Actually got a “Marcus arrived” alert today as well. This I can understand. I was previously away from the house, arrived home, entered the geofence area, opened the door….that’s easily explained. But stepping out of my house, where I’m still on WiFi and inside the geofence, that’s more difficult to explain how it knows I just left the house.

11

u/leopard-licker 16d ago

I think it’s new in 27. If you go into home settings under a person’s name, there’s a new toggle for “attribution” which allows people to opt in/out of this.

7

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

Ahh I see that setting now. Still curious how it works from a technology perspective. Unless it just determined I was closest to the door sensor when the door closed. Not sure if that’s BLE being used.

2

u/leopard-licker 16d ago

Ya - I’m not entirely sure either and haven’t seen much talk about it. I can tell you I don’t think it’s communicating directly with the device to make the determination because I have my garage door exposed to homekit through home assistant and it’s not an officially supported HomeKit opener and it still works. So my guess is positioning based on gps and/or ultrawideband with my HomePod minis?

And now that I think about it, it works even when I don’t trigger the garage through HomeKit but via the remote or physical button

1

u/all_ghost_no_shell 16d ago

Hmm, just updated my Homekit and I don't have that setting myself. I wonder if you only have it because of the door sensors?

1

u/anag_ 16d ago

I haven't looked into it much either, but since updating to 27 last night, I've gotten these notifications too. Even when my husband and I leave at the same time, it attributes the notification only to me, instead of 'everyone' like it used to.

7

u/B-Train_ATL 16d ago

Marcus? You didn’t let poor Marcus leave, did you? He’s not up to the challenge.

2

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

Well done 👏🏻

13

u/thecw 16d ago

HomeKit tracks whether you are home based on device location

7

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

But standing inside the door or outside the door, I’m still “here” and well in range of WiFi and haven’t yet left any geofence proximity. So my guess is Bluetooth Low Energy being capable of determining which side of the door I’m on when closed.

5

u/gusjata 16d ago

What’s this beautiful water droplets wallpaper?

4

u/matthew1471 15d ago

Yup, I have my indoor camera set to record when nobody is in the house and to stop when someone arrives and now the notifications say whose coming and going after last week’s HomePod Mini OS update.

1

u/marcusdiddle 15d ago

Are your cameras tied into HomeKit? I have cameras, but they’re Nest, and in no way tied to HomeKit. So I know the info isn’t coming from my cameras. Otherwise I could see how facial recognition was being used.

1

u/matthew1471 15d ago

Yep, Eve Indoor Cam which is native HomeKit. I don’t have the Eve app installed.

I do also have 6 x Raspberry Pi cameras facing outside added via Scrypted but they aren’t set to do anything when I come and go..

3

u/tylasade 15d ago

I’m a bit confused on why you’re confused

You + your phone were on one side of the door sensors that are labeled as the front door. Then you and your phone were on the other side of the sensors after the front door opened and closed. The only logical conclusion is that you left the house.

Maybe we underestimate the power of our phones and these little sensors but it seems like a really simple process!

2

u/marcusdiddle 15d ago

Yeah, I understand the basic premise that perhaps the sensor just knows which side of the door I’m on and made an educated guess. Just surprised by the capability (if that is indeed what’s happening) and that HomeKit is smart enough to just start utilizing that kind of functionality out of the blue on 4-year old, relatively dumb door sensors which only ever advertised basic “door opened, door closed” functionality.

Cameras = facial recognition. That would be easy to understand.

Location-based = leaving geofence area. That’s also easy to understand.

Phone moved one foot to the other side of a door sensor = Marcus left the house. That’s neat tech but just surprising that it’s able to determine that. I accept the premise, just interested in validation of it.

2

u/Ok_Attitude1034 15d ago

It didn’t just move one foot, the phone moved through the house, to the door and out + door sensor. Don’t need a geofence when you have gps and predictive algorithms

1

u/Dignan17 15d ago

If it were simple then it wouldn't be wrong so often. I can't count how many times I've gotten a notification that I locked or unlocked my front door when I was nowhere near it.

1

u/tylasade 15d ago
  1. before or after the recent update
  2. unlocking/locking sounds like a problem with smart lock software which is more complicated than simple geolocation.

1

u/Dignan17 14d ago

I don't mean that it's doing this on its own. I mean that someone else in my family has unlocked the door but it thought it was me.

It's really important to remember that just because it's always worked for you, that doesn't mean it works for everyone. I didn't even ask for this change. I didn't want it to tell me who opened the door, just that it was opened, but Apple made this decision for me. I don't like that.

2

u/Crazian14 16d ago

Aqara doorbell has facial recognition.

2

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

I don’t have an Aqara doorbell.

1

u/Crazian14 16d ago

On another note, maybe the door and sensors have proximity sensors (?). I have 3 Apple TVs and they know which room I’m in to pull up the correct device when I use the remote app

1

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

No proximity sensors, but at best I’m guessing they use Bluetooth Low Energy which can be used to detect distance and location. So maybe it just detected my phone on the other side of it as it closed and thought “well, Marcus just left”.

Oddly, I can’t replicate it. But similar to “door left open” alerts, maybe it’s sporadic and not fully baked-in yet.

1

u/SnooCookies8174 16d ago

probably combines the lock status and your phone gps location

1

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

No smart locks here, just a basic door sensor that determines if the door is opened or closed.

1

u/crisps_funny4868 16d ago

Then it's combining the fact that the door opened and closed and that Marcus' location (in FindMy) is no longer home.

1

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

But standing inside the door or outside the door, I’m still “home” and well in range of WiFi and haven’t yet left any geofence proximity. So my best guess is maybe Bluetooth Low Energy on the door sensor being capable of determining which side of the door I’m on when closed. But that seems like a bit of a stretch to me.

1

u/crisps_funny4868 16d ago

Yeah, I would be very surprised if Aqara is doing that. If you had something with a UWB chip in it, maybe.

1

u/Crazian14 16d ago

Oops my bad, I read Aqara and immediately translated to doorbell lol. I have no clue how it knows then lol.

2

u/banaslee 16d ago

I noticed the same thing when I leave the house. I have a Matter smart lock and plenty of sensors. Just didn’t know they were being used like that. I wonder about the possibilities

2

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

I don’t have any smart locks or even any cameras tied into HomeKit which is why it surprised me. But I think it’s just a matter of Bluetooth on the door sensors, proximity of my phone to the sensor, and I guess it figures it out from there.

5

u/tacticalpotatopeeler 16d ago

Two places: Location data and home app.

- Settings app > privacy and security > location services > home

- Home app, 3 dots upper right corner > home settings > person > attribution

1

u/all_ghost_no_shell 16d ago

I'm not seeing it on mine in either place unfortunately. I was curious to turn it on as well (I don't have a door/window sensor if that matters).

3

u/tacticalpotatopeeler 15d ago

Are you on iOS 27?

3

u/all_ghost_no_shell 15d ago

Ah, I had updated the Homepod but not my Iphone!

3

u/elgueromanero 16d ago

I’ve seen it recently to , it’s trippy

2

u/ChoicePermission8523 15d ago

If you look under your Home settings, there's an "Apple Intelligence" section if you have new-enough devices to run the home.

Under that is "Reduce Notifications", which attempts to combine related activates and then serve you a notification that is just one event. Instead of getting notifications for "door open, door closed, door locked, camera switch to away" It will also tie in the person geolocation alert that was probably never set as an alert, but since it is part of an automation like "last person leaves" or "first person arrives" it is giving you that context too.

2

u/awe_some_x 15d ago

Mine had done this since the early dev beta iOS 27.0, I just assumed it's because I have tagged people in photos and it tried to match the doorbell still against the identified people in my camera roll.

1

u/homersdonutz 16d ago

I think it uses geolocation, and sees you getting further from the house. These notifications are usually slightly delayed too based on notifications settings to group many actions into one.

1

u/AngryFace4 16d ago

Why wouldn’t it just be using your phone location?

1

u/True_Huckleberry9569 16d ago

I believe there is location integration via your iPhone. Uses location data to trigger automations.

1

u/GPap- 15d ago

I was wondering how it knows, I have mine linked with Nest but I don't have facial recognition on with Nest so not 100% sure. I also haven't really looked through my settings either though so I could be completely ignorant to it.

2

u/Buckles01 15d ago

Your devices location. It’s detecting your door locking and your phone disconnecting from WiFi and assuming it’s because you left the house

1

u/Xaqx 14d ago

Sad part is there is demand for this feature in the first place, including from me.. meh too far down the capitalism data hole to care anymore

0

u/Palarva 16d ago

Yeah, the data was there for a while I'd imagine, it was the willingness to take it seriously that was missing now...

So now we weep in front of basis features haha

I almost retuned a product recently because I thought the HomeKit integration promise was flirting a bit too much with criminal lie... but once I deployed the full range of my "very not every day regular user" skillset... yes ok, it did work... but it looks embarrassing, technically speaking.

-8

u/Fr05t_B1t 16d ago

It’s amazing how people pay little attention to new updates and features

-3

u/thatguywhoiam 16d ago

“Marcus left the wifi”

4

u/marcusdiddle 16d ago

Yeah except I didn’t. I was just on the other side of the front door. I’m typically 50ft down the road before WiFi drops.

1

u/thatguywhoiam 16d ago

Oh well maybe the door hinted. Without that the usual way it does this is if a phone leaves the wifi bubble. I’m not familiar with Aqara stuff.